This is your average pizza shop. They offer slices, sandwiches, and expected appetizers and desserts. I was at Cafe Nine for the night and this was this closest restaurant that was open late. There are a few booths inside and they play general music. Service was quick and actually very friendly. They weren't too busy so I was able to get a slice of chicken bacon ranch almost immediately. The slice was good! I enjoyed the crust which is what I judge pizza by the most lol. I haven't bought a single slice in a while, and my wallet was surprised to hear $5 a slice, but that's priced pretty fair for the area I guess. read more

See all

Love this place! I eat here often, I always get a warm welcome and a friendly smile from whoever is behind the counter. What ever I eat from a slice of pizza to my favorite garlic knots with cheese to my newest favorite. Sicilian baked ziti! It has meatballs and eggplant mixed in! It's so good! I ate it twice a week ago! The loaded fries, chicken parm! I can go on and on. I work next door and sometimes stay very late, I can get something at midnight when I am leaving! Good food, friendly service and always there..... can't ask for much more! read more

I've only had delivery, but great pizza! I'm finding that a lot of New Haven pizza is just way too salty!

Marco Polo is Top 5 New Haven Pizzas lets be HONEST!!! Skip the lines at the other places and come here

Customer service was not the best ! I ordered a slice of pizza and one of the customers bumped into me and they dropped my pizza and it fell on the ground I went to the clerk and asked nicely if could get a new pizza but he was so rude and said no I have to wait at the end of the line again and pay for a new one....mind you the line was so long and I've already waited for a while for a slice , I was so devastated. They didn't have no type of compassion. read more

Salads are ginormous and delicious!! I was in the mood for a salad and my go to spot ran out of the salad i normally get, so I decided to get a salad from here. My salad came loaded: Cajun grilled chicken on a garden salad with cheddar cheese and a boiled egg. Perfection. Perfect timing after a 5 mile walk on the canal! read more

Marco Polo - Grilled Chicken Salad (cheddar cheese and boiled egg are add ons just an FYI) - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Poor service. Food was just OK. Restaurant was cold. Table was not bussed following salad, too many plates on the table read more

Yes, yes, yes! Tuscan Chicken Pasta with (Whole Wheat Penne) was wonderful. The flavor of the sauce was so rich and delicate. Wouldn't recommend normal pasta, it soaks up too much of the sauce and leaves it dry. read more

The pizza was just fine - the toppings were quite sparse and overall it needed more flavor. The service was also slow. In the past they used to come and take your order, now you have to order at the counter and the employee seemed confused. I wouldn't go back unless just for a slice. read more

I'm new to the state of Connecticut and Marco Polo pizza was absolutely delicious, their delivery service was nice and the pizza was hot when it arrived!!! read more

Marco Polo - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

This is basically the pizza you get when you're out and there's nowhere else serving food. Which is how I ended up there at 12:30 this morning. The pizza was just meh, not enough cheese, and just tasted old. read more

See all

An authentic Italian restaurant. Food was so delicious made fresh everyday. The lasagna was the best I ever had

Got a slice of pizza for my wife and a calazone for myself. The pizza was burnt so much my wife couldn't eat it. I asked for a refund and they nicely said yes to the slice, but refused to refund the calazone. So, here we sit in the restaurant, wasting time because they couldn't cook pizza, waiting for a calazone we know will be bad, and still need to go to another restaurant. Bad food, worse service, DO NOT GO HERE. read more

I live close by so I've been here 3 times this year. The pizza has no flavor but it's in a very convenient location so I've ordered a few slices and added oregano and cheese for flavor. Yesterday, I had a very disturbing interaction with the owner/ front desk attendee. I entered the restaurant to pick up my online order and I was ignored for 5 minutes. I asked the man if my order was ready, he said: "I'm busy. I will get to you when I get to you". I stated that he didn't greet me or say anything and I've been waiting patiently, he continued to make the pizza and continued to ignore me. I will never go back to this establishment. I have never been treated like that in my entire life. If you want to be disrespected and get basic pizza, please check out this establishment. read more

Food was fantastic! I had the Penne with vodka sauce. I also had the red sauce with meatballs recently and everything was on point -! Good prices too. Not happy about them not keeping track of the 2 cokes I drank and paid for. Silly little kids read more

This place can do it all! I have ordered multiple things from Marco Polo and have never left disappointed. First off, I love how late they are open. It is the best when you have a late night craving for pizza or dessert. The portions are huge and the prices are very cheap. The pasta comes with a side salad and garlic knots and can easily be split with two people. Even the small calzone and pizza are huge portions that can be shared. The dessert here is also immaculate. I have tried all the cakes, as well as the cannoli. The chocolate cake is amazing and the oreo cake is to die for. Highly recommend anything from this restaurant! read more

Marco Polo - Farmer's Delight Pizza with no black olives - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

First time trying this place in New Haven. The food was Great and the portions were also very good. The service As very friendly and accommodating to our catering needs! read more

This turned out to be a great place for late night delivery. I got eggplant parm on a hard roll and a small chicken, walnut, and cranberry salad with their house creamy balsamic dressing. The sandwich was nice for the price. The sauce was good! The salad was made with mixed greens! A late night salad that isn't all iceberg lettuce? Yes please! Vegetarians take note you have choices here. Affordable food at reasonable prices and they didn't charge a delivery fee! I will order from them again when I get the late night munchies. They may just be my go to read more

Marco Polo - Chicken, cranberry, walnut salad - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

I was at Café nine with my friends tonight and of course did not eat lunch or dinner so I was starving. Café nine does not have any food which is unfortunate but I actually was told by the waitress that I can get food from down the street Marco Polo. I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich on a hard roll from Café nine and ran down the street to pick it up. What is a good sandwich I would do it again. read more

The delivery driver was very rude, gave us the wrong pizza and then demanded it back after we contacted about the mistake. We gave back the mistake and were given the correctly made pizza however, it was completely frozen. My concern is that since they asked for the mistake back that someone else had ours... to reserve food that was left unattended at a strangers house is absolutely ridiculous. The restaurant then refused to give us a refund. Do not recommend if you like warm, correct and sanitary food! read more

I don't know about you, but when I order delivery, I generally expect that means the food will be delivered to me...at my door. But Marco Polo disagrees! According to the very rude driver who, after I had to wave him over, walked up with an attitude, started to leave, then stopped to turn around to tell me "you have to come to the car!" No sir, I don't. Especially not for barely mediocre pizza read more

Though you need some thicker skin to not be offended by the rude staff behavior; that is the only issue I've discovered in my time eating here. Some of the best specialty pizzas around and some pretty slappin cannolis too read more

Recently ordered delivery there when working in New Haven and food was excellent. The only inconvenience was that the delivery time almost took 1.5 hours for a hot chicken cutlets sub and cheeseburger with fries. Beside the delivery been slower than I prefer I would definitely order again next time I'm in New Haven and have to take out. One other thing that I didn't like was that they didn't give us any receipt or napkins. Typically I don't care for the receipt but it was a corporate lunch so a receipt was needed to be reimbursed. The driver was nice enough to give us his hand written total. Next time I will make sure to ask for napkins. Maybe, I will try their pizzas next. read more

We placed an order from a hospital on 4/9. The chicken wrap was incorrect, and both pasta dinners did not get their salads with them. When we called back to tell them, they said the driver said the salads were in the bag . The salads were not in the bag!!!! They refused to send them. Good thing there's lots of other places for us to order from because we will not be ordering from them again!! read more

I ordered here for NYE 12/32/22 spaghetti and meatballs both me and my five year old shared since they give such a generous serving. An hour later my daughter started complaining of a stomach ache but she eventually went to bed and I begin throwing up throughout the entire night into the morning. read more

Last Time I Ordered Online 1hr 1/2 Later. Was Told They Didn't have a Order For Me,I could PLACE ONE Now... I relayed Order Confirmation, PAYMENT Ect. Man on Phone CLEARLY Irritated. Today We Ordered Sausage Bacon Pepperoni and Onions. We Got Pepperoni, Sausage,Ham , NO Onion.... I'm DONE. read more

I usually don't write reviews but! This place has grown to be such a nasty restaurant over the years. The staff has the worse attitude lately, NOT friendly at all or they have LACK OF TRAINING ON THE PHONE OR RESTAURANT MENU AND SPECIALS. I came in to buy the lunch especial and I ended up with a DRY chicken parmesan and when i asked for more sauce because it was so dry. The guy at the front charged me .75 instead of being curious after i just spent 21 dollars for my meal prior. DON'T WASTE YOUR ENERGY HERE. Lucky, i even gave you a star because you don't deserve it. ALSO, they made me stand there while they took phone orders like I was invisible, maybe there should be two people or more working in the front if it's that busy. read more

Marco Polo - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

There pastrami was not cut against the grain so it was tough to chew. The garlic rolls seemed to have raw garlic on top of it. And the buffalo pizza was ok. Not good experience read more

This place has become one of my go to delivery spots since social distancing began. It's really become one of my favorites. I find that the quality of the food is really up there; even the standard unapologetically junk food-y appetizers are done with a higher quality. I usually order for the salads, which I find are a great value. They're huge and are super fresh, and have a variety of ingredients. I wouldn't normally rave about salads (ok, maybe a little bit) but I find that I crave these-- they're that good. read more

I saw that another customer mentioned getting sick after eating the spaghetti and meatballs. I ordered the same meal also on the same day, only different is I did not eat it until the next day as an early lunch at 11:30am, around 12:34/12:50 I have to rush to the bathroom to regurgitate what I ingested for lunch, which was the Marco Polo spaghetti and meatballs. No matter how much I attempted to get that food out of my body I continued to taste the putrid entree for hours. I will give that dish a 0.5 read more

Poor customer service so disappointed We have been ordering from them for quite awhile, food is delicious, ordered today and unfortunately our order was wrong it and it missing things , our salads were not right simple items missing cheese the protein was wrong. Totally understand mistakes happen we called and explained and asked if a driver was coming this way could we get what was missing from our salads. We didn't even ask for new salads. They said ok ( no apologies) I could live with that but they actually had the nerve to call us back and tell us the salads had the missing items on them. We explained they did not and they proceeded to argue with us. Why on earth would we call them and ask for the missing items we weren't even asking for new salads. Crazy !! The gentleman got argumentive and nasty on the phone. Never ever again Marco Polo !! You guys made a mistake and needed to own it. Not very smart in these times to piss off loyal customers. Your food is good but not good enough for us to ignore such poor customer service. I can name many other restaurants who would of gladly brought what we paid for and most would of replaced our salads. Loyal customer no more read more

Stopped by Marco Polo after having a drink at Firehouse 12 (next door). Looked like more of a take out place but seating area was well furnished, clean and nicer than other take out places. I had a chicken parm sandwich and my two companions had a small meat lovers pizza and a pepperoni calzone. We were starving but all enjoyed our food. My sandwich was on a hard roll with a side of potato chips...chicken was hot and sauce was great...melted mozz cheese and some parmesan cheese completed my meal. Pizza looked great and my friend enjoyed it and had half for leftovers. Same with the calzone...looked pretty well stuffed with cheese and pepperoni and made me want to go back and try one. Will hopefully go back after another night out for drinks. read more

It is very difficult to stand out as a pizza restaurant in pizza headquarters of the world. Marco Polo is in a great location on Crown Street that I walked to from the train station. I was tired and a bit hungry and gave it a chance. I'm glad I did. The staff were very friendly and welcoming. The pizza was ready quickly. The sauce was tasty and there was so much delicous pullable cheese!!!! Just what I wanted. It hit the spot and was really affordable. Perfect for mid week pick up. read more

Ordered two small New Haven salads w/grilled chicken. For the first time in ten years I must say that I was disappointed. To much brown lettuce, bacon bits were soggy and fatty, and I asked for bleu cheese dressing. Got ranch instead. So now I am skeptical about retuning to Marco Polo. Also did not notice any kitchen staff wearing gloves. read more

Trash! Garlic knots microwaved and tasted freezer burnt. Pizza was upside down when it got here. I called them their service sucks. Last time. read more

Marco Polo is a great pizzeria and Italian restaurant. Price range is excellent. Excellent for lunch, dinner and late night. Excellent for family, friends and kids. Quiet, away from busy streets. Thank you! read more

Marco Polo - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

This was our second time ordering from here, the first time was great, and we ordered the same exact thing. The food took an hour to arrive, and when it got here, it wasn't what we ordered. one meal, the buffalo crispy chicken salad, had no buffalo chicken; it was regular chicken instead. it was also cold, and missing dressing. We called, and after some debating with the employees, they delivered the buffalo chicken and dressing. That delivery only took about 15 minutes. They fixed their mistake, but it was obnoxious to have to talk to 3 employees from there and wait even longer for food. read more

My husband has brought home Marco Polo's meatball pizza home, twice, after work. Their pizza is tasty... But their Garlic Knots will make me want to keep coming back. Though I have to say someone went a little too garlic happy on them this time. They used fresh parsley and garlic for the knots. I wish their meatball on the pizza had more taste. So far so good! Going to keep trying this place out! read more

Marco Polo - Marco Polo's Garlic Knots, Takeout- 10 knots for one order - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

The worst customer service in the city. They just made a mistake on my order and refused to correct it without charging me extra. The problem is not the mistake (I totally understand that sometimes mistakes happen). The problem was their customer service. Apparently the customer is always wrong when you're at Marco Polo. read more

Nasty uncooked food.. unprofessional and rude staff. I have been calling everyday for a refund and they tell me the manager is not there. I spent $20 for Buffalo chicken and garlic knots. The chicken was a sponge texture inside, which tells me it's not real chicken some pieces were hard and chewy not edible. Garlic knots In the middle were not cooked all the way. Do not order from this place the staff there take no responsibility or accountability they make mistakes and blame it on the manager that he cooked it so they assume because he cooked it, it came out excellent and the customer Is wrong. The food there is fake and processed. Definitely not worth it. Please read reviews before ordering here. Thumbs down no stars!! read more