Good pizza and a welcome change in the rotation from your typical New York slice. Ordered the other night and the delivery came perfectly on time. Unsure of exactly what to expect from sizing, my boyfriend and I split the largest size (the 14 inch) and each had two filling meals out of it. We got the classic (sausage, peppers, and onions) and I believe the pizza was $34 altogether. We also added on a side of the house paprika ranch for an extra $2 and they forgot it, which was pretty disappointing. With that said, the pizza was good and filling with plenty of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The blend of cheeses in particular was really great. The crust was a little on the sweeter side, which isn't my personal preference, but my boyfriend liked it a lot. The pizza also reheated notably well, which I generally can't say about most spots, so it made for good leftovers the following day as well. All in all, solid za. Will order again and/or try one of their sandwiches. read more

Delicious deep dish pizza, they had a table available during lunch time in soho so we decided to eat here. The pizza was incredible and the restaurant felt like a pub which was cool. The waiter was a little rude but did not ruin the experience read more

Came here for dinner on a date. We got a medium pie and we were stuffed. No need for appetizers, but if a third was to come, would probably recommend getting a salad as an appetizer. The deep dish pizza was delicious. I've had great pizzas in Chicago, and this definitely comes close, but not exactly at that level yet. My only complaint is that we got the Gabe, and I feel like there could have been a lot more toppings than what we got. I wish that we had more. Other than that, the flavors, crust density and chewiness are all there. Service is really on point. The place was packed but we always had water and our beers came out very quickly. Great place and would definitely come back again to try the thin crust pizza! read more

Emmett's - Beer menu - American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

One extra star because their deep dish pizza was really really good. Their Greek salad was really fresh. But they really burned the thin crust where it was inedible and only offered us 20 percent off the pizza. The owner was rude. It is really small and only beer and wine. I would order their deep dish for delivery read more

Amazing pizza, caesar and Greek salads. Warm and cozy atmosphere. Excellent service and attention to detail by Noah

Truly amazing pizza! Went there on a weeknight and thankfully we had a reservation so we were seated promptly. There was a bit of wait between the drinks and pizza but that's understandable given the pizzas are super fresh and right out of the oven to your table. We ended up making our own deep dish pizza which was delicious. We got a salad on the side which was good too and they also have an impressive wine list. Can't wait to go back! read more

Emmett's - Build Your Own Deep Dish Pizza - American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

So yummy. I loved the deep dish pizza and the cup pepperonis!!!! We sat outside, very nice ambiance. The Chicago dog was good, too. read more

Emmett's - Meat lover pizza - American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Service was quick even thought they were really busy for a Wednesday night. Deep dish pizza was good, it's not like a New York pizza but worth trying. Happy hour beers are a good value. Small place but eating at the bar is fun. read more

Been coming here for 5 years now. The staff are attentive, act with a sense of urgency, and always so helpful. Whenever someone asks me for the best pizza in the city I always tell them Emmett's thin crust. It's crunchy, the sauce is divine, and the perfect amount of cheese. Don't even get me started on the best Caesar salad of all time. 10/10 every time. read more

We split the Italian Beef for the appetizer. Good but beware it packs heat that I was not expecting. My fault, I didn't read the description. The deep dish pizza was good but our favorite was the thin cheese. Very tiny place but it was worth the visit. read more

I ordered the Italian beef sandwich and honestly my fat a$$ was like I forgot to tell them I wanted the ITALIAN BEEF SANDWICH not slider when I tell you looks can be deceiving or it could have been ordering while hungry the hand cut fries didn't stand a chance well seasoned crispy on the outside soft inside were inhaled I unwrapped the sandwich dipped it into the gravy and immediately walked into the next room and slapped my momma for holding out on this tenderness that I had to write a review from my hospital bed my mom didn't take it too lightly being smacked over a sandwich and although I didn't get to finish it the 3 bites were well worth the broken fingers sidebar rather than slapping your momma just get her a damn sandwich as well at least you'll get to enjoy it and she wouldn't be telling you how good it is while waiting for the ambulance to arrive ‍ read more

Came here early like 1 pm and sat and the bar w/ my girlfriend and we order all this ! Every part was good and tasteful..., the mozzarella sticks were a good start to order before you order the main meal but if you just want to order the pizza here . I would do it ! It does take time so be patient w/ the bartender who was name Fawn , Who is a great at telling you what to order. And also a Chicagoan as well . Get here early on a weekend or just wait at the bar while your watch pies come out one by one for tables . I will be back again , it's a small place so try to come in small party's of 4 so you don't tooo long for a table . read more

See all

We tried the thin crust (think hot papi) and a deep dish with sausage and mushrooms, my favorite was the thin crust. the crust was crunchy and the toppings went well. the deep dish was okay, i never usually have deep dish in NYC but it wasn't bad, just preferred the thin crust. read more

If you're looking to change it up and go deep dish, Emmett's is your spot. They serve legit deep dish with a wide variety of specialty pies. We went with the Classic family size and it was delicious with the sausage and peppers. Th crust had a nice crisp. The pie is pretty saucey, so just a heads up. The family size comes with 8 thick slices. If you're moderately hungry you can get away with 1 or 1.5 slice. One thing to note, it takes about 30-35 mins to prepare so don't come here if you're in a rush. The place is tiny and intimate with just a handful of tables plus a bar. The service is friendly, but due to the long wait for the pizza, an update at some point would have been helpful on when it is arriving. (Especially if you're starving and impatient.) Overall, great option for deep dish. read more

Emmett's - The Classic DEEP DISH, family size - American Near Me - New York, New York

Well Worth the Wait! My title has two meanings, the first that I have been waiting ages to try Chicago style pizza, but also the pizza itself takes time to cook so plan your meal here accordingly. We got here a bit early for lunch so it was almost empty, but while we had our meal the place did fill out nicely. So in reference to waiting, the say on the website if you are ordering a deep dish, it takes roughly 30 minutes, the one we ordered took a bit longer, Ill get to that soon, roughly 45 minutes. We were ok with this because we planned out the time so we weren't dyeing of hunger. My toddler daughter likes to nibble so when we got in we ordered fries and the arugula salad. Both came in nice serving sizes. The fries were seasoned really well, nice hint of salt, but not to much. Fried well, crispy outside with a soft interior all packed into thin cut fries. The salad was really good, nice balance of greens to other ingredients, enough to have a spread in each bite. Now the PIZZA! We ordered the THE CHEESE LOUISE in a 12 inch pie. Because of the caramelized cheese on the crust it takes an extra 15 minutes, roughly 45 in total to cook. Like I said we were prepared for this, we waiting on fries and salad, and yes, it was so worth the wait! The pizza is like and inch tall in the center, and a 2 inch crust. The center is this amazing mix of soft crust, thick layer of nearly liquid mozzarella, and super thick layer of amazing tomato sauce, deff needed a fork and knife for this. The flavors are super well balanced, very fresh and well seasoned. The pie was a six inch, but after the salad and fries we each only had one slice, it was so filling. Later for dinner we warmed it back up in the oven...and it may have been even better, just heavenly. Still super filling and we still have one slice in the fridge! Hit this place, you will not be disappointed! read more

See all

Probably the worst NYC pizza I've ever had. Maybe worst pizza period. My bf and I came Sunday afternoon around 1pm and it was empty minus a few ppl at the bar. We always eat at Raku (the Japanese udon place next door - 11/10 if you're interested) but the wait of an hr and our grumbling stomachs made us decide to give this place a shot. We got seated immediately and decided to get a chicago hot dog and a Mr. Red. The chicago hot dog was a fancier nyc hot dog and at $6, it's okay. Nothing to rave about. The pizza. Imagine a crappy cracker with a can of tomato sauce poured on top and then a few piece of basil sprinkled on top to justify the $20 price point. To be fair the waiter did say "its a cheeseless pizza" but I've had other cheese-less pizzas and this was just .... Crap. Do not go here. Go to the other places on the block maybe just not here. The one star is for the service which was fine. read more

Emmett's - American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Went there on a Sunday afternoon and it was super busy. We tried to get a table outside but the wait was over 2 hours so we order for takeout. The outdoor seating is limited as they do not have much space. When we went to pick up the pizza at the time it was suppose to be ready, we were told we had to wait a few more minutes because they were backed up. We waited an extra 30 minutes for the pizza to come which was crazy. But while we waited we saw only one waitress taking care of all the tables and the pickups. We did not complain for the wait and we took the pizza to eat at the park which was good but not worth the wait. read more

See all

It's not bad for deep dish. All jokes aside, this was OK and it's cool if you're in the mood for something a little different, it just didn't win me over. The place is small, expect a bit of a wait. They text you when your table is ready. They play great 80's music and have a heavily 80's themed bathroom. Service is excellent: friendly, kind, personable. We ordered a pie with caramelized onions, sausage, and mushrooms. Sauce is on top and it was more crushed tomatoes than sauce. The cheese kind of gets lost. Crust was pretty chewy, more like pie crust which I guess it has to be to hold the jacuzzi of sauce that goes on top. The toppings were sparse, the onions and sausage especially, we had trouble tasting them there seemed to be so little. The whole thing seemed to fall a little flat....like it needed salt? It was a good change of pace, and I'd come in for a drink, but I wouldn't seek out their pizza again. read more

See all

Service was good. Draft beer was enjoyable. As Midwest natives and deep dish lovers, we came for the deep dish pizza. Unfortunately, it pales in comparison to the hot Chicago spots. I'm happy I was able to get the experience out here in NYC, but there are better pizza spots in the area. The crust doesn't offer the traditional rich, buttery flavor one would expect from a deep dish. read more

Emmett's - Cheese Louise Deep Dish - American Near Me - New York, New York

Really cool place! It's super tiny with 6 two tops and 2 3 top tables. They literally pulled our table out so I could sit and pushed it back so getting up to go to the bathroom was out of the question. It's very rustic with a great old radio from the 80's behind the bar and the music is the same era sometimes early 90's plays. The pizza is very good and authentic Chicago style. There a small bar that shares the space and it was completely packed the entire 2 hours and we came at 10:30 on a Saturday night hoping it wouldn't be so busy but busy is a good sign right. We also really enjoyed the Cesar salad which had a light very well made dressing and the Innis & Gunn beer which was excellent!! If you are in the neighborhood and love Chicago pizza this is the place for you. FYI they also serve Chicago dogs. read more

See all

Had a casual birthday dinner here for 8 people and it was great! Service and food were all great, we enjoyed the thin crust just as much as the deep dish pizza too read more

Before picking up my Emmett's take & bake thin crust, I hadn't had pizza in over two months. That's tragic for someone who ate pizza weekly in a pre-covid life. The pick-up process felt safe. They don't let you into the restaurant, just into a one-person-at-a-time vestibule equipped with hand sanitizer. Then I went home and waited in anticipation for my pizza to bake -- they provided written instructions on how to do it. When I took my first bite, I knew this was the perfect pizza for curing my withdrawal. I also ordered an arugula salad which had a really nice dressing. read more

Emmett's - Pizza - American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great spot for a lowkey dinner and a fun vibe! Pizza was great, Caesar salad is a must! We visited Emmett's for a friends birthday dinner a couple weekends ago and will definitely be back soon! Given how many people were seated, the staff was definitely very accommodating. We got the jalapeño and plain pizzas as well as the chicken parm. Really hit the spot. For drinks, most of us ordered the grapefruit spritz which paired well with the meals since it was light and refreshing. One thing I will note is that it was very loud inside and I had a lot of trouble conversing unless it was with the people right next to me. Definitely not a dealbreaker as the food itself was really good! read more

See all

Emmett's is nestled just east of 6th Ave on MacDougal. We were greeted by a friendly staff member, Greg, who ushered us to our table while he chatted us up. We came here on a self-guided pizza tour so we ordered a 10" deep dish meat lover with beers and wine for the wait. The wait seemed a bit longer than the standard 30 minutes for a deep-dish pizza. When our pie came out, it was, unfortunately, the wrong order and we ended up with the sausage classic. The staff was apologetic for the mix-up and bought us a round for incorrect order. We did not want to wait for the correct order so we ate the sausage classic (which was our second choice). The pizza was not as hot as we would have liked. The sauce was cold and the toppings were lukewarm. The cheese looked stringy when it was cut which made it look hot, but surprisingly it was not. The other food that came out of the kitchen looked really good, worth coming here to check it out for yourself. read more

See all

This is the only place in NYC that has the Chicago favorites like the Chicago style hotdog, Italian beef sandwich and Chicago deep dish pizza. I had the meat lovers deep dish pizza. It was good but I have been spoiled by Giordano's, Lou Malnati's Pizza and Pequod's pizza. This is close but not quite. I can't explain what it was about the crust but if you in live Chicago you will know what I am talking about. But the service is great. This is the only place that I know that sells all of the Chicago favorites. read more

See all

I know pizza. I eat it at 2x a week. Emmett's thin crust is some of the best. Now I know most of you are expecting a review of the Chicago style pizza. I don't love that type of pizza, so this review is for the thin crust. What a hidden gem! So crispy and so tasty. Love the way the pie is cut because there are a ton of tun angles and slices to eat. It really makes eating an adventure. read more

I can't say this was the most memorable. I've had better pizza elsewhere but it was okay. We tried the hot papi pizza, the mozzarella sticks, and the caesar salad. The mozzarella sticks and caesar salad are exactly as you think they would be. Nothing notable nor nothing different, I also don't see how you COULD mess up things so basic. The hot papi pizza was okay but not special. It was crispy and the toppings were fine but I honestly wouldn't come back here again. read more

Delicious pizza that hit the spot. Waiter was overwhelmed on his own serving everyone. Owner needs to make sure that front of house does not affect the amazing pizza they serve. read more

WAY BETTER THAN THE HYPED LOMBARDI'S PIZZA!!! Don't get me wrong, Lombardi's was amazing, but this was off the charts!! My boyfriend and I were really craving some deep dish pizza and hands down, we did not regret this one bit! The location was a bit hard to find because their sign wasn't obvious and it's a bit of a hidden gem. The seating is quite limited with a max capacity of about 20-30 people, I would guesstimate. On a cold and windy day, heavy coats are a must, but these coats can be hung on a rack outside of the seating area in order to conserve seating space. We came in around 2-3 PM, and this place was still serving plenty of pizzas! DISCLAIMER - Just a heads up in case you've been starving yourself to come here; to prepare a fresh deep dish pizza, the wait time ranges from 20-40 minutes. Trust me when I say, the wait will be worth it! My boyfriend and I shared a medium (10" sized) Gabe Froman pizza. The portion was HUGEE and loaded with cheese, spinach, pepperoni, sausage, tomatoes, and sauce!! They really do not skimp on any of their ingredients. Each bite was packed with flavor and stringy goodness - incomparable to Lombardi's pizza. I never imagined myself in LOVE with deep dish pizza more than my love for thin crust pizza. I always thought of myself as a thin-crust-pizza-kind-of-girl, but this has changed my perspective entirely. The crust was not dry at all, like I thought it would be. It was thick and bread-like which complimented the sauciness perfectly! Not only was this pizza the bomb, but it was extremely filling!! We took 1/3 of this pizza home as leftovers!! When we were at Lombardi's we were definitely full, but didn't have any leftovers. Honestly, the best pizza I've had during my trip to New York! So GLAD we ventured away from our New York food itinerary list (believe me, it was long) and popped into this joint. read more

Emmett's - Gabe Froman Medium (10") Deep Dish Pizza was to die for!!! :) - American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The "food" is not Chicago food at all. The thin crust is gritty. The combo Italian sausage and beef is dry (even though I asked for dipped). The cheese on the fries is congealed. The fries are not salted or crispy. They are floppy thin and soggy. I'm from Chicago and know proper Chicago pizza, beef, and sausage. This is not it. If you are from the greatest city in the world, and know it's food, avoid this place. read more

See all

I'm a big fan of deep dish and if you're like me you know it's often a struggle to find. I ordered from here last night prepared to be disappointed, but I'm so glad I was wrong. Pizza was excellent. It will definitely be my new go to spot in the city for some solid deep dish . read more

Got the hot Papi and it was delicious! Also had a Caesar salad that was good. Amazing little restaurant in a great location. Seating options indoors and outdoors. Close to Washington square park and a great area to walk around in Greenwich. read more

Had lunch at Emmett's on Saturday afternoon. It is the New York City spot for deep dish pizza, with a very good pie. Absolutely worth a trip when the mood hits. Quality: I was craving deep dish pizza, and Emmett's is the deep dish spot in New York City. While they also have thin crust pizzas and an assortment of sandwiches, every single table had a deep dish pizza on it. Knowing there would be a wait for our pizza, we ordered Mozzarella Sticks to hold us over. They were solid, crispy and cheesy, with a tasty marinara sauce on the side. However, the main event was The Sausage Classic Deep Dish, which we added extra cheese to. While not perfect it was a darn good. The extra cheese was definitely a key component, it was lovely seeing it dripping down from each bite. I would have liked the crust down a bit more, I feel like you may be able to ask for crispier, as the outsides were a little too doughy for me. I also felt it was a little heavy on pepper and less so on sausage. Still I would not hesitate to return and probably would order the same pizza again. Quantity: Splitting the 10" Deep Dish with two was just a little too much pizza, but felt like the best option. The tables around us both ordered larger sizes and ended up taking multiple slices home. Value: $7 for the Mozzarella Sticks. $27 for The Sausage Classic Deep Dish 10" Pizza. $2-$4 for Extra Toppings. Ambiance: Emmett's is located in the South Village area of Manhattan. It is a very small spot on a bustling street. With a line of restaurants on the block, the street is now stuffed with constructed outdoor dining structures. For Emmett's it is crucial because currently they only have three small tables inside. The indoor area is snug, with the bar, kitchen, and seating area all close together. It is a space with very few updates over the years, a lot of cool photos on the walls, and rock music constantly playing. Crowd: Reservations are recommended, but not required. Because of limited capacity issues and the lengthly wait for a pizza, it is probably best to be safe and make one if you want to sit down quickly. Service: Come in with the expectation that you will be waiting at least 30 minutes for your pizza. If you are starving, you may get anxious, but patience is worth it. Parking: Difficult to find parking nearby, the subway is the better option. read more

Emmett's - Mozzarella Sticks - American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Service was outstanding!! Pizza I'm sorry it did NOT taste like Chicago deep dish. Maybe because I been spoiled with Giordano's. Italian beef was not Chicago style either. It was good but not even close to Chicago. Once again I been Spoiled with Portillos and Rosatis. Didn't try the Chicago style hot dogs because we were already stuffed maybe next time. read more

Emmett's - Meat lovers Deep Dish Pizza - American Near Me - New York, New York

I am so happy I discovered this place. So cute. Inviting. Warm. The people who work there are Amazing and so nice. Being accommodating. I wish we had tried the Chicago style however we went for their version of NY STYLE. OMG amazing! Thin. Crispy. No outside crust like regular pies. Tasty beyond belief. They put a time down so the pie sits then they cut it into squares. Fantastic. Truly a wonderful experience. Not cheap but then again what is right now? Totally worth the trip. Can't wait to go again. read more

This place did not disappoint. It's super small, so be prepared for a little bit of a wait. The bartender, JJ, was a rock star. I came here with a friend to celebrate our July birthdays. We ordered Prosecco, a Greek salad and a deep dish pizza with basil, sausage, caramelized onions, and mushrooms. JJ gave us some mozzarella sticks on the house too! Everything was delicious and we had a blast. Again, the place is small, not good for big groups, but worth it for some real buttery crust deep dish delights. read more

Emmett's - Deep dish with basil, sausage, mushrooms and caramelized onions - YUMMMM. Crust was so thick and buttery. - American Near Me - New York, New York

Good Chicago style pizza however double check your bill. I was overcharged ( Double) for ingredients. This was a take out order so I did not check bill until I was home. Next visit I had brought previous bill with me for refund. Individual indicated I would need to speak with Manager who was not there - Go figure. Sadly in doing so they did not get my next order for carryout read more

Deep dish Chicago style pizza was very good- takes awhile to bake, but worth the wait. Our server was the bartender too very attentive! It's a small place with some outside seating read more

Was very excited to go to this popular place. Got the deep dish pizza, the shaved beef sandwich, and the mozz sticks. The pizza was good but kind of bland, and the crust a little to thick for my liking but could just be my preference. Beef sandwich was good but the au jou too salty. Really liked the home made mozz sticks a lot. Overall solid restaurant definitely worth a try. read more

See all

I came into Emmett's around 12pm with a party of 5. We were seated right away, but I would highly recommend a reservation if you plan on coming after 12:30 or 1:00, cause it filled up really quickly. We opted to order mozzarella sticks and the cheesy garlic bread to start. Both were excellent, but the mozzarella sticks only came with 4 per order so kind of awkward to split. It wish our waitress would've said something about that when we ordered. We split the Hot Papi flat crust pizza to split. We had opted to get the thin crust instead of a deep dish because the deep dish would take 30-40 mins to make. Honestly, our thin crust took about that long to come out so really, we could've just gotten the deep dish. That being said, the pizza was really good and I really liked it. Two members of our party got the Chicago dog and the fries were on point. read more