Great NYC pizza is a thing of the past. I was here when a NY Slice was something you wished for anywhere else in the country. Now, 99% of NYC pizza is horrible. A horrible piece of dough that looks like a piece of cardboard that's painted red and white. NO taste. THAT is what a NY slice has become. SO except for the few great pizza joints that still exist, this one is a little better than your regular horrible NY slice. The pizza is NOT dry as a board. That's good. There is enough sauce and cheese and it has some taste. It's OK pizza . They're eggplant hero was good. Really good fries. I had the fries and onion rings and thought they were horrible UNTIL i realized that it was the KETCHUP. I finished the rest of them with no ketchup and they were fine. This is not great pizza BUT it IS the best in this neighborhood. Trust me, I've tried them all. This is the only one I'll order from. read more

Pro-tip: It's cash only but there's an atm inside. Highlights: Honestly I thought this place was a gem. I really like this style of pizza where it's on the thinner side, but not too thin. They are generous with the cheese leaving just a small sliver of crust and the taste was great. It wasn't too greasy like some other pizza places I've been to. Lowlights: If you're ordering a slices, they only have like 2 to 3 options at a time. read more

See all

This was my first time ordering from Tony's Pizzaria. I ordered the "Baked Ziti with Eggplant" and it was excellent. I spoke to Claudia and she was so delightful to speak to. She said Alex was in the kitchen today. I asked her to let him know that I shared it with a friend and we both enjoyed it!! I definitely will be ordering from you again! read more

See all

I have no problem with the service, everyone was nice. The place is a nice size no seating. It looks clean and well kept. They have a nice selection and of course you can create your own pie. I've had much better pizza for the price. This is very basic pizza the sauce and ingredients are meh. I was not impressed. read more

Tony's Pizza On Nostrand - a variety of pizzas on display - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Amazing jerk chicken- gots a kick to it, but a good one!! No great one! Thanks again! Will come again.

Worst pizza i had in nyc. The wings tasted frozen and not crispy. The dough was terrible dry and unsalted. Very mid read more

Tony's Pizza On Nostrand - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best place to go with a large group especially before the theater! Their portion especially the family style are very generous. Their pasta is awesome and their wine list is great too! The service is also always great! read more

Cardboard pizza. very mid. Wings tasted frozen and dry. Pizza were worst than frozen ,dough was hard and dry. Dont fall for it.

I came here with a pair of kids I was babysitting for them to get stickers and tattoos from the machines. I tried their 3 chocolate chip cookies for $2 and they were delicious. I also bought an Aranciatta Rosa Pellegríno soda drink which I believe costs almost $5 because my total was almost $7. I even gave him $1 extra tip, but I believe the guy at the counter over charged me for the drink since it was my first time there. I understand things in Brooklyn are more expensive than Queens but double the price? Really?! Anyway, he lost a client now. This place already has bad reviews from the bad energy from the people that work there. Never again! read more

I ordered 6 Parmesan wings, Mac & Cheese and broccoli. The wings were delicious! There was a semi thick sauce on the wings which was awesome. The wings were decently sized and packed with flavor. NOW, little did I know that this Mac & Cheese was going to feel like an explosion of perfect creaminess in my mouth! The first bite was almost immediately followed by the thought of 'there's just no way this take out M&C is this good.' LOL! The entire meal was great. Oh the broccoli was slammin' with the wing sauce too. --TWO ETERNAL DAYS LATER ::Sponge Bob reference:: I ordered Chicken Parmesan & Ziti and my roommate ordered a full side of the Mac & Cheese....wait for it... YES, the M&C was just as amazing as the first time! What a pleasant and delicious surprise. The Chicken Parm was ridiculous. Finger licking good. This has to be one of the best take out orders I've had in a while. I would for sure recommend this place and hope that each time you order it taste just like the first. read more

See all

I have been going here for years. Yesterday my family ordered 2 pies one Pepperoni and one Sausage. The pizza sauce was watery and nasty without any flavor. Today my family all has diarrhea. This is a first time but we won't be returning until they fix their issue. read more

Pizza arrived smashed and cold. Asked for a refund of pizza, tax, delivery fee, and tip (I even offered to pay for the rest of the order) and was told no. Won't be ordering from them again, obviously. read more

Tony's Pizza On Nostrand - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delicious and crispy. People are nice and the food comes out fast. I've tried their pasta dishes too and they come with a TON of food. I split one dish with Theo roommates and we all ate plenty. Budget friendly and tasty. I will definitely come back for a slice. I usually get the margarita slice or the vodka slice. read more

I order from Tony's on seamless, Uber eats and in person. All the time. The wings are so good and HUGE. They legit serve the best fries I've ever had in my life!!! I've gotten more than pizza. I've had the jerk chicken (if you aren't into spicy food stay away because it's HAWT), wings, pasta, mac and cheese, and even the cookies. Service is always A1!! read more

Tony's is a neighborhood fixture that's been around since long before I came to Crown Heights. What once used to have tables and the option for dining inside has transitioned to a full grab-and-go space. With that, anticipate going to Tony's to grab a casual New York slice. The pizza isn't anything groundbreaking; it's not hitting NY's best pizza list anytime soon, but it is moderately priced, satisfying when needed, and no fuss. All forms of payment are accepted from cash to apple pay which makes it convenient on all ends. Having lived across from here for 3 years, I've tried their jerk chicken, their meatball parm, their pizza, their baked ziti, and a few other dishes. I've never been disappointed as it's always been hot, tasty, and simple. It's a classic NY pizza place afterall. I've never had an issue with service, never had to wait unusually long for an order, and never felt the za needed re-heating. On all the necessities, I think Tony's checks the boxes. For me, I just think the interior could use some touching up. I think the space would benefit in eliminating the little 25-cent candy machines and that cash game thing. Put some tables back in and give the community a casual space to hangout again. And... I hate the yellow. But obviously that's a personal thing! Will miss this and all the other NY pizza when I move to Boston. read more

Good pizza. Courteous and helpful staff. Although I ordered online, they helped with a miracle I made online

Took the train to President rather than getting of at Franklin to give this place a shot. Love the open air space and Brooklyn vibes, but the pizza was just OK. Sauce had good flavor but crust was a bit thick. Also, they advertise "brick oven" but they have stainless steel gas ovens like any dollar slice place. Maybe once upon a time. A better time... Also they left my slices in the oven too long to warm, even though I asked for them out in advance. Otherwise they would have seemingly never removed them. This leads to dry slices. I'd go to other places in the neighborhood before his one, but in a pinch, it's an okay, well-priced pizza place. Maybe next time I'll tell them to take it out sooner. read more

this is my favorite pizza spot, this pizza is always fresh and tasty with fast service everyone is so nice but sometimes crowded

What do you do when it's too cold to go outside and all the nearby restaurants only take cash and you have none? You get Yelp Delivery! Searched for a decently priced place for me and my picky father. He doesn't eat a lot of food that he doesn't make himself, so it takes some thinking when it comes to what he likes. Tony's seemed safe. The Yelp reviews were here and there, but most of them seemed to complain about customer service. I wasn't going out in the cold, so none of that applied to me! We got two orders of chicken tenders and fries and two side salads. Came to $20. Place the order. Gets here 15 minutes ahead of time. Delivery guy was nice. It wasn't spectacular, but it was good food that hit the spot. Our salads were fresh. No brown spots on the lettuce, tomatoes were firm, red onions didn't smell like atrocious BO, and the correct dressings were on the side. The chicken tenders were thoroughly fried and the fries were those nice steak fries. Dad was happy. And I asked for a bunch of sauces on the side and they actually came! Most of the time, that doesn't happen to me even when I pay for them. Thanks, Tony! read more

See all

Pizza not very good. Low quality ingredients, not very tasty. Very bready. Will not order again

They are close. They are convenient . They are just okay. The good think about Tony's is the variety - where else can you get a jerk chicken and a buffalo-chicken pizza? They deliver too so that's helpful. But sometimes the food isn't very hot (either taste or temperature). Usually the orders do come within the window but then need to be reheated. The jerk wings have a lot of heat on them in my (non-Caribbean opinion). I order there because it's sometimes the best option though I could hope for better. read more

Called to get some info about an old order. Guy on the phone asked me if I was on drugs. Really unprofessional.

When ever Im in Crown Heights near my cousin house. I always come here when I'm in the mood for jerk chicken and Mac and cheese. The jerk chicken is very fresh with the hard dough bread. I add jerk sauce and bbq sauce to my chicken and it hits the spot. The staff are welcoming. Some of them don't really speak English. Place is very clean and spacious. read more

See all

The vodka pizza was AMAZING. This pizza is inexpensive and reliably delicious. Will be returning for more read more

Tony's Pizza On Nostrand - Slice of Vodka Sauce Pizza, Slice of Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

4 Words: BBQ Jerk Chicken Pizza When I first moved to NYC this was my first pizza spot. Whenever I'm in the area I grab pizza from them. Do yourself a favor and try the BBQ jerk chicken pizza. Like seriously, what are you waiting for? read more

Best Wings in Crown Heights. Don't bother looking anywhere else. Pizza is alright, better than most of the places in the area, but can be too greasy for my liking. I usually order to deliver and they are always super quick. read more

Super great wings with a variety of flavors! This place is a pizza spot and then some. Love the open layout of this place, but not the customer service. I felt as if I was expected to know the Tony's pizza routine of ordering and what additional condiments costed extra. All in all - I'd come back again. read more

Tony's Pizza On Nostrand - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Honey Mustard Wings were saturated too much in honey mustard sauce. The macaroni and cheese was bland, no salt to taste, I had to add pepper for a more flavorful taste, when that didn't help, I started to add the red pepper flakes and jerk sauce, just to be able to finish eating it! Now don't confuse with how I'm describing the dish, I was expecting a spicy dish, just a dish that was seasoned like Mac and cheese dishes are. Maybe offering baked macaroni dishes read more

If you never had jerk chicken, this is the best place to have it. I know I don't eat meat but this is def. the best place to have it. Their pizza, their fish, their cookies! Everything there is really good. read more

Tony's Pizza On Nostrand - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Don't order from here , staff extremely unprofessional. Was provided with an eta of 45 minutes for my food , waited over an hr for my order. I called the establishment several times , in which staff thought it was funny that someone took my order: no apology was provided. After waiting for over an hr for food, sorry is unacceptable. Called several times and no one was aware of order. Don't support this establishment, go somewhere else , where your time and money is valued. read more

The food is good for the value, but don't come when you're in a rush. Also for pickup, make sure they've made your food before you come to pick it up- its usually 2x as slow as they quote (which is nbd) and sporadically forgotten (which is far more annoying) read more

I generally go to this pizzeria after completing work and dropping off the city vehicle which is parked nearby. It is located near the President St 2/5 train stop which I take home. The restaurant is large and bright, which is a surprise from the typical pizza shop. They offer a wide selection of menu items (another reviewer mentioned jerk chicken?!), which is unique. I have only had their pizza which is pretty good, though the crust is a bit hard, I like it softer. Not quite up the par of my favorite places, but pretty good nonetheless. I will definitely be back and will try the jerk chicken one of my visits to update my review. read more

Legit worst customer service I've encountered yet. While on the phone the man asked me 5 times if I'm sure I wanted to place the order because the wait would take an hour. After confirming with him for the third time he started to sell me out of buying the pizza... Wtf?! Bro just bring my food and take my money. It's the simplest transaction. He then said they had too many customers and I should call back to order something later... Trash!!! Yea, Tony needs some new employees. Good luck selling more people out of buying the food. It wasn't Gods Plan I guess. read more

I've been a patron of Tony's Pizza for about 3 years now and it has consistently been some of the best food and service - not only in the area, but all of Brooklyn. Don't be fooled that this place looks and is advertised as a pizza joint, because the jerk chicken here is PHENOMENAL. I usually go with the platter for $10 which comes with two sides and a hefty portion of jerk (or whatever main you decide on). Because the jerk is so delish, it's hard to actually order anything else. Though I have tried their pizza and meatballs - both are great. But once again... the jerk chicken.... Y-U-M. And I can't forget the staff - always friendly and attentive :) read more

I got two pizzas, mac & cheese, sweet & spicy wings, and chicken parm delivered. Everything was so reasonably priced and delicious! Well cooked, hot out the oven. The wings were to die for - crispy and smothered in sauce. Definitely will be ordering from here again! read more

So my sister told me about this place that makes really good jerk chicken I didn't believe her and so I had to try it. You don't normally here of a pizza spots demanding this on there menus ,but YOU REALLY GOTTA TRY IT !! It's AMAZING!! And the customer service was OUTSTANDING!! Thanks to the crew ! I'll be visiting again very soon. read more

Tony's Pizza On Nostrand - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I love Tony's and feel so grateful to live close to it. The pizza is delicious and the staff is friendly. My favorite pizza is the vodka sauce one. I think it is one of the best vodka sauce pizzas I've ever had. It is my real comfort food! They have a card minimum, which is important because the slices are cheap. They aren't the cheapest in NYC, but it's worth it. check it out! read more

The degree of incompetence and rudeness here is hard to find. Half the time I order theres somehow an issue. The last time the guy didn't repeat my order back to me (hello basics here, clarify make sure you heard right so you don't waste your time and my own!) and big shocker, the order was wrong. Instead of making it right, they basically gave me two options, take the thing I don't want or add the missing topping which would obviously burn the already finished dough?? As I stood there blown away by the stupidity, the bald owner who is a supreme D*ck, looked at ME like "what's up hurry up, chose" yeah no make my shit right! Both options don't work. The food is okay when it's done right, but I order the same stuff all the time and it's always WILDLY different and inconsistent. Gotta love that in a food business. I only go because it's right where I live and unfortunately I'm forced into way too much. Worst pizza place of all time. No Parmesan cheese at pizza place is commonly a big tip off a place is questionable. You're not getting Parmesan here! What a disgrace read more

While the food is good, the customer service is ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE. I've ordered from them twice now and will not be doing so again. Last night my food was over 20 minutes late, so I called to check on it. Here's EXACTLY how the call went. Tonys: Tony's pizza. Me: Hello. I was calling to see if my order was en route? Tonys: (pause, pause, pause, pause, 15 SECONDS LATER) Me: Hello? Tonys: Sir you need to be gentle and not come at me like that! Me: What? You didn't respond. Tonys: Address? Me: (provides address) Tonys: It left already. *hangs up* I'm not sure who the lady is that answered, but she needs to be terminated ASAP on the spot. She has cost you a lot of business because I certainly like your food and certainly can afford to buy it on the reg. read more

It's ok,I meant o k, not going out of my way for it. No taste,had the chicken ranch and the only thing I tasted was the nasty onions they put in it. Again it's ok,but next time I would have to go somewhere else read more