My top pick for the best slice of pizza, hands down. Their basil infused marinara, right amount of silky cheese and an exceptionally thin crispy crust makes this the perfect slice. This is the first pizza I have ever tasted and I reassure you it will be the last. Other favorites of mine: Alfredo slice (Must, must, must try), and the white slice (only place where I eat it) and by far the best pepperoni slice in Brooklyn. This may sound corny or cliche but you've tried the rest, now try the best! [Andrew "dice" Clay voice]: "Put some flava in ya box, agush!" read more

If I could give it a half of star, I would. I was very hungry and ordered a chicken roll to go. What could go wrong with a simple pizzeria dish like chicken roll?! Everything!!! It was the worst chicken roll I've ever seen or tasted. I only tried a piece and threw the rest in the garbage. First of all I've never seen a chicken roll so dry, not a drop of any kind of sauce. Absolutely dry and burned pieces of chicken a drop of cheese and almost raw tomatoes. It seemed as they took whatever the leftovers they had and make a roll. It looked and tasted absolutely disgusting. Last time my parents came over and wanted to order pizza from them, because it's supposedly the best. It was very dry with burned crust and not a single person find shed their slice, went to garbage. This was the last drop, I'm never ordering from them again! read more

This place is my golden slice, the perfect slice of NY style cheese I compare all other's to. My family has been enjoying the pizza here since the 60's. When I make the trip to NY this is one of my must stops. Needless the say, the crust is ideal, with a light crispness. The sauce has a nice tang with out being sweet. Their sign says they are famous for white pizza, and I can see why. They spread the slight sweet ricotta evenly where the sauce would be, it is then topped with mozzarella cheese, this goes on their same wonderful crust. I this was my first visit in over 8 years, the neighborhood has changed alot, I think this is one of the few business that has been there over a decade (let alone 4). I dropedin for a late slice and some Gino's iceses on a Monday night and was a bit surprised that they did not have any italian ices. I don't know its seasonal, or if the change of the neighborhood brought about this travesty. If you have a taste for the more exotic pizza they will have what ever the current fad pizza is, over the years there has been Al la vodka pizza, eggplant pizza, pizza with pasta on it, and today a bacon Alfredo seems to be en vogue. The inside is straight forward counter upfront to order, a few booths in back, and a restroom past that. If you want some of the best pizza in the word, with out any of the long lines i highly recommend trying this family owned place. read more

See all

The only place i use to order pizza. Always fresh pizza and the dough is super thin and yummy! Highly recommend

This place is so clutch for a classic NY slice. It was delivered in 30min with the crust still crispy and the cheese piping hot. I got a plain cheese pie, fresh garlic on the whole thing with half pep. Very satisfying. Can't wait to try the grandma! read more

NOOO! they are temporarily closed as they are completely renovating after SANDY b/c they got flooded. I love love love their pizza. Their pepperoni pizza is amazing simply because they put the cheese on top of the pepperoni, makes such a great difference. 2 of my favorite pizzas at this places are the Vodka pizza, which is nothing like any vodka pizza i've ever tasted anywhere else, and also the Alfredo pizza with bacon bits. Both of these are so delicious, and are the reason I love this place. Amazing how a small pizza spot can be so good even though it's just a storefront shop. Hope they hurry and re-open! read more

I want to start by saying this was a one of the best pizzeria in sheepshead bay but recently they got alot of new young employees and the customer service and morale has just changed I ordered a specific order and the girl on the phone kept saying anything else as if she had everything the way I asked. Then the food took over a hour and a half to get here. When I contacted the store for the first time the girl had a attitude and said its going to be about 20 mins more 45min pass I call back she laughed and said another 10mins then hung up. When my food arrived it was cold and not at all the way I asked for it. I'm just disappointed!!! But w.e on to the next one. They dont need my money anyways. read more

I've yet to try a regular slice in New York that comes remotely close to delmars. And I always make it my priority to try new pizzeria wherever I go. Their sauce to cheese ratio is perfect and the crust comes out crisp to perfection about 99% of the time. The grandma and vodka slices are also pretty amazing. This is a true hidden gem in the heart of south Brooklyn. I'm kinda glad none of these bs food network shows have gone here yet, all we need is another place with ridiculous waits because of tv hype. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Delmar Pizzeria is absolutely amazing. The menu is extensive, I was overwhelmed with the choices. A dish that I guarantee you will definitely love is Vodka Pizza. Very friendly workers. I would come here again. read more

Extremely rude girl who answers the phone for orders. For this alone, this place will never get my business. Hire someone who knows how to speak to customers. It seems people forget that pizza in Brooklyn is not hard to come by. If a customer chooses your business, treat them with kindness and respect. read more

One of the best pizza in NYC. I have ordered it by phone, and it has been delivered in about 45 minutes. Super delicious! read more

This pizza was one of the best I've tried in Brooklyn. The pepperoni and Vodka were my favorite.

favorite pizza spot in the neighborhood. grandma style and yodka slice are always really good. I've been going here for years and they've always stayed consistent besides raising the prices by a couple quarters. Highly recommend the regular style as well, its always crispy! read more

Their Alfredo slice is the best pizza I've ever had. I have not found a place to compare.

I used to enjoy eating at Delmar Pizzeria until today. I walked in, starting cleaning a table cause staff never cleans tables after people get up. A man in a rude tone said I must show my vaccination card. This was not a problem since I always have it. I responded by " my mom has it." "Your mom has your card?" The guy said. This really isn't his business who has my card as long as I show it. Look, I get it, we all have rough days, but do not take it out on customers. I go to my mom to take out my card after she showed hers and I showed another guy my card. He had to analyze my card as if I was lying. Very odd!!! I said you know last time we were here, no one asked for our cards. Again, respect wasn't taught to these workers (I'm guessing), he responded, well these new rules just went into effect last week. Actually they did not, it's been in effect for a few weeks but the city is cracking down and fining places now. He gave me an attitude from that. To sum it up, he asked me what my issue is, I said I didn't like the way the other man "greeted" me with his attitude about the card.. and the guy started yelling I had the attitude. (I'm pretty sure this is the owner) I wouldn't eat at this place, but before I left he made sure to say goodbye by calling me a BITCH in front of other customers. Absolutely disgusting!!! I would never eat here again and I've been going there for years. I could handle the dirty place but the disgusting attitude from people is not OK! Their pizza isn't even that good. Go around the block by the train station to the pizza place and you have nice workers and a clean place. read more

Delicious pizza and best chicken paninni Use to order many times, delivery always on time read more

Best pizza in this area...no other pizza in this area compares. Good sauce, nice and crunchy crust. A little pricey.

Worst pizzeria ever. They can't take an order properly and can't cook anything right. When I order a chicken roll I received grilled chicken and tomato in wrap. Since when is that a chicken roll. Th manager is not nice. Delivery boy doesn't come with change. Who doesn't bring change. I'm not giving a 9 dollar tip on 40 order. read more

Pleasantly surprised to find this place. The pizza is great and the restaurant is sooooo clean. The menu has a nice variety but not overwhelming. No wonder this place is busy. read more

I use to order at least ones a week from them, and noticed quality went down. Today I had a group of kids in the house and ordered pie. When it was delivered cheese was falling off the pie and I called to complain. I was interrogated with allot of questions like who took my order and when, instead of asking what is wrong with my order. When finally I had a chance to say the cheese falling off the pie lady yelled ti the kitchen "she complains about cheese falling off the pie". I will never order again. read more

Ordered a grandma pie and buffalo chicken pie. Grandma pie was delicious, buffalo chicken pie was ok. Expect to pay$$, the pizza pies are pricey. The Yelp free Garlic knots offer are no longer accepted, I showed the cashier the offer after checking in, he didn't apologies or anything but said "we don't take that". Overall experience was ok. Cashier could be a little more friendlier. Guys behind the counter making the pizza were great. read more

Was in the area visiting and came across this restaurant pizzeria.Only had pizza one regular one Sicilian, it was amazing pizza.I highly recommend Delmar to anyone looking for good quality food.I eat pizza many x a month and always go to different pizza restaurants read more

Best neighborhood slice in sheepshead bay. Pepperoni is seriously on point. I won't order pizza from anywhere else.

Great local pizzeria that has been a staple in the neighborhood. Whether you are eating in or ordering the delivery, the quality is always there. Definitely recommend it. read more

BEST PIZZA IN BROOKLYN! This has been my all time favorite place since I moved to brooklyn. The crust is very tasty and its nice an cheesy. You can dine-in, take- out, or get it delivered. read more

Very good pizza! Great representation of Brooklyn Pizza! I definitely recommend going to Delmar Pizzeria!

As a kid (prior to the days when I owned a stringing machine) a walk up Sheepshead Bay Road to Bay Sports to have my rackets restrung was conducted on a weekly basis. Upon my return, a slight delay was conducted to grab a quick slice of pizza at Delmar Pizzeria. There isn't much that needs to be said about the interior confines at Delmar. The establishment itself resembles that of most Pizzerias in the surrounding Sheepshead Bay area. Most patrons that go to Delmar find themselves getting their Pizza to go. Those dining in can render themselves at ease on many of the Formica based seating booths available in the back of the establishment. Forget the Fresh Mozzarella, at Delmar's, it's all about the specifically processed stuff! Plain Cheese Slice: Similar in appearance, contrasting in taste. What should be highlighted about Delmar's rendition is the complex textural contrast derived from the three primary components of the Pizza. For starters, the slightly crispy crust foundation provides a welcoming introduction to a sauce that's both tangy, yet sweet. Slight hints of black pepper and oregano were detected when consuming the slice. The specially processed mozzarella topping was perfectly gooey, without the excessive renderings of the oily byproduct. What should also be noted about the cheese is the marveling balance of saltiness in its flavor. Just the right amount of salt was detected between the sauce and the mozzarella. All of the elements combined to create a well rounded slice of Pizza for which was both delicious and affordable. Needless to say, I shall return for a slice... or three. read more

Every time I goto delmar for pizza or pasta is always on point great atmosphere...... the pizzeria is always clean the PIZZAMAN and Manager are great guys read more

I worked here one summer, errrr, 10+ years ago; it was actually one of my first jobs. WHY, you ask? Because it was damn delicious and a girl needs her pizza fix. I'm absolutely not biased, because I couldn't care less about who works here now and if you've seen my previous reviews, I am very objective about the pizza game. It is no laughing matter. I order every now and then, and this slice never disappoints. Really, it is your classic Brooklyn slice; perfect amount of cheese and robust tomato sauce, with a crust that's always fresh. Vodka slice here is good, but I always go for a classic regular. Honestly, I even stopped getting pepperoni because it messes with that cheesy regular slice that takes you back to childhood in Bensonhurst. The pasta here is delicious as well, but I have ONE complaint keeping this from being a five: guys, why is the penne vodka not al dente? Was disappointing. Everyone knows all you do is put pasta in boiling water and set a timer for 7 minutes and drain. DO IT. Keep it up, Delmar! read more

Pizza is okay, garlic knots were too greasy, not enough garlic, service is okay as well. Delivery was on time, when we dined in however it was slow and the staff weren't very friendly. Had better pizza and service at other pizzerias, nothing special. Won't be returning back. First and last. read more

Here is an excerpt from my review originally posted on our site: I was walking down Sheepshead Bay Road near Voorhies Avenue sometime close to 11 a.m. and a wonderful, garlicky smell permeating the air reminded me that I hadn't had any breakfast. It was as if my feet had a nose of their own, because they immediately brought me to Del Mar Pizzeria at 1668 Sheepshead Bay Rd. Sure enough, there was a hot, cheesy pepperoni pie just coming out of the standard, stainless steel pizza oven. Naturally, I decided against the plain one that had just come out a minute, before. The pizza-professional swiftly rolled his knife into the pie and asked me if I wanted my slice to stay or to go. I could have just grabbed the whole pie right off the pan, but it was blocked by the glass display. I looked at the normally-busy dining area and noticed there was no one there. The thought of having the place all to myself somehow made me feel like Will Smith must have felt in I Am, Legend. Here I was, the last person left in Sheepshead Bay (oh, the pizza chef was just a robot - oops, sorry, this is I Am Legend, not I, Robot), about to indulge in my steaming hot breakfast. Figuring there was no one around to call the ambulance should the liquid lava-cheese... read more

Charging $5 per topping on a pie and then putting 2 small slices of pepperoni per Sicilian slice? Embarrassing. You've hit a new low when you have to rip off customers by skimping on toppings to save money. Sauce was good and so was the cheese but once again low quantity of cheese. Crust was okay but the bottom of the pizza had a plastic texture to it. Was weird. With the good reviews and $23.95 + tip, I expected something at least average. Extremely disappointing. Wanted to give them a chance. Probably the worst experience with pizza I've had in the area. read more

This is not first time ordering delivery pizza from Delmar and it is not the first time receive disappointment. The issue is not with the flavor or presentation. The issue is with the delivery service. The pizza arrives with all the cheese in one conner of the box. It seems like the someone has been kicking the pie around. To give a toping to this review, the pizza arrives cold. This is hard to understand due to we live 5 minutes away. read more

Delmar Pizzeria - This was suppose to be vodka pizza, but it's not! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I called to place an order for delivery. I asked the girl 2-3 if there was any meat in the food and she said that didn't. When the food came in it turned out that there was ground beef in the half of the food I ordered. The rest of the food wasn't great either. What ticked me off was when I called the manager blamed me. He said that I didn't tell the girl that I didn't eat meat, when I know that I checked with her multiple times. Mediocre food. Really, really bad service. read more

feels like brooklyn is the pizza mecca of the world, and everyone's telling you to go to totonnos or grimaldi or difara (god, how I love thee, difara!). but sometimes, you just don't want to trek all the way to who knows where to wait in a line for however many hours just for a slice of pizza goodness. Sometimes, a girl just wants to be able to quickly grab a really good and legit slice of ny pizza...thin, crispy crust, yummy sauce, perfectly foldable and really delicious. This is that slice! Had their regular slice and it did not disappoint!!! Also tried the garlic knots...these were a 1 out of 5...they were dry and all dough, no fresh garlic or herbs or anything else. People behind the counter were friendly. I saw other yelpers talking about the vodka slice...a group in front of me grabbed the entire pie *whomp whomp* but I'll definitely be back here again to try it :) read more

Pizzas always good. I've eaten here many times and it's always consistent and fresh. The plain slices are great but if you wanna try something new get the bacon Alfredo and the vodka slices. read more

One bite, everyone knows the rules. The pizza is nothing special at all. Don't judge a book by it's cover. 6.7 at best. Lots of flop, poor quality ingredients. read more

Over the years, I have ate there countless times, the regular pie is great, plus the pizza bianca has always been great...Yesterday, we had the eggplant pinani's and it was perfect... - Always clean and comfortable, close to the train station, managed/owned by the same family for years.. If you are in the Bay, hit the Delmar.... read more

Some of the best pizza you'll find in Brooklyn in an extremely unassuming atmosphere. The best slices I had were the Vodka slice and the Alfredo slice. Let's start with the Vodka. Instead of tomato sauce, it's vodka sauce -- and everything is better with vodka sauce. The flavor, the zest, the taste is unbelievable. I'd like to share an entire pie. Alfredo is creamy and has pieces of fresh bacon. Enough said. If you've never been to Delmar, make the trip to Sheepshead Bay Road to sample their wonderful creations. Don't expect anything fancy and the prices are very reasonable for the incredible pizza you'll receive. I will be back again and again. read more

I have been eating Delmar for 30 years. Last week I order a chicken parmesan with pasta for delivery. Well next day or 2 I was food poisoned by the chicken. Took me over a week to get over it .I will try and speak to Gus about my experience. Be careful if your ordering chicken dishes . No problem with the pizza read more