Very delicious pies, never disappointed. Ladies are delightful and friendly. Cute homey decor that makes you want to have a slice with friends. On the expensive side because of their charitable contributions but worth it. read more

The world's best pies come from this gem in Mayport. My husband's favorite is the chicken pot pie, mine is the wild blueberry pie. We've also had the old fashioned custard pie and the apple pie is-to die for! The quality and freshness cannot be beat, and the proprietor and staff always friendly and gracious! read more

This place is very good and provides exceptional products the pie is great and highly recommended

A little piece of country heaven where you know the pies are made from scratch. Their chicken pot pie almost rivals my own. Love the friendly welcoming environment. I think they are a little pricey for the size of their servings but I believe it's because a portion of the money goes for donation to kids in need. Also they have a business to run. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Chicken Pot Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

So I heard about this place a couple of months ago. It took me awhile to get to it b/c I don't live in the area. Very seldom to I visit the Mayport/Atlantic Beach area. I got off work early and decided to finally take a drive and visit. I am so glad I did. The place is easy to find. You can't miss the blue building with the big Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe sign. The have a couple parking spaces on the side of the building. But not too many. When you walk in the have like a chalk board menu to the right. With pieces of paper attached to it, showing their menu of pies and drinks that they offer. Also on the counter, they have a "Ready Now" menu that shows pies that are already ready to but. Either the pies can be purchased whole (9"), mini's (5") or by the slice. I decided to try three. I purchased the Coconut Custard, Triple Berry & Bourbon Pecan Pie. The Triple Berry by far was my favorite. You can taste the freshness of all the berries. Like the berries were picked minutes before they were put into the pie. This pie uses blueberries, blackberries & raspberries. The Bourbon Pecan pie had a nice hint of bourbon followed by the the crunchiness of the pecans. Brought me back to my youth when I would eat my grandmothers pecan pie. I rarely eat coconut pies, but the Coconut Custard was really good. Not to sweet, very fresh and melted in your mouth. With so many good looking pies on their list. This place will be my pie hot spot for awhile. If you give them a call they can prepare a pie for you ahead of time, if it's not on their Ready Now menu. This place is still new & I think a hidden gym. I feel that will change very soon. This secret will definitely get out! read more

See all

My daughter bought me a lemon merangue pie for my birthday and when she picked up the pie she was told to let it set gor awhile before cutting so we put it in the refrigerator for a few hours and then tried to cut it but it was still wasn't set firm enough to cut. It's the next day and it's still not firm enough to cut without it running out. But I got a spoon and had at it, the flavor of the filling was ok but the attempt at the meringue was a total failure it tasted like marshmallow fluff from a jar and it wasn't set either. So I think I will buy pie from Publix from now on. Of this is Pie Heaven than pie hell shouldn't be that bad. read more

This is heaven, if you love pie, or quiche or food in general! Just tried the southwest quiche and chocolate bourbon pecan pie. Amazing! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

I'm in Awe at the astounding customer Service and professionalism I received today. Never in my life has someone been more gracious. I really felt like this a part of my family. Not to mention her and my Aunt have the same name. :) i'm not bias I swear. MY FACEBOOK POST: (Keep in Mind, I'm in California) My wasn't around this year to celebrate her Birthday, SO I contacted a Local bakery Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe and spoke with the owner Anita, who went above and beyond. First off they're handmade, ontop of that Anita went out of her way to find a delivery service that could deliver today. My Mom and Aunties/uncle just got them. The pies are still warm. Thank you so much Anita, you really made my moms Birthday. Comfort foods.... #lemonmeringuepie #chickenpotpie From my family to yours Thank you! I will have to come see you and your Bakery when I'm out there next year. I'm jealous they get to enjoy all your amazing food without me. lol Hey Mom how are the pies? "Beyond Delicious" read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Best pie ever!!!! We can't have enough!!! The shop smells spectacular and the pies are to die for!!!

Holy wow! I drove 35 minutes to get this specially made pie. Totally worth the drive. It's a cute little house with small tables inside if you want to eat inside. I needed a strawberry banana pie. I literally called 10 bakeries, none did pies, or if they did, they didn't special order. The ladies on the phone asked me exactly what I expected. They made it perfectly. I remembered graham cracker crust, they freshly ground the crust, clearly that morning. I thought the fluff tasted tart and she made it with cream cheese. They blended fresh strawberries and mixed in bananas and strawberries and placed on top. I'm just so happy, I can't wait to go back and try more. They have many flavors daily. They sell in 6 or 9 inch pies, also slices! They had a meat pot pie and quiche Lorraine! Thank you!!! read more

Beat pie I've ever had! Great prices, the owners were super nice. Totally would recommend!

Saw reviews for this place on yelp and once again yelp did not disappoint this place has savory pies sweet pies anything you can think of I got the country chocolate pie slice and a slice of the apple pie all delicious! I'm definitely going back because I want to try the quiche I want to try the lemon meringue I'm gonna try the coconut pie I want to try the chili cornbread pie I want to try all the pies! I definitely definitely recommend awesome place read more

Salted caramel apple pie is to die for. Although every pie I have tasted has been absolutely amazing! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Salted caramel apple pie - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Amazing!!! I've been wanting to try this place for over a year now. I finally stopped in the other day after work!!! I got a slice of the Margarita Key Lime Pie which has tequila and triple sec!! I couldn't have asked for better. You can still taste the alcohol in it which doesn't bake off. I thought about saving some for my bff but it definitely didn't make it. I ate every last morsel!!! Delicious! I'll have to go back for a whole pie! God Bless Pie Heaven! read more

The crust is absolutely amazing on all of the pies we've tried. The flavors are delicious and everything tastes homemade. You won't be disappointed! read more

I love everything they bake there! I've had many pies, Pot pies and Sheppard pie they are delicious and full of flavor!

Fabulous pie. We ordered a strawberry rhubarb pie at midnight the night before I needed it it was ready by 10 am the next morning.

This place is a hidden GEM! I have tried the apple pie, chicken pot pie, pecan, and country chocolate! If you want a traditional high quality pie, this is YOUR place. Of course, for the price of one slice you can technically get a whole pie from Publix. But... let's be real. The personal attention in each pie and time required to make everything from scratch is reflective on the price you pay! You will never be disappointed on the slice you eat! The owner is the sweetest lady! Whenever you dine in, it feels like you're eating at Grandmas house! The greatest hospitality, and I always look forward to going back. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

A must visit cafe. We came for dessert after seafood at Mayport. Three of us enjoyed chocolate, cherry and lemon chess pie. The fourth ordered salted, caramel apple pie. We stayed for pressed coffee. The proprietors are a joy and make you feel like family. read more

Oh La We their pies for me. I saw this little place for the first time last week and had to stop. I mean what's not to love about a desert cafe? I had a piece of apple and a piece of rubarb strawberry pie, it was excellent. Took home half of a coconut custard. All were really good. I just ordered a whole strawberry rubarb. My only concern is how I am going to hide it from my ravenous family. They taste just like my mom made them. Don't try to follow me I am driving an unmarked white F150. Get your own you will like it. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - No lie.... - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

We had the triple berry pie for Thanksgiving and it was a huge hit! I am never a big fan of pie but this one was delicious. The berry mixture was thick and the perfect sweetness level. It was the talk of our Thanksgiving meal, you need to try it! read more

A year later on my visit to Jax and its all still delicious! I'm a fan of the strawberry rhubarb slice ($6) and the margarita custard ($5) slice. read more

See all

We drove by this little place the day we went out to Singleton's. Unfortunately - or fortunately - they weren't open that day; otherwise, my wife would have taken a hard right and we would have perused their offerings. To my surprise she went on a reconnaissance mission for cherry pie, but came home with a savory cousin for dinner. I fault her 90-mph personality for not realizing the mini-pie truly was a MINI pie. She did have a point it would allow us to try the chicken pot pie and determine if we would get another one in the future. WIth reheating instructions in hand (and a little bit of extra roux) she started to 'cook' dinner. The pie browned nicely in the oven and as we cut into it, we were happy to discover it was a thick gravy rather than a soupy gravy like you can get in the frozen variety. It was chock-full of veggies and the crust was buttery delicious. We both prefer a little more tooth in our crust, so we might let it bake a little longer next time. While my heart was torn she went without me, I'm glad I got to taste. I'm looking forward to going back. They offer quiches, savory pies, and sweet pies. You can buy most of them by the slice. They have mini-pies for some of their savory pies and full pies for most of their delicacies. You can find the different flavors they have on their website, however, you really won't know what they have ready for your tastebuds until you get there. They have a board on the counter letting you know what they have available to bite into or to take home for later. Do yourself a favor and go a little bit out of your way to find some 'made with love' treats. read more

This place popped up on my radar earlier this year as the reviews started showing up. And then I figured out where it was when we found ourselves in Mayport one Sunday afternoon. Picked up a slice of the bourbon pecan pie & a mini chicken pot pie. Not the biggest fan of pecan pie, but PHBC makes a good argument for why I should be. Plenty of flavor packed into this healthy slice. Still not my first choice for pie flavors, but if you're a fan of pecan pies, you'll probably love this one. I was, however, impressed with the chicken pot pie. One day I will order a whole one. On a cheat day. In the very distant future. It was so rich and ten times better than the one's you can find at the grocery store. I've made chicken pot pie from scratch before, but it didn't turn out anywhere near as good as this one. I will definitely keep them in mind when my mom sends me to buy pies for the holidays. read more

I had read about this place when it first opened, but living in another part of Jacksonville it took a while to get here. After taking my kids on the St Johns River Ferry, this was the perfect stop for a treat. We ordered a slice of Apple, Organic Cherry and Country Chocolate. They cut six slices to a pie, so they were large portions. So much so that we had to get a box to take the rest home! Really yummy pies. My only suggestion is to find a way to serve the fruit pies at room temperature rather than out of the fridge. The chocolate pie was very smooth and creamy. I look forward to coming back to try the chicken pot pie and quiche! read more

This whole place is a treat. Adorable blue building, the most wonderful smells when you enter, warm and friendly staff not to mention a wonderful selection of old fashioned home made pies! The gentleman behind us in line said he was from Tennessee and made sure he came back again after trying their pies last time in town. read more

If it were physically possible to eat pie for every meal without your organs shutting down, I would eat only Pie Heaven. Come to think of it, they do offer savory pies in addition to their huge selection of dessert pies, so this might be doable. We sampled slices of the apple, mixed berry and strawberry rhubarb. Were they good? No, they were great! Also tried their pinwheels, which were light and crunchy spirals of buttery pie crust. It was pie without the filling and it was amazing. I wouldn't blame you for balking at paying $6 for a single slice of pie, but one taste and you'll realize it's worth every penny. read more

See all

I'm not a pie person. I like chocolate and ice cream if I'm going to have a sweet treat. But this place has totally changed that! Got a slice of pecan and apple cranberry and LOVED them both. The apple cranberry was my favorite. The crust is soo moist but flaky at the same time - I cannot wait to go back and try more! I will definitely be ordering a party pie for the holidays too! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Pecan and Apple Cranberry - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

A nice 'home-y' place. Very friendly staff. The can explain how all the pies are prepared/made. The wife is obsessed with the chicken pot pie. Their crust, in general, is fairly thick, soft, and flakey. But the pot pie IS pretty flavorful. Every bite has chicken in it. There are vegetables in it and it's not 'soup-y' inside. They also have a bunch of variety of pies that changes quite regularly, and some are seasonal fruits. They also have pies with meringue on top. They offer chocolate pies too! They also have quiche and Shepard's pie! This visit we had chocolate pie, Shepard's pie, and chicken pot pie. Delish! The Shepard's pie is very beefy and have nice creamy mashed potatoes on top. The only thing is that it's SO savory we could only eat half lol. So we switched over to the chicken pot pie after eating half of the Shepard's. But, nonetheless, we enjoy the variety of pies this place has to offer. The only disadvantage I see is that cost per slices ranges from about 5,8-10 dollars a slice. Whole pies ranges from $30-35, I believe? The portions are pretty small for that price, in my honest opinion. For example the pot pie in my picture is about 3-4inches. Pretty small, though it's so delicious! But for what it is, the pies are good! If the slices were bigger or cost goes down, we could see ourselves coming in more frequent. So, for now, we just come in every once in a while. Thanks for the great pies! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Major pie lover here; If you like pie, or flavor for that matter, run here! Had the cheddar tomato basil pie, with the strawberry rhubarb pie for dessert. Both were absolutely delicious! Tender flaky crust and perfectly flavored filling for both. The strawberry rhubarb had a great sweet tart zing that made me savor each bite. The ctb pie had basil leaves and fresh tomatoes on the bottom, which gave it something special; I can't do it justice with my description, but the flavor was so fresh and vibrant! The ladies are really nice and the little dining room has a laid-back vibe. Also saw several folks buying whole pies; the prices are more expensive, but the quality can't be beat! read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Hubs had the triple berry, the strawberry rhubarb is the one in front - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Just terrible. Some of the worst quiche I've had for $9. I stopped by for lunch. I thought; "Okay. Nine bucks. They'll give me a tiny little 5 inch quiche." Nope. Just a wedge. Burnt on top, wet in the middle. I didn't even finish it. The place is uncomfortable and the woman at the counter is negative. I'll never go back. read more

The name is apt. This is literally Pie Heaven. We each had a slice on the spot and each got a slice to go. I had Apple Pie both times because I love apple pie. My wife had Coconut Cream Pie and a lemon pie whose name I forget. Everything was awesome! The folks that run the place are friendly, too! Next time I am near Mayport I will get a whole pie to go! read more

Tried it for Pi day and it is super. Key lime was better than any I've had in Key West/south Florida. Bourbon Pecan was tremendous. Great Apple pie and decadent chocolate. Glade they offer slices to get a variety. But could of eaten a whole pie since they are so good. Took a chicken pot pie for next day. This was super also. Loads of chicken and vegetables. Even though 30 miles from home will be going back on a regular basis. Try it, you won't be sorry read more

I have been looking for over a yr for a place that makes real homemade pies. This is the place. It is small inside, but well worth it. The pies are so good and you can tell the are made by someone that knows what they are doing. We got the peach and country chocolate. They were both so good. Real fresh fruit was uses. And the crust, omg the crust was so delicious. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone that is looking for real homemade pies. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Peach and triple berry - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

There aren't words to describe how delish these pies are!! The place is so cute and the ladies are so sweet!! We had out of town guests and I bought a strawberry Rhubarb, a chicken pot pie and a pecan pie, and all were so delicious and I guess just love them. I can't wait until our next visit so we can enjoy more delicious pies! read more

Everything is outstanding! Great people and great atmosphere. I come here daily! Love this place!

The Gluten Free Strawberry Rhubarb pie we got here to celebrate Canada Day was unbelievably good. It was like a little piece of home. I have never had pie crust so flakey! I don't care if the pies are pricey as noted by some reviewers, when the quality is this good. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Gluten Free Strawberry Rhubarb pie. - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

OMG! I plan on making it my mission to come back and taste every single pie she makes. Great ingredients + amazing crust = Best. Pie. Ever. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Fresh Strawberry Pie (6" single) - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

See all

Oh dear heavens. This pie. I ordered my moms fav for her birthday and got their organic cherry pie. The freshest pie I've ever had and the crust was perfectly flaky, and just absolutely unbelievable. The atmosphere inside the cafe was totally adorable and needless to say, I will be coming bck to try their other pies. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Birthday packaged with a beautiful ribbon! - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida

Wow wow wow. Stopped by for a slice of pie and enjoyed the most delicious chicken pot pie I have ever eaten. Better than the church ladies served at a Sunday social, Pie Heaven is a slice of heaven in Atlantic Beach. For dessert, the ubiquitous key lime pie was tart but sweet and creamy as silk. Linda and Anita are culinary Angels, and I can't wait to try this place again. Don't wait for a Saturday drive to make it to Mayport Road. And when you need that special dessert they take whole pie orders. Love it. Five stars. read more

Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe - Key lime pie - Bakeries Near Me - Atlantic Beach, Florida