We went for brunch and I loved it! The service was good and I loved the atmosphere. If you're in Eagle and want a quick nice breakfast or brunch this was a great place! I wish I would have taken pictures of my plate lol read more

Great dinner! Exceptional music! A quiet Wednesday night! The atmosphere in the facility is always positve.

Such a great place! I have yet to see a band or go there for dinner; however, Rembrandt's breakfast menu is wonderful! The few times I have been there, I have always ordered the Brussels & Sweets Hash. Oh, the poached pears mixed with the brussel sprouts, sweet potatoes and eggs- yummy in my tummy! I wish I could have this every day for breakfast (or lunch, or dinner)! The huge sweet roll is on my to do list for sure! Wonderful staff and an overall great feel to the place! Budget friendly, too! read more

First time and absolutely loved it! Server was great and knowledgeable about menu. Love the atmosphere and that it used to be a church. Food was fantastic! So many Eggs Benedict choices. Eggs were poached to perfection. Hollandaise sauce was perfect. Want to go back on a nice day to enjoy the beautiful patio! read more

This is hands down one of the BEST restaurants I've been to in years!! The Prime Rib was cooked to perfection! The Shepherds Pie was made with Lamb and was amazing! From the atmosphere to the service and the food, everything was absolutely outstanding!! Chef Rob and the kitchen staff produce delicious food! The servers and bartenders were all so friendly and knowledgeable about the entire menu! The bartenders handcraft wonderful drinks! I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

See all

Had breakfast there this morning and the service was just fine. However, two eggs that were supposed to be over Medium were so runny, two tiny little pieces of bacon that look like one piece, broken in half and a small scoop of potato squares that look like it was served up with a tablespoon for $14. It was absolutely infuriating. That was a seven dollar breakfast at best oh and one small slice of toast cut in half. What's happening to Rembrandt? I remember when it used to be good. And now all I hear about is how it's going downhill and this morning it was proven to me, what a shame. I honestly felt like I left there completely ripped off with tip and 2 cups of coffee. I was out the door at $43. For probably two of the same breakfast that should've cost $15-$18. I truly feel like the Owner's laughing all the way to the bank, so I'm done with it. read more

Gave this spot 3 solid chances and they fell short every single time. We will no longer eat here again. 1st time we waited for over and hour for our food and was told by the server they forgot to put our order in. 2nd time we came in and put our name on the list and was told it would be around 10 minute wait to be seated, roughly 45 minutes pass by and we ask the host what the status is of our table and she said that she called our name 5 times which is a lie bc we sat down in the waiting area next to the hostess, we left bc we wouldn't want to wait another 30 minutes for a table. 3rd time the 1st incident happened again. In short this restaurant is a complete failure and ran by young dumb kids that don't care about anything. read more

I think this is one of the best brunch spots in Eagle! Love the food options. It's always great and Service is really great too.

Best food, ambience AND service! Ask for Lisa, and she'll take great care of you too! read more

No dessert? Really? (sad face) Please answer the phone... it would have been nice to know before came all the way here. My 88 yr old dad was really disappointed. read more

Rembrandts - Worst Caesar salad ever... - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

I have been here a few times but today was the most amazing...Madison was such a bright light..myself and two friends sat at the bar top and she was so welcoming and kind...such a great experience....be back soon!!!! read more

Food was fine but nothing to write home about. I ordered the Rembrandt Burger with sweet potato fries. It was good but not spectacular, pretty bland burger and aioli. My husband had the corned beef and hash and my father in law had the breakfast tacos. Good portions, pretty restaurant. read more

I'm always looking for new places to eat. We found this cute place that it looks like an old church from the outside, but when you walk in, wow, you are greeted by the host, then open the floor with tables everywhere and the bar to the right. Which is a full bar by the way which it opens at 10 am for the full bar. The food was good, and the service was actually pretty good, too. She was training someone and it was all good. We were well taken care of. read more

See all

You can't disassociate the dinning experience at Rembrandt from the building, which is just majestic! It's a former church building, so dinning in under the vaulted high ceiling, looking out of the lancet windows is half the experience. The other half was very good as well, service was excellent, from the kids greeting you at the entrance, to my server Stacie. I ordered the Pick Any Two Hollandaise option which allows you to mix different Eggs Benedict options, I picked one Avocado, and the second Salmon, both very good. A great place for a weekend brunch. read more

See all

Food is pretty good, drinks are great. They had one waitress serving the whole restaurant on a Thursday night and she did great! It wasn't packed but I could see it being pretty loud if the restaurants full. While we were there it was fantastic. Food took a little longer to get out and they were out of the first two things I wanted which was a bummer. read more

Great food and service!! We shared the choose two Benedict and each had it the way we wanted! Heidi took excellent care of us.

Average food at high end prices. It can get warm inside the restaurant on summer days. Be careful about menu prices as they can be deceiving on their HH specials. read more

I went in just for the coffee not realizing it was a restaurant. I got a togo coffee which they let you do, I just felt a little awkward getting a togo coffee at a restaurant and they wouldn't let me sit at the"bar" since I had kids with me which makes since but it felt more like a counter than an actual bar. 4 stars for the coffee but won't go back just for coffee. I do want to try the restaurant though. read more

My second visit to Rembrandt's was early Saturday of Easter weekend. Parking lot was nearly full but we got right in with a party of 7 for breakfast. So many great options. I chose Larry's Breakfast because I got the breakfast burrito last time and was headed out of town and couldn't take the leftovers with me (the burrito is pretty big). Larry's is a solid choice of egg, meat, toast and potatoes. I almost got the avocado toast or veggie omelette. So many tempting choices. I'll be back! The ambience (historic church building) is enhanced by the enticing, creative food choices. Great news! They are adding dinner on the patio! read more

Rembrandts - Love the historic church building setting! - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

We are new to the area and wanted to try this place after driving by. It's got a lot of curb appeal but after eating here, not sure if it's worth a return visit. The food was ok. My husband said the french toast was thick, dry and pretty bland. I have to say the eggs benedict was also bland. There was very little hollandaise and little flavor. That said, the waitress was nice and we didn't have to wait long to get our food. read more

Rembrandts - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

Second morning in ID meant a second coffee shop to explore! Rembrandts had quite the hype on Yelp, so I had to try it. Firstly, prepare for the parking situation. It was super busy, but it was also a Saturday morning during brunch hour. I strictly came for coffee, so I did not try their food. Ambiance: fun! Lots of activity inside. Busy. Service: 3/10. The baristas kept forgetting about me. Had to remind them about my drink several times. Coffee: 1/10. Tasted like steamed oat milk, which was super disappointing. read more

Rembrandts - Inside - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

Used to be my favorite restaurant. Went Thursday evening got French onion soup. First it came out cold. Presentation zero. Soup with a piece of processed bread and a square of very processed cheese on top. Sent it back. On the way back, the waitress put her finger in the soup, presumably to see how cold it was. The kitchen decided to put the whole bowl in the microwave and send it back. Now it was patchy cold, the processed bread had soaked up most of the juice and the cheese had died. The same fingered soup came back. Sent it back. Now they re-microwaved it sans bread, but the bread had soaked up all the juice, so now it was mostly a plate of onions sans most of the fluid, with a new piece of processed bread and processed cheese. The plate was caked dirty now where the juice had been and was still the same fingered soup. All in all pretty disgusting management of cook staff. The picture is the third attempt by the unmanaged kitchen staff, dirty caked plate and all: Disgusting. Spoke with the "manager" all the while a teenage bespectacled male kid stared at me through the side window. Please please manage your cook staff. read more

Rembrandts - 3x microwaved, caked dirty plate, fingered by waitress. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Mediocre food at best, with a misleading menu. The menu clearly states "happy hour all day Sunday" and directly underneath lists specific food items included. We asked our server if there was any difference in quality between the happy hour and regular menu items, and she assured us the burgers and steaks were identical except for the sides. We explicitly ordered two burgers and a New York strip from the happy hour menu, clearly stating "from the happy hour menu". The burgers were mediocre, served on dry, stale buns. The fries were decent, but the ranch dressing was thin and extremely watered down . The New York strip was just okay, but the mashed potatoes tasted like a diluted, boxed mix. Overall, not worth returning for and WILL NOT RETURN. Now for the bill -- instead of the $9 burgers listed on the happy hour menu, we were charged $18 each. The $15 New York strip was also rung up at $35. With no paper receipt, we could have easily missed the charges. When we asked about the discrepancy, the waitress told us that "people are always confused" and even admitted she was confused herself when she first started working there. She then claimed that Sunday happy hour only applies to drinks. In my opinion, there was not confusing about the way the menu was written. When a restaurant states happy hour days/times then proceeds to list the items... nothing confusing there. We explained that we had clearly ordered from the happy hour menu and even used those exact words when placing our order. At no point did she correct us or clarify any limitations. The pricing was misleading, and the lack of clear communication was deceptive. The manager came out, and while some rude comments were exchanged, the core issue remains: this establishment is fundamentally dishonest. From the way the menu is written to the lack of clear communication by the staff, it feels intentionally misleading. What should have been a simple and enjoyable dining experience turned into frustration over poor food, unclear pricing, and unapologetic service. We won't be returning read more

Met for business lunch. Busy place. Had to wait a bit for table but worth it. Had Brussels Seeet Potato Skillet. Yummy! This is a favorite place for me. Was a little noisy for business but we struggled through. read more

Sat out on the patio and had a great time! No wait for Sunday on a holiday. Had huckleberry mimosa, coffee, side salad, delicious Ruben and sweet potato fries. The wait staff was fast and pleasant. This place deserves higher ratings from my experience. read more

Rembrandts - Menu - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

I used to be a customer here when they were a cute little coffee shop. They had the best chai tea latte in town! It took me a while to come back after they reopened as a full restaurant. I was not disappointed. The food was so yummy and the unique vibe of this place is what makes it so great. read more

Rembrandts - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

The food was absolutely amazing, we tried four of the eggs Benedict and the kids got waffles and it was really great food. Our service was not so great. But we sat outside and the area is super cute and the building is an old church so that's cool too! read more

Perfectly tasty sweet yet refreshing rose berry cocktail, I get this every time I come here read more

Rembrandts - Rose Berry Cocktail - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Great dining experience--Rembrandts is now open for dinner. We had Pamela as our server. She was so wonderful! Great atmosphere. Not loud like some restaurants. read more

Love the friendly atmosphere inside or outside. Been going her for breakfae brunch or just for the coffee bar. The Benedict's or breakfast burritos are the best. Can't go wrong with anything on the menu! read more

This place was popping! Busy, but the servers and staff were attentive. The pick two hollandaise plate is awesome! Tried the pork Benedict and the chorizo Benedict. So good! The coffee was tasty and everyone was happy with what the ordered! read more

Rembrandts - Nashville chicken and garlic parmesan rosemary fries - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

Had the chicken fried steak, best meal I've ever had here! Service is always great and the food is always good!

Thank goodness this wonderful venue survived the economic shutdown! First visiting this former coffee house in 2010 and traveling again in Idaho, we happily returned to dine in the now restaurant. Our food was terrific and the service exceptional. How lovely it is to be able to relax in the gothic former church, surrounded (but not too closely!) by other happy diners. The restaurant was conducting a photo-shoot of the new menu items and allowed me to take a shot to post here on Yelp. The items along with new cocktails debut tomorrow! read more

Rembrandts - New menu items debuting tomorrow! (Photo uploaded upside down for some reason) - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

Rembrandt's continues to be a convenient coffee klatch good for conversations and close to the downtown Eagle shops. It is exactly what it sets out to be and not more. Don't go with expectations of world class food and service. I enjoy coming here to catch up with friends while grabbing a snack. Once in a while I catch a great cinnamon roll, or a nice eggs Benedict. Service has always been a struggle with a younger staff using it as an off-duty hangout and high turnover. It's hard getting good help these days to be sure but Rembrandt's has always struggled here. I recommend coming here for an afternoon bite and conversation. read more

So I came back here on Father's Day at 9:00am and they ran out of pancakes and cinnamon rolls . Which was a joy kill for my kids who had a positive experience on mothers . Then a week later I celebrated my birthday here and again they ran out of pancakes and cinnamon rolls at 9:00am I'm probably not going to go out of my way to come back . read more

Our strawberry mimosas & coffee, along with veggie Benedict, Benedict, & chorizo Benedict was 100 % delicious! Our wait person was Pam - ask for her. She's was attentive, helpful, funny & kind. You need to eat here right now! We forgot to take pictures. read more

Rembrandts - Strawberry mimosa & coffee. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

What can I say...waited 45 minutes for breakfast, to get horrible food. Food tasted bland and dry. Sausage burnt. Never coming back again. It used to be great a few years ago but it's just bad now. read more

Rembrandts - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Eagle, Idaho

See all

I freaking love their patio! Multiple stationary umbrellas which can be rotated and move for when it gets too hot, which even now, October 5th, happens later in the mid morning, as we experienced today. Our server, Bailey, was on point and the food was yummy! Too much pork quesadillas to eat in one sitting so home with me it goes! Bar menu is extensive with craft cocktails and wines. We're looking forward to trying their dinners in the very near future! It's refreshing to have service with a smile and kindness. It goes a long way for us. Thank you Bailey and Rembrandts for showing us good service is not lost. We need that. Fondly, Heidi and Tom read more

Well Eagle is lucky to have this pretty place .....food ok has a wonderful outdoor patio .... Inside the sound reverb is a deal breaker .... SERVICE GOOD It would be wonderful if they could get their SOUND DEADENED. read more

Loved sitting outside, excellent food, friendly staff, menu variety was good. Would visit again.... I had eggs benedict, I would like to go back for lunch. read more