We chose Toomey's because of the great reviews, but we ended up with average-quality food and a very expensive bill. The staff was friendly, but the cost vs food quality was just way too high. We're not sure we'll give it another try in the future. read more

Can't say enough great things about this place. The owner Mike is a true professional and the food is delicious! Erin our server both nights was fantastic! All the staff is friendly and on top of it. Highly recommend if you are visiting Mammoth. read more

As always, Toomey's is one of our favorite places to visit. The service by Anna was great and the food was excellent! And it's always a blessing to talk with Matt Toomy!They went above and beyond during a busy holiday weekend. Everyone in our group was all smiles! ~ Glenn read more

The burger was very dry, the fries were good. The waiter forgot my clam chowder. He was very nice though. We sat outside but the cushions on the chairs were really dirty so we opted for the uncomfortable metal table & chairs. read more

Service and food has definitely gone down since the last season we visited. We got take out, got there and waited...and waited...owner too busy chatting up customers at a table, cook too busy, cashier no where to be found. No one seemed to cared that I was just standing there waiting to pay and serviced. Meanwhile, I can see my food sitting on the counter and lobster taquitos getting cold! After we came home I saw that the Caesar salad that I requested for no Parmesan cheese had extra cheese. The receipt clearly stated no cheese. The quality of the lobster taquito also weren't what it was. read more

See all

Everything was Perfect, the personnel was the best in the country. We are ranch lovers and they didn't hesitate to give us a lot. A million percent coming back. read more

The food here amazing and full of flavor...everything was cooked to perfection...didn't need to add any salt or pepper...after a long day or work or hitting the hills...this place will hit the spot... read more

Toomey's - Pork chop in a mixed berry sauce, purple cabbage, carrots, and mashed potatoes... - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

Thank you, Matt for the great baseball stories and for not hating on my Red Sox hubby and our Yankees friend! You certainly made our visit fun! Your Fish and Chips got a nod from our British friends. They were the best I've ever had...thank you for the recommendation! Everyone enjoyed their meals. We will definitely be back to see you this winter! read more

See all

We ate here 4/5 nights in Mammoth. Great restaurant, good food, very friendly service. And had a really nice thanksgiving dinner, totally a surprise. Conveniently located. read more

Best food in Mammoth! And we have tried them all. Fillet, fish sticks, and ahi tuna stack were all delicious!

For Ski resort food, Toomey's is pretty good! Service was helpful and very attentive. We also received our food relatively quickly. The food was pricey, but all above average. The fish and chips were moist and soft but still crispy, and the salad + ahi dressing was tart and refreshing. I've rarely had elk, and opted to try the elk rack chops. They were prepared very well, perfect medium rare cook, and minimal gamey taste. The elk was tender but lean, almost resembling a filet minion, just with those gamey elk hints. My only complaint would be the accompanying mashed potatoes; they were dry and just not very tasty. Toomey's is great village food. The portions are hearty, and the food doesn't disappoint! read more

Toomey's - Elk Rack Chops - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

Excellent meal in Mammoth. I highly recommend the meatloaf. The service was great and they are dog friendly. read more

Toomey's - Meatloaf - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

Customer service was good in terms of the server. Low rating because of the food quality. The meatloaf and taco were good but was extremely disappointed with the elk chops. Ordered medium rare and came out almost medium well; barely pink. Overcooked, Very hard and dry. Last time I came in 2018 it was delicious but this time was terrible. Maybe chef changed but hella disappointed with quality especially for a $50 dish. read more

The vibe of this restaurant is like a sports pub, a lot of baseball theme and references. Recommend if you're a baseball fan. It's solid American food with big portions. Not bad for a small town. The wings are too sour. read more

Toomey's - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

We were seated immediately as there was no one in the dinning room. We did go on a Tuesday mid afternoon and they do have pick up. I was drawn in by the lobster taquitos and wanted to give them a try. My husband ordered a clam chowder and fish tacos. All the food came out hot but I wasn't impressed with the taste. The lobster taquitos were subpar, however the clam chowder was good. read more

Toomey's - Clam chowder - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

The food was meh. The wine list was small, but awesome. The server was amazing! Ask for Freddy/Freddie. He was one of the sweetest, most genuine servers I've ever met. Really cool peeps. Good vibes. It was closing time, and he didn't rush us at all. Gave us first-timers to Mammoth really good, local recos. Love that! Five stars because Freddy/Freddie made our experience that good. read more

Toomey's - Lobster taquitos good. Salad good. Black beans not good. - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

Yummy lobster tacos and the best burger in mammoth. It's a great place for large groups and families. Matt is a baseball Dane and it shows with all of his baseball memorabilia on the walls. Great place you won't be disappointed....but if you are please let them know and they will make it right! read more

Good food and service. Prompt and friendly. We would go back. Clam chowder was the soup Of the day. read more

This is our go-to spot during our yearly Mammoth Vacation! The food is always absolutely delicious no matter what you order. They are always able to seat us quickly and the staff is very friendly and accommodating. The service is great and they are very attentive. The owner comes by and makes recommendations and even took time to acknowledge our family's elders and honored the hard work that it takes to create a united family. We were all very touched and it made for even a more memorable experience. We absolutely recommend this place. (Also, the bathrooms are clean!!! ) read more

See all

WOW! First words said once i bit into and savored the lobster taquitos! The Ribs were spectacular fall off the bone quality! The cabbage and salad along with the meals were savory as well. Beers were cold! Our waiter Mitch provided exceptional service and the entire time felt we were at a family oriented establishments. Diner style. Definitely will be back. read more

Toomey's - Baby Back Ribs: Lobster Taquitos: - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

The food is worth the money. It's expensive. But, it is good. Their amazing soup is kind of a tradition of every skiing trip now. Definitely a check out place. The one star off, is for not having enough Aloha in the place. (Can you tell I'm in Hawaii right now.). Just a little smile, go a long way. That's all I am saying. I know, work is tough. Work and smile is even tougher. But, if the UFC guys & gals can do it while they are beating up on each other, so can we. Super happy we have this place in Mammoth. read more

Toomey's - Owners Business Card - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

Just enjoyed Toomey's best burger in Mammoth. It lived up to its billing. The crispy fries were awesome too! Thanks!

What a rip off! My husband was still hungry after two tiny crab cakes on top of a pile of Spring Mix so ordered the carrot cake. He didn't check the price on the menu as how much can cake be? Well it wax $18.95 for a piece of mediocre CC! Was so ridiculous. He got another piece for half the price on the Mountain at McCoy Station the next day and said that looked, and was way better. Been coming up to Mammoth for decades & will definitely not go to Toomeys again. read more

I would not recommend this place, first of all we ordered a filet mignon and they served us a ribeye!! The mashed potatoes were cold and they do not give free refills on fountain drinks. The bus boy was horrible, he barely came by to clean our table. With all that said we did have a very nice waiter but due to the food we will not be returning. read more

Came for dinner on a Saturday night last month... tried to walk-in at other restaurants while we were staying at the Village and every other place was super packed. We were pleasantly surprised we could get seated easily (for a party of 6) during the dinner rush. The service was excellent and everything we ordered was delicious! My husband even said the seafood jambalaya was the best he'd ever had and my salmon Caesar salad was so good. Would definitely recommend! We'll be back to dine here the next time we're visiting Mammoth. read more

Toomey's - Salmon Caesar salad & cream of mushroom soup - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

This restaurant was relatively empty passing by, but it was undoubtably the best meal we had in Mammoth. Far better than any of the other village restaurants. We had a party of 12 and they seated us quickly. Everyone loved their food: the lamb, seafood jambalaya, pork chop, buffalo meatloaf, and seared Ahi were exquisite. Amazing flavor. The mashed potatoes reminded me of my grandma's famous potatoes. Also amazing atmosphere with baseball memorabilia dedicated to Royals and Padres legends. Great dining experience and massive wine pours. read more

Toomey's - The house sauv. A "mammoth" pour. - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

Expensive, but worth it. Great service. Fun options for food. My steak was cooked perfect and my husbands meatloaf was delicious. Left happy

Really nice owners. Great vibe and decor in there with a baseball theme. I got the crab cakes and they were delicious, and my bf got the fish and chips, which were also delicious. Definitely will be back! Only downside is parking, which is a lot across the street, and is kind of pricey, but that's to be expected in the area it's in! read more

Classic spot to grab a bite in the village. Pork chop was flavorful, juicy, and cooked to a perfect medium. Good portion for the price. Will be back to try more next time! read more

Great food and great employees! Best Burger in Mammoth! Everything on menu is delicious....

Ordered to go. Ribs were so dry they were inedible. Fry's tasted like they were day old left under a warmer. Salads order with dressing on the side and were delivered over dressed. On a Positive note, the strip steak was very tasty. read more

Best Lamb I've ever had. They had a rack of lamb special and it did not disappoint. I like lamb and had it a handful of times. Some people might find the taste too gamey but this is why the lamb rack I ordered was so perfect. It was very subtle on that gamey aroma but you knew you were still eating lamb, it was also sooooooooooooo TENDER. The mash potatoes were delicious and creamy and veggies were cooked perfect. The rack was also priced very well for the amount it came with.. personally think they can price this higher and I would still have it again... and again.. and again. read more

Toomey's - Lamb Chop Special - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

My husband and I called prior to arrival to ensure the restaurant could accommodate us, and were told to come in! Upon arrival, we were seated in the patio with our two pups for dinner. Our waitress was extremely friendly and kind to both of our pups, who were admittedly on their best behavior for dinner. Special thanks to her for the warm and welcoming service. We had a lot of trouble picking what to eat on the menu - the selection wasn't huge, but everything looked SO good. As usual, I was paying close attention to what other patrons had ordered and what their meals looked like. I almost ordered the meatloaf, but we ended up getting the jambalaya, chicken wings, and ribs. All three items were SO insanely good!! 1. The ribs were tender, juicy, and perfectly flavored with just the right amount of BBQ sauce. 2. The jambalaya was delicious and filled with seafood. It came with bread to soak up all the delicious sauces, veggies, and seafood. 3. The chicken wings were giant and lightly sprinkled with blue cheese. Yum We weren't expecting to eat like kings in Mammoth, bit we certainly did. Thanks for a lovely dinner, Toomey's! read more

Toomey's - Jambalaya - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

We got good food and great service in a convivial atmosphere. This restaurant is also conveniently located near the village.

Delicious food, friendly staff, great menu options for all palates. Several local brews on tap (why have Budweiser if a local brew is available). Plenty of parking. Lots of TV for sports. read more

Amazing place great service . It's run very well. Every time in Mammoth. This is the place for sure. read more

Toomey's - Mammoth - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

I wasn't going to leave a review, but I was just looking at my photos and they brought back disappointing memories of the food at Toomey's. You know the awkwardness when you're the only one at a table? Ooof. The woman that waited on me was very nice. The food came out quickly! But... it was SO GROSS and OVERCOOKED. I ordered the fish and chips and it was all breading. There was not much fish at all. The fries were crisp but had a burnt flavor. YUCKY. The photos are before and after... notice all the breading! Inedible. Total waste of $20. read more

Toomey's - Fish and chips. $20. Overcooked. All breading. - New American Near Me - Mammoth Lakes, California

See all

Solid food and service. Easy seating for 10 at lunch on a snowy day. I was super pleasantly surprised!

Food, service, and atmosphere were top notch. Very attentive wait person. Best seared ahi with salad ever had!! Wife really liked her grilled salmon w salad as well. read more

The food was amazingly delicious! Best in Mammoth Lakes. Service was excellent. And we got to meet the owner, which was super fun.‼