Toomy's has gone downhill, a shell of the chef prepared food like it use to be. We spent $250 (only one cocktail) for three people and a total waste. $60 ribeye and filet was underwhelming, and the $32 pork chop tasted like it was prepared in the microwave with watery "chutney" that consumed the plate. We ate half and left dissatisfied. read more

Many things weird and wrong with the experience. First of all the dining area is way over in the other room. Then, server was slow but I guess you can't complain on a Saturday. Just read the menu, $17 FOR A KIDS MEAL. Fortunately, it's a little bigger than a decent portion. Then, there were not very many items on the menu anyway, which one of them cost $58 DOLLARS. They also gave one out of the nine of us kind of a crappy meal. If you want to eat out, this should not be your first priority for restaurants to visit. read more

Toomey's - picture - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

We always come here with a big party, especially when everyone wants something different to eat. This place has it all, soup, salads, tacos, wings, burgers, seafood, ribs, steak, kid's menu, etc. Perfect place to appease everyone. Very relaxed family friendly environment. Lots of sports memorabilia on the walls. Patio seating with fire pits. Food is good. Nothing really outstanding but overall great flavors. Salads are good to share. The soups are comforting. The fish tacos with mango salsa hits the spot. The wings sprinkled with bleu cheese is a win. Good service. Our server gave us tips for summer backpacking in the area. Appreciate her! Just overall a good choice for lunch or dinner in this ski town. read more

See all

Food great, price high, but what can you expect for this area. Wangz were tasty and full, also good service. The ambiance was nice but there was a blinking light, eventually my buddy asked to fix it and they allowed it. There are tvs for sports watching. Go there if you're a fan of Kansas City and you will know what I mean when you get in there. read more

Toomey's - Wangz - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

Matt was the kindest and most helpful server. Truly went above and beyond and gave us the best recommendations and excellent service. All of the staff were very friendly but Matt really stood out. read more

Great service. But food just ordinary. Not worth the price. Fish and chips weren't crispy. New York steak which was on special was just ok. Garlic mashed potatoes were delicious (and I don't usually eat mashed potatoes). read more

The food is amazing! I tried the fish and my husband had a steak. Everything was delicious. The staff is very friendly and helpful and they allowed our dog to sit with us in the patio. And offered to bring her a bowl of water. I love people who care about animals!! It was a perfect summer evening. read more

Loved the hospitality and service. Really nice people and great waitress. Food was delicious, the whole family devoured their plates.

Our server Erin was the shiny star of our family dine in dinner experience at Toomey's. She was a gem and provided such excellent service. From knowing to being extra napkins for our 2 and 4 year old, to the subtle promise of a special sticker if they are their dinner, and her patience with listening to our littles' stories, she is by far the best server we had our entire week in mammoth. Food was great! My husband enjoyed the fish and chips, I had the New England clam chowder + salmon Caesar, and our girls enjoyed the kids chicken nuggets. Ambiance was a casual, sports bar feel. Great for kiddos or if you are coming in from the slopes for a bite. We will be back next time! read more

Service was fantastic. The food was pretty bland, that's being polite. 1 person in our party of five got a serious stomach issue. We probably won't go back. Sorry read more

Great meal in Mammoth! Don't let the sports bar look fool you. I had the elk and it was cooked perfectly with a mushroom sauce. My friend had the meatloaf and it looked like a steak and had an incredible seasoning. Mashed potatoes were creamy! Best meal in Mammoth! read more

Food is great! Big portions. Go early , not many seatings. Elk was fantastic, the lobster taquitos were Huge. It's was a nice place for a quick and simple dinner. Very casual please. read more

The food here is fine, but compared to some of the dining options nearby it's nothing too noteworthy. Skip the crab cakes if you do decide to drop in for dinner - the small portions and average flavor aren't worth the added price tag. read more

Toomey's - Crabcakes - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

I had the buffalo meatloaf and my husband had fish n chips.My meatloaf was dry but still tasted good! My husband loved his fish n chips.He said the fries were amazing! Fast and friendly service too read more

Toomey's - Fish n chips so good - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

Staff is inviting and very attentive, food is phenomenal & the overall environment is very welcoming. Felt like home read more

See all

We come here whenever we're in Mammoth. Food and service always great. We love the outdoor patio so we can have our dogs with us while dining. We should have split a burger! Generous portions of everything. read more

See all

Fantastic tasty food. Great customer service. Buffalo meatloaf was outstanding. Fresh salads. Baseball themed eatery. Highly recommend read more

Toomey's - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

If you don't know, now you know .. Best fish n chips this side of SD. Erin & Anna are true professionals & make the experience. So much baseball history & likely you'll see a pro athlete enjoying a meal. Lobster taquitos is a colorful, flavorful plate. Toomey's is a total vibe. read more

On our last night we wanted a little night life and to eat out. Toomey's was right below us at 8050 PRC. It was filled with families and was full of life. Loud, talkative & cheerful folks eating and having a good time. The menu is broad enough to appeal to everyone's taste. It's a bit pricey but our meals were delicious. My steak salad was modestly priced and loaded with perfectly cooked juicy & savory steak. The chicken wing platter was more of a meal and those who had them seemed to devour them at a fast pace. The grilled cheese Sando and homemade soup was also wonderful. Toomey's s also has a full bar for those who wanted libations. The owner & his son came out and were a delight to get to know. Soon it will be expanded to connect to a new bar-club going in next door. RC the unofficial mayor of mammoth will be the new developer and will share in the fun and help run the joint operation. Great times. See you soon! read more

Well the service was great and everyone was very friendly. Small place with less than 10 tables. I would consider this fast food. I asked what was good and was told the lobster burritos. Well they were 3 small fried lobsters burritos that had no lobster taste at all. The lobster was a mash filling which really tasted like nothing. The black beans on the plate and the salad were good. My partner had tacos which at least you could tell what meat was present. Don't know what gave this place 4 stars but our food sure didn't. I don't think I will be back. read more

Casual place with interesting and flavorful dishes. We are here 2 nights in a row. Started off with the tuna tower and it was amazing, very interesting flavors, fresh, and delicious. The pork chop was done very well as was the sea bass. Great service, friendly staff, and decent prices. Will definitely come back. read more

First of all the food was simply incredible and the waiter who waited on was so happy and informative. Dave is the man!

Pretty Solid! My friends and I went here for dinner because they recommended it. The ambiance is definitely a baseball fan kinda vibe because of the memorabilia and posters in every corner. The customer service is top knot good with employees that are happy to help. This restaurant is in the upper side of sport bar/ family type of scenery. I can just imagine watching and dinning here during a World Series.. must be pretty dope :) My girlfriend and I shared on their Grilled Pork Rack Chop. We were glad we did shared it because the portion was quite hefty. The pork chop dish was delicious because they put a berry glazed on a salt marinated pork chop, which gave the meat a flavorful experience. Although, I suggested a gravy on their mash potato cause it's sorta bland without any sauce. One of our friends ordered their World Greatest Chicken Wings, which was not what I expected. The chicken is quite okay and definitely not greatest, however it did satisfied my belly. Although, their prices are in the expensive side of the spectrum, so not really a big fan of that. Overall, if you love baseball and American food.. this is the place to be, but if not try somewhere else :/ read more

Toomey's - Not so World's Greatest Wings :/ - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

We chose Toomey's because of the great reviews, but we ended up with average-quality food and a very expensive bill. The staff was friendly, but the cost vs food quality was just way too high. We're not sure we'll give it another try in the future. read more

As always, Toomey's is one of our favorite places to visit. The service by Anna was great and the food was excellent! And it's always a blessing to talk with Matt Toomy!They went above and beyond during a busy holiday weekend. Everyone in our group was all smiles! ~ Glenn read more

Can't say enough great things about this place. The owner Mike is a true professional and the food is delicious! Erin our server both nights was fantastic! All the staff is friendly and on top of it. Highly recommend if you are visiting Mammoth. read more

We came in for dinner on a Sunday night. The atmosphere is a sports bar with baseball memorabilia all over. I had the salmon salad and my husband had the ribs. Both dishes were just ok. I noticed there were no burgers on the menu but the couple at the table next to us ordered them so I guess this is a secret tip. The service was a bit slow so nothing too special for us here. read more

The burger was very dry, the fries were good. The waiter forgot my clam chowder. He was very nice though. We sat outside but the cushions on the chairs were really dirty so we opted for the uncomfortable metal table & chairs. read more

My boyfriend and I visit Mammoth a few times a year. We have eaten at many of the yummy restaurants in town and recently ate at Toomey's for the first time. To say that the food was amazing would be an understatement. There just aren't words to describe just how yummy our meal was. We stopped in for a late lunch last Sunday and we split the buffalo meatloaf. It was like eating a delicate, savory cloud! The meat melted in my mouth, and I haven't been able to stop thinking about it ever since it graced my grateful tongue. Matt Toomey is clearly a culinary magician. I can't wait to go back to Toomey's and eat again, but I will not be only eating half of a dish there again (unless I get half of my boyfriend's too lol) read more

Toomey's - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

Great location in The Village. Super friendly and helpful staff. Menu that is out of the ordinary. Really enjoyed the lobster taquitos. read more

See all

Toomeys is a great, well run establishment. Can't go wrong here during your stay in Mammoth! Parking: street parking in the village. There's a lot across the street that's paid but difficult to see during the winter time. Atmosphere: toomeys has a spacious bar area and also seated area to dine in. There's also a separate take out area adjacent to the restaurant. There is 2 bathrooms available as well. Food: we had the soup of the day (clam chowder) with a grilled cheese as well as the meat loaf. Both were so good and great to have on a cold night. On top of the good food, the service was fast and polite which I appreciated! Overall I had a pleasant experience at Toomeys and highly recommend if you're looking for some comfort food to come here! read more

Toomey's - Meatloaf! - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

Everything was Perfect, the personnel was the best in the country. We are ranch lovers and they didn't hesitate to give us a lot. A million percent coming back. read more

Had a great dinner here with my group and had awesome service which was attentive and friendly. They have outdoor tables and we snagged one with a fire place in the middle and nice cushy lounge chairs. Jambalaya - this eventually fed me for three meals, so the portion is pretty big! There was very little (no?) rice in it so it is chock full of seafood goodies - fish, shrimp, mussels, and even baby scallops. Honestly I was surprised by the depth of flavor, it was super tasty. The burgers got good reviews all around and they came with tons of fries! read more

Toomey's - Jambalaya - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

The place was packed with people and the service was still great. They let us bring our dog in to the restaurant. The waitress brought him a water dish. The food came fast and good. I would recommend Toomey's! read more

Best food in Mammoth! And we have tried them all. Fillet, fish sticks, and ahi tuna stack were all delicious!

We ate here 4/5 nights in Mammoth. Great restaurant, good food, very friendly service. And had a really nice thanksgiving dinner, totally a surprise. Conveniently located. read more

Service and food has definitely gone down since the last season we visited. We got take out, got there and waited...and waited...owner too busy chatting up customers at a table, cook too busy, cashier no where to be found. No one seemed to cared that I was just standing there waiting to pay and serviced. Meanwhile, I can see my food sitting on the counter and lobster taquitos getting cold! After we came home I saw that the Caesar salad that I requested for no Parmesan cheese had extra cheese. The receipt clearly stated no cheese. The quality of the lobster taquito also weren't what it was. read more

See all

Excellent meal in Mammoth. I highly recommend the meatloaf. The service was great and they are dog friendly. read more

Toomey's - Meatloaf - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

The food here amazing and full of flavor...everything was cooked to perfection...didn't need to add any salt or pepper...after a long day or work or hitting the hills...this place will hit the spot... read more

Toomey's - Pork chop in a mixed berry sauce, purple cabbage, carrots, and mashed potatoes... - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

Just enjoyed Toomey's best burger in Mammoth. It lived up to its billing. The crispy fries were awesome too! Thanks!