While visiting from out of state, I stopped by The Bagelry and had a fantastic experience! The owner and staff were incredibly friendly, welcoming, and courteous. I ordered the Garden bagel sandwich, and it was fresh, perfectly made, and absolutely delicious. It was one of the highlights of my visit, and if I'm ever back in Cincinnati, I'll definitely stop in again! read more

Their bagel sandwhiches are great. I enjoy the ability to customize sandwhich and smears. I have never encountered them selling out of bagels however I have only visited only earlier in the morning. They have parking behind the building. read more

The Bagelry, with locations in OTR and Oakley, is serving up fresh-baked bagels every day Their menu has all the classic staples you'd expect from a bagel shop, along with some unique and creative sandwich options. If you're craving a taste of a New York-style breakfast right here in Cincy, this is definitely the spot to check out! It's a solid option but I do wish maybe we added cream cheese or something to the bagel sandwich because it was pretty dry. Not much seating inside so a good spot to know that you would take it to go! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Solid breakfast sandwich! Quick order and many varieties, a fast find for a breakfast on the go.

Nice but quite small shop, the variety of bagels is not bad, but the bagels are very good. I've tried the everything bagel with avocado and onion and was delicious. It's a great spot to try if you're craving a bagel! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

One of my favorite places to stop in on a weekend. It can get busy Saturday and Sunday morning but it is totally worth the wait. You can always order ahead online! This time I came for the colab with The Rhind and got the Raclette and Ham bagel. It was super good and great flavors. There was just a bit too much mustard for my liking, but other than that I loved it. On any other day I always get a sausage, egg & cheese breakfast bagel. It always hits the spot and I think they are pretty consistent with their orders and quality. I am always satisfied no matter what I get. Coming here after a night out or from a Saturday morning workout class is the move! read more

The Bagelry - Raclette & Ham - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

I came in on a busy Saturday morning .. I got through the line promptly but I was very disappointed with my bagel . I got a blueberry bagel toasted with strawberry cream cheese .. the bagel just tasted sweet - it had no berries in it at all and the cream cheese wasn't very strawberry either. For a bagel place I would expect to be able to get a delicious toasted bagel with cream cheese but I was very mistaken. I honestly thought I was getting sick and lost my taste buds while eating this. I will say that my mom got a build your own sandwich that she said was delicious and well worth the price between the taste and the size. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I have no idea how I have not been here before, and I think thats a crime. I love me a good bagel, especially a fun bagel sandwich. OMG was this bagel delcious. I ordered the lox bagel and wooooow I was impressed and mesmerized. The salmon was fresh and cold, the best combo. Their were red onions, a nice sized tomato slice, capers, and a bit of cream cheese on top. The toppings weren't overwhelming and they paired perfectly together. The onions added a great crunch to the softer sandwich. I also appreciated how little cream cheese they put on because it did not overpower all of the other flavors and added the perfect creaminess. Now for the building and business itself. First of all, it was bussyyy but to be expected for a saturday morning. They were very quick with their orders both online and in-house. The service was nice, fast, and patient with me when I wasn't sure what to order. I have ben itching to go back soon and try something new, maybe this weekend :) read more

We saw this place in the other location but had already eaten so I am glad we got to try this on our way out of town. We stopped on a Sunday morning before traveling home. It was perfect timing most people were getting to go orders because there are only a few seats. We got one. We both tried bagel sandwiches and then took some other bagels to go. It was crusty on the outside and soft on the inside with great flavor. read more

This is such a good place for breakfast in the morning. Super cost friendly and fast plus the people there are super nice and will answer any questions you might have. I got my food togo but there are a few seats inside to sit, most people get it togo tho. I ordered an everything bagel with geotta and bacon and egg and it was so delicious ! read more

The Bagelry - egg sandwich with gotta and bacon - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I catered Bagelry for an international woman's day event at work and i will absolutely order again. I saw on Yelp that the business was female owned and I spoke to the female owner herself when I called to inquire about catering (we love you Colleen!). The order process was very easy, pickup went smoothly and it was a massive hit in the office. They were also very accommodating for food allergies and were able to prepare a gluten free bagel on the side for us at request. The catering menu was quite extensive and prices were very reasonable so I would highly recommend for any event!! read more

The Bagelry - Dozen Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Found this place close to our hotel! Cute little shop, great menu & delicious bagels! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Got two bagel sandwiches to takeout from here and was pretty disappointed after reading all of the great reviews. We got the the GECCO on an everything and the Southwestern on an Asiago. The everything bagel that the GECCO was on seemed to have many of the seeds burnt and the bagel itself seemed kind of soggy. The Asiago bagel was okay, just didn't have that exterior crisp that I was hoping for. The toppings on the sandwiches were good, but I was hoping for better bagels. Maybe it was just a fluke, we'll have to try them again for sure. read more

The Bagelry - The Southwest on an Asiago bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Food was very good. The place can be crowded due to layout and size. Service is good.

Very solid bagel spot. Great selection and tastes fresh. Low key spot with limited seating. Service was fast and received food very quickly even though they weee busy. read more

The Bagelry is CLEARLY popular based on how busy it was during my visit, every time I drive by, and how many people are working on the food line during a shift. The whole process of ordering and receiving food was quick and easy. It's fun to be able to see the food being made. There is also a window near the back of the restaurant where you can see the bakery and the bagels being made/baked. Really cool. The menu is a good size. There is enough variety, but it's not overwehleming. My friends and I got 3 breakfast sandwiches and enjoyed them all. I got mine on a gluten free bagel. It was a bit dry, but did the job. The decor in the restaurant (and bathrooms) is simple and fun. There is no designated parking lot, but street parking was super easy to find. read more

See all

Great bagels and schmears, sando's are good as well . Definitely would recommend if you're in the area.

Trying local places on our trip to Cincinnati. And I can't pass up a good bagel. The space is cute and cozy. Staff is incredibly friendly and helpful. I ordered the Lox bagel for lunching and it was really good. Will go back if I'm ever that way again. read more

I'm hooked my third day since they opened, their bagels are delicious. Enjoying the multi grain with roasted veggies cream cheese the best. Also enjoyed a southwestern egg sandwich too. Welcome to Oakley! read more

See all

Picture this: you wake up on a Saturday morning with a slight headache and a dry mouth. How did a couple of after work drinks turn into this? Did you do jaeger bombs with your boss last night? Your tummy rumbles. You say to yourself, "I need carbs." Doctor Kyle prescribes you join the line of slightly hungover millennials and Gen Zers (gross) at The Bagelry. The price point makes these bagels a treat. But they're very good, and seasoned on both sides. They're generous with the toppings and cream cheese schmear. If the line is out the door, don't fret. They're professionals and it won't take that long. All of a sudden you're ready for buckets of beers at the Oak by noon. read more

The Bagelry - Build a bagel sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Loved it! Great tasting bagel and a super friendly staff. Parking can be a little tricky as the lot around back is very small.

I got this place delivered two days in a row via Uber eats. Both times the bagels came hot, eggs were hot and delicious. We tried multiple different meats: ham, sausage, and goetta. My favorite was a build your own bagel sandwich that I got egg, goetta, banana, peppers, and cheddar cheese. It was absolutely delicious! I tried one of their plain bagels, the cinnamon raisin with butter, it was also yummy. Definitely some of the best bagels in Cincinnati. read more

The Bagelry - Build your own bagel sandwich with egg, goetta, banana, peppers, and cheddar cheese - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

This place was utter chaos. I ordered ahead and waited well over 20 minutes when I arrived at my pickup time.

The bagels are the best I've had in Cincinnati. Whenever we are near Oakley we stop in. Service is fast & friendly.

Southwestern bagel, it was delicious very filling and you could tell everything was fresh. Would definitely come back again! Clean and minimalistic interior, quick service too! read more

The Bagelry - Southwestern bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Delicious and well run bagel business! Service can be fast or slower depending on time of day. Cute little shop inside but only a limited number of tables. Parking is in the back or across the way next to fleet feet. Highly recommended and goetta sandwiches or BLT. Absolutely love that they sell cold Diet Cokes to go with my bagel. Win win! read more

Great bagels. Interesting sandwiches on their menu. Fast service. Ample parking behind the store.

Today I had an egg sandwich on a gluten-free everything bagel and it was delicious! I forgot to take a photo, but it was a great texture, and I couldn't tell much of a difference. I highly recommend it. I'm non celiac gluten sensitive, so I can't speak for cross contamination, but I was fine after having it. It was fresh, done on time and tasty! I look forward to getting it again. read more

Decided to try out the Bagelry for Saturday morning breakfast. The line was out the door but moved very quickly. While most folks in line were getting breakfast sandwiches, I went for bagels with cream cheese. This may have been my error. I ordered one everything with roasted veggie and one Asiago with bacon scallion. The bagels had a nice crackly crust and chewy consistency. I would deem them good, but not special. While the bagels were passable, the flavors of the cream cheese were just weird. I ended up scraping off most of the roasted veggie. Neither I nor my daughter finished our bagels, despite the fact that we were hungry! I would visit again to try a breakfast sandwich but wouldn't make a special trip. read more

The Bagelry - Asiago with Bacon Scallion Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Nothing better than a fresh bagel. Can feel a tiny bit overpriced, but I think it's worth it since it's fresh and locally made. Sandwiches are great, but sometimes I'll just get a blueberry bagel with cream cheese and it's just as good:) read more

Must have good coffee..bruggers bagels better than bagelry..bagels lacked taste..cream cheese didn't improve it..would stop at krogere or go to buskens instead...even starbucks scone tastier. read more

Highly recommend a morning stop here for an egg bagel. The line looks intimidating but moved quickly. I'll have to come back to try the Nitro Vanilla Oat Milk Cold Brew as it was already out but the standard iced coffee was good too--love that they keep non-dairy milk out too in the cooler. The brown butter chocolate chips cookies are unexpected but amazing! read more

The Bagelry made it to Oakley. Highly recommend to come check out their brand new location. The service was very quick and the entire staff was friendly. The bagels were fresh and they put plenty of cream cheese on them. The everything bagel is covered in seasoning on both sides, something you typically don't find on an everything bagel. The roasted veggie cream cheese was full of flavor and very creamy. There is plenty of parking behind the Bagelry as well, so no need to worry about street parking. read more

See all

Went here for breakfast. I got the avocado sandwich with Asiago bread. It was delicious and so filling! Loved how fresh the food is.

The bagelry is consistently good and luckily for my friends it's in walking distance from us. On sunny days, the patio is a nice little outside escape for coffee and a bite. Helpful to know: Pickup is quick and easy, parking in rear, and available on food delivery apps for days when home life is busy. read more

I work at a hospital and a patient's family brought us in bagelry bagels and cream cheese. Wow- SO good. The onion chive cream cheese-amazing. read more

The bagels were excellent. I thought the prices were fair- a bagel sandwich from Panera would cost about the same and wouldn't be nearly as good. Considering how many people there were working behind the counter/in the kitchen, I thought the service was slow. I got my food to go. There were probably ten or so tables. It was cramped and very loud. Not sure if I would ever sit down to eat there to eat, but I will definitely be back to get carry out. read more

Delicious everything bagel sandwich with fluffy cheesy eggs. Very good, will be back! Good parking lot too. read more

The Bagelry - Front entrance - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Nice staff, efficient service, and DELICIOUS bagels. 10/10 recommend and I reallly wish they had a location in New York read more

The Bagelry - Southwestern - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

No matter how busy they are they always seem to crank out those bagel sandwiches in a timely fashion. And because they are so delicious they are usually extremely busy! Kind and courteous staff mixed with fantastic bagels makes for a really good breakfast place. read more