Bella's New York Pizza was one of the highlights of our trip. Tucked into a modest building with a nostalgic charm, it felt welcoming from the moment we walked in. My family and I stopped in late for dinner after a long day, and despite it being close to closing time and having served plenty of sandy beachgoers, the cashier/waitress was incredibly friendly, attentive, and professional. Her kindness left a lasting impression. We ordered the Margherita pizza with pepperoni, and it was easily the best Margherita pizza we have ever had. The sauce was rich and flavorful, the crust was delicious, and every bite was excellent. It even surpassed our favorite pizza place back home, which we never expected. Based on the amazing food, welcoming atmosphere, and outstanding customer service, Bella's has become our favorite pizza spot in the area. We will definitely be back the next time we visit. read more

Bella's New York Pizza - Margherita pizza with pepperoni's - Pizza Near Me - Calabash, North Carolina

Pizza was delicious Great crust and toppings Ordered by phone and ready on time I love to give patronize a small business read more

As a former New Yorker, Great ! New York style Pizza. Good service. Highly recommend !

2nd time I've eaten at Bella's ! Wonderful! I ordered a pepperoni pizza slice! Generous portion! I'll definitely be back!

Our first night in a new home called for pizza in bed. Turning to Yelp led me to Bella's. We ordered two 14" pizzas, one meat lovers and one white pizza with mushrooms and meatballs. Jen took our order and I went to pick it up. She was super friendly and very personable. The place was pretty empty but it was a Monday night. The order was ready exactly as expected and still hot when I got home. New York style thin crust with just the right amount of chewiness. Not too much sauce on mine with great flavor. The ingredients seemed fresh on both. $50 with a tip seems a little steep for 2 medium pizzas so we won't frequent this place but the pizza is good and staff is nice so worth a visit for sure. read more

See all

This place came recommend as the closest thing to NY pizza. You would be better off getting a Tombstone pizza at Walmart. Sauce had no flavor and the ham tasted like the canned hams. We ordered wings and they were not deep fired, over boiled and sauce was drizzled. Definitely not a place I'll return to. read more

Bella's New York Pizza - The welldone w8ngs we ordered BBQ'd - Pizza Near Me - Calabash, North Carolina

See all

This is the second pizza place I've tried in 2 weeks. The pizza was cold and the woman who gave it to me was not very friendly. Guess she was having a bad day... not my fault! read more

Workers on their phones Terrible customer service. I sat and waited for quite a while and I finally asked if it was ready and the girl said she'd look. It had been ready for almost 15 minutes and she Laughed. The pizza was cold when I got it home and I'd heard so many great things about Bella's but definitely will not ever go back ! read more

Ordered a pie over the phone to be delivered and it got here quick and it was hot. Very good pizza. Will continue to order from them. Very happy. read more

We ordered pizza for carry out and it was good. The gentleman that waited on us was very rude. He expected us to leave a tip for just picking up. When we got there and paid our order was not ready which was ok so we waited. When our pizzas were done he carried them out dropped them on the counter didn't even say it was our order or thank you turned around and walked away. read more

My spouse was wanting a New York slice and this place did not disappoint. She thought it was one of the best she has had. She ordered the lunch special which included two slices and a drink for only $6.50. A couple days later since we were still in the area, she ordered another pizza and I got the spaghetti dinner with garlic knots. All were very tasty. Will definitely return one back in the area. read more

It's good to be back as the Community Ambassador for the North Carolina Triad. I can't wait to get going again in my area, but first, I need to leave a review for one of the places out of town that I really enjoyed while taking a short vacation to the beach. Bella's Pizza is not much to look at, but it's a great place to order pizza on those beach nights where maybe the family has gotten tired of seafood, and you're just looking for a good local pizza joint instead of a chain. It's really not a dine-in place, especially not right now during COVID, but they are efficient in getting your take-out orders in, finished, and served up to you hot. My wife and I tend to like Calzones when we can get them, and that's exactly what we opted for here, as well as a side of garlic knots. First off, the Calzones were very large and packed with lots of mozzarella and ricotta cheese, and that's half the battle right there! I got mine stuffed with pepperoni and italian sausage, and was very pleased. The calzone interetstingly enough came with what was clearly a meat sauce for dipping instead of just pizza sauce. I really enjoyed that fact, but my wife would have preferred just plain marinara. We both enjoyed dipping our bread in the leftover garlic butter mix at the bottom of the garlic knots pan, though the knots themselves weren't anything overly special. Why five stars then?? Because this is CALABASH, NORTH CAROLINA. The fact that you can find something close to authentic NY style pizza and the like is a small miracle in a town that is pretty much just a seafood outpost. This place clearly outpaces the other options in the area, and deserves your business. Bella! Bella! read more

See all

Best Stromboli around!! Thank you for your NY inspired pizzeria!! Delicious!! I will be getting this again for sure!! read more

Tucked away in a small strip center, Bella's appearance is deceiving. They only have six or so tables inside so take away is probably the way to go here. We ordered three 16" pies and a couple chefs salads that was more that enough for our crowd of seven. The pizza was very good. I loved their Meat Lovers though a couple of people in our group found it too spicy for their tender pallets. The veggie pizza was also very good as was the cheese pizza. The chefs salads were really good with lots of toppings. If you're in the area Bella's is a good choice for takeout. read more

Excellent Food Excellent customer service. A nice small town local joint. I recommend it !! read more

Salad was fresh and tasty. The pizza was very tasty but I prefer an oregano pizza sauce. But we will order it again.

Just ate at Bella's pizza very good pizza and salad. Will be back to try wings and other menu items

Best pizza at the beach! Excellent service. Dine in, take out, and prompt delivery service

I remember when we had our first house in Sunset Beach this was one of our favorite pizza and sub places in the area. I had a doughy not fully cooked experience when I moved back the second time... Well three times a charm I'm back for the third time and after seeing how Bella's slices their meatballs thin I had to try and I am so happy I did. Both pizzas were really good and the Ruben sub looked fantastic. My mom complimented the quality of the pastrami and enjoyed it. I will def keep Bella's in mind going forward when I'm in the mood for a Ruben but for now I am in love with the thin sliced meatballs on their pizza so this is just another Non disappointment and for sure go to pizza place within minutes of my house. read more

See all

People can't really complain about the prices when ordering online. There is a menu and plenty of webpages with the cost. It is pricey but you either agree to pay for it or you go somewhere else. I agreed to pay the price and it was worth it. We've ate here twice. Would I eat here again? Yes but it's only like once a year so it's not that bad to pay for. I wouldn't mind eating here more often but the price wouldn't allow that but that is the times we live in. read more

Finally got their pizza. I asked them for thin crust, and they made it for me. Both people there were extremely nice. The pizza was how I like it! Great flavor and a little greasy. read more

Best Pizza we have had since moving here! Truly best NY style pizza! Service was great and owners do friendly!

We didn't like it. I don't know how to explain it better than, no one wanted the leftovers and we threw them away.

Two nights in a row, we have Ben pleasantly surprised! Really awesome Chk Parm Sandwich and Meatball Parm Sandwich! Thank you! We are local and we will be back! read more

Great pizza does not look like much from the outside it's very undated but the pizza was delicious we'll be back again The waitress went above and beyond to get us what we needed. read more

Bella's New York Pizza - Large pepperoni pizza amazing - Pizza Near Me - Calabash, North Carolina

See all

We were looking for a tasty pizza that could be picked up in a reasonable amount of time. Bella's didn't disappoint.

Ordered two pizzas for pick-up and was pretty disappointed in the taste (and we were all VERY hungry, so takes a lot to say that)! Pizza is thin as expected, but crust was bland and chewy. Inside the establishment didn't quite give us that "clean" feel either - Eve though we were just picking up. I know this is a staple pizza shop in Calabash, but we would look elsewhere before ordering from here again. read more

A 16" supreme pizza and two cannolis cost over $30. The pizza had no flavor even with all those toppings. New to the area trying new places. We will not be back. Expensive and poor quality. No thank you. read more

We ordered takeout food 2 pizzas,chicken cutlet parmigiana and calzone all we're good not excellent but had good flavor,I'm use to NY pizza,but would definitely recommend Bella's of Calabash,we will be back read more

Just love this place!! Authentic people, authentic food, enormous smiles every time!! Meatballs and Garlic knots, bruschetta, calzone with chicken, sausage, mushrooms with extra ricotta. All good, every, single, time!! read more

Great food.... Owners a dick must be a northern transplant ... disrespectful and out right called me a liar saying my service dog wasn't a service dog read more

I have eaten at Bella's a few times and have ordered many times there subs, but for whatever They had going on tonight , our subs were Pretty sloppy, did not have very much of The meat, cheese or hardly a few bites of Chicken Salad. We also told the lady we wanted A piece of chocolate cake, which she repeated Our order but we did not get cake. The Pickle Looked like someone took a bite out of it. THEY SOUNDED LIKE THEY WERE VERY DISORGANIZED, while I was on the phone placing my order. VERY DISAPPOINTED read more

Really good pizza and a decent facility. Waitress was very nice and attentive. It was definitely worth the trip! read more

Bella's New York Pizza - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Calabash, North Carolina

See all

Pizza is great! Open late! Ambiance a little lacking but pizza makes up for it or take it to go.

The pizza was hot and good! Freshly made. We ordered by phone which took awhile since we had to hold awhile. The place is located in a small shopping center and a little hard to find when we didn't know the area. read more

There for a family reunion with over 30 people. We took over the restaurant. Service was awesome and food too. Shout out to Bob for his patience. read more

Great pizza, but shabby dine-in area. Order takeout & enjoy at home. Pay ca$h, otherwise they tack on a 3% surcharge if you pay with plastic. read more

second time visiting here, 2 for 2. the pepperoni and mushroom pizza is very good. we also had Caesar salad, it was ok but nothing too rave about. nice staff and good service. we will be returning. read more

Plenty of food choices, Tasty subs and super fast delivery. Enjoyable meal in Calabash.

Nice people, good food, good value and a pizza that's NY enough for a hardened New Yorker. I like this place! The meatball topping is killer. read more

Bella's New York Pizza - Yummy, small sized meatball, pepperoni, and anchovy. That's a real pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Calabash, North Carolina