We went there with our son and his family , consisting on a one year old and a three year. They had coloring page for them to work on. They enjoyed their food. All of the food was delicious. We even had a spilled drink, we cleaned it up our selves. The price was good, the food was good and our waitress was wonderful. Oh I wanted to comment, I use a rollator. We were able to park in handicap capped parking right out side the door. My rollator was not a problem at all. read more

My wife and I have eaten here several times. The food had always been pretty good until this visit. I ordered the garlic fettuccine with shrimp. Not good. You could see the fettuccine was not cooked fresh and it looked old. The garlic cream sauce was like glue. A few of the shrimp still had the shells on their tails (I found this out while eating them). I ate most of it because I was hungry, but mentioned to the waiter that I was disappointed with the meal. It just wasn't as good as others I had there. I was happy that the manager took my meal off the bill. However, later in the evening I did not feel well. I was nauseated and my stomach hurt. I can only attribute this condition to the dinner I had. My wife had the spaghetti and meatballs (which is what I usually order) and she had no issues. I won't let this incident keep me from going back again. I just won't get the garlic fettuccine with shrimp. read more

PROS: +plenty of parking to west of restaurant +bread brought to table was fresh / hot +our server Josh was very personable and positive +variety of sauce options for spaghetti +value for quantity of food [salad / entree / ice cream] included in 1 price is good [Spinach & Cheese Ravioli 19.25; Pasta with Clam Sauce 17.75] NEUTRAL: ~most all of our food was just OK flavor-wise, nothing we definitely would order again, but most of it not bad ~atmosphere is 'eclectic' I suppose between trolley with tables in dining room, standard tables and booths around the main room, kind of cool glass lamp shades over many of the tables, and large cushioned chairs around tables for 2 in spots CONS: -the timing for the beginning of our meal was less than ideal as we received our salads and ate them before we received our wine and eventually our bread a bit prior to our entrees finally arriving. -the included salad that comes with the meal is a subpar basic offering -high ceiling may contribute to a higher noise level in the space -our table was positioned against the end of the trolley, which was very close to the table within the trolley (one of the kids from the family inside the trolley was frequently leaning out above our table). It also is in front of double-doors the the east through which a lot of light pours in and folks from the outside who don't know approach thinking they are the front doors. -discolorization of the fabric on the large chairs seems to give the impression that they aren't completely clean OVERALL: Perhaps our experience would have been improved had we dined at a different table. Not sure we would necessarily return unless we had a very good deal to take advantage of and a different spot for our meal. read more

The decor is the same as all the other TOSF. Pleasant, clean. We had a large party at noon and our server was amazing. We were served our food by the manager, and she was fantastic! I thought the food was basic at best. My meatballs were very dry and hard. The spumoni ice cream is always a favorite. Pistachio ice cream with chocolate and cherry ice cream. The real deal spumoni. I will go back, but probably order something else read more

It has been years since my last visit to one of these stores but, we have my 19-month old and need some kid-friendly places lately. After visiting the Christmas Market nearby - we stopped in for dinner and had to wait about 40 minutes and the staff were exceptionally understanding about my adventurous daughter who doesn't like to sit still. When they seated us, we were in a quiet back room area and our waitress was prompt and took excellent care of us. I didn't realize everything was a 3-course meal and the prices were very fair for the portion size and amount of food. I chose the meatballs with meat-sauce and angel hair pasta, a ceasar salad, and spumoni ice cream. The bread was delicious and the portions were huge. The salad was out quickly and served on a chilled plate and was a huge portion. The meat sauce was delicious and hot with two large meatballs. I couldn't finish it all but I sure did try! My daughter enjoyed herself and the pace and meal was exactly what we needed! Love the location near in the Carmel City Center. Plenty of nearby free parking and lots to see and do. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

My wife and I were craving some solid pasta and thought let's go to The Old spaghetti Factory. We arrived and were greeted after a short wait and then seated immediately. The restaurant was clean and forgot how nice the atmosphere was here. Our waiter Lashon came around shortly after being settled in. He took our orders and we got our drinks quickly and soon after our bread, salad and soup. Our entrees came next my wife got fettuccine Alfredo and I got the dish they are know for the Mitzhra brown butter pasta. Both of our meals were cooked well and very fresh. After our meal we got our ice cream and both agreed that this is just as good as we had remembered. The value here is great for the servings and overall great quality and service at this Carmel, IN location. read more

See all

Visited for lunch. Interior dining room was very fancy looking and well decorated. It was a busy lunch service and some people in my party had to leave before ordering. Food was delicious. Ordered the pot pourri with four different sauces. Loved the different flavors in one plate. Spumoni ice cream was refreshing. read more

See all

Had a server spill a tray of drinks down my back as soon as I sat down. Accidents happen. But surprised I didn't get offered or comp'd anything. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - White Clam Sauce - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

It feels weird giving a chain 5 stars. But I can't lie. I've never had a bad meal at this location. The food is always great, the staff are always friendly, and the dinning room is always clean and inviting. This has been one of our go-to dinning out options for years. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

12.7.25 popped in on a Sunday, early for dinner, but that was great because we got parking and seated right away (I will say, the hostess look annoyed with some others in the lobby), and by the time we got our food, the place was packed. This time, we tried a few different things & had the calamari; I had the minestone soup and chicken marsala; hubs has the caesar salad and chicken parm; we both had the spumoni. I do like that it's the three courses inclusive in the price, that makes everything pretty reasonable. Our food was good, and I had leftovers for lunch the next day. Service was very friendly (nice young man), but it did take a while. (The world is understaffed.) There were lots of people in the waiting area by the time we left, so rsvps are probably a great idea. #yum #ReviewsByRL read more

Visited Old Spaghetti Factory on Rangeline Road. It is a chain sitdown restaurant. They have a full bar I got the Meat Lovers Treat for $20.99. It is spaghetti with a Sicilian meatballs, Italian sausage and meat sauce. My wife got the. Manager's Favorite. You could pair any two of the Pasta Classics for $18.99. She got the mushroom sauce and the cheese and brown butter. Both meals came with hot bread, choice of soup, or salad, and ice cream. I really liked the sausage and meat sauce. Of the two pastas my wife got, she preferred the mushroom sauce. It was a red sauce with mushrooms. The cheese and brown butter was more a white sauce, and a little rich for her taste. However, our server said that it was one of the customer favorites. So, give it a try, you may like it! We sat in the bar area. Our server was friendly and prompt. Our food was quick to be delivered and was hot. We find it funny, every time we visit, that their Parmesan is the stuff out of the green can. We always wish they served fresh shaved Parmesan cheese, similar to Olive Garden. As mentioned, this is a chain restaurant. Do not come here expecting fresh handmade or unique pasta dishes. But if you are looking for something quick and easy, and the price reflecting the quality, give it a try. The atmosphere is nice, and kids would enjoy eating inside the trolly. read more

See all

Ordered to follow. It had been years since we had eaten at the old spaghetti factory. We will not make that mistake again. Very small serving size of spaghetti, with very little meat sauce, the side salad was also very small and had nothing but lettuce. It was a very disappointing experience! read more

Haven't been to a OSF for 25 or so years. Now I know why . It took forever to get our food and it was like warm when it arrived. Meat sauce was terrible flavor and runny. Meat balks were over cooked. Service was awesome that's why it's not a 1 star review. Save you money and go somewhere else read more

We had not been to an old spaghetti factory forever. We thought we would give it a try 4 of us made reservations. Dinner includes soup or salad and the main course along with spumoni ice cream. They also have a senior member which is served as a smaller portions and costs $2.00 less. We notice the restaurant itself is so clean and polished. You would not know you are in the middle of downtown Carmel. Parking is crazy. We parked on the street only to find they had a lovely parking spot in the back. Seating was nice and semi-private. A party of about 30 people came in just after us, but our waitress was aware and waited on both tables without any problem. We each had something different. Two had soup and two had salad. The soup was delicious and a rather big bowl. The salads were head lettuce and also a more than fair serving. The lettuce was cold and crisp. Two of us had mizithra Cheese with burnt butter and I had spaghetti with meat sauce. Lastly one had chicken parmesan. Everyone was pleased and end was the spumoni ice cream. Wonderful. No pictures were taken as it would have been in appropriate but if you look at their web page or menu you will see everything we had photo'd Will we go back again, you Betcha! read more

First of all, the place is absolutely beautiful. The food came out quickly and it was well-seasoned and hot.The server: Katherine was great! She was friendly and great with our two kids. Will definitely come back! It brought back amazing memories of field trips when I was young. Thank you for continuing the excellent service. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

The location is fantastic and the ambience is just beyond fabulous... love the train car that you can eat in and staff is always exceptional. Unfortunately, we've eaten here five times and have just never loved the food. And the prices are just way too high to not love it. Maybe it's one of those try-for-yourself places because it's worth it to say you've been here Atleast once. Just not somewhere we'll go back to. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Beautiful Christmas decorations in a beautifully appointed restaurant... - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Haven't been in years. Went for my 55th birthday. It was as I remembered. The brown butter pasta was outstanding!! Some of the best pasta I've ever had. The only complaint I had was our server was less than intended in waiting on us. No personality at all. He acted like he didn't want to be there at all. I would definitely go back. Just won't want that waiter again. read more

Walked in and was ignored for a bit. The hostess sat multiple people with never greeting. I even had a reservation. We ended up just leaving. read more

It's been quite a spell since I last ate at one of the links in the Old Spaghetti Factory chain, but we throughly enjoyed the food at this one :-) Tip: I had a draft pale ale to pair with my meal; it was nice, delicious, and icy cold - just the way the hops gods intended The venue and the restrooms were clean; the entire place was very nice. The prices were reasonable given the quality and quantity of food - I'd be happy to come back for another meal. read more

See all

We love this Old Spaghetti Factory location. We always asked to sit in the chairs by the far windows - large wing backed chairs away from larger groups. My usual order is the Managers Favorite, pairing the white clam sauce with brown butter with Mizithra cheese. The chef will probably hate me, but I immediately stir the two together and eat them in combination. Delicious! This combination, along with the house salad with creamy pesto dressing, and spumoni for dessert, makes for a lovely meal. Oh, and I always include a piece or two of their freshly baked, crusty soft bread. My husband usually gets either the baked lasagna, or the spaghetti with meat sauce. You can't go wrong with either of these. Very solid classics. This time, though, he deviated and tried the crab ravioli, and said it was very good. The cocktail menu changes periodically, so we always see what's new and try different things. The prices are good, and the drinks substantial. read more

See all

The warm bread and fresh salad greens were a delicious start to my meal. The salad was simple with shaved carrots, croutons and so crunchy and tasty. I loved their French salad dressing. On to the main course. Chicken parmigiana is excellent. The spaghetti is as great as expected. I mean it is the Old Spaghetti Factory. My server was attentive. The ambiance is family-friendly. Even though I was dining alone, it was quiet enough even with big tables of families nearby. read more

See all

For my husband's birthday, we decided to visit The Old Spaghetti Factory. My kids were a bit overstimulated at the time and our waitress was very helpful to get our order in quickly. We ordered fettuccini alfredo and lasagna. The food was pretty good and we'd love to try it again to take our time to eat the food (we had to rush off because of the kiddos). I'm happy our waitress was patient with us and understood! read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Great service food was awesome little slow but it was a weekend had a nice vibe to the place plus got a funny hat. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Went for an early dinner to have my 'free' birthday entree. The spinach artichoke dip was a perfect start. A salad and a soup led to the Pasta with meat sauce and an order of wild mushroom ravioli which were very good washed down with glasses of the Conundrum red blend. Nice laid back atmosphere and our server was prompt - including the requisite 'happy birthday' sung by the staff as we started our Simon dessert. So nice that meals include soup or salad and dessert. read more

Disappointing experience from start to finish. The service was painfully slow and the staff seemed completely unorganized -- orders were delayed with no clear communication and no sense of urgency. After a very long wait for our food, we were told a discount would be applied due to the delay, which we appreciated at the time. Unfortunately, when the bill came, we were charged full price anyway. To make matters worse, when the food finally arrived, the meatballs in the spaghetti were undercooked, which is unacceptable from a food safety standpoint. At that point, the frustration outweighed any chance of enjoying the meal. Between the extreme wait times, the lack of organization, and the failure to honor what was promised, this was a very poor dining experience. We won't be returning, and I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone expecting decent service or properly prepared food. read more

Sorry Old Spaghetti Factory. I'm taking away all the stars I've given you over the years. You took a great thing and you hosed it up. Completely. There was an entire Seinfeld episode about this: "The reservation holds the table!" What's the point of letting a person make a reservation for three people at 6pm when you don't seat us until 6:30 ?!?!? Oh - I almost forgot: When we finally got seated, we waited another 13 minutes before anyone came to our table and acknowledged us. I'm never coming back. This has happened my last three visits. We're done. Hire some people and contact when you're ready to be a restaurant again. Good Lord. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

The food was good! The service was very excellent! The ambiance was in the medium of it being busy and the floor was clean too. read more

See all

I haven't been to spaghetti factory in years & was excited to check out the Carmel location. This location has a cool train with some booth seating that I'm sure is every kids favorite place to sit! Our server for the evening was nice but she kind of seemed like she didn't want to be there. No real issues either way overall with service, just not impressed. Spaghetti factory does have a gluten free menu- I had the GF mizithra pasta with grilled chicken breast. The chicken breast was fantastic! The first few bites of my pasta I thought were great but then the taste got too overwhelming- maybe too much butter or oil or just not a fan of mizithra cheese. I'm not sure but 1 hour after dinner my stomach hurts thinking of that meal. I would not get the sauce again but would definitely get the chicken. My husband had the chicken Alfredo with marinated chicken and that chicken tasted more dry. Each meal comes with salad and icecream. The balsamic vinegarette dressing was a little too vinegary for me so I was glad I went with the creamy pesto. And icecream- nothing to complain about but was a nice finish to the meal! read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Mizithra & brown butter gluten free pasta - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Staff was pleasant enough. Told by hostess that we couldn't be seated because our waiter wasn't there yet. Salad was not very fresh. Main course was just okay. My daughter ordered the adult Mac and cheese and was quite disappointed. Another in our party got the soup and salad and waiter forgot the soup. Dining area and bathroom was clean, but the automated paper towel dispenser was right over the trash can. Can't say I'll be going back read more

This place is always good!! Very consistent and I think that is a good thing. This is a fact of our families

Food was fresh, and tasted really good. Great menu too. Service was good even though they were really busy! Our waiter came by checked on us and made sure drinks filled, answered questions, made recommendations and delivered good appetizers, main course, and dessert all good! Ambiance is unique nice level of music and felt comfortable. read more

I loved the old world feel of the restaurant. I was there Wednesday evening and the place wasn't crowded at all, unlike the rest of Carmel Downtown. I ordered the 2 kinds of Spaghetti with Mizithra cheese and brown butter and my second choice was white clam sauce. The Mizithra cheese was unbelievably good! For the price, the entree came with bread, salad and Spumante. Our waiter Jaydon was friendly and efficient. He deserved the 20% tip! read more

A group of us had dinner here on a Saturday night, and they were packed. We were glad we made a reservation! Our group was all adults, but I think their target customer base is families with young children. There were a lot of kid birthday parties going on and the menu features a lot of kid focused items like a blue limeade with cotton candy on top. They do have some wine, beer and cocktail options, including a decent house Chianti. Meals all come with a basic soup or salad to start and a scoop of ice cream for dessert. I had the soup and it was fine; a basic very mildly seasoned minestrone which I preferred over the iceberg lettuce salad option. For my entree, I had the Pot Pourri which included marinara, meat sauce, white clam, and brown butter sauces on spaghetti. The brown butter was unique and definitely the best of the 4. It was rich and I really liked the combination of the nutty brown butter and cheese topping. The other 3 were good, and would be kid friendly. The scoop of spumoni ice cream for dessert was a nice finish. They were very short staffed and everyone was hustling like crazy t take orders and get food and drinks out. Management were jumping in as servers as well. Yes, service was slow, but we were in no hurry as we wanted time to visit anyway, and could see how hard everyone was working. And...somehow everyone was super nice despite likely being dead tired. Anyway, if you're in the mood for spaghetti comfort food, this isn't a bad option particularly if you have kids with you. Parking is available behind the restaurant in a free garage which is actually where the main entrance is...main entrance is not on Rangeline and I drove past it the first time; there is no lighted sign on the front. Be sure to turn in before or after your navigation app says you've arrived and you'll find the parking and entrance around back. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Spumoni - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Loved the spaghetti! Cute Restaurant Great appetizers Wishing they had a restaurant in Noblesville read more

Server didn't come by for 20 minutes (we were seated in a room at a 2 top with 2 30-Top tables ). After we put our order in we didn't get anything for 30 minutes. Host had to come bring us water. Didn't get food or drinks from the bar for over an hour. Tables next to us that were seated go their food and left before we even got our food. Food was luke warm at best. Probably won't ever be back. Sad because this place could be decent. read more

I came in for lunch with a couple friends and we enjoyed the warm table bread with butter and I ordered spinach ravioli. My meal came with either a cup of soup or a salad. I opted for the minestrone soup. It was great! My spinach ravioli was good too. We also got a scoop of ice-cream with our dinner. Everything was good. Nothing was over the top amazing just good food and okay service. read more

The Old Spaghetti Factory - Dining room - Italian Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

I've always enjoyed dining at The Old Spaghetti Factory, but my recent visit to the Carmel location left me feeling embarrassed and unwelcome. I was there with my family and paid the bill in two separate transactions. Despite this, the manager, Caitlin Johnson, assumed I hadn't fully paid and brought a second check to the table. She insisted--loudly and in front of other guests--that I needed to pay again. I had already completed the full payment. The way this was handled was not only humiliating but felt accusatory, as if I was trying to get away with something. It made me feel discriminated against and completely unwelcome in a place that should feel warm and hospitable. Mistakes can happen, but how they're addressed matters. read more

Our party had a reservation for 615p. We got there early at 545p, not in any rush to sit on a table since we were early. We were told to wait at the bar, knowing the parties were under age 21. So the manager apologized and took the party to the patio (that was closed by the way to wait). However, patio had dusty tables, etc. so that was already a red flag. Once we sat down, It took 45 minutes to get a drink (6 waters and 2 strawberry lemonades.) The restaurant was packed and probably saw 3 waiters total. Another family came and gone before we even got out our food or even to check out. It was by no fault of our waiter, but management didn't seem to have it under control at all. read more

My wife and I went to THe Old Spaghetti Factory in Carmel. It's too bad it doesn't have the same charm as the one in downtown Indianapolis, but it also doesn't have the crime and what that area has become. Still, it was very nice. The service was good. The Garlic Mizithra pasta was delicious. Highly recommended. The chicken marsala, not so much. I've had better, in fact I've had much better. BUT, it wasn't terrible. The pasta though, it was terrific. read more

The food and ambiance are always great, but the service is dreadfully slow. You could easily be seated and order, leave for a movie, and be back in time for dinner to be served. This is not great when you have little ones. The servers always seem overworked, bread is hard to get, and what could be a quick meal turns into a 2 hour dinner service. We have been multiple times and it's always an issue. read more