Went for lunch today. Thoroughly enjoyed it. It was my first time here and found it by accident. I work about 5 min from here. Both slices of pizza had good flavor. I liked the sausage slice better. I will go back and try other specialty slices and different menu items. There was a nice little crowd dining in for a Saturday afternoon so I figured this place has a good reputation. read more

See all

Stella Pizza is a great pizza place located on a busy street in Collingswood. Indoor and outdoor seating is available. We arrived right at lunch time and the restaurant got busy pretty quickly. Stella's offers a variety of pizzas, salads, cheesestakes and hoagies. Stella's also has a variety of pizza slices if are undecided and garlic knots that looked amazing. I ordered a spinach, tomato and ricotta cheese pizza. I also ordered the antipasto salad. The pizza was great. I wish I had gotten my salad chopped. read more

See all

Haddonfield is such a cute town with a busy Main Street. Stellas is a great place for a bite and has a patio area that is dog friendly. The salads are nicely presented and served with dressing and toasted garlic bread on the side. There were so many delicious pizzas slices available. Grandmas pie is popular and the bruschetta pizza looked amazing! The real MVP of this restaurant is the baseball size garlic knots that are to die for!!! My friends and I shared a small spinach, tomato, and ricotta pie which was the perfect amount for sharing lunch with friends. You order at the counter and everything is brought out to you. I had to go back in to tip the person at the counter because she was doing it all! She took our order, gave us silverware and spices, delivered food to us, and cleaned up! Delicious pizza, great staff! read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Spinach, tomato, ricotta pizza - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

My mom bought about 10 pizzas for a birthday party I was having at the pottery painting spot nearby and they were pretty good pizzas. I called days before and they were the most accommodating. The service was good and I was pleased with the product. read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

See all

We ordered here for work, so I cannot comment on the restaurant dining experience or location. I tried 3 different pizzas- Buffalo Chicken, White Pizza, and Margherita. The pizzas were good; I especially enjoyed the White Pizza (very garlic-heavy). It's thin-crust pizza. 3.5/5. read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

See all

First of all I live in Collingswood NJ which is a dry town, and unfortunately my favorite food is a great pizza with onions and hot peppers when the mood sets me to my taste buds, along with a nice cold beer or two. My other favorite pizza joint changed owners, did away with beer and wine, and changed their crust to soft and droopy so enough said. I needed a new pizza place fast !! Welcome to Stella Pizza, a bring your own booze, and enjoy their top of the line ingredients and selections of pizza, steaks, wraps, and everything in between to please your palette. So if you really want a cozy bout plain nice friendly pizza joint, this is it. read more

See all

They have really upped the game with their square thin-crust pizza a 10/10. I ordered the Grandma and it was delicious.

Incorrectly charged my teenage son for a pizza and refused to listen to him when he said they overcharged him. They are too busy to care about their customers. We called and they say sorry but they haven't fixed it. Over $40 for one pie. read more

This place is a cute hidden gem. Ive only ever gotten wraps here and they are consistent and delicious. The place is clean inside and the staff has always been nice! The garlic knots are buttery and good. I will definitely be back to try the pizza next! read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Crispy Chicken Wrap w/ side of ranch - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

See all

Recently moved to town and Stella is the closest pizza joint to mi casa. And that's more than completely fine in my book. I've been here a handful of times now and have tried a couple of different slices including the Grandma, buffalo chicken, and tomato pie. I've been a fan of each and every one. It seems to me like they use a nice mix of quality ingredients all held together by a thin, yet supportive crust. This is also a place where you should splurge and get the garlic knots. They are medium sized balls of oily, garlicky goodness served with fresh marinara on the side. Completely unnecessary calorie wise but completely necessary to pleasure your tastebuds. One of the other things I like about Stella is that there is a parking lot and plenty of room/seating inside the restaurant, which can sometimes be a challenge along Haddon Ave. We're not talking shag carpet and vinyl booths. The inside is clean, well-maintained and nicely lit. Show them some love and stop by for a slice or two. Oh and get the garlic knots. It will be more than worth it. read more

See all

Great local Pizza and sandwich shop with a sparkling new interior and great outside eating space. They serve up a nice variety of tasty pizza, cheese steaks, hoagies, classic pasta dishes, wings, wraps, and don't forget the garlic knots. A few of my favorites here are; the Grandma Sicilian pizza with a crispy thin crust, mozzarella cheese, fresh garlic, Parmesan cheese, oregano and basil, the pizza margherita, the penne pasta with meat sauce, and their Italian grinder (hoagie toasted in oven). They have a kids menu, delivery, outdoor dining patio, ample indoor seating, free parking in their private lot and friendly service. Be sure to try a a filled-to-order cannoli for dessert on your visit. read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

See all

Another amazing dining experience, not only beautiful and clean inside, and excellent service, but the food is simply great . We ordered the margarita pizza, super good, perfect crust and flavor , enjoyable surroundings to dine peacefully, consistently good food. read more

See all

Good pizza and sandwiches with friendly, attentive service. Friends ordered an assortment of sandwiches (wraps, chicken cheese steaks, sausage and peppers) and were happy with their food. I ordered a 9.5" tomato pie that came out hot with a very thin crispy crust and a good amount of tomato sauce. The sauce was very flavorful and the crust was nice and crispy. I actually was expecting a thicker more sicilian style crust (Philly style) but this was ok. I shared half with the table and everyone agreed it was t read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Tomato pie. - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

Have you ever craved a tomato pie? Me neither, until I had a slice of Stella's. Perfect crust- the right mix of springy and crispy and the sauce is fresh and delicious. I now crave it at least once a week. read more

I recently moved down the street from Stella and tried them for the first time tonight. It definitely seems like a no-frills, no happy-go-lucky facade type of place, but it seems to work for them. And, if that's not a draw, at least they serve up good eats. I ordered an Italian hoagie and plain pizza. Due to running after a new puppy addition, I still haven't actually tried the pizza, but my boyfriend said it was "really good." The Italian hoagie was superb, so I'll definitely be back. read more

The past couple of times the pizza has been ok but def not as good as it had been. We still love the garlic knots and the service was great but fresh and as left overs the pizza makes us not want to bother again. When we get pizza we consistently get half sausage and half plain and while I usually don't complain anymore about the lack of toppings she has. When the pizza arrived I was happy to hear her say "What is it with pizza places not wanting to actually have toppings?". This was a good call since the sausage was so scant I couldn't even taste it. To be far we haven't had anything but pizza and garlic knots but I don't see us going back for pizza. read more

The best pizza, excellent crust not greasy pizza and innovative delicious varieties. I drive about 8 miles past multiple pizza places to come here. It's beautiful inside too and the food is excellent. Looks nice too for dinner to eat in. It's byob. Very clean and nice and good parking onsite . read more

See all

Just ordered pickup from Stella for the first time and was not disappointed. I asked for extra sauce on my Grandma pie and got it, which doesn't always happen around here. Will gladly go back. read more

Stella Pizza is a fantastic family friendly pizzeria. You can rearrange the tables and have a larger party. This is good news! They serve chicken fingers and fries if you have a kid who inexplicably dislikes Pizza. Win-win. We had the white pizza and the Margarita. Both were thin crusted and very good. There's parking. What can I say! It is Collingswood, and parking is a gigantic plus. read more

One of the best Neapolitan pizzas in the area. I haven't tried their Sicilian yet. I get off my butt and go to stores myself. I disregard complaints about delivery, because if you want delivery and get a cold pie, it's your own damn fault. read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Grandma pizza - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

See all

I just tried Stella's pizza for the first time today. I ordered a large pepperoni pizza and I was disappointed in the amount of pepperoni, or should I say the lack of pepperoni on the pizza. I called to let them know I was disappointed and the answer I got was "I don't know what to tell you". Not a great response. I will add Delivery was prompt. read more

Yelp has to work on adapting to a grading outside of the symbol five stars. We've come a long way. This pizza is a 6.3, and it's a generous one. That being said 6.3/2= 3.15, round it down. It's not worth rounding up, it's not even in the top of the list for me or the middle. Reminded me of a 711 theme or something inside. Not a place I'd go back to, that being said its standard pizza. Nothing special. See photo attachment for clarification from a longtime pizza expert. read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Plain and Sicilian . Neither were noteworthy. 6.3/10 for both. - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

Decided to try here since the normal place was closed for business and I am super disappointed. Ordered a buff chicken cheesesteak extra meat no roll. Had delivered and when I opened my container it was all on one side and didn't look like extra meat. The amount of meat looked like it would fit on a regular size roll, there was barely any Buffalo sauce on the chicken and the whole bottom of the container was very greasy. I really hate giving bad reviews and rarely do so. read more

Outside of the fantastically delicious "grandma" pizzas from Cafe Antonio at the other side of Haddon Avenue, Stella is our favorite pizza in the Collingswood area. The pizza, salads, and jalapeno poppers (a favorite) are consistently high quality, and the space itself is clean and modern with a really nice outdoor patio section. We often order from the list of speciality and gourmet pizzas, and we're never disappointed. In fact, we've ordered these pizzas for several parties and it always gets compliments. Can't ask for much more than that from a South Jersey pizzeria! read more

SO! There's a bunch of people there who need hearing aids apparently and can't take accountability for messing up orders. Figures. Don't order from Stella's pizza in Collingswood. Horrible incompetent customer service. It's a shame, their buffalo chicken pizza was really good. oh well. (Shrugs). read more

Wow. This pizza is BOMB.com - We got the bacon chicken ranch and grandma's pizza. Holy hell. Amazing! We got it delivered to the brewery we are at, it was fast, warm, and effing delicious. 10/10 recommend. read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

I only stopped in for a quick slice of pizza on a Sunday afternoon. It was a packed spot, but I was served quickly. I only tried the Sicilian pizza. It was a fluffy crisp crust with just the right amount of tomato sauce and high quality cheeses. I devoured my slice and it was perfectly filling. Great spot, comfortable atmosphere, tasty pizza at a good price! read more

Stella Pizza & Restaurant - Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Collingswood, New Jersey

I love their pizza , salads, sandwiches & pasta. I moved to Collingswood 3 years ago and my daughter welcomed me with a delicious Stella Pizza. Yum !! read more

Recently my dad felt the last time we ordered from here it was bad! They used a seasoning on the cheesesteak that some pizza places do and we hate it! We not go to papa Mario in haddon heights as our go to for cheesesteaks read more

Stella's pizza is so good. I feel like I could eat it for every meal, and their service is great and they have friendly people who work there. Their outdoor seating is amazing! read more

Excellent pizza pasta and salads ,Professional staff good Covid protocols.Also A good neighbor-I live on the block and they maintain their outdoor area A-1 read more

Will not be returning. Ordered a vegetarian pizza and the counter person proudly told me they could never eat pizza with veggies on it..?! Thanks for the tip. Do yourselves a favor and try Angelos on Haddon for the best pizza around! read more

Ordered pizza and wings for the first time. There were 2-3" black hairs in both the pizza and wings. Called and spoke to 3 people. The manager was very defensive and said that none of the employees have hair like what was in our food. Very unprofessional. Will never order from here again. read more