Went tonight because my father-in-law loves the fried oysters. I ordered the grilled chicken sandwich with bacon and cheese and an order of crinkle fries. Best chicken sandwich in Savannah! And the fried oysters were outstanding. read more

This is a local small chain restaurant with about 6 locations in the Savannah area. We ordered take out pulled pork with coleslaw and Brunswick stew side orders. The pulled pork was tasty, fresh and moist and grizzle free. The sides were delicious as well. The prices are super reasonable and my order was ready when I arrived to pick it up. We will definitely visit Carey Hilliard again! read more

Decided to come eat here as this is my usual spot. Got sat and we already knew what we wanted so when the host brought our drinks my husband told her we were ready to order, she ignored him and kept walking and didn't go get anyone. We sat for 10-15 minutes without a server coming by when I finally got someone's attention and she got a different guy to take our orders. The girl that was the hostess, all she was doing was walking around and gossiping. Extremely unprofessional. Food was pretty good, other than the fried chicken was overly salty. Won't be returning to this location. Chris, the manager did speak to us, but clearly a lot needs to be done in this establishment. read more

Serenity was a great server. It seemed like she was the only one attentive to the customers. Everyone else was hanging out in the back somewhere. The line had got to 6 people waiting on the host to be seated. The host ran so fast to seat people and place their menu down just to go back to wherever. The bartender spoke when we came in and said good bye. The host looking frustrated leaning on the desk said nothing. The food came out quick and taste good. It seems like the staff wasn't happy to be working and the customers noticed it as different ones commented. The smash burger and fries was very filling. If it wasn't for the lack of good customer service this would be a nice place to bring the family. read more

Carey Hilliards Restaurant - Smash burger - Barbeque Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

I ordered Lunch from this restaurant today.The white tail on shrimp was not cooked in fresh cooking oil they we very dark brown.The shrimp was also over cooked.The salad had no dressing in the bag as I did request salad dressing.There was no sour cream or butter for the baked potato.The entire meal was not worth the price and poorly prepared. I did call to speak with a manager and he was not very concerned. I may not be coming back to this resturant. read more

Service is inconsistent and specific requests ( like "hot" fries) are disregarded. Several tables were left unbussed for a long period. CH has fallen in my opinion. read more

I stopped in on my way home from a very long drive. CH has always been one of my favorite restaurants. I ordered the Captain's Platter, save some for later! The service was terrible! I asked the waitress, nicely, to wipe the crumbs from the table. She looked at me with one of those 'no you didn't' looks. She then wiped the crumbs in my lap. She did not give me utensils nor the Splenda I'd previously requested. I later asked for a to-go box and my check. She argued with me about letting me see my bill and stood over me while I was getting my card. I felt intimidated into giving her a tip that she did not deserve. Oh, the flounder was so thin that it curled. read more

This is the first time in decades since I have had the opportunity to visit this location on Waters Avenue. I was skeptical because the old running name of this location was "the bad Carey Hilliards." I felt as though I was taking a chance but I had been to the Southside location and it really had changed. I knew that the family really wanted to return to the model that made us locals flock here and stay here, so I wanted to give the Waters Avenue spot a fresh take. I was pleasantly surprised and glad I did. I ordered the flounder and scallops with the cheddar baked potato. Yum, yum, yum. The seafood was fresh and it tasted local. The restaurant had several decorations that were The Grinch themed which was really cute. I was well satisfied with the food and I would return and recommend my friends to come here too. Carey Hilliards has been a staple in the Savannah community for many years and I am glad they are returning to their roots when it comes to the seafood place. read more

hubby and i went into hillards on waters yesterday and it sucked out loud, food and service both was awful , the manager wasnt very nice either.we will not go back into that place period. gone wayyyyy done hill. read more

I would classify this restaurant as a comfort food restaurant. That's not to say that's a bad thing, but there doesn't seem to be a lot of food choices that really stand out above and beyond comfort food. I would say it's a safe place to take a family or have a gathering where everybody would be satisfied by what's on the menu. I had the deluxe club sandwich, and while it was good, I didn't care for the fact that the toast slices were very very thin. It made the sandwich difficult to eat because the thinness of the toast was almost difficult to hold the sandwich because it absorbed the moisture in the rest of the food and kind of came apart. The toast between the slices actually was non-existent because again it had absorbed the moisture and come apart. The servers were friendly and at one point the manager came by to ask how everything was which is always appreciated. read more

Carey Hilliards Restaurant - Deluxe club sandwich with thin shaved ham, good but could use some thicker toast. - Barbeque Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

I haven't been to Carey Hilliards for several months but that's going to change. I picked up 2 orders of chicken fingers tonight, one with baked potato and cole slaw and the other with cheddar bake and green beans. The food was delicious. All I can say is every item tasted better than on my previous visits. I called the restaurant and asked them what had changed and was told it was under new management. Whatever they're doing, I hope they keep doing it! read more

Can never go wrong with Carey Hilliards food. Our server, Destiny was a delight. And provided excellent service. Soft background music and a quiet enjoyable dinner with my spouse. The kind of food and service that keeps us coming back time and again read more

I always have a great experience here. the staff is great and thorough. y'all have a gem in Janae. She is always so sweet.

The food here is always good, but the service we received this time was completely unacceptable. Our waitress, Jessica, never greeted us when we sat down and acted annoyed when we said we were ready to order -- she told us to "give her a second" and made us wait even longer. She ignored our table multiple times, and our drinks sat empty until we repeatedly asked for refills. To make things worse, the host -- who wasn't even our server -- brought out one of our meals and managed to be more polite and helpful in a few seconds than Jessica was during our entire lunch. It's a shame that the kitchen and food quality are great, but the service ruined the experience. Definitely disappointed and won't be coming back if this is how customers are treated. read more

I went to Carey Hilliards on Waters Ave like 3 days in a row. Each time they never gave me condim for my baked po or my pork club. I called the manager and told her what happened and she gave me a credit for a whole meal. I am so appreciative of her and that she didn't downplay my concerns. Thanks Carey Hilliards! read more

The girl took order was just so nice. The food was hot fast and ready traveling from Jacksonville nice lunch! Great price 1 sweet tea thank you so much. Enjoyed my lunch. read more

As long as I been dinning in/ takeout at this restaurant me and my family has NEVER had the most welcoming, respectful, font counter experience Brianna ( hope I spelled it correctly) continue to be grateful! read more

Best ! Thanks Timmy for keeping it real , the food on waters never disappoints, fresh , hot , cool to order , great prices, nothing like Carey's ! read more

Nice atmosphere, they were a little short staffed, had to wait 10 or 15 min at 3:pm, no big deal. We were seated and our waitress was new, she did a decent job. We ordered smoked wings for an appetizer. We got 6 smoked wings, a little small but WOW, they were delicious, give them 8, only because they were small. Our main meal I got shrimp, scallops, oysters with green beans and pasta salad. Wife got grilled flounder, a baked potato and coleslaw. We did not like the pasta salad and green beans were just plain. The hush puppies were very plain. The seafood I give it a 4. The flounder had a little too much pepper, also a 4. If we ever go back there, we will stick with the wings, they were by far better than any wings I have had in SC. read more

See all

Ordered the Fish Sandwich (flounder).. It was Awesome.. Fresh and a nice size as well. My lettuce, onions and tomatoes were fresh as well. Had to call the Manager to let them know to keep up the good work. Also, good customer service.. always good to me... I have no complaints read more

Seems to be inconsistent the service and food here Have never complained but the baked potatoe I had to remind my server to bring out wasn't even warm The butter wouldn't melt My guests potatoe was the same Also the Brunswick stew was minimally heated. The server also offered no sauces for my shrimp had to remind her and no sauce for the Barbeque. We weren't even offered beverage refills Hoping the owners will see this and see what may be going on Hilliards has been known for their quality and always consistant read more

04-17-25 ordered a house salad without any cucumbers and when she repeated it back to me again I said no cucumbers. when it came it had cucumbers! When I told her that it had cucumbers she said " I really wasn't listening " She did offer to have it remade but I didn't have time to wait so I just ate the chicken.i guess when I want a salad I'll go to the places where you make your own! read more

In the last few months, this is March 24, 2023, The food has degraded. I believe that they are recycling french fries and perhaps hush puppies. When I asked for replacement fries, they never came. Now going to the one on Abercorn and seeing similar with the fries. WTF read more

Visiting from Florida at Skidaway Island State Park, this was our first time at Carey Hilliards. The restaurant was clean (including restrooms), we were genuinely welcomed the moment we entered, the service was outstanding as was the food. JA was our server and she was polite, helpful and knew the menu, helping us make good selections. Our drinks never hit empty! We shared pick 3 seafood plate and had food to take home. It was delicious, properly done and fairly priced. This is a spot we recommend and will revisit. A great find!!! read more

This long running, locally owned restaurant still offers curb service, in addition to, online ordering at careyhilliards.com, carry out and dine in. While this locations interior and exterior look a little tired, the service is still as friendly as ever and is a family restaurant that has something for everyone. Also, they cater and have banquet facilities for private events. A craving for their crispy onion rings were what brought me here today. They were served piping hot, hand battered and crispy crunchy, as always. They should box and market their breading - I'd buy it! The 10 piece tail-on fried shrimp, ($7.99) were very good, but I regretted the choice of side upgrade to Brunswick Stew. The consistency was mushy with all the ingredients as if they were puréed together. Other information to note: they serve a variety of 5 hand spun milkshakes, open until midnight every night, locally owned since 1960. read more

Carey Hilliards Restaurant - Fried shrimp and Brunswick Stew - Barbeque Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

absolute favorite restaurant in Savannah we celebrate our holiday party and it was a blast so many people came and happy with us on our birthday the staff were amazing everybody is very friendly the food is fresh the chicken is the best in the south there is covered parking and they bring the food outside if you need we will definitely come back read more

Carey Hilliards Restaurant - Barbeque Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Just wanna give a shoutout 2 my girl McKenzie every time I come & your there you always go above & beyond making my experience a pleasure when I place my order with you. You always make sure I get exactly what I order, the way I order & I appreciate you always having Respect & GREAT customer service when I pull up on the curb ! ***** read more

Grilled catfish and Cole slaw were so delicious and at a very good price Service was very good, everyone was friendly and helpful. Ann Johnson read more

Good food and service but we need one in berwick/south beige or close to RH county kine

one star is too much. I am a native Savannahian. In the past, Hilliards had the best fried chicken and we would go weekly until a few years ago when things changed. That was when they started using the lowest grade of chicken that could be sold for human consumption. We decided to give it another try last week. Both my husband and I ordered the white meat fried chicken. The cooks did an excellent job of frying it but the quality of the chicken is so poor that nothing could make it good. There was bruising throughout the chicken that had purple colored slime. The bones did not have the normal coloring of a chicken bone purple instead. My breast was white in color with just a little purple slime. but my husband's breast although well fried was a pinkish purple color throughout the meat. not at all the coloring a chicken breast. Totally disgusting. Maybe this poultry should not be used for human consumption. read more

Placed an order for my wedding. We did not receive all the food. Several items were not brought out. The young man said that they can keep the items that we don't use. How can we use them if they never brought them out? read more

The food was great, and our waitress was new to waiting on people I think. The issue was with a different waitress, I got up and went and ask for a box to go, the waitress I ask barked at me saying go sit down and I will bring you one. She didn't my wife had to get up and get us a box. I won't be back no excuse for bad customer service. Nice quiet place read more

Let me begin by saying I was born and raised in Savannah Ga. Carey Hilliards on Waters Ave have always been one of my favorite places to eat. I ordered a Fried shrimp and grilled scallops for my dinner on August 24th. I received fried shrimp and grilled shrimp. I normally check my orders before leaving but I didn't. I immediately called once I arrived home. The manager James stated I could come pick up a new order which I told him I couldn't that I would come the next day. I am sitting in my car waiting for my order as well as another order that I placed. I was told I was only getting credit for scallops. Called the corporate office and she stated she will just charge for the other portion of the meal. I am still sitting in my car after 30 minutes. Still waiting on my parents food. Carey Hilliard's it was nice knowing you but you will not get my business again. read more

Hilliard's is a local chain that's been around decades. I've eaten here several times (various locations) over the past 40 years. The food is consistent, servers typically very personable, and attentive. Seafood seems to be their primary offer, both fried and broiled, and taste is god but fairly typical of these kinds of restaurants. That said, I am a big fan of their fried chicken. I don't know how they do it, but it's better than restaurants specializing in this dish. I suspect the extra time needed to fry it has something to do with it as the menu alerts to an extra 30-35 minutes needed to prepare it. However, Hilliard's heart may not be in making barbecue. Tonight, for a change, i ordered St. Louis ribs as a take out. The ribs were dry, and salty to the point of being inedible. I rinsed them thoroughly under hot water and used some sauce we had in the pantry. There still was a strong salty taste, but they were edible. Dry, but edible. I hope this was a one-off kitchen error as the green beans were unusually salty as well. I'll go back because I like Hilliard's, but I'll got o a proper barbecue spot for ribs. read more

We take the RV to the state park at Skidaway most years around Thanksgiving. Just about every trip includes a visit to Carey Hilliards for a plate of fried shrimp. No exception this year. The White Shrimp platter was the usual excellence. Shrimp were breaded and fried - plump and tasty. I had a baked potato to go along with it - wish it had real butter instead of "spread," but it worked OK. Being this close to the sea, I never felt the need to order from their BBQ menu. But this year, I noticed the Premium Side menu offered Brunswick Stew as a choice. I love a good stew and ordered it as a side. What a disappointment - the stuff in the bowl was more like a paste than a stew. Not sure if a blender or food grinder is involved in making this stew, but that's what it seemed like. Flavor might have been OK of the texture didn't make it look like something that I'd rather not compare to food. It took big points off what was otherwise a good meal. The fried shrimp has always been a safe bet here - spend the extra dollar for the "white shrimp" over the regular. Price is good, atmosphere isn't very "seaside-like," but it does have a certain character. Waitstaff is always friendly, and I've never had to wait for a table. Just be careful about the stew! read more

I just moved to the Savannah area, from Dallas / Ft.Worth ..listening to the radio, I heard a commercial about Carey Hilliard's,. of course I decided to try them out, So I went to the one on Waters Avenue.. I got my dinner To-go, I could see that the restaurant had a small town feel, the staff was very welcoming. My To-go Specialist, Grady was so kind,, he was professional and informative. Chicken Tenders AWESOME read more

I've been going here my whole life, I will never again go back, the last few times it's just so gross. This was my uncooked hamburger steak tonight, I am sick to my stomach. read more

Carey Hilliards Restaurant - Barbeque Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

Not as advertised. Food was cold. Potatoes not done. Best thing was the onion rings and they were greasy. Service was not good at all.

We dined at the Abercorn location after an appointment on 1/17/24 for lunch. I don't know why we have been sleeping on Carey Hilliards! I eat crab stew everywhere and it was the best I have ever had and was full of crab! I had the seafood platter too and made three meals off it. The hush puppies were also phenomenal! All was nearly as good as at the restaurant reheated in the air fryer! The prices are great too! read more

Interesting night to say the least. The positive note about this posting is the staff enjoys each other's company very much, however if you're expecting service you can forget it. This review actually begins a few days ago, when I came in for sweet tea, that's it. After waiting 30 minutes I asked the cashier how long she thought the tea would be. She turns and asked another lady at the food window, that says nothing and continues what she is doing. After about another 10 minutes I asked again, the cashier ask the same lady yet again, this time the lady looks at me like I'm interrupting her whole day, says nothing, and walks away. I think about 5 more minutes passes, and, now annoyed, I ask for my tea. This tea was a gift for someone and found out today the tea wasn't even sweet, even though I asked 3 times for sweet tea. I figured I'd give the place another go, giving we all have our days, right? Ohh no! This is some of the most horrific service I've ever seen. In fact, tonight I was able to witness a staff member cussing and threatening a guest. There needs to be a review of this restaurant and corrective actions should take place. There are 100's of places to choose to eat at. This shouldn't be one of them. read more