We've been here twice; both times absolutely phenomenal. Any low reviews you see are from tightwads who would just as soon order a NY Strip from Gustav's Diner as a real NYC steakhouse. This restaurant is for lovers of exquisite food and service.
Decor is old-school New York steakhouse. It's a pleasure to take in the scenery -- for any true New Yorker, it's a comfortable, familiar setting. There's space between the tables so you're not eating on top of other diners.
Waitstaff is nearly perfect. Busboys and servers are efficient and mostly unobtrusive. Waiters are old-school NYC waiters, almost a dying breed: slightly older gentleman, intense NYC accent, strong but friendly NYC personality, and a wry sense of humor. Competent. Both times our waiter took the order without writing it down and got everything correct. Nice! Only negative comment: please be more mindful of not interrupting table conversation. That's beneath the quality the of Uncle Jack's Steakhouse experience.
The manager is perfect. We arrived at an awkward time between lunch and dinner (1st visit). We wanted to order from the lunch menu even though the kitchen had stopped serving lunch. The manager snapped his fingers and made it happen without us even asking. He saw the need and made it happen. A true professional. On our second visit he gave my daughter ice cream, gratis. He's obviously a proud Dad who loves his kids because only Dads think of this kind of thing.
I won't lie, the prices are steep (charging for bread is a misstep, IMHO, that will anger some people) but that's the price for exquisite food and service. If the price is bothersome, you should be going to Gustavo's Diner. I think the prices are commensurate with NYC steakhouse. In fact, more than fair -- food quality and prices are on-par with Peter Lugers, but the service at Uncle Jack's is MUCH better, and Uncle Jack's accepts credit cards!
Baked Clams: A-
Nice and garlicky. Lots of sauce with a half lemon in cheesecloth to catch pits (nice touch!). Breadcrumbs are like a garlicky bread pudding. The only better baked clams are my mom's because she uses bacon and even MORE garlic! We were given 9 or 10 clams. I wish they were a bit larger.
Skirt Steak: A+
It's hard to make a bad skirt steak: it's one of those cuts of meat which is naturally soft and almost cooks itself. That said, this was still one of the best skirt steaks we've ever had. In fact, it was cooked so perfectly that we ordered a second dish to take home with us! Juicy, tender, and beefy without being too fatty or oily. It was a perfectly cooked steak.
Hamburgers: A+
Perfect charbroil on the outside, medium rare on the inside: Perfect! The bacon is thick slab smoked bacon, the cheese is beautifully sharp cheddar. A perfect American hamburger.
Prime Rib Chop ("Fred Flintstone"): B
Slightly underwhelming. I ordered medium rare and it came mostly medium. The very center of the cut was medium rare, but the rest was dry, indicating that the meat was cooked at too high of a temperature. They need to cook the chop at a lower temperature to allow the entire chop to cook more evenly. However, there was enough au jus, the cut was beautiful, and the outside was nicely grill charred (perhaps a bit too much charring, but that is a subjective point.)
Boneless NY Strip: A+
NY Strip ("boneless" means you don't get the T-Bone with it) is a beefy, tender cut of meat. When cut against the grain, it almost melts in your mouth with a strong USA beefy flavor that you can't get anywhere else in the world. This is a winner. Perfectly grill-charred. Insanely soft. Obviously an expensive cut of meat, meaning it was aged for several weeks before being sold. This is why you order steak from a place like Uncle Jack's rather than a diner. If you want a perfect NY Strip this is it. You can't do better.
Kurobuta Pork Chop: A
Anyone who speaks Japanese will recognize "kurobuta" to be 黒豚, which means black pig. The meat isn't black, of course.I'm guessing this refers to a Japanese breed of pig. You get two very thick, nicely charred pork chops, soft, fatty, and succulent, as Japanese meats tend to be.
Wagyu Kobe Meatballs: B
As of July 2016, only one restaurant in NYC serves real kobe beef, and it's not Uncle Jack's. Any other NYC menu that says "kobe", including this one, is a lie. I lived in Japan for a year, and know kobe beef. This is NOT kobe beef! In fact, using real kobe beef for meatballs would be a sin: kobe is known for marbling -- you would grill kobe beef as a steak, not grind it up for a meatball! Meatballs are still good, even though they're not real kobe beef.
Creamed Spinach: B-
Too much nutmeg. I like my creamed spinach chopped finer.
Mashed Potatoes: A
Nearly perfect. They obviously use some kind of cream here. It would be an A+ if the potato skin was left on (I really like the skin for rustic mashed potatoes). Consistency is *perfect* in my opinion. read more