Ordered over the phone for carry out. Ordered babes ziti and calamari. Food is very, service was rushed but then it was the rush hour for food 6:30. I recommend this restaurant to all. I lived in Calabria Italy for two years and this is very close to what I had there. read more

Marcello's not only has great pizza and subs (cheesesteaks), but they also have amazing dinners! The veal saltimboca is one of my favorites here! The bruschetta is to die for, and so is their seafood misto! They are always friendly and willing to accommodate any special request! This is one of my "go-to's" read more

THE WORST!! Stopped by for lunch. Ordered Italian sub and side of onion rings. Sub was NOTHING but lettuce; one thin slice of fake ham, one thinner slice of salami and almost a half slice of cheese! Also, there was a real shortage of dressing on the sub unless you count the water on the head of shredded lettuce! Onion rings were shaped like a circle but contained NO ONIONS!; Complete disappointment for everything! In addition to lousy food you could have your pick of any DIRTY table in the place. DISGUSTING!! read more

My new favorite place. Been working so much I decided to order delivery. And I'll tell you what, made my night! They said an hour but it was 30 minutes. The delivery guy was super nice and even took the time to play around with our puppy. Food was hot! And to my surprise it came with bread, warm bread! I lit some candles we played some music and had a great delicous meal all at home. Next time I'm going into the restraunt! It's definitley worth the time! read more

Marcello's - Ordered delivery and had our own set up at home. Food was hot and absolutely delicous. Our new favorite place. - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

We have eaten here or gotten takeout several times a year for the last 3-4 years and have never been disappointed. I love that they have several gluten-free options, like subs, pizza, & pasta. Just had GF seafood Misto tonight and it was loaded with scallops, shrimp, clams, & mussels. The white wine garlic sauce was perfect with the level of garlic just right. I added pepper & a little Parmesan to top it off. Their evening dining room is very nice (byob) & casual lunch dining area is clean & comfortable. Great value for the price & friendly staff!! read more

The place was busy but then again it was a Friday night! O red red a white pizza, antipasto salad, and two additional slices. The pizzas were hot and delicious. I love their house salad dressing! read more

The Lobster Ravioli filled an 10 " plate. The lobster and ricotta cheese filling was delightful and the blush sauce had taste. Mixed in with the sauce was crab, asparagus and shrimp. The salad was crisp and the dressing was good. I took half of this meal home and will enjoy it tonight. I was so full I couldn't finish my meal nor have a dessert. read more

Almost always our go to place when we just don't want to cook. Amazing food, reasonable prices.

We came to this restaurant for our anniversary dinner. Not a lot of Italian restaurants in town, but this one came highly reviewed. Service was wonderful (only two women - they worked so hard and were very cheerful!) You could tell the locals love this place and frequent it. The eggplant parm I had was wonderful. The fettuccine Alfredo was good too. The bread was warm and freshly baked. And if they offer you soup - go for it! Amazing. read more

Food was delicious & helpings were enormous! I had chicken cacciatore & mentioned that I don't eat wheat so our WONDERFUL waitress asked if I would like roasted veggies instead. Yum. Hubby had chicken alfredo and says that was fantastic as well. read more

Marcello's - Chicken cacciatore w roasted veggies instead of pasta - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

We are back again--once more for wonderful authenticity-- We asked when they might have mushroom soup again, and the chef asked which night we wanted it--so we'll be back Thursday ! read more

My first time at Marcello's. I will go back again. The decor was quite nice. A nice dining room on one side and a more casual area on the other side. I ordered calamari fritti as my appetizer. It was plentiful and good. My main entree was the Fra Diavolo (spicy) over linguine. The linguine was perfectly cooked. I don't order pasta to often when I dine out for the reason most times it's overcooked. All in all a very nice dining experience. read more

Marcello's - Calamari Fritti with a side of marinara sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

This was one of my favorite places for pizza, but after yesterday's pizza I have to say it's worst pizza I ate.For an Italian crust base is so thick, I hated the crust. read more

A hidden jewel I never would've found without Yelp! I got a daily special: veal with marinara, buffalo mozzarella, and some pasta on the side. I also had the Italian wedding soup. Everything was very flavorful and served hot. The veal was prepared perfectly, the pasta was perfectly cooked. The soup had the smallest spicy kick to it which made it perfect. Service was good. The place was quiet for the most part; some patrons had a few too many glasses of wine but their boisterousness can't be blamed on the restaurant. All in all, I would visit again if I find myself in Carlisle. read more

We ventured off the turnpike thanks to yelp and we're rewarded for our efforts. This place is great, good choices for the kids and the pasta selection is amazing and tasty. We will plan our trips going this direct to ensure we stop here for lunch/dinner. read more

Meats imported from Italy, homemade bread and amazing customer service. All you need in a true Italian spot.

It's been a long time since I've eaten Italian. Don't normally go for pasta, cheese and sauces but loved this place. We got to bring our own wine, the waitress was fabulous and the food delicious. Sorry we don't live closer - just passing through..... read more

Marcello's - Eggplant rollatini. - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

I've been trying new pizza places near me since the one I've gone to for years changed management and is now horrible. This place is definitely a contender for my new favorite pizza place! I picked up a meat lovers pizza from here for dinner tonight, 9/24/15, and I was pleasantly surprised! Pros: Great price for what you get. Our pizza was STACKED with meat! You definitely get more than enough food for the price that you pay. The pizza tasted delicious! I like the sauce and the toppings very much, although the crust had a little trouble holding up to all the toppings. Cons: A little greasy for my liking (although I think that was because of the large amount of meat on the pizza, so I'll forgive it more than usual) I'd definitely recommend giving this place was a try if you haven't yet! read more

Fantastic pizza! The FRESHEST and BEST veggie pizza we've ever had!! read more

Marcello's - Veggie pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Here from Ohio with my husband on a business trip. The locals said this is the spot we tried . I'm in love . Was awesome! read more

Marcello's - Sausage n pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Carlisle has many several serious contenders for good pizza, but Marcello's sits alone at the top. I live close by and frequent this establishment frequently, both to dine in and to take out. They have a fancy dining section and a simple pizza shop area, making them a great option for many different occasions. They make huge stromboli and their pizzas are big too. The sauce is a perfect blend of flavor and smooth texture, great on pizza and pasta alike. While you can get fancy Italian dishes (which are usually great), their simple cheese pizza is perfect every time too. read more

I found Marcello's by using the Yelp app and searching for an establishment to dine at with my father on a Sunday afternoon. We ordered onion rings, chicken caesar salad, and a large plain pie. All of that food and two drinks came out to about $22, which is fair given the quality. The chicken caesar salad was one of the best I have tasted in recent memory. The pizza is not thin enough to be thin crust or thick enough to be Sicilian/deep-dish. So, it struck me as unnecessarily doughy . Good place to dine, and there is more depth to the menu than just variations of pizza. read more

Two days on the road, exhausted and trying to find a decent eatery that delivers (our dog travels with us). My wife's not a fan of pizza. I love a good pie. Found Marcello's thru Yelp, reviews looked good. Wife went with Va Diavolo with Capelinni pasta. I had the meat-lovers pie. We were both very happy with our choices. Very generous servings and delicious. Leftover za for lunch on the road tomorrow. Great variety in the menus. Quick delivery and very reasonable prices. Just do it and you'll understand read more

Kyle was the best server ever. Phenomenal service and great food. Portions are huge! A must try if ever in Carlisle. Thank you Kyle! Will definitely be back. read more

Great sub and pizza place with counter service connected to a sit down Italian restaurant with delicious food and good service. I like the pizza steak sub on the sandwich side, and all is good on the table service side. I will be back. read more

I normally don't like to give bad reviews unless they are very much earned. So today this was earned I started off ordering their special 2 one-topping for 18.99. That's a good deal being as though that I have three young children and their friends over for a sleepover Perfect Price and I don't have to cook. I called and place my order at 3:12 pm. An hour passed I called them at 4:15 p.m. and ask them where was my order they informed me that they mixed up and had the wrong address. That's fine everybody makes mistakes the delivery guy makes it to my house and he is very polite I signed my ticket because I paid with my card he asked me if I need plates or hot pepper and I'm like sure I don't have to wash the dishes at this point I'm very happy he goes to the car and gets the plates and the peppers. As I go in the house and try to look at my order to see if it's correct the first pizza looks amazing the second Pizza pie however it's not what I ordered I asked for onions and steak they gave me onions and pork now my children don't eat pork so I could not feed that to them. I called back to the restaurant and inform them what happened they tell me that steak does not apply to the special which is fine but I should have been told before I ordered and it was delivered I was not so while on the phone with their representative he informed me that he can remake my pizza and I would just pay the difference for the meat. He did not give me a total he did not tell me how much it would be for the difference. Instead they charged me half price for a specialty pizza a cheese steak Pizza which I did not want I was very specific on what I wanted. When I informed them that I was not happy and that's not what I wanted the gentleman on the phone eventually got very rude which I can understand because I was frustrated but it was like I did something wrong like I messed the order up in all they did not remake my pizza and give me the difference for the topping they remade my pizza and made me pay for their mistake I am very unhappy with this service. So I called back this is the third time now and pretty much the person on the other end of the phone made me feel as though that I was not ordering right or that they were not at fault for messing up my order in the first place. Eventually I got fed up and I went to the establishment after I ordered delivery. The delivery guy was actually trying to take up for me because they were trying to say that I didn't pay for my first order and he insisted that I did ( don't know his name but he was very nice) when I got to the store with my box of pizza in hand somebody said can I help you and I said yes I walked to the counter and started to explain to them what happened an elderly gentleman with salt and pepper hair told me to calm down........ I disregarded his comments and explain to him what happened he did however give me my money back because I did not authorize the transaction on my card from the beginning of the. 2nd delivery but the experience here is like none other I never went through anything as disrespectful as this as far as customer service and I work in customer service it is shameful. I do not. Appreciate how I was treated and I do not appreciate them authorizing transactions on a card that they had no permission to do this restaurant would never get my business again and everyone that I know and Carlisle will know what happened to me today shameful read more

We ordered a take out order through grub hub delivery was great. But the chicken parmeson my husband got was more breading than chicken and it was burnt. We also ordered two chicken fingers and fries. You could taste it on the fries that it is time to change the oil gave the fries a funny taste. Dont think we will order anytime again soon read more

We get lunch here at least once a week if that tell you what we think. The pizza is good and the subs are even better. If you want a VERY nice Italian dinner, skip the holy jeans and dine on the restaurant side. The food will not disappoint. read more

Ordered Eggplant rollatini and Chicken Scallopini. Delivery was prompt despite their being quite busy. Food was delicious. Will eat again next time I'm in town. read more

Our favorite Italian restaurant in the Carlisle area for authentic dining. We especially like their dinners in their pleasant dining room. The veal dishes are fabulous, and their veggies on the side drizzled with reduced balsamic Is delicious. The bread is freshly baked. BYOB. Love this place! read more

We normally just order pizza when we do order from here but tonight U decided on somethi g a little different. I got my children something from their childrens menu, chicken fingers and fries for my 4 year old and a cheese burger and fries for my 3 year old. Their fries were soggy, and my 3 year old couldnt even eat her cheese burger! The roll was so hard I could barely even bite into it!! I had to put it on regular bread in order for her to eat it! And all this was after it arrived over an hour after i had ordered! I live 5 minutes from them! We will not be ordering from here again. read more

Seems prices went up and they did not tell anyone, order 2 subs and a bag of chips with tax and me picking it up bill should of been a little over $16, nope they rounded up to a flat $18, either they can not add, or they are taking advantage of the covid -19, either way shame on them. read more

We go here all the time. Their food is authentic Italian and tastes amazing. The prices are also really decent. They make the bread fresh for their pizzas and subs, so if you come in at the right time you can smell amazing fresh bread right out of the oven. read more

Good food! We took our U14 girls soccer team (53 ppl) here after a long day of soccer. They hooked us up with a private room and buffet style catered dinner which was excellent. We had chicken Parmesan, baked ziti, lasagna, fettuccine Alfredo and Caesar salad. For the price, it was well worth it. read more

The pizza wasn't very good. The crust was really tough and bland like a saltine. It ruined the pizza. Staff seemed unfriendly. Guess I'm spoiled by the good pizza and friendly staff of my regular place read more

I LOVE Marcello's! Everything here is great - from the food, to the prices to the fantastic service - just a magnificent Italian place - ALWAYS come away happy! Mike read more

Food is good. Isn't the best Italian I've ever had. Pasta and pizza are both amazing. Definitely a good choice.

Margarita pizza was ok, not a true Margarita and a bit on the salty side. Chicken picata was ok.

Terrible service. Waitress mumbled under her breath when asked for refills. For a table of 8, she only brought out one pitcher of water and one basket of bread. When I asked for a water refill, waitress told me that I had to get the other end of the table to share their pitcher with me. Again, it's a water refill I asked for!!!!!! Service was slow. It appeared something wasn't right with the staff. They seemed shorthanded and unorganized, as if the regular help didn't show up that night. This is a BYOB diner. Nonalcoholic drinks are limited to colas and tea. Tea is not free refills, or at least mine was never refilled this particular night. Food was large portions yet a little over priced for the service. Restaurant is divided into two: a pizzeria and a sit down restaurant. The restaurant does NOT have pizzas on their menu. Server said that you may NOT order pizzas, but she would make an exception this one time. Terrible, pitiful service. Don't go there. read more

I knew Yelp could be manipulated. Now that all the family and friends have checked in with 5 stars, here's the unbiased straight scoop. This is barely a two for food. Mundane entres, with little resemblance to good Italian cuisine. We had gnocchi and penne a la vodka. Might compete with canned goods. Service was OK, but waiter did not understand the specials. I was prompting him from my glance as I entered. We'll still rely on Yelp (or we never would have had the fantastic food at City Bar in Honolulu, fer instance). Stay away from Marcellos if you know good Italian. It will sorely disappoint you. read more