Always excellent quality and lots of topping options! Appetizers, Calzone and add on's have all been great!

We got the Amazon pizza and stuffed cheese bread. Impressed by both! There was too much sausage in the pizza meaning it was impossible to pick it up and eat a piece. We did the drive up and ate in the car and it was very smooth. Would go back and try another pie! read more

Great food, beer and service! Worth the wait! Try one of the specialty pizzas and a craft beer! read more

See all

We had food delivered and it was great! We had a couple of calzones, a pizza and a caesar salad. The food arrived quick, fresh and the delivery person was very friendly. The pizza and calzones were very good, the caesar salad was just meh and I wouldn't order it again, dried huge pieces of romaine lettuce, packaged croutons and mediocre dressing. Nice job on the pizza guys, we will be order again for sure. read more

Sugar River Pizza is "sweet"! Great product and even better people. So many pizza joints always popping up, but this one is a keeper. They're going to be a mainstay for sure. Thanks guys! read more

Order for pick up- was ready within 20 minutes. Artichoke dip was delicious. Pizza was always very good (we had hand tossed). And dessert was just as good. We are in the area for two days and plan to have lunch from there we well read more

Nice clean pizza place in what looks like a new building. Staff was super friendly and service was quick. The fried cheese curds were hand breaded and came with a ranch dressing that tasted like it had a bit of dill in it. The curds and sauce were paired perfectly with each other. We had the kickapoo taco pizza and the pizza was excellent (being from Chicago and all..;)). It came with toppings (Sour Cream, Lettuce, Salsa, and tortilla chips on a seperate plate that allowed each person to add more or less toppings to their taste. Overall great experience and highly recommend if you are in the the area in general or are visiting the Duluth Trading outlet store. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

See all

Well, it's good to try new things, right? It's a nice looking building in the middle of nowhere. None of the many hostesses looked at all happy to be there. It took LONGER than the estimated time for us to get a table! And then they wanted to seat us at a high top - we were there with a 5 y/o. Good beer list but terrible wine list. Don't get the Chianti. Maybe I was just very hungry but it bothered me that the waitress struggled to pronounce some of the wines. But, on the other hand, our waitress was very nice. And one big plus is the large sheets of paper on the tables and crayons for kids to draw with, and scrabble tiles to play with. The food didn't come at all quickly, not even the kids food. However, there was a Badger game on, so perhaps they were busier than usual. However, the pizza was very good. I thought the hand tossed crust came with too much cheese, the thin crust looked like it had a better amount. We got the Asian Chicken, which was delicious! The asian sauce was the right combination of sweet and spicy. The BBQ Chicken also looked good. This place is not at all near me, so I'm not sure I'd get take out, but lots of people were coming in to pick up to go orders. I'm not sure if you can make reservations, the hostesses seemed unsure if that's an option. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Kids cheese pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

Twice now I've stopped in for lunch with the fam and everything has been delicious. The first time we ordered a specialty pizza and kids pizza and the seedings time ordered a sandwich, salad, and a pizza to go. Service the second time was slow but the food is worth it. It's also very kid friendly (we have a rambunctious toddler). read more

Never disappointed. Food, service, drinks... all is well at Sugar River Pizza. Don't hesitate to go.

It's one of my go to favorite places in Verona. The specialty pizzas, sandwiches, pastas are amazing. We do the take out option a lot. My kids love the Mediterranean pizza and the spaghetti. Last night, we split a 12 inch for Mediterranean and Clearwater Garden and it was the best. Waffles fries are great too. Good for all ages, the scrabble pieces and crayons provided in a jar keep the kids busy. read more

Amazing pizza! The sauce was great, the crust amazing, and the toppings generous. I had the meat lovers pizza and all the meats on it were so good. read more

Just tried the new Sugar River Pizza in Sun Prairie, it was excellent. The wings are awesome and crispy, we had thick crust, it was awesome! Like a soft bread, with a buttery outer crust! Well be back! read more

We tried the chicken Alfredo pizza and the taco pizza. Both very good. And the beer cheese for the garlic bread...so good!

This is getting to be my new favorite to go place for Pizza and more. We went there for lunch the Saturday before Mother's Day and it was a long wait to be seated but it was worth it. Our server was Daniel and he really made our lunch get together great! He had such a pleasant attitude it made us feel truly welcome. We had appetizer Cheese Bread with Marinara sauce and then Pizza and all were great! We will be back but will make sure to have reservations. read more

AWESOME PIZZA Our family got takeout from here while on vacation in WI. My dad ordered a hand tossed pizza with extra sauce, light cheese, and mushrooms, and was extremely satisfied with their attention to his special instructions. I ordered the 16" Amazon deluxe together with my mom and brother and we devoured almost the entire pizza. Delicious sauce, generous toppings, great cheese, delicious crust, huge portions. We will be back here the next time we visit! read more

A staple for pizza in this part of town, especially on a summer Friday night where you can pick one up and head across the street to the brewery. We've been here several times now and it has always been pretty good. In the months following the opening of this location, it was pretty slow but that has improved a lot. There's plenty of seating but on a busy night you'll need to prepare yourself for a wait if you don't have a reservation. On this particular visit, not especially feeling pizza, I ordered the chicken Parmesan. Huge portion! I thought it a little strange that the chicken was served cut up already and also felt it was a little heavy on the breading, but the flavor was good and the pasta was cooked nicely. We always end up not being able to say no to the loaded waffle fries and these did not disappoint yet again. I've tried several different pizzas and they are good - average, I would say. I did think it was strange that the taco pizza was served with most of the toppings separate, on a plate, ala carte style, when I last ordered that. They do offer a gluten free crust but take care to mention that a true allergy may be a problem due to the presence of high gluten flour in the kitchen. Good beer selection and likely not to let you down overall. read more

If you could actually call and order a pizza it may be good. I've never experienced such horrible "service". Not sure that's technically true since they NEVER answer the phone... Silly! Oh and the website is worthless!!!!! read more

Sugar River Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

See all

I was a fan of their fare, but the people side of the business is a disaster. The newest location is 6 miles from home, according to tonight's staffer. They won't deliver that far. Frustrating, ridiculous and enough to write them off. UPDATE!! I hope you occasionally review your delivery areas. I'm very happy for you- the Verona location appears to be doing great business and I hear steady raves about the quality of your food. I really do hope the delivery options spread a bit, as I have been reduced to ordering from Pizza Hut tonight. Pizza Hut. That's low. With the amazing Maria's temporarily closed it deepens the cut that the Hut is my only delivery option. ANOTHER UPDATE!!! Delivery has been extended! They'll come to my house!!! I now love this place without bounds. Thank you for helping this lifetime guest!! read more

My all time favorite pizza. They do pizza at another level!! Since I discover them few years ago I only order pizza from them.. I love their pizza!!! The best pizza I ever had and I been many places read more

The Kickapoo Taco pizza was awesome. It also looks like a great place to dine-in. Thanks so much!

Probably the best pizza we have had since moving to Madison. It was extremely kid friendly. Scrabble and crayons on a paper table top. Wide variety. Lots of brews to choose from. Does seem to fill up fast. Was able to seat 8 within 5 mins at 6PM on a Friday. Shortly thereafter it was packed! Dan was the BEST server ever. read more

Sugar River Pizza - Table for kids :) ... of all ages.... - Pizza Near Me - Verona, Wisconsin

I wasn't sure if I should give them four or five stars, but all things considered I went with the five stars because the pizza is great and the beer selection is spectacular! First, the pizza: it's typical American style, heavy sauce and cheese pizza. They've got a great selection of unique specialty pizzas that would probably make a Nona roll over in her grave, but I have to say they were quite good. I highly recommend the Mediterranean pizza, even if you're a carnivore. Next time I'd like to try the pulled pork... The draft beer selection is awesome, they've got a number of beers that I haven't found on tap elsewhere in the Madison area! If this place had a few more TVs, it could be dangerous--I'd be coming here way more often. Can't wait to come back in the summer and have a seat on the outdoor patio! read more

Bartenders were so friendly and made best old fashioned I've ever had. They were friendly and made our visit so wonderful. New Nov pizza special is fire!! read more

BEST pizza I've ever had! I'm a huge fan of pineapple on my pizza, so I got their special with BBQ sauce base with chicken and onions and pineapple on top, on their hand tossed crust. I also loved their homemade ranch dressing! read more

Everything was delicious! We tried 3 different pizzas, the meat lovers, Buffalo chicken and the four alarm or something like that. Each was outstanding and the crust is so good. We also had the pesto shrimp pasta which might have been the best pesto I have ever had. Finally we had the Buffalo wings, and they were perfect, crispy and delicious. read more

Best pizza around! The Tropics pizza is amazing! I substitute pepperoni for Canadian bacon and add green olives. Service is always top notch too. read more

We enjoyed a birthday dinner for 11 at Sugar River and the experience was very positive. Our server was kind, patient, and accommodating. She was knowledgeable and responsive regarding food allergies and intolerance. The food was plentiful and very good, from children's meals to shared appetizers, pizzas, and pitchers of soda. The pizza ingredients were great quality and the recipes were delicious. A great experience! read more

I am a huge fan of Sugar River Pizza. I think their pizza is delicious and the service and atmosphere are great.

Legit gourmet pizza! Crust is good, toppings are great! Cold beer and good service. We had the Mac and cheese pizza and it was super filling! Better than the other options in the area, unless Kwik Trip corn dogs are your jam! read more

I have ordered carryout every week for the past five weeks...only because the food is good. There has been something wrong with the order every time. If your ok with poor service or your order messed up this is the place to go. read more

Best Pizza in town. From Sun Prairie, to Monona, to Middleton, to Verona, this is my favorite spot surrounding Madison. Food is great here and my wife and I order weekly on Friday nights. I will say this place gets PACKED and I always order take-out (which can be 30-40 minutes on a busy night). I've dined in a couple of times, the atmosphere is fine and very clean, but nothing worth dining in for if you can just take it home. Moving soon and know that I won't find another pizza place as great as this one :( read more

Pizza is good, beer is good. I am an overweight Wisconsin resident who enjoys both pizza and beer so you should trust my review.

This place is fantastic!! The atmosphere is really welcoming and the staff is friendly and caring. We went for trivia on Wednesday night and had a blast. It was our first time there and we are definitely going again!! read more

See all

The BEST pizza!! I prefer to dine in as the pizza delivered can get a bit soggy if you don't order thick crust. Chicken strips are crispy and delicious. Sandwiches are just ok, not much meat and filling in my opinion. read more

Ordered a calzone tonight. Spinach and pepperoni. They had it ready in a decent amount of time and when we got home things looks strange. The calzone was flat and extra crispy. We cut it open and there was no ricotta inside. We called and were told "we can't do anything about the missing ricotta" now understand that we thought we were getting a normal calzone that has ricotta but I guess we were wrong. It was surprising that a mistake on their end got us "were sorry nothing we can do" they didn't even offer to give us ricotta. We weren't asking for a remake or our money back. We just asked why the ricotta was missing. Then we started eating it and the pepperoni was not pepperoni they were clear, kind of white and didn't even look cooked. And we found maybe 3 pieces of spinach inside. We normally enjoy our food from here. But this really makes us question why we picked them. Obviously they are not the only pizza restaurant in town. read more

The pizza is awesome ! Atmosphere is casual ! My girlfriend and I split a small tropics ( Canadian bacon, pineapple, red onion, green pepper ) hand tossed pizza ! We also got 2 side salads and order of breadsticks ! Salads were a good size and the lettuce was a good spring mix. The French dressing was delicious ! The cheese on the salad is a cheddar/mozzarella mix! The prices are fantastic ! I highly recommend this place ! Our service from Ellie was superb! read more

Our first time back since the pandemic started. Food is as good as before. Service was a little slow for the time of day but certainly friendly enough. We'll be back more often moving forward. read more

Always good food and they've had a really good COVID response

I would give this zero stars if I could. First time we ordered for curbside, it was a 1/2 hour late and we were given a $10 credit. We decided to give them another chance, and again, 1/2 past the estimate wait time. Talked to the owner, she said "we are very busy between 5-7pm on Fridays." Well, it that is your busy time, I would suggest PROPER PLANNING for the influx of orders and people, rather than having someone wait extra long time. Sure they would give us another credit but why would we go back? The pizza is good, that I will give them, but not worth the aggravation of waiting....and waiting.... and waiting. And unapologetic owners who said "sorry" but not much else. And basically said "don't order on Friday nights" read more