February and the weather is finally releasing winter a bit. Lunch on a Friday, downstairs in the bar (10 tvs), very cozy, not busy at 11:30 (I mean, we got a parking place by the door!). Server is the bartender, casual and welcoming. There's plenty of offerings on the menu but we both went with burgers with me getting the Angus burger and RRR getting a smashburger. Both burgers were quite good as was my coleslaw and his waffle fries. The coleslaw has lots of black pepper which I was able to tolerate, unusual. All in all a nice beefy winter lunch. read more

See all

We came here for an earlier dinner date. We sat at the bar and I loved the vibe in there. The fish tank was cool, there were sports on the screen, and the bartender was good to chat with. We ordered the pretzel sticks, boneless wings, and chicle sliders. All the food was incredible! 10/10 read more

See all

Honestly the worst dinner I've had in a long time. I can't believe this place is owned by the same people who run divvy, which is 1000% better in every aspect. Our waitress was nice but inattentive. We were there over an hour and only got one water refill after flagging her down. The Brussels sprouts were okay in flavor but hadn't been properly trimmed and were under cooked. When ordering them off the appetizer menu, we asked for there to be a delay so we could finish them before receiving our entrees. There was about 2 minutes between receiving the appetizer and entrees coming out, which was disappointing. The pot roast was 80% fat and while the mashed potatoes were good, the broccoli was raw, sitting in water, with no seasoning. With no gravy or au jus (surprising for pot roast), the meat was not tender. My husband, who will eat just about anything and is rarely critical about any food, said his chicken florentine was very dry and his broccoli was also raw and unseasoned. He also said this place tasted like the worst cooks in America show opened a restaurant. The crème brûlée was pretty good, it's a mini for $5, the only saving grace for a second star. I told our waitress about the food experience but other than replacing the broccoli with equally bad broccoli, nothing was done, not even an apology, and she was MIA for most of our visit, despite the restaurant not being busy...at all. Honestly, I have no idea how this place stays open. The concept is cool, but there's a lot of "stuff" all around that's collecting dust, and with food this bad, it's not worth your time, money, or calories. read more

See all

Had the best meal here Friday night. Patio is absolutely wonderful on a warm evening for eating and enjoying downtown Carmel life. Our waiter was great and more than happy to make recommendations and help us navigate the menu. Food was perfect. We'll definitely be back! read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

I met a couple friends here for Devour week. The parking is limited and I was surprised to get an open spot. There is plenty of outdoor and indoor seating. We were there early so it wasn't busy. I had a Mango Mockarita, House Salad, Pot Roast, and Vanilla Blondie. The pot roast was really hearty and full of flavor. I was full and took my dessert home to enjoy later. Overall everything was good and I'd come back to try more off the menu. read more

See all

The different levels of this restaurant are super cool! Has outside seating and a bar area with tables that both have open seating so you don't need a reservation. Then, upstairs a reservation is recommended. We had Brussel sprouts and fried mushrooms as appetizers. The brussel sprouts were AMAZING! The fried mushrooms were good but we have had better. The Cajun tots were also a table pleaser as several chose them as their side. We have the chicken florentine, grilled chicken sandwich, vegetable stir fry, and the crispy chicken. Everyone really enjoyed their food. We would go back! read more

See all

Popped in here for a nightcap after dinner with friends because they are open late and not super packed. A nice, lowkey spot to hang with a small group (plenty of space downstairs). It is also in walking distance from so many other drink and food spots, so it could be a great initial meeting spot to figure out what to do for the evening or a great spot for a nightcap. Our server was really sweet, made sure we always had water, and checked on us frequently to see if we needed anything else. The staff upstairs were also really friendly and let us know that seating was downstairs, but when we left we could exit through the covered patio and didn't have to come all the way upstairs/go back down the front steps. read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - Espresso martinis - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

I was greeted at the main door with a smile and a beautiful welcome. I was then directed to the bathroom. The bathroom was dated and brought me back to memories from my childhood that made me smile. This was my first time here so I was a little confused about seating but eventually found where to sit. Bella was our server and she was great. We went for the devour menu. They didnt have any vegetarian options but I was able to find something else on the menu. The blueberry mocktail was AMAZING. The sprouts was a decent sized portion for it to be a side. And lastly, I ordered the blondie and a side of ice cream. My dessert was so cute and tiny. read more

See all

Some friends and I decided to stop in to try their Devour Indy menu - Bella was friendly and took care of us while we dined in. It wasn't very busy and that worked out for us, our orders came out fairly quickly. I went with the Chicken Tortilla Soup, The Pot Roast and the Brownie dessert! Everything was pretty good, we really liked the pot roast - highly recommend! read more

See all

I went to Woody's in Carmel with family and had a really enjoyable experience. We started by ordering the Parmesan Brussels sprouts which were crispy and well-seasoned. The baked goat cheese appetizer was also excellent, warm and creamy on toasted bread. At the end we combined some of the leftover goat cheese with the Brussels sprouts and the combination was absolutely fantastic. For the main course I had the mini Sloppy Joes with sweet potato fries. They were hearty, savory and very satisfying. To finish the desserts were small but full-flavored, a perfect way to end the meal. The crème brûlée was especially delightful with a perfectly caramelized top and just the right amount of sweetness. read more

See all

The atmosphere is really neat but the food!! We came for the devour menu (runs until 2/2/25) and they had 3 different specials running until noon. 1. A 3 course menu for $21 person 2. 3 entree options w/ waffle fries for about $15/each 3. Brunch options My girl friend and I decided on: Parmesan Brussel sprouts for our appetizer: so yummy! Both got the breakfast sliders which were 2 small smashed beef patties on slider buns topped with a fried egg each, hash brown patty, slice of bacon, and smothered in sausage gravy with a side of seasoned tots. Omg, SO yummy, flavorful, and filling! For drinks: she got the citrus mule and I got the canned Ash & Elm option Parking: we parked a block on the street. When: Saturday at 1:30, walked right in, no wait for a table Server: Ryan and he was quirky and fun! Highly recommend and would definitely go back! read more

See all

We visited on a Saturday in mid-May. Hoping to sit on the patio, we found the wait was too long for how hungry we were, so we decided to head upstairs to the library area. As soon as we walked in, we were met with a cloud of smoke--it smelled like something was burning. We sat down, ordered our drinks, and discussed whether we wanted to stay. Initially, we thought we could tolerate the smoke as it seemed to be dissipating. However, after about five minutes of looking at the menu, it worsened again. We politely asked the waiter if we could pay for our sodas and leave. He was apologetic and understanding, especially since some people in our group were having a hard time with the smell. We're hoping this was just a fluke, but I'm not in a hurry to return anytime soon. read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - Inside filled with smoke - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

I wanted to give a shout-out to Heather and the team for saving a table for myself and my family from out of town! They typically don't do reservations in the basement, but I called ahead to let them know we were going to have a group of 10 and they made the accommodation for us! Thanks so much, the family had a great time and really enjoyed the meal! read more

I've been to Woodys twice and have had a good experience both times. The first time was the middle of summer when the patio was open. Our server was very kind, a man that said he has been there for a long long time. I got the filet medallions that were very good! They come with a horseradish sauce on them that makes the flavor come together in my opinion. I also had the draft root beer which was delicious and refreshing on the hot summer day. From my memory you can only get it refilled twice or three times- but worth it. The second time I went I got the same entree and the Brussel sprouts. Those I don't recommend as much only because they are drowning in sauce, but the flavor itself is good. Just would be better if there was less sauce overpowering the dish. The interior of this place is different and historical. There isn't a ton of space though which surprised me. Overall I would return to get the filet medallions with the horseradish sauce- it has become a favorite of mine read more

Overall very good food. Only gave it 4 stars because it is a bit pricey for what they offer.

Great ambience and great food! It was our first time dining at Woody's. I was just curious about what library restaurant was like. The service was slow at times but overall they took very good care of us. They have variety of items on the menu and it took me a while to decide what to get. I ordered chicken pot pie- it was more like stew, and a pie sitting on top of it but it was so delicious. Very nice choice for a cold evening for sure. read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - Chicken Pot Pie - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Atmosphere is fun .... Food was generous and good. Our waitress was so sour.....no smile no conversation. She should NOT be in the hospitality business! Get another career! read more

I ate lunch outdoors today at Woody's Library. What a great setting on Main Street in Carmel - open air, covered with overhead fans. We both ordered the blackened pork tenderloin sandwich served on a Brioche bun. For sides we both selected the balsamic & Parmesan roasted Brussels sprouts. What a great choice - thesandwich was well seasoned and filling and the Brussels sprouts were very good. I would order both again on my next visit. read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - Blackened pork tenderloin served on a brioche bun with balsamic & Parmesan roasted Brussels sprouts - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

My wife and I had lunch today at Woody's. They had one of the best burgers I've had in town. My wife got the dry rub wins and raved about them. Our server was attentive and very friendly. The outside patio was awesome. I also love the Carnegie library decor on the inside. The old books in the inside are really cool. If you're looking for a great spot for quality food and a lively atmosphere, I would highly recommend Woody's! read more

It was love at first sight with Woody's. We brought my mom this time about a month later and the upstairs was closed so we sat in the patio which was enclosed, hot, and stuffy. Service was not friendly at all today and very slow, but the food is so good so I'll be back again. But today's experience was a 3-star occurrence. read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

We came here to celebrate my husband's birthday and appreciated they could accommodate a large reservation a few days prior to the date needed. They allowed us to bring in our own cake (just needed to sign a waiver) There are plenty of fun drink options here and an extensive menu. I appreciated all the gluten free options they offer too. I had a burger which was decently tasty. I have heard you need to check out the library bar downstairs so I will need to do that the next time we visit here. read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

I was visiting a friend that I met when we both worked at a library so this place seemed perfect. I loved the ambiance with all the books. Our service was excellent. The tenderloin was crispy and waffle fries are always a good idea. My daughter had the Mac and cheese and the portion size was huge. We took a lot of food home. Highly recommended! read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - Pork Tenderloin Sandwich - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

What a great option for lunch and dinner in Carmel! I've stopped on a couple of occasions for both throughout the past six months and have decided it's one of my favorites in town. The service is wonderful and the surroundings of the library are perfect. Food was excellent and we would come here again! read more

See all

I was psyched to come here for a work trip dinner when I read about the building's history. Unfortunately, they don't really capitalise on it and the room where we ate was not at all in the vibe of library. The mocktails are nice but food is just regular old pub grub and I was not at all impressed. I got the stir fry with shrimp for my main and the shrimp was over cooked. Service was fine - it's hard taking care of a large group when we all arrived at different times too. No points off there. I just feel like this town had more to offer. read more

Tristan was our waitress and she was amazing!! Always making sure we had drinks and enjoyed our food, all while putting a smile on our faces. The food came out quick and delicious, while the service and friendliness topped it all off!! read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - Bbq boneless wings, loaded caesar salad, water, and coke zero - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Superb experience at Woody's. Food was really good, enjoyed tacos and mini burgers, good portions and quality. I can't wait to try their other restaurant, Divvy. read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - Tacos - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

A local favorite that I'm not certain why it took so long for us to visit. The patio was booked but the interior has a comfy, neighborhood vibe. The menu wasn't large but everything we ate was tasty and better than anticipated. Service was prompt and attentive. We will definitely return. read more

I love going to Woodys! Whether I sit on the porch, upstairs or in the bar, the service and food is great! In fact yesterday we celebrated my mother in law's 94th birthday! It was a wonderful lunch, with great service and Woody checked on us several times. We will be back again soon! read more

Love this place! The food is always excellent and the staff is phenomenal. We just went to celebrate a birthday and they welcomed our big part with open arms. Great ambience being in the library too - it's so cool! read more

I was meeting a friend for a casual dinner in Carmel and they recommended Woodys. We sat on the patio which has the plastic sides down. They also had heaters so that was helpful My food was so good. I got the pork nachos which was a full meal and too much for me to eat! I would get them again! We were there on a Tuesday which was half priced bottle of wine day. We enjoyed the Block Pinot Noir. I look forward to going back. read more

See all

Delicious food and fantastic service--what a great evening out at Woodys! We had reservations upstairs. Our server was friendly and attentive. I had the Caribbean Chicken Tacos with balsamic Parmesan Brussel sprouts as my side. Both were great! Others in our party had the deconstructed chicken pot pie, the Chicken salad, and the veggie burger with Cajun seasoned tots. The tots were a hit! Everything was delicious. Highly recommend Woodys read more

Drinks are strong, good beer selection, delicious comfort food, and friendly servers. The nachos were loaded well, there were no extra chips left without toppings. Buffalo chicken wrap had a generous amount of sauce. But the real star was the pot roast. read more

See all

This has become the place we suggest when people ask, "what's a good option to eat in Carmel?" Food was delicious and the building is beautiful! Staff was so extremely helpful. read more

Right in the heart of downtown Carmel, this is your run-of-the-mill bar food. The patio was well equipped with heaters and screens to enjoy into the fall season. Dog friendly too. Great service! I did not get to see the main library room which I know is the main attraction! The breaded mushrooms are a great appetizer. Other than that, the burgers, chicken and wraps were standard. read more

See all

I always enjoy the food here and the bartender Grace is the best. Super friendly, attentive, and entertaining! A great place to go with a group of friends. read more

Our server was an absolute delight. He knew the menu up and down and was so professional and attentive. I got the Caribbean chicken tacos with sweet potato fries and it was delicious and so colorful! My friend got clam chowder and Caesar salad and she said everything was delicious. It was a chilly day today and the heated patio was a good mix between being indoors and outdoors. The library section is closed on Mondays, so will have to come back to eat there! read more

Woody's Library Restaurant - Tasty Tacos - New American Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Our waitress Tristan was delightful. She was very nice, efficient, and perceptive. She checked on us several times and was incredible at remembering the drinks to bring and fulfilling our requests. It was amazing how she spotted the empty drinks and our preferences without us even mentioning anything. The food was delicious and the service topped it all off! read more

A favorite local haunt for date night or bringing friends for double dates or visitors out of town. The history of the Library and carryover ambiance make for a unique experience. Coupled with the outstanding meal, Woody's is often a winner! The downstairs bar is a blast later evenings but I personally favor eating in the dining area or enclosed patio when possible. Service has been at all levels but mostly favorable. We had a private room one of our visits with a larger party and the server was one of the best we've had anywhere around! I frequently order the Bison Meatloaf as I find it absolutely delicious. Most recently introduced two friends to it and they were similarly praising! The meatloaf blended with the mashed potatoes is just a perfect balance! In the colder months the boozy hot cocoa is divine with the homemade whipped cream! read more

Our waitress Tristan was phenomenal. She was on top of it at all times, extremely attentive without being overbearing. She juggled every single detail for 6 people at once without a single error. Could not ask for better service. The food was out of this world and it was fairly priced. Truly one of the best meals I've had in my life. read more

Wanted to live this place so bad. The restaurant itself is so cool with great atmosphere, 2 great bar areas and spacious outdoor patios with heaters for the colder months. Staff was amazing, perfectly friendly and attentive and quick to refill drinks or answer any questions. Unfortunately the food wasn't great. Brussel sprouts were good, but everything else lacked a serious amount of flavor. Wrap came out cold and tasted like canned chicken. Both sweet potato and waffle fries were good. Salmon sliders weren't bad but also lacked any real flavor. Loved everything else enough to definitely give it another try. Next time!! read more

See all