How do you mess up an easy supreme pizza ? They added everything at the end. Cold vegetables. When…read moreI order a sandwich and I ask for it toasted, guess what. Not toasted and soggy. I'm switching to another place.

Terrible! Terrible Terrible!…read more Everything Cold and no flavor in the sauce! What's worse than cold sauce with no flavor? No one coming by to see if everything is ok.... I guess they know it's not so why ask? Should have known from a restaurant you have to order full dinners at the counter then go sit down. And who hasn't changed their name on yelp because it's Sidney Joe's now.

We have some family friends that live in Norwich. We made our way to this part of town to have…read morefather's day lunch with them. They called ahead and made a reservation for us. It was nice that they had 16 of us in a banquet room, the penalty box. The penalty box was quite spacious for the 16 of us. They had a few tables set up with silverware and popcorn for us. Three of the four tables were great. I really question the last table they set up. It was literally falling apart. It was so unstable. It needed more than just a couple coasters to stabilize the table which they tried doing. Common sense to me is don't use the table but as unstable as the table was, they actually thought it would work. It's quite humorous really, that you thought in the whole process of getting everything set up that in your sober mind it would work. After the whole fiasco of getting the tables rearranged, we finally got our drinks started. After drinks were dropped off, I went ahead and told the servers that we were ready to order. I didn't want to wait any longer. They were gone for long periods of time. With that big of a party that's in the back, you'd think that they would be around more often. For starters we got the giant pretzel to share. For lunch I got the hot honey smothered chicken with extra brocolli subbed for the mashed potatoes. The giant pretzel was very giant. It came with two types of cheese sauces. One was regular nacho type. It had a nice heat to it. The other cheese sauce was topped with bacon. The pretzel itself was not overly salted. It was harder on the outside but soft in the middle. It was plenty for the 5 of us to share. Lunch finally made it's way out. Some adjustments needed to be made since they wasn't enough broccoli for all of us. Our server adjusted two out of the four of us that needed our brocolli subbed. My plate was one of the last to get served. I had to ask my server about my second side since I asked for double brocolli. No other hot vegetable was available so I settled for coleslaw. My chicken was tender. There was a good amount of veggies and cheese on top of it. It was ok, I had a few bites and wasn't all too thrilled about it. The brocolli was roasted and had a nice char on it from the roasting. My son got a side of butter for his brocolli so I added a a little on mine. It was a good addition to it. The coleslaw tasted like store bought so I didn't eat much of it. We started off our dining experience with 2 servers and then ended with 1. Clearly she wasn't equipped to take on a party that big alone. Refills were asked for multiple times. Same with boxes and my husband's slushy. She finally told us that the slushy machine was down after we waited a while for it. She never checked up on us after lunch was dropped off until it was time to close us out. She was gone 85% of the whole time. It was honestly some of the worst service. As a past server, how does one leave a table unattended for that long of a period of time and feel like you deserve 20%? I feel bad that my husband spent his father's day meal here. He does so much for us throughout the year and he had to settle for less than basic food and service. From the table to the lack of service and everything else in between, I would recommend you going somewhere else but here for a meal.

I've been for lunch a few times. Staff seems very friendly. Nice place. Each time I've gone on…read moreThursday for boneless wings.. which are half off on that day.. sweet potato fries are really good too! I recommend, definitely stop here

Really good sandwiches and homemade chips, along with friendly customer service. I'm glad I found…read morethis spot downtown. Note that the higher-priced sandwiches are larger portions that can easily be shared, and they also come with fries. The staff at Wise Guys is warm and welcoming, making you feel like family from the moment you walk in. One minor note is that the draft beer selection is a bit limited. 10/10, would recommend

Very disappointed with my order like everything else, price went up and quality went downread more

Amazing people.. Joe and Eileen are great people. I love their bar. Feels like home to me.read more

Excellent local bar with great food specials. Worth a stop for sure. A few good local beers on tap…read moreas well as the regulars.

Just got delivery from here and had NO idea this place even existed! I absolutely loved the pizza…read more-- and everything else we ordered as well. Worth every penny. Being born and raised on Long Island and living up here for the past 28 years, I've spent a long time searching for pizza that reminds me of home. This is the closest I've found to the classic Long Island pizza I grew up loving! I am on my 3rd slice and don't want to stop.

We enjoy there food. Always fresh when picked up. Serves excellent. Highly recommend.read more

Wings were AMAZING!!!! Service was great! Just a little family friendly dive bar with great drinks,…read morefood, and prices.

We went there at lunch and got a table outside. Wewere told if we wanted to order anything we'd…read morehave to go find the waitress and place an order with them because they were only two people on duty at lunch hour. The bar was not taking orders either.

realllly wanted to give this place at least 4 stars. So much so, I tried the food on two separate…read moreoccasions, months apart to give them time to settle in. The first time i ordered food was within the first couple of weeks of their grand opening. Now Afton hasnt had a good pizza parlor since the original owner's of Vincent's pizzeria moved to South Carolina so we were all super excited about this new business moving into our small town. On my first trip, my husband and I ordered a large pie, antipasto salad and mozzarella sticks. I'm a firm believer in always getting a plain cheese pie the first time you visit a new pizzeria. Nothing to disguise the flavor, it either hits or misses. If the plain is good, pretty fair shot that the "gourmet" slices will be good. Our mozz sticks were good, battered not breaded. Kinda hard to f*ck up fried cheese but it can happen. Not the case here. They were hot and the sauce was pretty good. I opened my antipasto salad and found a bowl of lettuce with tomatoes. That's it. No meats and cheeses. No peppers or olives. Just lettuce. And tomatoes. I live 3 minutes from the Pizza Parlor so I called and asked what exactly came on the anitpasto salad and the owner told me ham, salami, provolone, etc. i explained that my salad had lettuce. And tomatoes. Nothing else. He apologized profusely and said he would make it right "next time" i was in. I told him I lived around the corner and would rather just grab a new one now if that was okay. He said he'd make it right up and have it waiting. Problem solved and I greatly appreciated it! My husband ran over to pick up the corrected dish and I opened up the box to check out my pizza. The pizza was sliced Utica style, so squares and not the triangles that most NYers are used to. I'm a native Queens girl and prefer my triangle slices but it really wasnt a big deal as long as the flavor was there. It was...okay. Sauce was a little funky with long strings of onions in it. Pizza wasnt super crispy but it wasnt bad. My corrected salad was also a little lacking in the toppings but again, it wasn't bad. Fast forward to tonight when after having to stay a little later at work than anticipated, i really didnt want to cook and didnt feel like driving back to Sidney to grab pizza there. Figured we'd give our small town parlor another shot and hoped for the best. We ordered just shortly after 6 and I placed a very simple order because google said they closed at 7. Didn't want the staff to hate the "late order" people. 1 large pie. Thin. Extra crispy please. I looked at some of the pics posted by other reviewers for a large pie because i wanted to make sure I wasnt being judgy. The other reviewers pics and pics on the Pizza Parlor's Facebook page show large pies that fill the box. The crust of the pizza is touching the edges of the box. This is definitely not what I received. I received a very thick crust, medium pizza at best. Might've been a bigger small but it wasn't bad definitely not a thin crust, extra crispy large. I received cheesy, tomato soup on dough. Picked up a slice, (they did switch to triangle cuts) everything slid off. Cheese HEAVY, very saucy, very doughy. Now, I'll give credit where credit is do, what I was able to eat was pretty good! The sauce didnt have the weird stringy onions and it wasn't too sweet. Cheese was good there was just so much of it. Im pretty sure its going to be pretty tasty after I reheat it in my little pizza oven but it was just not able to be eaten without a knife and fork while it was fresh. Sacrilege for any real NYer. To be honest, I got the feeling that it was towards the end of the staffs night and maybe they just slapped this pie together without too much thought. Posting two pics, one is a reference from another reviewer to show the size difference between their large pie and mine. Trust me, I think you'll be able to see a difference. I will try this place again cause I do think the flavor is there and I so desperately want them to succeed in this town that needs the business!

Everything was delicious! Everyone was super friendly…read more The blue cheese dressing is the bomb! Lasagna pizza and chicken wing Stromboli legit!

PERFECTO!!!!!! OMG so good!!! I found this place on accident while cruising around looking for…read morefood. The chicken wing Stromboli was excellent!! Not greasy at all....I dare to say this was healthy, especially paired with the really good marinara sauce!! I love my friendly the staff were and the cozy seating inside was just right! Great deal too! I was full for under $10 !!' That's so hard to find these days! If I was a local I'd be here all the time !