I had half Under the Sea and Coconut Almond Bar in a delicious Waffle Bowl! So delicious! read more

See all

Best in Southern Maine! Get the Salted caramel! So good and consistently great service, the girls at the window always have a smile on their faces. read more

Overpriced. Two medium ice cream cones almost$20. Waffle cone was way above average, but the ice cream itself wasn't anything special.

Eat in your car or there are some picnic tables. Ice cream was really good. This place is a favorite, we drove by later and the line was 20+ people deep. read more

The ice cream is fine, but the ambiance was disheveled. Went on a busy night: orders came out wrong, employees were calling out for people to get into other lines and then not taking their orders, skipping people who were waiting 15+ minutes, and bugs everywhere. When our two ice creams came out wrong, there was no attempt to fix it - just an "oh no." Which was a bit shocking and frustrating. Not worth going back when there are so many other homemade ice cream joints. read more

I just LOVE coming here for ice cream each summer! I've been dieting, so I've limited my ice cream outings. This was such a treat! Everything was neat and tidy. Staff was very friendly, helpful and polite. In the past I've REALLY been happy with the White Chocolate Lavender ice cream...I got two flavors, that and black raspberry chocolate chip. The lavender is divine! I WISH I'd only gotten that flavor!!! The black raspberry was very good, but there was waaay too much chocolate chip for my preference. read more

See all

The ice cream here is top notch, and has always been consistently good. Their menu is overwhelming, and they'll have something for everybody! Servings are very large- I got a small cone and it had at least two big scoops of ice cream. Everything is very high quality, and the staff is always very friendly. read more

Bayley’s Ice Cream - Cake Batter Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarborough, Maine

Second time I have been here! I went last year with my boyfriend who has gone here his entire childhood! We had a very delicious pb&j ice cream I was looking forward to but they didn't have it this time so I opted for black raspberry Oreo and was NOT disappointed! Serving sizes are amazing! Cant wait to return again next year read more

Bayley’s Ice Cream - Twix ice cream and black raspberry oreo - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarborough, Maine

Haven't been here in a few year, hard serve is still as good as I remember. Solid variety of flavors, workers are friendly. The prices are becoming outrageous though, $6 for a small Like I get the cost of things are going up but these are the highest ice cream prices in Southern Maine! read more

Bayley’s Ice Cream - a menu for the ice cream parlor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarborough, Maine

We love this place and go at least once a week! Not only is their ice cream the best tasting but they give large portions! We drive there from Gorham instead of going to our local place, it's just that much better. The kids that work there are friendly, too! read more

Omg just spent a few cents shy of 8 dollars for a medium ice in a cup. Never again I realize prices have gone up but that is ridiculous

Yum! They have some great flavors here, and be sure to enjoy it with one of their waffle cones! read more

Bayley’s Ice Cream - a hand holding a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Scarborough, Maine

We didn't go to Baley's Ice Cream enough!!! Maybe my only one complaint about our summer vacation. I was sad to say good bye. They have awesome flavors and large portions. I am smiling as I write this. We tasted a variety of flavors and my new fav was the choc rasp truffle. So so yummy! My daughter got the Almond Joy and we all tasted a variety of things and loved them. I can't wait to go back but it can get buggy depending on when you go so bring spray or sit in the car. read more

See all

We utilize this little hidden gem after baseball games for our son. Has become a bit of a tradition for us to make sure that he knows we reward his hard work with some fresh and delicious ice cream. The thing about here is that they are super friendly and they have a wide range and assortment of soft serve ice cream and others galore. I think that I would dive right in but my son loves the fresh vanilla ice cream and he loves it over any other crazy flavors that they offer. It is not too far from your typical ice cream stand but I like the fact that it is pretty local and quick service to be helped and also that you can walk to the next building over and get some friend seafood especially fried whole belly clams. I like the fact that you can grab your ice cream and scoot along the trails so it is very convenient for that. read more

We love ice cream! We have been enjoying Bayley's Ice Cream for over 30 years. The consistency and quality of their ice cream is top notch. The wide range of flavors and outstanding hot fudge sauce make this place an ice cream lovers dream. Not to mention, the staff is Always pleasant and friendly no matter how busy they are. https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g40861-d5099222-r706905318-Bayley_s_Ice_Cream-Scarborough_Maine.html# read more

Do yourself a favor and go here. You will get the best damn soft-serve ice cream you'll likely ever have in your life. With 24 flavors to choose from, they take their soft serve seriously. The texture is exactly what you want it to be. Creamy and unctuous. No icy bits in here, it's just right. We tried maplenut and it was heavenly. Not too sweet with a strong maple flavor. Don't let the unassuming location fool you. There is outdoor seating and is a bit off the oft-taken route but totally worth it. read more

Great ice cream! Tons of flavors! Great value. A must! Never disappoints. Much better than dairy corner.

I have been coming here for years and love the ice cream and the staff is always wonderful so I refuse to leave a low star review, HOWEVER!! Tonight was a rather busy night for a Tuesday and the girls behind the counter were doing their best to keep up with a smile on their faces as usual. They were doing a great job. A flavor my boyfriend ordered had run out and while the girl at the window was offering him alternatives, another girl (who I can only assume was the manager) began yelling at them from the back of the shop. And I mean yelling. I was really bothered by how harsh she was to these girls and the fact that she yelled at them in front of a full crowd of customers to begin with but never mind the fact that SHE INTERRUPTED them doing their job to scold them for not doing their job quickly enough! Girls at the window: keep it up, no one was complaining! I can only hope it was just a bad day for the manager. read more

So many choices! We stumbled upon this place after having dinner by the water. I kept it simple and had the strawberry soft serve. It was delicious! The line moved very fast and it was clear that this place is a local favorite. read more

Classic quaint ice cream spot....30 flavors of hard pack....plan on a wait on the weekends as there is always a line. The ordering process is quick, but it takes time to get your cone or cup....relax and enjoy the ambiance. I had Kailua Chocolate Chip... 4 stars. read more

This is our go to place for ice cream at the beach. So many choices! This is the old Beals location, that was taken over by Baleys. Nothing seems to have changed but the name and the ability to park at the Bayleys restaurant next door. Order the peppermint stick ice cream, it's awesome. read more

We happened to come upon this place just driving by because I missed my turn and had to turn around. Well I'm so happy we stopped. All the ice cream is made in house! That's not common anymore. It was creamy and rich and the portions were larger that expected. My husband said the soft serve was the best he's ever had. We must've arrived at the perfect time. By the time we left the line was out to the road. Definitely worth the wait! Lots of flavors to choose from and quick service once you placed your order. read more

What! I thought I gave this a second review!! I guess I'll just have to do it right now!! If I could give this place a double rating of 10 stars, I would! My favorite ice cream ever!! It's around 100 degrees today and we had to stop here, of course. I just happened to meet the maker of the ice cream today! What a neat meeting! I told him a flavor I've been pushing for at "Bayley's"! He gave us tons of yummy snacks to try! Told us a new flavor that he'll be whipping up soon. I can't tell you what it is..I'll ruin the surprise. What a super nice guy! I've always wondered who was the maker of my delicious ice cream..and now I know! Thank you for my chocolate candies!! You're totally sweet! My new favorite flavor this Summer is "Chocolate Doughboy"! It's chocolate ice cream with chocolate cookie dough and chocolate chips in it. It's so creamy, chocolatey and oh so yummy! I'm telling you...best ice cream around for MILES! I miss it so much when I have to go back to Massachusetts.. This place is always super clean inside and out. The parking lot is always so neat and has tons of pretty flowers. The girls at the window are always so sweet. They never screw up your order like other places..why you ask? Because they right it down! They are always dressed nicely and always have their hair braided super cute! Bayley's...you totally rock!!!!! It's my Summertime..love affair!!! read more

A friend and I were craving ice cream in early April. I knew that it was opening weekend at the Dairy Corner so we attempted to go there and saw the line from a mile away. I like ice cream but not that much. So, we decided it to check to see if Bayley's was open and they were. Bayley's ice cream is the best!!! It wasn't my first time there but it was for my friend and she was very happy. Later in the week I wasn't feeling great and I knew ice cream was the cure. I begged my boyfriend to go to Bayley's but they were closed (still weekend only season). I was bummed but luckily the owner was in there making ice cream and he told us to come inside. He scooped us some ice cream and had a great conversation with us for about a half hour. He won customers for the summer and beyond. read more

Amazingly good ice cream with lots of options and smiling staff. What more could you want?

Ordered the two scoop..portion was big enough but the M&M ice cream had small fake M&M"s. Also had the purple cow and barely any chocolate or white chocolate pieces in it...not impressed...hopefully will improve over the summer but plenty of other ice cream joints in the area. read more

It's your basic all American roadside ice cream shack. Though it does have quite a few more flavor options than one would usually find at such a place. Makes Baskin Robbins look like amateur hour. Also it's like 100 yards from the lovely Scarborough Marsh. So you can take you dairy desert to go and wander along the lovely paths. Or just stand around in the parking lot. This is America. Do whatever you want. read more

Bayle's is by far my favorite ice cream place in the whole world!!! When I ate there I got Oreo/Cookies and Cream ice cream and it was very tasty! I recommend it! read more

Nightly experience every year! Love the white chocolate lavender! Sea salt caramel! Nice big serving sizes. A small goes a long way. Friendly and quick window service. Delish. read more

Our family was impressed by the polite happy young ladies working at Bayley's last night! They were all smiles even though it was a busy crowd that the faced! The ice cream was absolutely fantastic! Everything my family got was scrumptious and full of flavor! We will be coming back to enjoy more experiences there! The owners have a gemstone! read more

Delicious, creamy ice cream with great flavor.. blueberry ice cream with whole blueberries, black raspberry Oreo..so delicious. White chocolate lavendar .. OMG...very friendly & efficient counter staff..it's our go too summer ice cream spot ! read more

Great flavor selection! Currently they're operating as a drive up operation--employees come to your car to take your order and then bring out the ice cream to you, very easy and efficient! read more

The more people that go to Dairy Corner and Beale's, the better. Translates to shorter lines at Bayley's for the rest of us. Anyone with a brain knows Bayley's is the best in town. As locals, it's our second-most anticipated opening of the Spring - right behind The Bait Shed Bar at Bayley's Lobster Pound! read more

Delicious ice cream, and tons of flavors. Don't miss the pumpkin pie (while in season) and the Maine blueberry -- freaking excellent. Awesome hot fudge sundaes, too! read more

Bayley's is my family's favorite ice cream shop! They are always offering innovative, fun flavors. Last night we tried "purple cow". It was DELICIOUS!! read more

Great ice cream. Caramel sea salt is the best I have ever had. The sizes are large and we usually order the kiddie size and it is plenty. Every flavor that we have tried has been really creamy and delicious. The folks that work here are really nice and patient. Our little ones sometimes take a minute to finally decide on a flavor. We love to stop for ice cream here on the way to and/or from the beach down at Pine Point. read more

One of my top favorite ice cream places in Maine!!! It's all homemade ice cream and there are so many unique choices that you can't find anywhere else. Their employees are also the greatest! read more

Huge portion, but the quality was not good. I got a small cone of key lime ice cream w choc sprinkles for about $4.50. I had to throw half away because it was really gross- had bright green fake-lime tasting slime through it. I would maybe try this place one more time before writing it off completely. read more

This place continues to be amazing. Large selection of homemade flavors and great service. Seriously, try the cake batter! It's my favorite! read more

This place is awesome! So many ice cream flavors. They even offer gluten free cookies & cream, as well as gluten free brownie and cookie sundaes (if that is a need for you). The service was great and they have kid sized picnic tables and adult sized chairs. This is a walk up ice cream spot. Very clean and yummy. the selection is just amazing. read more