If there's a diner around, I'm always going to go. I LOVE diner food. I stepped in here quickly for a late breakfast and i was immediately seated and greeted with water and a coffee (that was desperately needed). The menu is your standard diner menu. I got the French toast and turkey bacon and eggs. I LOVED that my syrup was warm!! The French toast was a perfect balance of sweet and the salt of the eggs and bacon made it a complete breakfast. And i love that this place is 24 hours ! No frills so i would go back! read more

The Flame Diner - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Apparently, the evening staff is lacking... Food not edible. Service only after to cover the mistake. Atmosphere - I'm afraid to look. If this is what they serve, what do the bathrooms look like? Is the kitchen ever sanitized? read more

The Flame Diner - Red Snapper and baked potato... - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

I swear to God every single time I go to a diner I'm expecting diner prices, but I need to remember I'm in New York City. - at least the service here was great. they were attentive, and the place was huge with a classic diner ambience. - every dish she was a solid portion and came with two pieces of toast and some really good super soft mushy hashbrowns. usually I'm a crisp hashbrown girl but I oddly liked these? - I got the egg omelette and it was exactly what you think, a little bit overcooked, but there was a ton of super juicy large piece of sausage in it - they probably refilled the coffee at the table 18 times in the communal pancakes were warm and bursting with blueberries read more

The Flame Diner - Sausage Omelette Breakfast - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

A classic NYC diner experience. The food was good, the service was quick, and the tables felt a little cramped. Prices have definitely gone up compared to what diners used to be, but overall it was a decent experience. read more

This place is way too expensive. I got basic French toast for $11 and I'm glad I did. The place just doesn't look that amazing and it's very basic easy simple cheap breakfast food. I'm fine with easy breakfast food, but you can't be charging $20 for it. Staff was really nice to celebrate my friend and bring him birthday cake. And they sang to him. I appreciated that. Very friendly service and the owner came and checked up on us a couple times. Again, service was really good because they kept filling up our waters. read more

The Flame Diner - French Toast Breakfast - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

This is a solid neighborhood diner in the area. Lots of locals frequent this place including myself. My main reason to go to a diner is for breakfast, so that's mostly what I've had there. Everything is done well and quick. Pancakes are fluffy. Service is friendly and efficient. Managers are very nice. A good option for diner grub in the area. read more

The Flame Diner - Scrambled eggs and sausage - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Ehh... no frills type of spot. Service was cool friendly staff. The food is just ok. Prices are decent though. I had a pastrami wrap and fries. My brother ordered grilled chicken and mash potatoes. read more

The Flame Diner - Grilled chicken with mash potatoes and gravy - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I had a great experience at the Flame Diner, our waiter Hipólito was friendly and attentive. Ordered the breakfast burritos and it was absolutely delicious we were seated right away and our food arrived in less than 5 minutes. Excellent service and great food I will definitely come back! read more

This hits every time I come here. Portions for your hungriest moods! From their omelets to steak sandwich can't go wrong with this classic diner read more

My extended family has been going to the Flame Diner for 37 plus years. We go mostly for their terrific breakfasts ( yummy omelettes and pancakes) but often for lunch (we love their Mediterranean salad!) or dinner. The food is terrific but the staff and service is also wonderful. They treat us like extended family. Places like the Flame are the soul of New York- they are irreplaceable. read more

Of course I had to come here on my NY trip. It's tradition. I have been coming here for over 10 years with my dad. So I brought my best friend with me on this trip and she loved it so much we went twice on this trip so far. I got a margarita, my usual chicken soup. I tried a Caesar salad with grilled shrimp! It was really flavorful and came with tomatoes. read more

See all

This diner was mediocre and it is open 24 hours a day. The burger tasted good and the bacon was well done as we requested. The French fries were skinny shoe sting fries and just okay (plus they got cold very fast). The grilled chicken caesar salad wrap was also okay, "nothing to write home about" because the dressing was oily and there was no Parmesan cheese and no croutons that usually make them taste a lot better. The onion rings were good and crispy. Everything pictured for $53 seems like a pretty steep price for average food. read more

See all

Bland soulless expensive brisket sandwich with pasty white rye bread apparently programmed to self destruct after two bites....check. Side of $10 coleslaw which could've been made at a KFC for all I knew....check. Suffice it to say that this place must have a damn good reason for staying in business that doesn't have anything to do with the food they serve. read more

The Flame on 9th Ave and W58th IS NYC in every sense! Just a good old fashioned New York Diner. Very reminiscent of the now demolished Market Street Diner that had been on 11th Ave at W43! It's a big menu! If the cream of turkey is on the menu, I highly recommend it. I will stop in if walking by and I see it written on the board! It's a step back in time! Who doesn't love watching the dessert revolve I love our NYC diners and they are slowly closing up shop! Let's hope this "Flame" doesn't get extinguished! GO! read more

Ordered a steak, they gave me a burger. The server tried to tell me, this was their steak. I must be boo boo the fool!

I was in the area and wanted some breakfast. I stopped by the flame diner for my first time. The diner was cozy and felt like an old school diner which I like. I always judge a diner by the coffee. The coffee was excellent and the wait staff was pleasant and quick. I highly recommend this diner if you want a bite to eat. Two thumbs up read more

I would give 0 if I could. There was hair in my food and I still have it a chance but I got a stomach ache after & had to pay extra. Second time dinning here. First time drunk and hungry. Second time sober and hungry and with a foot injury and cane and this is the time I got a stomach ache after Food 0/5 My food had hair The eggs Benedict Florentine are not poached but the egg is broken and yolk runs outside cooked The server claimed Florentine came with feta albeit the menu does not say it and it did NOT The eggs Benedict Lox not only cooked but over cooked the lox (yes, it's possible) The potatoes or diner fries as they are called are soggy instead of crispy and have 0 flavor The omelette came with toast. Toast was the best food item Service 0/5 Server was good with his words and apologized about the hair BUT his actions were another thing I asked server replaced Benedict Florentine w/ Benedict Lox so I can better see hair because the spinach in the Florentine is dark What I did not expect: the server asked for me to pick anything to replace the Florentine ($18.95) so he could apologize for the hair and I chose Lox ($19.95) and he charged me for the $1 difference We did NOT expect a discount but I did NOT know I had to pay someone to make up for a mistake they committed. I am NOT talking about the server (only) but the restaurant itself plus kitchen staff and lack of hair caps Price 0/5 It's pricey for a diner especially for one with hair in your food. We paid $40 for 2 entrees before tip. Ambiance 0/5 It's a typical diner but not the Manhattan trendy way, but the local mom and pop shop that smells like bleach and people hand write orders on the lined notepad that has a "total" field Verdict: I rather vomit when completely drunk AND walk 6 streets down when sober and hungry even with a foot injury and cane than eat here a 3rd time My brother still tipped 20% read more

See all

24 hour diner just round the corner from where I'm staying makes it a very convenient location when one is hungry in the middle of the night. We came over for breakfast food as recommended by my friend. Stick with the breakfast stuff. They do it better than the other food. I had the corned beef hash and eggs. It came with toast and potatoes. I like the corned beef here, very tasty. Service was a bit lacking when we were there. The server forgot my friend's order and we had to remind them. Payment is at the cashier near the front. read more

See all

Order pancakes and they came with no syrup no butter... what................................................................................

Came here for dinner and it was actually kind of packed ! The vibe is very old school diner. Service was good. TEX MEX QUESADILLA The hybrid I needed between breakfast food and cheesy quesadilla I was looking for. Diner food is diner food but this just hit the spot for me. I think it could have used hot sauce but the jalapeños scattered in the quesadilla itself are a very nice touch and take this from basic to quite tasty. Would def come back here again when in the mood for diner food. read more

See all

First time ordering to go here - big mistake! The old lady at the front, flashing her aggressively red nails, took my order like she was running a Michelin-starred restaurant--when in reality, she's just a cashier with an attitude. Food? Eh, it's edible. But if you value your health, do not drink anything here. I asked for hot tea. She asked what kind, rattling off a lineup of what were clearly bargain-bin teas from supermarket boxes. I said, "Never mind." That should've been the end of it. But no--she suddenly discovered a new level of patience and repeated the flavors like I didn't understand English. Fine, I said, "Just hot water." I was fully prepared to pay for it, but then she hit me with, "No, that need to pay. That's $1.50." The audacity. $1.50. For water. And not just any water--served in the absolute tiniest coffee cup possible. I asked for a bigger cup, and suddenly, it turned into a full-blown soap opera--cue the dramatic side-eye exchange between her and another employee. Truly next-level pettiness and peak low-class behavior. I have no issue paying for water. But It tasted exactly like gym pool water. Guaranteed chlorine overdose. So, for anyone planning to eat here--if you don't have a death wish, DO NOT DRINK ANYTHING THERE! The moment they add a tea bag or coffee, you won't even realize you're sipping on chemical soup. Stay safe! read more

The Flame Diner - This is where all their drinks belong. - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Everyone in my party agreed the food was just okay, so the high prices seemed unwarranted. My plain beyond burger, which did not come with fries or anything, came out to about $17, which is a lot for a mediocre burger. In addition, the service was a mixed bag. Our server was nice, but he and other servers seemed pretty eager to clear our table as quick as possible even though there were other open tables. Again, the food was fine, but you can almost certainly find better options at the same price point. read more

I had lunch with 2 co-workers here today. I was happy that we were seated in a booth to add to that old school diner appeal. Service was attentive and efficient. The menu options were plentiful. The prices were a bit high for diner food but they are Manhattan prices after all. I ordered a feta and spinach omelette with home fries. Surprisingly it was not greasy but it lacked enough flavor so I added some salt and pepper and all was good. Regardless though, i just love diners and this area definitely benefits from having this one. read more

The Flame Diner - Fresh Spinach and Feta Cheese Omelette Breakfast - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

ugh! $20 for a Greek salad that was inedible. Floors were mopped with strong scent of ammonia while I was drinking my weak iced tea. what a depressing place. read more

Classic diner interior but very clean with well maintained tables, floors, and bathrooms. Solid food for the speed it comes out and the 24/7 hours. My water glass was kept full every 2-3 minutes. read more

The Flame Diner - Pizza Burger Deluxe - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place is the perfect place to have a meal after a late movie. Lots of tables, quiet, plenty of space. The food came a bit colder than expected but it didn't really affect the taste, so no big deal. Very good, very tasty, just a classic diner taste. Fries are thin and crispy, and better than I was expecting. I wish the poached eggs were goopier and the corned beef has crispier. The service was great and they had awesome recommendations. read more

The Flame Diner - Corned Beef Hash - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Blt on toasted rye. Perfectly made with the tomato in the middle sandwiched between the bacon slathered bacon and the crunchy bite of lettuce. Service was good. Old time neighborhood diner. read more

The Flame Diner - Blt on rye toast - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Totally screwed up order and had no desire to correct their mistake. Way to expensive to deal with their unwillingness to respond to customer issues. read more

Great food but seriously what is up with the soft drink policy? No free refills on your 10 oz sodas from a fountain? And $3.50 for each? What a rip off. read more

Bottom Line: Great for a quick meal, casual meal if you are in the area. My husband and I were in search of an early and quick breakfast while staying next door at The Algonquin. As luck would have it, The Flame Diner was right next door to the hotel and it opened earlier for breakfast than the hotel's lobby restaurant. On an early Sunday morning we were seated immediately and our food came out quickly. I enjoyed an omelette and my husband had his standard eggs, hash browns and bacon. Our meals weren't gourmet but they were satisfying and about what we were expecting for a diner breakfast. Service was attentive. read more

I cannot believe I have never reviewed the Flame! I often frequented the Flame for dining in and take out when I was studying basically down the block at Fordham. It was a staple of the entire university and I'm sure it still is. I had breakfast here twice during my in-laws' visit. Both times, we were in and out in a timely manner and service was always excellent. Our coffee was always topped up and we had more than enough food. Portion sizes continue to be super big and filling. I had a California omelet the first time and a breakfast quesadilla the second time. Others in my party had pancakes, French toast, and omelets. Everyone really enjoyed everything and the prices are very fair. I honestly think The Flame was my MIL's favorite restaurant the entire week she was in town! read more

Burgers at midnight were a disaster. Order a freshly made omelette instead. 23-he dining is always welcome.

Was craving diner food and decided to stop by here around 9pm on a weekday evening. It was surprisingly busy giving the timing but there's ample seating. Tried one of the omelettes and overall liked it! The food was slightly over cooked / dry. I'd go back for diner food. read more

The Flame Diner - Farmer's Omelette Breakfast - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

The family wanted a New York diner experience. I wanted to get in and out fast because of other considerations. They handed us the standard thick diner menu. Every one of us ordered something different. Everyone was very pleased with the food and the service. And we were in and out quickly. Fast and good is a nice combination. read more

Great service, extremely clean diner, and tasty meals! What more could a girl ask for? read more

The Flame Diner - Southwestern Burrito - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

The Slim Line is a simple meal of a burger patty, peach half, cottage cheese, and melba toast + breadsticks. The flame grilled patty was unbelievably delicious, perfectly cooked top quality meat. What a treat. And the service was excellent. read more

The Flame Diner - Slim-Line - Diners Near Me - New York, New York

Yes, it truly is the very best NYC has to offer. No matter what time of day, this place is going to deliver, and the food and service simply cannot be beaten. Whether for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, if you are near Columbus and 58th, this has to be a stop for you. If you want great food, fine service, and a nice family atmosphere, that is for sure, folks! read more

Okay, I will admit it. We showed up rather intoxicated but hurting for some food, like pancakes, hot wings, or both at like 2am? I can't remember so is that bad, don't judge me! I do remember we were rather sober compared to other people having a blast in this true to life NYC diner. Quick YELP Help - go here if you're near Columbus Circle after midnight. Not sure what the place is like during non vampire hours. Location: Perfect for what it is.. Menu: I am pretty sure nothing is healthy, healthy was not on my radar. Food: I ate it, most of it. The buzz faded as the grease absorb the alcohol and I felt like I needed to forget what I just swallowed, so what did I do? Bar: What the hell was I thinking, I ordered a Long Island Iced Tea like I needed it... well they do have a bar if your binging which apparently I was, idiot you're going to pay for this one which I did. Wait Staff: So awesome during the early morning hours anyway, they are pros who relate to drunk people and I think they are all related or share the same DNA somehow. Super guys, funny we had a lot of fun I am sure of it. Value: Oh, I have no idea I don't remember paying so thank goodness I took a photo of the menu. Just kidding, It was a fair exchange and near our hotel. Full disclosure: We visited The Flame twice, kind of a NYC deja vu kind of thing I guess... We had an awesome week in NYC, so much fun and the Flame was a memorable place... Scary they remembered us, hope that was a good thing. read more

See all

My friends and I have been frequenting this diner for the last few months. It has become our new go-to for a quick, consistent meal. We love getting diner staples and are excited to try more items as we continue to come. Pancakes are super awesome as well as wraps and grilled cheese. We haven't strayed too far from typical diner food so can't speak to that, but if you're in the mood for pancakes, these ones are amazing. Service is great, water is speedily refilled. Ambiance is very NYC diner-esque with colorful booth seating and bright lights. read more

See all

If only I could give this place negative stars... DO NOT GO HERE!!!!! They gave us RAW CHICKEN in our chicken quesadilla. Please see the photo. We asked them to place take it away and they didn't even apologize. Then they charged us for something they fully forgot to give us. When you see the chicken they gave us you will find it crazy they had the audacity to still charge us 53 dollars for two orders of mozz sticks and one order of chicken tenders. If you care about your health stay far away from this place. My friends and I are going to the actual doctors because we likely have salmonella. This place should be shut down. read more

See all