realllly wanted to give this place at least 4 stars. So much so, I tried the food on two separate…read moreoccasions, months apart to give them time to settle in. The first time i ordered food was within the first couple of weeks of their grand opening. Now Afton hasnt had a good pizza parlor since the original owner's of Vincent's pizzeria moved to South Carolina so we were all super excited about this new business moving into our small town. On my first trip, my husband and I ordered a large pie, antipasto salad and mozzarella sticks. I'm a firm believer in always getting a plain cheese pie the first time you visit a new pizzeria. Nothing to disguise the flavor, it either hits or misses. If the plain is good, pretty fair shot that the "gourmet" slices will be good. Our mozz sticks were good, battered not breaded. Kinda hard to f*ck up fried cheese but it can happen. Not the case here. They were hot and the sauce was pretty good. I opened my antipasto salad and found a bowl of lettuce with tomatoes. That's it. No meats and cheeses. No peppers or olives. Just lettuce. And tomatoes. I live 3 minutes from the Pizza Parlor so I called and asked what exactly came on the anitpasto salad and the owner told me ham, salami, provolone, etc. i explained that my salad had lettuce. And tomatoes. Nothing else. He apologized profusely and said he would make it right "next time" i was in. I told him I lived around the corner and would rather just grab a new one now if that was okay. He said he'd make it right up and have it waiting. Problem solved and I greatly appreciated it! My husband ran over to pick up the corrected dish and I opened up the box to check out my pizza. The pizza was sliced Utica style, so squares and not the triangles that most NYers are used to. I'm a native Queens girl and prefer my triangle slices but it really wasnt a big deal as long as the flavor was there. It was...okay. Sauce was a little funky with long strings of onions in it. Pizza wasnt super crispy but it wasnt bad. My corrected salad was also a little lacking in the toppings but again, it wasn't bad. Fast forward to tonight when after having to stay a little later at work than anticipated, i really didnt want to cook and didnt feel like driving back to Sidney to grab pizza there. Figured we'd give our small town parlor another shot and hoped for the best. We ordered just shortly after 6 and I placed a very simple order because google said they closed at 7. Didn't want the staff to hate the "late order" people. 1 large pie. Thin. Extra crispy please. I looked at some of the pics posted by other reviewers for a large pie because i wanted to make sure I wasnt being judgy. The other reviewers pics and pics on the Pizza Parlor's Facebook page show large pies that fill the box. The crust of the pizza is touching the edges of the box. This is definitely not what I received. I received a very thick crust, medium pizza at best. Might've been a bigger small but it wasn't bad definitely not a thin crust, extra crispy large. I received cheesy, tomato soup on dough. Picked up a slice, (they did switch to triangle cuts) everything slid off. Cheese HEAVY, very saucy, very doughy. Now, I'll give credit where credit is do, what I was able to eat was pretty good! The sauce didnt have the weird stringy onions and it wasn't too sweet. Cheese was good there was just so much of it. Im pretty sure its going to be pretty tasty after I reheat it in my little pizza oven but it was just not able to be eaten without a knife and fork while it was fresh. Sacrilege for any real NYer. To be honest, I got the feeling that it was towards the end of the staffs night and maybe they just slapped this pie together without too much thought. Posting two pics, one is a reference from another reviewer to show the size difference between their large pie and mine. Trust me, I think you'll be able to see a difference. I will try this place again cause I do think the flavor is there and I so desperately want them to succeed in this town that needs the business!

Love the pizza here. A nice, thin crust and not too saucy. Word to the wise, many long time…read moreBinghamton natives say the rest of the food is sub-par and not worth the money. I personally do not get anything other than the pizza.

We stopped by this place while on a road trip. Being a fan of New York style pizza, and on our way…read moreback from New York City, we wanted to grab another bite off New York City style pizza as pizza tends to get thicker as you get from New York City to Chicago. While we decided to stop in the Binghamton area, we looked at various pizzas online and found this restaurant whose Pizza appeared to be the closest to the New York City style. We ordered a medium pepperoni, the guy working in the counter seemed friendly and made us a fresh one while we sat and watched. When the pizza was done, he showed us what it looked like and whether we wanted it cooked more. He did warn us that he can always cook it more, but he can't uncook it. We asked him to cook it more, and he did a good job. We then sat in the car and ate this delicious pizza. I definitely ate way more than I was planning to, because it was just that good. In hindsight, I wish we ordered a large. The medium pepperoni pizza was roughly $20. They also have and all you can eat buffet, though neither of us can eat more than two slices of pizza to make it worth it. But if this is your thing, that would be another reason to visit here.

Best margarita pie and calzone in town! Hands down fresh mozzarella and garlic in the set tomato…read moresauce for the pie. The calzone is one size and can feed two starving people or 3 people who want to share. The staff and owner are so nice and we're accommodating to my niece who had a wheelchair. I definitely think it's quality vs quantity here. But don't get it twisted because they do get busy so call ahead if you need a pie.

Where do I begin!? First off, the pizza was beyond bad. Hardly any cheese, no flavor, weirdly…read moresweet... just not good all around. The main reason for the review though is the service! There was one male employee that was probably the most rude employee I've ever encountered. We were in line to pick up and there was a decent line behind us and one lady in front of us. We were all talking about being excited about Cooperstown but still listening for our Turn. The employee then asked the people in the back of line to start a new line. The lady ahead of me was like "oh excuse me but we are in line to order and pick up..." and he said "welp you're too busy talking so oh well!" The lady said "what? It was never even our turn!" He ignored us and kept taking the other people's order. The lady that got to skip the line kept looking back at us with apologetic eyes. She finally said sorry and I told her "don't be! It's not your fault!" The employee overheard and said "you're right, it's not her fault, it's yours". Then he called someone's name, whose food was ready, gave them about 5 Seconds to claim it and then tossed it to the side and yelled "hope you like cold food!" I would rather eat a frozen pizza from Aldi than ever stop in this joint again. You want good pizza? Drive to Cooperstown and eat at that Sal's! Great customer service and yummy pizza!

Stopped in after return to base at Mirabito gas station for gas and as I enter the shop to get my…read moregas receipt saw Subway next to their cash register. Hence ordered footling veggies sandwich. You choose your selections of veggies like spinach, onions, cucumbers, jalapeños, tomatoes, pickles, black olives, lettuce etc. Veggies were very crisp and fresh. So it was very delicious takeout. Also they have Dunking Donuts also at same location. Will stop again at Exit 8 off I /86 going south or north,

I walked into Tinos unsure of my expectations but they were beyond met!…read more I tried a plain cheese slice to taste the base which was delicious. There was no overload on sauce it wasn't sweet and the crust was delicious!! Next I tried a buffalo chicken slice (my favorite) and it was SO GOOD!! I got a side of ranch with it which basically just topped it all off! Bit pricey per slice I will say but I'd definitely be back to order more pizza if I'm ever looking for something quick!! (They served me within 5 minutes) Everyone was so nice while ringing me up! Good vibes good people! Delicious pizza! (So far I'd rank tinos high for pizza in Oneonta based on the other places I've tried)

Highly recommend this establishment. The food is delicious and the people are so friendly and…read morewelcoming. They also have some cools pins to trade if you're in town for the Cooperstown baseball tournaments! Thank you, Your customers who came all the way from Sacramento, CA!

Mariah had the best hospitality even at 2am!! Highly recommend and great customer service.read more

I ordered 4 calzones. All were amazing. We also tried two of the desserts. So Good. The…read morefamily deal was a great price. This day a time everyone is gauging us on price, it good to know DP Dough doesn't. Friendly Staff. Plenty of food! I've told everyone in my office to go. See you again soon!

This is the second time they got the pizza wrong ! My wife doesn't eat meat and they put sausage…read moreand pepperoni on it-not even close to peppers, onions and mushrooms. Then they refused to make another, said it was the last one for the night-at 6:00 ??? We're done, T's Hitchin Post from now on.

Randomly found myself in the Hornets Nest on my way to the Catskills. I had my doubts about this…read moredive bar but the friendly service and pizza won me over. The pizza was surprisingly good. It was a pan style pizza and was loaded with cheese and pepperoni. The service was great. Very friendly bartenders/servers that were accommodating and seemed to be running both the kitchen and bar. Place was packed with regulars. Worth a visit!

Delicious. Kind. Reasonable pricing. They don't have the easily accessible restrooms, but they let…read moreme use the employee restroom.

-simple (One large table for dinning in or several seats along a bar at the front window…read more-quick (Ordering is easy to figure out and "slice options" are on display) -free refills while you eat there -CLEAN -only street parking (found a spot right in front)