Yummy pizza friendly staff. Cute little pizza shop. Good garlic knots. Decent price will be back!

Best pizza I've ever had!!! Love love love it! Will always order from here from now on. Finally! Land o lakes has something good!!

This is a hidden gem! We've been here several times now and each time we've received fantastic food and service! Check out the whole menu because they offer more than you might think! read more

New Yorker here, this place has the best pizza compared to Brooklyn pizza. 10/10 would recommend Service is fantastic, employees are always polite, never had a bad day with em. Price is okay. They have a great Tuesday special, best day to come in! That's that! Hope y'all try it out. read more

The slices were huge and just off of one large pizza I was able to feed 4 grown ups ( all with hefty appetites ) and a 3 year old who LOVES pizza read more

This is the best pizza in Land O Lakes. I highly recommend the steak , tomato and banana pepper pizza ! Taste like a Philly cheese steak .. Amazing ! read more

Just ordered an 18" pizza with susage mushroom pepperoni and onion. Let's start with the crust it needed to cook 8 minutes longer. Yes, it was doughy. There was also too much sauce coupled with large hunks of diced onion. Any cook worth their salt knows onions contain moisture, so thin slice never dice also pre cooking your sausage, and pepperoni leads to dry and flavorless pie. No, im not from Jersey Never owned a restaurant, just a Chicago native who knows a good pie. This wasn't one of them. read more

If you're from NY or CT this will scratch that itch for good pizza in FL. close to what you're used to up north and way better than those chains around here. read more

Cannot say enough good things. The pizza is great and the best around, but the homemade fettuccini and eggplant is what keep me coming back. The Friday before Christmas is probably the worst time to order pizza, but they were still absolutely killing it with an hour and a half wait. And I waited, because their food is so worth it! read more

The best pizza around, no doubt! Great quality, quick service, friendly employees. 100% recommend! We come here weekly and are never disappointed. read more

Always delicious, never a bad meal!! Food tastes like fresh ingredients are used consistently. Would highly recommend Pizza Pie!!

The food here is incredible. I was first introduced to this restaurant through the land o lakes high school softball coach. Now I'm ordering again for this weekend we are having a birthday party. We always try to support local authentic businesses. This is one of them. read more

This place is totally amazing. I recall a long time ago, I placed an order on line and when I went to pick it up, they did not show it. The actually gave me my entire 50.00 order and said I can pay them if the charge never showed up. It was not on my CC, so I went and paid them. Anyway, the quality of the menu and the owners is amazing. It's our number one place. read more

If I could give this place a zero stars I would. The pizza is overly greasy, I had to pat it down with four paper towels and it completely soaked them. The Philly cheese steak that my husband ordered had wilted nasty lettuce on it. My daughter's chicken picatta was the worst. The noodles were mush, they were swimming in sauce and the chicken had no color almost like it was boiled. Save your tastebuds and money and go elsewhere. read more

Pizza Pie - Chicken picatta - Pizza Near Me - Land O Lakes, Florida

Great tasting pizza. My main pizza shop from now on. No problem going out of my way for delicious pizza. Also tastes fabulous reheated at home for leftovers. read more

The GRANDMA PIZZA is amazing! Crispy crust, sweet tomato sauce and lots of gooey mozzarella - yum! So happy to have this in LOL it is hard to find grandma pizza on local menus. I ordered close to closing time and they stayed open for me, very accommodating! Highly recommended read more

Horrible and long wait no matter what time of day. I'd rather run to Brooksville to Pizza Villa and at least get a real pie.

Love this place! Me and my fiancé have gotten the thin crust 12" with sausage and peppers twice now and both times it was delicious! Being from NYC I thought I'd never find a decent pizza place in Florida but I'm definitely going to have this at my go-to pizza spot. read more

Pizza slice choices were good. Staff super friendly. Food tasty. Price excellent for lunch special. Only down fall not much room to dine in, however more room equals more rent equals higher prices. read more

Good place, Tuesday special ex large pie. Small place in middle of 52@54 on 41. Happy to be a customer read more

Food (pizza/knots/salad) has always been ready on time and very tasty! You also get a LOT of food. Everyone there has also been friendly and helpful. read more

Our neighbors owns this awesome pizza restaurant and honestly, best pizza I've had!!! We loved it! Even the kids lol you guys should def try the pizza here, it's definitely worth it read more

I've use the place about four times now most was for my guys at work when I'm buying lunch food was good price was good food was always done on time always give me extra paper plates and napkins looks clean it's definitely a place I would use as a good standard spot I did stop once just to grab a cheesesteak and I was very pleased with it good local business good people read more

Definitely worth the price and the quality is great. So glad to have a good option for takeout dinner in our area!

This pizza is so delicious! The slices are large & very filling. It's become our favorite pizza spot. Very nice staff as well.

Very yummy and fresh!! A little pricey but I get it times are hard right now with pricing and shortages! The garlic knots could be more garlicky but overall the pizza was great read more

Authentic NJ pizza right here . Even the cheese pizza is so flavorful. So worth it! Will definitely be back

Connerton has gained an AMAZING pizza place!!! This pizza is fresh and so good!!! I highly recommend anyone in the land o lakes area to come try them!! Very pleased!! My new pizza spot!!! read more

The pie was the worst I have ever had. Gave me heart burn. We'll never go back there again. It's a shame too because it just down the road a mile.. read more

This is hands down the best pizza in Florida! The sauce is true Italian.. not that sugary paste you find at most places. The owner gives amazing customer service! Always up beat and accommodating. Im obsessed with the margarita pizza.... And recently tried the grilled chicken salad.... (Wasn't expecting anything amazing) wow! It was outstanding! Amazing value, great fresh grilled chicken meat (not processed) and super fresh produce. I love this place! read more

Great pizza at a great price. Friendly helpful staff. Orders are ready when promised and I have never had an order made wrong.

Best pizza in this area. Authentic NY style pizza, and I'm a Brooklyn Girl, I know NY Pizza!

Pizza pie is the best in town. This is our go to for pizza and everything else that they have on their menu. I swear that pizza is so good I would drive 20 miles but I don't have to since we can order for delivery. Thank goodness. I will go out of my way for their pizza over any other. read more

Excellent pizza. If you're from Philly or Jersey/NY you'll love this place. Owner is from NJ. Quick and good prices also. Tuesday he has pizza specials. Highly recommend! Owner and staff are wonderful and always great to support a small business. read more

Gosh I agree with the previous reviewer. I'm a huge pizza fan and there was a birthday party that happened in a closeby community and decided to get some pizza to go. The full meat pizza was so tasteless and gosh even worse were their meatballs in tomato sauce. Absolutely no flavor. It was the worst meatball dish I have ever had in my life. At one point while chewing my first meatball, I even questioned if it was actually meat or some other weird meat. Meatball even without no salt or any flavor tastes of something as beef/pork has its own flavor. This was like literally eating an absolutely tasteless meat looking piece of thing. So bad that I threw the whole meatball dish away. Pizza as I mentioned was very very mediocre. I can get better tasting frozen pizza from Publix. Now granted I haven't tried their Sicilian pizza but guaranteed I will not be giving this place another try, considering how painfully confusing their meatball dish tasted. read more

First time we have had a chance to get a pizza here. I have to say it was very good! I will definitely order from them again!

I tried this restaurant because it was closer to home than my usual pizza pIace. I ordered a meatball sub and was surprised to find that the meatballs were undercooked and flavorless. I had to doctor it up with several seasonings to make it taste okay. I also told them to toast the bread, which they might have done because it was brown, yet the bread was still soggy. Sort of like the consistency of walmart packaged breads and rolls. This was served with fries. They too were soggy and they put packets of ketchup on top. Not very hygenic. Their pizza, though it was large, was extremely saucy under the cheese and soggy in the middle. However, it wasn't terrible. Sometimes, when I go to a restaurant I just want to go to the kitchen and push the cook over and say "let me show you how it's done". I guess I will be spending a little more on gas, as I will be going back to my original pizza place. I must say though, the staff was very helpful and courteous. read more

Amazing pizza and an even more thoughtful business. Thank you for supporting Land O'Lakes softball program!

Cheese pizza is amazing!!!! We rarely eat every slice when we order pizza. We always order two extra large from here and no leftovers. We also get the buffalo chicken pizza!!!! read more

I ordered 2 18" pizza online and was given a pickup window of 5:47 to 6:02. I showed up at 6:07 and the guy says it's in the oven will be another 6-7 mins. No problem. 15 mins later o go back up and he says again it's in the oven. I notice pizzas sitting on top of the oven that had a ticket stuffed in them like they were ready. I thought it was odd the pizzas would be sitting there since the place was packed. Im still patient at this point. Another 20 minutes goes by so I go back up and again ask for my order. He picks up the pizzas that were on top of the oven that were sitting there 20 minutes before. He doesn't even apologize. I said it was a waste of my time and his response was oh well..... So frustrating. We love supporting small business but will never again go. Pizza was pretty good but no where need good enough to deal with the rude staff and disorganization. read more