I first found this place through TikTok, where people were hyping it up in Italy. I was pleasantly surprised to find out they had a location in New York City, so I obviously had to give it a try. There are a few locations, but I decided to visit this one because it was the most convenient for getting to and from home. I got there around 7:00 PM, which felt a little close to closing time since Google said they close at 9:00 PM, but it wasn't busy at all. In fact, I was only the third customer to place an order. I ordered the La Summer sandwich and added pesto. After sitting down and taking my first bite, I immediately understood the hype. Without a doubt, this is one of the best sandwiches I've had in a very long time. I'm not even a huge sandwich person when it comes to subs and deli meats, but everything tasted incredibly fresh. The ingredients paired together perfectly, and you could still taste each one individually. The only thing I'd change next time is the meat. I had no idea prosciutto was a type of ham, but honestly, it didn't even taste like ham to me. It was sliced paper-thin, slightly salty, and worked surprisingly well with everything else. Next time, though, I'll probably add salami just to see how it compares. Overall, this sandwich was a solid 10/10, and I will absolutely be back--whether it's to try a different sandwich or, if we're being honest, order the exact same one again with salami added. I will say it's on the expensive side, but that's New York City for you. Apparently, all of the ingredients are flown in from Italy. After tax and tip, I paid a whopping $28 for a single sandwich. That said, it was incredibly filling and definitely kept me satisfied. The workers were also really nice and accommodating, and the indoor seating was beautiful. The atmosphere felt like a fancy Italian café, complete with couches and artwork throughout the space. I wish I had taken pictures, but honestly, I was too busy enjoying what might be the best sandwich I've had in years. read more

See all

This is such a great spot for a quick Sammie that is big enough for two. Don't let this place intimidate you. The menu inside breaks down all of the sandwhiches, you roll up to the deli counter when they say next, spill out your order (add/remove stuff to your order) and you're done. The most overwhelming thing is deciphering the Italian sandwhich menu. I hit up the Italian Hot. Pretty decent! I added sun dried tomatoes...but it would have been just as good without it. Be PREPARED this Sammie has some chili honey liquid /oil sauce they put on it and it's tasty but it's a lot. The staff are friendly - just focused on getting your order and getting it to you so you can enjoy. The wall is pretty interested they have made their own decor out of door panel fixtures. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Italian Hot - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

All' Antico Vinaio Excellent sandwiches, fresh in store bread. This sandwich shop offers huge, flavorful Italian sandwiches on freshly baked schiacciata bread with high-quality ingredient La Paradiso Mortadella, stracciatella, pistachio cream, pistachio is a heavenly combination Just a simple tasty sandwich that fills you up.at a reasonable price. Works everytime for me read more

See all

All'Antico Vinaio means "to the ancient wine merchant" (Thanks, Google). I thought it would be closer to Italian for delicatessen like salumeria. This is in a ritzy part of town on 60th St between Madison Ave & Park Ave with Ferraris & Bentleys parked on the street, so you have to guess that the storefront rent must be astronomical. But oh, these gastronomical sandwiches are off the charts and can justify the price. Once you decipher the names of the sandwiches on the menu and see what's between the bread, you will want to try all of them. I settled on 2 finalists, but decided get both anyway. All sandwiches are made fresh with some of the best looking meats & ingredients I've ever seen! And what's better is that they bake all the focaccia for the sandwiches fresh and in-house. You see the bread oven right behind the register. I wonder if I could buy a slab of that bread? L'Inferno brought images of Danté Alighieri's version of the Underworld to mind, but was a spicy hot masterpiece of sandwich art. The combination of thinly sliced roasted porchetta, nduja, spicy grilled eggplant & arugula was fantastic! The fresh baked focaccia took it even further. But I did learn something new today besides Italian pronunciation, which was that nduja (silent n) is a spicy sausage from Calabrese that's spreadable like butter. I gotta get me some of that stuff! La Paradiso sounds like the third installment of Danté's Divine Comedy trilogy, but is a very mild, but tasty sandwich with mortadella, stracciatella & crushed pistachios in pistachio cream. The pistachio cream is a stroke of culinary genius and gives the sandwich an amazingly smooth texture & taste. The only part of the Divine Comedy missing from their menu is La Purgatorio and I do not want to find out what would go into that sandwich! read more

See all

This is a busy place in midtown Manhattan. I stopped in for lunch and got in line. The line moved quickly, thoigh as they make each sandwich to order. Mine was porchetta with a mild tasting condiment. The bread was crispy and delicious, but I found the filling to be underseasoned lacking flavor. The ingredients were all high quality and fresh, though. I found a stool with a narrow shelf where I enjoyed my sandwich. Overall, a pleasant stop for a quick lunch. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Porchetta - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

I came here with honestly low expectations. Whenever something from abroad comes to the US, quality tends to not be the same. However, this place exceeded my expectations. I got the La Paradiso which comes with Mortadella, stracciatella, pistachio cream, pistachio. The bread was fantastic. It was light, yet crispy and thin but thick enough that held everything together. The pistachio cream, cheese and meat ratio was just perfect. I honestly regret not downing 3 of these. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My friend and I ordered the La Schiacciata Del Boss and Italian Hot. The best thing about the sandwiches was the bread. The rest of the sandwiches were pretty underwhelming. The Boss sandwich ratio of cheese to prosciutto was too much. Every bite was overpowered by cheese, and there was no sauce or flavor. The truffle cream was too light, and we couldn't taste it at all. The Italian Hot sandwich was really sweet due to the chili honey. There just wasn't much flavor outside of it. The turkey was pretty thin as well. Overall, we took our sandwiches home to add some vinegar and sauce there. The sandwiches didn't feel substantial for the price. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Boss Turkey - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Having just come back from a trip to Italy, this sandwich shop/franchise from Italy really does a great job at satisfying a necessary craving. It is located in an area in midtown where it's safe to say it's one of the best quick lunch stops in town. I would say it's one of the pricier sandwiches I have had but for its quality, I would say it's definitely worth it. The bread is slightly toasted, just perfectly crisp. I'm most impressed by the quality of meats here. Fantastic prosciutto with wonderful taste. The sandwiches my friends all tried were quite impressive and did a really good job at recreating the taste in Italy. Each sandwich is quite filling and makes a worthwhile visit. The restaurant had quite a bit of a line when we visited on a Saturday afternoon. It took us around 30 mins from the back of the line to get our meals. The staff was lovely and even explained a few of the questions I had regarding the meats used /'d what they recommend. There is quite a bit of seating in the back and also benches by the bathroom for you to sit inside. But given the crowd at the time, it fills up fast. Good thing sandwiches are quick so the turn over is quite fast. Will definitely be back here in the near future! read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Menu - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Love love love this place.. Short walk from my hotel, stopped in and got a couple of amazing sandwiches. The crew working behind the counter was very helpful and friendly service. Place had great atmosphere too very clean. read more

See all

After bookmarking their first U.S. location a few years ago, I finally made it to All'Antico Vinaio. It was even easier now that they have fourteen locations across the country, eight of them in NYC. I'm not entirely sure why it took me so long, and the quality of the food here made me especially annoyed at my decision to put it off. These sandwiches are spectacular! Each one is served on freshly baked Tuscan bread, with freshly sliced meats and an amazing array of cheeses and spreads. For example: La Summer which has Prosciutto toscano, mozzarella, tomato, basil, or La Favolosa which has Salame toscana, pecorino cream, artichoke cream, spicy eggplant. As well as a dozen or so standard sandwich's, there are special too. My current favorite of those is La Regina which has Prosciutto Crudo, Stracciatella, Pistachio Cream, Sundried tomatoes and Arugula. I'll eventually work my way through all of them and then start back at the beginning! There is also a very relaxed dining area in the back of the restaurant with long, communal tables and ten two-tops. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - La Regina - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Delicious!! I've been to the location in Italy and it was comparable! We got it to eat on the Amtrak ride back home and it was a delicious treat. read more

Very high quality product. The sandwiches are very large. Bring a friend and split one. Delicious flavors from Italy. The staff is friendly but the line gets long and can be somewhat unruly. Dine in option out back, lots of delivery business. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

After 3 pm, great deal half sandwich and a glass of wine for $15! Friendly workers, cute place. A great place to grab a bite before a show at 59e59 read more

All'Antico Vinaio - half la paradiso, rosso spritz - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

A long pending spot that we've been wanting to visit since our return from Italy . This is an Italian sandwich spot that is one of favorites in our Italy trip that we were excited to try it again. As in Italy there was a long line to get in . Once in they were quick in making our sandwich. We stuck to vegetarian options with La Broadway and Fade Away . The original Italian sandwiches were soft warm made with fresh baked one of a kind focaccia bread . La Broadway had Pistachio cream, stracciatella, sun dried tomato, spicy zucchini & Arugula Fade away was loaded spicy eggplant, spicy zucchini sun dried tomato , Gorgonzola and Arugula . Both were delicious but on the heavier side . The pros first - there was abundant filling and the flavors were amazing. For the cons - Bread was not warm which made it chewy and was quite a strain eating it . The veggies were cold as they were refrigerated , which was different compared to the original Italian version . We were hungry and it did bring back memories of our Italy trip that we ate the entire sandwich. The brownie and olive oil cake were the highlight of the meal . Soft , mellow sweetness and needed moistness . Was casual ambiance , limited seating area but was a fulfilling experience. read more

I am late to the game in trying this place but even though this has been open for a few years now and this wasn't the original location I still thought it was delicious. However, paying $20 for a sandwich is A LOT. The sandwiches are on the large side so maybe eating just half with someone else is more justifiable but i finished the entire two halves by myself. The food: La Schiacciata Del Boss- Prosciutto toscano, pecorino toscano, truffle cream. This was bursting with flavors especially from the truffle cream, this was the more flavorful of the two sandwiches but I found this one to be a bit too rich. I thought it was good for the first few bites but then the more I ate it the more heavy it felt. La Favolosa- Salame toscana, pecorino cream, artichoke cream, spicy eggplant. This was the first one I tried and I thought it was good. For me, the biggest difference between the two were the spicy eggplant. The eggplant offers a nice eggplant flavor and nice eggplant texture. Both sandwiches are worth getting but both are kinda similar. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?userid=Y_iTTjKvV5hLy-880SZzlA&select=cs8uKWu2bhN34A2STWHqVg read more

All'Antico Vinaio - La Favolosa- Salame toscana, pecorino cream, artichoke cream, spicy eggplant - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Wow my sandwich was so BIG! And delicious. I forced myself to eat half and was stuffed, tomorrow I'll finish it. I enjoyed viewing their artistry in the preparation. All fresh ingredients, they even cut the bread in front of you. There's seating inside and out. It was quick, the guys were all Italian ;). I'll be back. Great choices, I went with the Caprese, prices seem reasonable for NYC. read more

See all

Our favorite sandwich counter in the area. They're big; each half sandwich is enough for our small appetites. $17-$20 for thoughtful combinations fine Italian ingredients on freshly toasted schiacciata bread (like Florentine chewy foccacia?). Think prosciutto, porchetta, pancetta, soft cheeses, pistachio cream, mushroom cream, sundried tomatoes, arugula. The meats are sliced to order. They also have sodas, beer (Peroni, naturally), and wine. There's a spacious seating area in the back. The sandwich guys are all nice, efficient, consistent, and lots of them have cool Italian accents. read more

My must-get any time I'm in the city! Something about the L'Italiana... it is my personal god tier sandwich. Prosciutto, Pistachio Cream, Stracciatella, Sun-Dried Tomato, Arugula- SO GOOD! I also like that this location has plenty of seating if you'd like to dine-in. A perfectttt Italian deli sandwich. read more

A lot of hype surrounded the opening of All'Antico. The sandwiches--at least, the one I ordered--unfortunately fall short of the lofty expectations. We ordered the La Schiacciata Di Manolo. And don't get me wrong, the bread (a focaccia-adjacent schiacciata) is phenomenal; it's every bit as soft, chewy and delicious as advertised. But what's on the inside counts, and the flatbread still can't compensate for the overly oozy inside. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - La Schiacciata Di Manolo - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

An excellent sandwich. I tried the new "La Regina," with prosciutto crudo, stracciatella, pistacho cream, sundried tomatoes, and arugula. It was delicious. I ate half on site and took the other half home. At 2:20 pm on a Friday the line was not that long, only a couple of people in front of me. Some tables in the back for seating, but I sat at the countertop in the front facing the street. The stools for that countertop (facing out, North) are the same height as the ones for the countertop on the East side of the restaurant; as the latter countertop is higher up than the former, this made for awkward eating. I felt like a giant hovering over the table. read more

See all

Really good sandwich. Took a star off for price and charging me for switching spreads but unique flavors for sure. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Caprese - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Food: Huge sandwiches! Being a big salame fan, I ordered the La Favolosa! Saw a lot of clips of this place back in Italy so I was excited to find out one opened up in NYC! Cost: A little on the pricer side for a sandwich but the portions are fairly large and they seem to use good ingredients! Environment: The front is fairly narrow however there seems to be a good amount of seating at the back of the restaurant! Service: Quick with no frills! Need to ask to get your sandwich cut in half (but be aware, they wont cut it in half again haha) Uniqueness: Great artisanal sandwich shop originating from Italy right in NYC! Definitely a place to go visit a few times for their unique sandwich takes however I don't see myself going out of the way to seek them out. read more

See all

La paradiso was our favorite I'd highly recommend getting anything with the pistachio cream on it! The ingredients are so fresh and the girl behind the counter made our sandwiches super quick. Will be back! read more

All'Antico Vinaio - LA PARADISO (left) & LA SCHIACCIATA DEL BOSS (right) - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Absolutely delicious! Had a caprese sandwich and the portion was very generous. Nice flatbread, perfectly salted and the right amount of mozz. Would recommend! read more

Delicious Sandwiches, fresh ingredients and many options to try. The bread is one of the freshest in the city, i haven't had any like it. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Delicious sandwiches, fast service. Fresh ingredients and the bread is like no other in the city. - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

I'm confused as to why no one is talking about "The Italian Hot." It is by far the best sandwich on the menu. 15/10. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - The Italian Hot - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

The food and service were amazing Unbelievably good sandwiches. The freshness and quality of ingredients is amazing. The only possible area for improvement would be if the food was organic. This restaurant is New York gem and I'll continue going back forever read more

Came during late lunch so little lines and very quick service. The sandwiches are expensive but the Favolosa had good amount of eggplant, good amount of cream, and good amount of meat. It's a hefty sandwich that maybe for a normal person, it's probably worth 2 meals. Late lunch for me and I was stuffed. Def will come back for a second round. Once I scrounge up some more cash. read more

See all

Every sandwich on the menu is divine. The focaccia each sandwich is crafted on is so delicious. Sandwiches don't come warm/pressed. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

4.5 / 5.0 - All'Antico Vinaio is a must-try for a delicious Italian sandwich, with fresh ingredients. I'd only had sandwiches from their Times Square location, but this UES location was a perfect stop for lunch after ice skating in Central Park with a friend. Even though the line wasn't long and they had a bunch of staff behind the counter, it took a bit of time to order and get our sandwiches. I ordered the La Schiacciata del Boss ($20), which has prosciutto, toscano, pecorino and truffle inside. Even though I'm not a truffle-lover, I love the combination of these ingredients with freshly baked focaccia. It is a huge sandwich and great for sharing. I do wish they had a half size for half the price. At this UES location, they also had a small but lovely dining area in the back. Hope to be back again soon! read more

See all

I've known about All'Antico Vinaio from my trips to Italy - but never tried it there because of the ridiculously long lines. Luckily they opened up a spot locally in NYC and oh my gosh I can't believe it's taken me so long to try this spot! All of their sandwiches are made to order in front of you and they are all bomb - I need to try all of them! Sandwiches are all around $20+, but it is worth it - the portions are huge and I have never been able to finish one myself in one sitting. Their bread has a nice crisp to it and all the ingredients are fresh. I want to try them all!! read more

See all

Food was delicious - large square flatbread, generous amounts of filling - simple and elegant. Service (especially Steven) was speedy and helpful. Ordered La Golosa, Diavola, Venice Beach + Avocado, Mamma Mia (personal favorite) read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Mamma Mia sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

To me this is such a magical place. Is really taste like home. Love it here, the flavor, quality, service, friendliness- it is consistently fantastic read more

All'Antico Vinaio - Il Calvino - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Just as good as the locations in Florence.... Fantastic sandwich, quick and clean. Decent sized portions.

Delicious and fresh Italian sandwiches, can't go wrong. Was wanting to try this shop after seeing so many focaccia Italian sandwiches being made on TikTok, and I'm happy I tried it. They have a nice big menu, so something for everyone including the vegetarians. I got and highly recommend La schiacciata di Manolo, especially if you like truffle! La Broadway is a good vegetarian pick. Their location on E 60th St has lots of seating in the back, and service is decently quick. read more

See all

Went with the la Regina and it was so so so so good. All the hype is true I highly recommend checking them out. Great location especially if you want something quick and easy before heading into the park. read more

All'Antico Vinaio - La Regina - Sandwiches Near Me - New York, New York

Food (3/5) - Got the Toscano and Inferno. Perhaps I prefer my sandwich ratios a little more to the wet side. The roasted vegetables in the toscano was helpful in that regard. Bread (I believe foccacia) was okay. Ambiance and service (3/5) - Came early afternoon on a weekend and was pretty busy. Ordered out so did not have a full dine-in experience but from what I could tell, decor was homey, simple, classic red checkered tablecloth type of vibe. Price (3/5) - 20 per sandwich roughly, though as per other reviews, they can definitely be shared, probably a light meal for 2 people. read more

Eat there, warm focaccia bread. crispy on the outside and warm, pillowy softness on the inside. Gast and effortless, efficiency on point for made to order sandwiches. Casual dining. read more

See all

I was first alerted to All'Antico Vinaio by one of my colleagues - she had gone to the one near Times Square and had great things to say. Since we had a gap around lunch time between meetings and the weather was good, she suggested that we and a few more of our colleagues take a walk there and pick up some lunch. After doing a little research, I found out that the original All'Antico is in Italy, and they had recently opened new locations in NY. This really got me pumped, so off we went. In addition to their original location in Italy and this one on the UES, All'Antico also has locations on 8th Ave and Sullivan Street. The interior is somewhat small - there's clean lines with a neutral color scheme and touches of red throughout; one of the highlights of the decor was a wall filled with doorknob and lock plates. As we approached, there was a line out the door but it moved pretty quickly - they had a lot of people working behind the counter which definitely helped. The menu is exclusively sandwiches; there were about 16 of them - a really good variety so something for everyone. It was hard to choose, but I ultimately went with the La District - this came with pancetta, pecorino cream, sun-dried tomato, and arugula on focaccia bread. The sandwich was delicious - the pancetta and arugula were rich, and the arugula provided a nice reprieve. Everything was super fresh and high quality - a total win. Did I mention the size of the sandwich? It was huge - half was more than enough (I had the other half later ;-). They use focaccia bread on all their sandwiches which was nice and soft mmm yes. All of the staff was friendly - they have a good workflow in place to make sure that despite the crowds everyone is taken care of in a reasonable amount of time. Overall, All'Antico was a total yes - the ingredients were super fresh and makes this place a destination spot wherever you may be in the city. I would have no qualms returning for another sandwich. read more

See all

We dropped in for Brunch. My wife found this place - she's good at ferreting out any good breakfast and lunch places. And dinner places. But I digress. This is the location on the south side of 60th street. We had a bit of a walk to get there - New York is very walkable. The sandwiches were very large, so we shared a La Toscana. I had a Diet Coke, and she had water with it. The La Toscana was nice and tasty. It had Salame toscana, pecorino toscano, and enough truffle honey that you could taste it. Service was blazingly fast, but this isn't a big chain. They assemble the sandwich at a reasonable pace - and it tastes better. We really liked the sandwich. Inside the restaurant, you have various old tables that have been repurposed that you can sit at. Some even have couches or loveseats to sit in while you eat. There is some eye candy on the walls to keep you busy while you eat. We enjoyed it! read more

See all