Order a bacon spud. Potatoe was not completely cooked, cold and only had one piece of bacon. Noticed not many people in restaurant when I arrived. Now I know why. read more

The food was great, but I was able to see employees chatting in the back, leaving one single worker to do everything. I simply find that unacceptable. Team work makes the job better. read more

Ugh- I want to like this place but there is something wrong with my order every.single.time. The employee that takes my order asks if I want a pickle with my sandwich. I always say yes but more often than not, I open my order and there's no pickle. Why do we even do this little dance? My daughter likes to get nacho chips with cheese as her side item with a half sandwich. Last week that was ok. This week, that is not something they have ever done or can do, apparently. Oh and that half sandwich ended up being a whole one. Yes I paid for the whole sandwich and yes the second half was thrown away. I was too busy checking my receipt for "no mustard" so I missed the up charge. I went ahead and paid for a full order of nachos and got home to find there was no cheese with that. So I paid $8 for some chips and jalapeños. I want to give props to them for having a veggie sandwich- a healthier option than many quick serve restaurants. Even though it takes an incredibly long time for them to make the veggie sandwich (no cooking involved so that confuses me a little) it is very tasty. I think it boils down to a script that the employee has to say, asking about rewards and a tip, etc. - there's so much to remember that they can't focus on the words coming out of my mouth (aka the actual order). If I'm supposed to tip someone to listen to my to-go order, the order should at least be correct. I've pledged to not ever tip here, which doesn't feel great but they have forced my hand in the issue. I did call about the nacho cheese and lack of pickles. After a drive back up there, they corrected this problem. Good job on them, but the consistent mess-ups are making me take a break from this location so they can better train and better serve. read more

McAlister's Deli - Nacho chips with NO CHEESE - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Food is great and I always love coming here. But... this place is so dusty recently. I dont even want to sit down.

I for one love to eat at McAlisters no matter where they are located in Greenwood or Indianapolis . The one thing that I enjoy the most is ordering a baked potato. I do wish they could provide a soft butter spread instead of small containers of hard butter that takes for ever to open them or enough to cover the potato and please make sure the potato is hot . Great. Food but need to improve on this one thing Great Tea as well read more

This location has seriously went downhill. We used to love to come here. Tonight we gave it a try again. Pictures are of what is supposed to be a nacho basket app and a kids Mac and cheese. The nacho basket app used to be our kids favorite, now you barely get any cheese and it is chunky. The Mac and cheese looks disgusting and our child would barely touch it. The employees were all very young, mostly stood around talking. No one came around to check on us like the old McAllisters way. We will definitely think twice before going here again. read more

See all

I love McAllisters because they are set up like sit down restaurants with a large dining room as well as outdoor seating. I have neve been disappointed with the food or the service. The employees actually seem to like their jobs and they always seem cheerful and friendly. I usually get their "Choose Two" which runs less than $9. It can be soup and sandwich, or salad and soup or salad and sandwich. Today I ordered The McAlister's Club Sandwich and the Chicken Noodle Soup but received the Vegetable Soup, No worries, I like both soups equally well. I had them hold the Honey Mustard and the Sharp Cheddar cheese on the sandwich. The sandwich was excellent! The soup came with a package of oyster crackers. A nice surprise. The Pecanberry salad is my wife's favorite. Greens including spinach, strawberries and blueberries, lots of candies pecan pieces with a raspberry vinaigrette dressing. She says it is absolutely delicious! She also had a Chicken Salad sandwich. It came in a croissant. Their sweet tea is the perfect beverage to go with your meal. I didn't get any dessert this time but they offer large cookies and brownies should you want to top your meal off with something sweet or just want to take it home and eat it later. I have used Mcallister's in the past when ordering sandwich platters for holiday parties or special events. They may seem a little on the expensive side but I can tell you everyone loves them and there won't be any left. Sometimes it is worth paying a little more for quality ingredients. I did visit the restroom and was overwhelmed at how nice it smelled. I would say it was the best smelling fragrance of any restaurant restroom I've ever been in to date. read more

See all

I recently visited this location with some friends and had a great lunch! What I love most about McAlister's is that I can get a sandwich with gluten free bread. I ordered a choose two, half gf club and half Savannah salad. It's easy to customize so there's no dairy and gluten in my meal, which is honestly refreshing. They also have some of the best tea. I get it unsweet and it's fantastic. This location got a bit busy during late lunch on a Saturday, but not overly so! We were a group of five and found a table easily and could talk just fine (not too loud in there). They employees were kind and pretty quick! I'd come back to this location in the future! :) read more

This is the first time I've been to McAlister's. The Greenwood location had steady business for a week night. I opted for the McAlister's Club and was able to sub swiss cheese for provolone, and a side of Mac and Cheese. The Club was very filling, just wish it had a little more honey mustard for a little more umph, with all the layers of the club so it isn't too dry. The Mac and Cheese was not bad, not great, just generic... I should have gone for a soup. Overall the meal was filling and their menu was HUGE! Plenty of options to try next time. Now, I heard they had famous sweet tea. When you walk in you even see a "tea bar"! But this tea was subpar. I've had better from fast food even. read more

McAlister's Deli - McAlister Club with Mac - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

The amount of food you get keeps getting smaller & smaller with the same or higher prices! read more

Stopped in for a lite lunch and had a good salad. Our cashier, Jody, was super nice and went out of her way to be helpful. The place was clean and organized. My only gripe is the size of our 1/2 salad. Seemed more like a 1/4. It was good though. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

In my book "Our Lady of the Flowers," I wrote, "Violence is a calm that disturbs you; eroticism is a disturbance that calms you." This connection is something that Americans seem to embrace and even celebrate. The violence of war, the violence of the police state, the violence of a culture that places such value on guns, and the eroticism that is found in the consumption of food, especially in places like this, is not lost on me. But let us not focus solely on the violence and eroticism in America, for McAlister's Deli has something to offer that is both delicious and inspiring: the Chicken Spud. This is a creation that can only be described as a work of art. The spud is perfectly cooked and fluffy, the chicken tender and juicy, and the toppings are the perfect balance of flavor and texture. It is an experience that can only be described as erotic. But why do we find violence and eroticism so intertwined? Perhaps it is because violence has the power to transform, to destroy the old and create the new. And this is what the Chicken Spud does: it takes the humble potato and transforms it into something new, something exciting, something that satisfies in a way that only the most erotic experiences can. But my experience at McAlister's Deli was not without incident. As I was enjoying my Chicken Spud, I witnessed a bizarre spectacle that I can only describe as a microcosm of the violence and absurdity that runs rampant in American culture. Two men were arguing over the last packet of honey mustard. Their voices rose to a fever pitch, their faces turned red, and they began to circle each other like animals in a pen. I heard one of the men shout, "You're living in a fantasy world, man. Wake up and see what's happening in this country." At that moment, I knew that the connection between violence and eroticism was on full display once again. As I reflect on my experience at McAlister's Deli, I am left with a feeling of both satisfaction and unease. The Chicken Spud was a culinary delight, a masterpiece of flavors and textures. But the violence and absurdity that I witnessed were a stark reminder of the deep-seated problems that America faces. I urge you, dear reader, to confront these issues head-on and demand change. Despite these issues, I must give McAlister's Deli a positive rating. The quality of their food is truly outstanding, and their Spuds are second to none. I will certainly return, but I do so with a sense of trepidation, knowing that the violence and eroticism that pervade American culture are never far away. In conclusion, let me leave you with a quote from my own works: "The true revolutionary is always guided by a great feeling of love." So let us embrace this love, let us fight against the violence and injustice that surrounds us, and let us do so with a Chicken Spud in hand. read more

They forgot items that were supposed to.come with our kids meal and that kinda sucks since it was delivered so we're not gonna drive over there to get it....also my potato soup was good but watery...I was expecting a creamy texture. read more

The guy taking our order was not friendly or nice. He acted like we was annoying him. All we were doing was giving our order to him. Didn't see a name tag so I took a picture of the receipt so maybe they can figure it out. Go figure he got my moms order wrong and had to have it remade. She said corn beef she got roast beef . I kids grilled cheese was not good. She wouldn't eat it. No cheese taste and the bread was not right tasted like it came from the toaster. Cheese looked like it was spread on the bread instead of grilled. I couldn't even eat it. Not a happy customer read more

McAlister's Deli - Kadence trying a pickle - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

See all

This afternoon, my friends and I had made a stop to this McAlister's location. They had ordered the Steak and Mushroom Submarine Sandwich (Half Size), with the Cheddar-Broccoli Soup. I ordered the Chef Salad with French Salad Dressing. Our food was fresh and delicious. We were also able to get a fun-photo of what seemed to be.... Quite the Cheese-Pull from the Soup. The Staff was very welcoming and friendly. However, we did notice a few customers that were trying to find a seat, having trouble with finding Tables and Booths that were sanitized and clean. Due to Covid-19 precautions, they ended up cleaning them after being notified. With that said, if they didn't bring it to their attention, that could've ended up as a potential situation. This is only intended as a constructive-criticism. I would advise to have 1 or 2 Employees specifically be a look-out of who comes and goes, so they'll know when and where to sanitize before the next person sits down. I know this can be a very hectic and busy location, so it may be a struggle to keep track. All in good time. read more

See all

The best sandwich place that offer gluten free bread and other options! I love the orange cranberry club on GF bread and it's amazing!! They also offer GF tomato Basel soup, fantastic. Amazing service and amazing food. read more

McAlister's Deli - Orange Cranberry Club (Gluten Free bread) - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

I really like this restaurant. If I want something light to eat, I can find something light. If I'm super hungry, they have so many foods to fill me up. I also love that they have gluten-free bread for all of their sandwiches. I hear this restaurant is a training one so you can always expect amazing customer service. They are so eager to offer refills or clean up your table when you are finished eating. My daughter enjoys the simplicity of the children's menu and the lack of fried foods. So many restaurants these days seem to have the same things: fried chicken nuggets, hotdogs, or grilled cheese. Here, though, she can have a simple turkey and cheese sandwich or a baked potato or Mac n cheese. If you're looking for good service, a great atmosphere, and food to fit your liking, go to this one. You won't be disappointed. read more

The place was clean and it was relatively fast. However, you can go to Costco and make a better sandwich yourself for 95% less money. I can't wrap my mind around the fact that anyone would think these sandwiches are good. If you are really lazy and hate money then these sandwiches are awesome. I thought Panera was overpriced...my mind has been blown again. Never go. Please. read more

Have eaten at the McAlister's Deli many times at 135 & County Line Rd so I have something to compare our experience last Saturday night to and it was terrible. To begin, the a/c was either broken or turned way down because it was "warm" in the restaurant. The line to take our order was very slow. I presume due to no help and I can live with that. Thirdly, it took about 25 minutes to receive our food after we sat down ... not good. Lastly when my wife's "ultimate nachos" was delivered it was obvious they forgot half the dish. No cheese and chili sauce. I immediately took it back to the counter and a young lady who appeared to be some sort of manager at first replied that "these" were utimate nachos but after a second look it was obvious they were not. When the 2nd dish of nachos was delivered it looked like someone had thrown up all over the platter. The chili sauce and cheese were obviously just "slung" over the nachos with no attempt for a proper presentaton. The young lady who appeared to be a manager had a bad attitude toward the whole situation and this is what prompted this poor review. It's unfortunate because I have to talk my wife in to coming to McAlisters and now I'm afraid she will not be convinced to return. read more

The food was delicious and the tea was excellent. However, the person who cleans off the dirty plates is often the same person who takes your glass for a refill never changing gloves. My solution to avoid spreading things was to go up myself for a refill. read more

I love McAlister's...but NOT this one. It's 90 minutes prior to close. The have half the dining room blocked and instead of cleaning tables in the open section~they are staying dirty (about 20 minutes so far). Ordered my food after waiting about 5 minutes....no one in front of me~plenty of staff around just not taking my order. I ordered my food and it arrives...attaching photos. Pickles look like they have mold; which seems unlikely since there is so much turn over of food here. My French dip has about half the meat that comes on it at other locations I have visited~and check out the plethora of ranch I was given (I added it to order assuming paid for it). And the tea....I LOVE their tea; but the equipment needs sanitized here...the tea is NOT the McAlister's I'm accustomed to :-( They should really the location at Shelby and 31 or in Carmel to find better ways to care for equipment and customers read more

See all

Now that the weathers starting to cool off, I love their pick 2 with either half a sandwich or salad and soup. But the sweet tea has me coming back over and over. ( Yes I have the refillable tumbler, I'm addicted) it's not too sweet with a nice size of lemon. Great place for a reasonable lunch or dinner. read more

McAlister's Deli - Two of my favs together. - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Having been hunker down for a year and now all Vaxed up and back from visiting my daughter and grandkids, and made up for the virtual Christmas. We have gotten somewhat brave and ventured out to our old neighborhood eateries. McAlister's on 135 was somewhat of a disappointment this week. Their menu has changed and I believe the prices have gone up. The kicker was my wife ordered a bake potato and with the it besides the toppings the ordered when it came with 2 pads of butter. The waitress came by to our table and asked if we needed anything else. I asked for some pepper for my "country potato soup" and she asked for another butter. She return with 1 pad of butter and explained they were rationing the butter because they were running short and not expecting a delivery until the next morning, and I got 3 packets of pepper. I offered my wife some pepper because I said I have plenty, and she naturally rolled her eyes at meand muttered something under her breath. But I thought that was a little odd for a business to run short like that of a condiment. Especially with other McAlisters not being to far away, or Gordon's Food Service or even Costco who sells in bulk. I know we can blame this on the pandemic and business is not running as usual. However service is trying to get its mojo back. But I was disappointed because I usually would get is no longer available on the menu. What I substituted in place of wasn't really that satisfying. So don't let the ramblings of an old man discouraged you from going to McAlisters maybe you won't be quite as obnoxious. LOL! read more

Won't allow DELIVERY drivers to pick up food that has ALREADY BEEN MADE. This was just a few minutes after close and they had the doors locked and they just looked at me while I tried to go in to get the order. read more

We waited for 40 minutes for our meal and having 3 kids with me, it was a challenge. When our food came they only apologized for the wait after we said "wow that took a long time." Good customer service would recognize the wait and apologize first, and possibly offer us something... nope not here. The food was ok but the kids meal grilled cheese was pretty lame and the edge was hard as a rock. No one came around to check on us to see if we needed anything or refills...nothing. I will not be back to visit this location and hoping this is not a trend at other locations. read more

I've had a heartier sandwich from McDonald's for $1.49...this looks like about 40 cents of roast beef from the Kroger deli and a slice of cheese. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Delicious salads. Friendly staff. Clean environmental. I will always return to this location when I'm in town. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delicious salads. Friendly staff. Clean environmental. I will always return to this location when I'm in town. - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

According to the times on my receipt my food was done 4 mins after I ordered it. But for some reason they set my order to the side behind the counter. Never called my name. Once I went up to the counter to see what's going on the employee that took my order saw me and gave me the look like (oh you haven't gotten your food yet?) she looked at the screen to see where it was and then grabbed my order which was behind the counter and way off to the side. Then acted like it just got done. I was waiting for over 25 mins. I watched a family of 6 that ordered after me get their food, ate, and were about to leave by the time I got mine. How is grabbing a bag and saying the name of the order difficult for their team. read more

The service here is always amazing. The food, well let me tell ya, no matter what you order here its amazing. To was it all down your choice should be a sweet tea, its the best. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

See all

One of my go-to favorite lunch (and dinner) spots in the area. If I could steal their recipe for their Chicken Tortilla Soup, I would be one happy girl. There is no other place that compares to their tortilla soup. Add in a bread bowl with chips on the side and it's one of my favorite meals. And if I'm really not worried about what I'm eating, the giant Heath cookies they sell at the front are hands down my favorite cookies ever. I've also heard great things about their sandwiches -- specifically the Reuben and the New Yorker. But I love the soup so much that I rarely want to order anything differently. This McAlisters is not any different from other ones in my opinion. The workers are friendly and the place is always clean. I have noticed they aren't as spot on when they're busy, but I think that is to be expected. It's also very quick service and I never have to wait for long. I always love McAlisters, and I have just as good of an experience here as I have had at any other location. read more

They blamed me for there mess up with my order and then complained about it then left without my correct order. Maybe would come Agian this was my first problem, would recommend coming. read more

This is my favorite place to get a salad and sandwich. They have lots of choices and always made fresh. They have large dining area with friendly staff. The best iced tea around that comes in a very large cup. Love all their food! read more

See all

We chose to eat outside at this McAlister's because they had a small patio area not much to look at close to State Road 135 they weren't too busy so there wasn't too long of a wait it's about 8:20 in the evening on a Sunday Well my Neil arrived grilled I did not order my sandwich Grill get it came grilled. Not enough chicken for the price the sandwich. read more

McAlister's Deli - Carrot cake chipitle chicken and macnchee - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

This location needs to improve the quality of sanitation and food service as well as to go orders. I found a hair in my salad which was my first bite and was just opened. Threw that away. (No was not matching my own hair, thanks). They NEVER INCLUDE PICKLE SPEARS even when you click to add. They never include extra dressing inside the place or if you add on Togo orders which infuriates me. The soup is like WATER, potato soup, French onion, tortilla... you name it. It's literally maybe one item floating around a bowl of broth, ew!! Not appetizing. PLEASE LOOK OVER THE ORDERS BEFORE YOU SEND OUT. Little items can mean the most. Especially when you continuously forget. Where is the manager or expo leader that is making sure hair nets are worn and to go orders or dining orders have everything needed?!! I should not have to check order and unravel all through that bs in the hot car. Get it right the first time Mcallisters, then we will talk. read more

One of my favorite deli sub shops. Bit expensive but the food tastes great, and the employees are usually friendly, and keep the place flowing well. I like to request a 12 inch white bread sub bun, instead of the normal sandwich bread, for my turkey and beef sub. The sweet tea is made very well here too. Mac n cheese is great too. Portion sizes are average as expected. read more

Went there this afternoon with my parents and almost walked out. After placing our order, watched an employee blow her nose with a napkin while standing at the the pass through window, throw the napkin away, reach into the window and retrieve customers food, pick up plastic ware to place on the tray, and then proceed to turn around and hand the order to a runner to be delivered to a table. My father complained, stating please do not not that employee touch our food! We stayed at the counter to make sure our food was properly handled, but we won't be going back . EVER. The manager was standing right there and heard everything, but said nothing. This is how contamination is spread and people get sick. These employees need to be trained. BEWARE, no not eat here! read more

Frankly, I haven't visited a McCallisters in years. I was never really into their menu or the taste or quality of their food. Because I didn't pick our lunch location this time, I was determined to be open minded and I was pleasantly surprised at the many additions to their menu since the last time I tried them. There were many dishes I would be willing to try and opted for their Reuben sandwich which comes with a generous 8 ounces of corned beef. My daughter ordered a bowl of broccoli cheddar soup and we both had the mango green tea iced tea. Our order was delivered to our table in just a few minutes despite how busy it was (prime lunch hour for working folks). The marbled rye of my sandwich was super soft, just the right amount of sauerkraut and thousand island dressing and a tall heaping of corned beef. It was very tender though my personal preference is a thicker sliced corned beef but I can't hold that against them. My daughter inhaled her soup so I didn't even have to ask what she thought of it! I wasn't even 4-5 bites into my sandwich when she took a bite of the other half of my sandwich and it was never seen again. Is it humanly possible to eat half a sandwich in just one bite?! Anyway, all I had left was the potato chips on my plate - which was a generous serving by the way. I really love that in their condiments area, you can self serve pickle spears, banana peppers and jalapeno peppers in addition to the assortment of hot sauces. Overall, I really liked it and today's visit changed my mind about eating there more often! read more

Staff is very nice, and always welcoming. However; it seems as if management is the one slacking. The past few times I've ordered online and come in for pickup my food is routinely late. Today I came in for a pickup and my order was ready 13 minutes after my pickup time online. I wish the website would reflect a proper pickup time so next time I don't waste time waiting in the store. The real reason my food was late is that the poor employee working the window was slammed with orders, and had no one helping. Also my order was missing a salad dressing when I got home. read more

Great deli style restaurant great for soups sandwich and salads. Baked potatoes are huge and the rice crispy treats are delish. Their sweet tea is the best! read more

McAlister's Deli - Sweet tea is deliash - Delis Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

It's always hoppin' when we eat here! Service can be slow for refills and we generally go get our own, but the staff constantly has a smile, so it's hard to be picky. I was sad when they changed their menu a few years ago and I generally order the same thing, but I can't think of a reason to not go back. read more