Never again, unless they change cooks or owners. The sandwich was unappealing to the eye, extremely salty and the Cole slaw didn't taste home made. It used to be a place known for its burgers but my mom found hers to be bland and the fries flavorless. Hopefully they'll be some improvements since it's in a good location. read more

Gordy's Burger House - Philly Cheese Steak with Sauteed Onions and Home Made Cole Slaw - Burgers Near Me - Bronxville, New York

So, I was supposed to write this review two weeks ago, but I'm still recovering from the deliciousness overload I experienced at Gordy's Burger House. Me and my BF or on our way to Trader Joe's on a bright and sunny Saturday afternoon, but realized that we were starving, and it's not a good idea to shop (especially at TJ's) on an empty stomach. I decided to look on trustee or Yelp for suggestions in that area, which is totally unfamiliar to me. I looked at the stars and thought, "mediocre," so I read a few reviews that sort of contradicted the stars. We were hungry and decided to give it a chance regardless. The outside was nothing impressive... We entered what looked like a low-key old school Irish bar. That was just the far side of the establishment. A friendly gentleman escorted us to opposite of the bar to the restaurant side of the establishment, which had much brighter lighting. The menu had what appeared to be typical diner fare, but with a little extra here and there. I was tempted to order a milkshake, but I'm so glad I did not! Let me explain... As far as the burgers are concerned, you had an option of what I think was an 8 ounce burger, or an 11 ounce burger. Don't forget we were hungry, so 11 ounces for me and my boo. We started with soup, and were surprised by the fresh, unsalty rich flavor. I can go into great detail about the French onion soup that I ate two weeks ago because it was so delicious, but I recommend that you go and see for yourself. So those burgers took some time, but not too much, and came out all pretty and shit. And yes, I took pictures! LOL! So so good... juicy, not greasy, well seasoned, and completely filling. I ate half and that was strenuous. My BF's sweet potato fries were cooked perfectly and were very enjoyable. The place was relatively quiet on both sides, except for the family with small children. Nevertheless, the kids were great, the bar side it was quiet with two or three day drinkers, and our server was really pleasant and accommodating. I almost forgot... thumbs up for the great prices! Perhaps this will be our out of the way, Saturday morning/afternoon spot where we pig out every so often when we make the occasional trip outside of NYC on the way to Trader Joe's. The photos haunt me... read more

See all

I went back to Gordy's yesterday for my bacon Swiss cheeseburger fix, and for some reason, it tasted better than ever. My wife had the Rigatoni with broccoli rabe and sausages which she loved very much. I gotta go back there and sit at the bar with some beers and other types of food. There burgers are addictive read more

Not a fan of their burgers, they're fine! But they're not the ones I crave. Same meh for their wings. Other spots have them beat. I want to like this hyper local spot but it's outdated. read more

Great food and portion sizes! I ordered online and was pleasantly surprised at the quality, taste, size of my burger and potato skins.

Moved to Westchester County and began looking for superior burger places. Saw positive reviews of Gordy's and it did not disappoint. I was surprised how hard it was to find a good burger - and Gordy's was great. Wonderful local bar yet family atmosphere. Standard pricing. Great find and I urge you to try it out. read more

Sunday--July 2, 2023--We just left and I paid for NOTHING. From outside we hear kids screaming. We walk in and there are two small kids running through the restaurant screaming like they're at a playground running around the restaurant through the bar. The place was empty so I guess they thought it was okay! It's not okay. You get the idea. These screaming kids finally end up on the bar side. The man they were with (I'm assuming their dad) was sitting at the bar. With this screaming continuing, the waitress comes over and closes the door to the bar. We can still hear them but at least not as loud. Honestly, I wanted to leave. I'm not up for someone else's kids screaming and running around while I'm trying to eat. Our food arrives. We are eating maybe five minutes. Those two kids break out from the bar area and again are running through the restaurant screaming their heads off! Now they're at the door right opposite our table. Are you kidding me with this? My mother raises her voices (honestly because they were screaming so loud you have to raise your voice!) and says "Hey, hey...you don't do this here!" The bar door opens. I can hear the dad saying something to correct them. Two seconds later the waitress with the blue hair (I didn't see a name tag and I didn't get her name) comes over, puts her hand out and says to my mother "don't yell at someone else's children!" Excuse me but you don't speak to an elderly person the way this waitress did. That is not acceptable and it was just downright rude and disrespectful. I was expecting an "oh sorry for that" or "I'm sorry the kids are loud we'll try to keep them on the other side" something to that effect. But no. The waitress with the blue hair decides to correct my mother! Oh girl. . .that's a hell no! I jumped in. Not happening. You are not going to talk to my mother like that. I said, "Excuse me! We are paying customers trying to enjoy a meal in your restaurant. I am not here paying for a meal to listen to someone else's kids running around screaming like lunatics. This is not a place for that." The look on her face was one of shock! Her eyes just about popped out of her head. I guess she didn't expect me to say anything. She said again "but you don't have the right to yell at someone else's kids like that!" I said again, "I absolutely have the right to say something when I am in a restaurant trying to eat a meal and have conversation and I cannot because someone else's kids are screaming while I'm trying to eat. I am paying for a meal!" She looked at me like this is something so foreign to her! Where is your customer service??? I said "You know what? Get the manager. I'm not paying for this meal. I'm not paying to listen to this." She was like okay...okay. She came back with to-go containers. I said, "No I don't want your food. I'm not paying for this food. I'll pay for the salad my son ate." Then we just left and didn't pay for anything. At minimum I expected the waitress to apologize for the noise and the screaming. I did not expect her to talk to my mother like that! Not happening. I was going to spend about $90 maybe $100 between the meals and dessert, but that did not happen. Needless to say we will never be going back to Gordy's again. read more

Well, tonight I am back for the third time in 4 nights. Last night, I brought my brother-in-law to see and taste for himself the magnificent wings and burger. He agreed with my last review. Tonight's fare is the NY Strip Steak, medium well, baked potatoe with butter and sour cream, steamed broccoli and Gordy's Famous Southern Cole Slaw. He says it's southern if you put onions in it. He told me the other ingredients, but you will have to ask him yourself. I don't want to reveal trade secrets! The steak is cooked well. I didn't need the A1 that sits on the table. The meat was tender and as a steak should be. The sides are also good. The broccoli wasn't overcooked. The cole slaw is delicious. The baked potatoe is a baked potatoe. Lol. You will be pleased with this combination as it is delicious and each item complements the others. Gordy's continues to please and is well woth the trip. Did I mention the prices are great? Don't tell Gordy, we want the prices to stay reasonable for such good, wholesome food. And say Hello to Susanna, his wife. She was my server, and she is friendly and makes great suggestions. read more

Gordy's Burger House - a plate of steak, potatoes and broccoli - Burgers Near Me - Bronxville, New York

Stopped in on a Monday night to grab a burger and beer. here is street parking and across the street, so it's convenient place to stop in. Bar is small, but folks were distanced apart, so I could sit there. If it was an issue, I could have gone to the other side where the booths are located since it's separate. Thought my cheeseburger was ok, about on par with most other bars, and enjoyed the cole slaw. read more

See all

Horrible Horrible service. Took 3 weeks to get a hold of Gordy- who once I spoke to him called me "dear" in a condescending manner and raised his voice. My husband and I have called multiple times to get resolution on a delivered burger that was pretty much raw (I ordered it med as I am pregnant) and nasty uncooked thick diner fries (I ordered shoestring fries) He then also told me why was I wasting my time on $50. Mind you- $50 for 2 burgers and fries. Another show of horrible customer service... No one else at this establishment would help us when we called- they told us they didnt know what to do- and to finally speak to the owner of the establishment and be screamed of made rhe whole experience even worse. It was a basic american burger and fries- shouldn't be that hard. Run from this restaurant- if they can't get that right, how horrible must the rest of the food be? read more

I decided to update my review and raise their rating. I do believe their burgers are tasting much better these days. I stopped ordering from them for a long time, but about 6 months ago I started ordering their burgers again and I find them to be much more delicious now than in the past. Since then, I've been ordering burgers from them a few times a month. My father, who is the pickiest man on the planet when it comes to burgers, actually loves their burgers and makes me order from them every time he comes by. I've also ordered a few other items on their menu, but it's all just basic bar food really, and pretty limited in choices. I do have to be honest though and say that this place is still in need of a major update, and their bar area smells kinda funny. About a month ago I went into their bar area to pick up my order (I was wearing my face mask), and I could still smell that unpleasant smell that those old, dingy bars have. It smells like spoiled beer or something...can't really explain it. I also found the bartender (older gentleman) to be rather discourteous, but maybe he was just having a bad day. Besides all this, I do really like their burgers and will continue ordering from them. Give them a try! read more

I got a delivery today, a cheeseburger with mushrooms and onions and french fries... the food was ice cold like it's been sitting there. Meanwhile, the delivery was quick so that makes you wonder if they have them just there waiting. The mushrooms were like as if they just came out of the refrigerator. My bread was so soggy like I said, it's because it was probably sitting there, the french fries were so greasy they had no flavor and again they were iced cold. I would definitely not order food from them anytime soon unfortunately read more

So this bar has been down the block from me for literally my whole life...restaurants and businesses came and went....and some how this mysterious little old school looking Burger place was still standing. I recently noticed that they had delivery and pickup ordering on Grubhub, and decided to order some buffalo wings and sweet potato fries on Super Bowl Sunday for myself... since I wasn't planning on going to or doing a whole party this year...my order was ready in about 35 minuets and I walked in the dark outdated bar to get my food...the bartender handed me the wrong meal (which I noticed in the car) and I came back and I think the manager, made sure my order was correct. The wings were pretty good they had like a sweet flavor which isn't exactly what I look for in buffalo wings but also mildly spicy...the sweet potato fries were actually amazing and fresh exactly what I was looking for. I will probably order pick up again (definitely fries again) because like other people said, this place is underrated food wise..but they 100% need to update this place, it looks musty and old school and I don't think I would ever actually eat in here or hang out. read more

Gordy's Burger House - Take out buffalo wings and sweet potato fries. Wings a little on the sweeter side but the fries were great. - Burgers Near Me - Bronxville, New York

Truly lives up to its name. One of the best burgers I've had in a long time. The potato skins were amazing too. Excellent service and a great atmosphere. I'll be back very soon! read more

I ordered using Ubereats. The burger was quite literally one of the worse I've had. It was bland and undercooked. The cheesecake was basic and lacked flavor. The BLT was partially burnt, and the bacon was of poor quality. All around, this was a horrible experience. read more

Gordy's Burger House - Cheesecake - Burgers Near Me - Bronxville, New York

This is a great place for Burgers !! Make sure you get the 12oz Burger ! My Father owned Fran-Lee Burger House in Mt. Vernon and Gordy's has Burgers that are just as good ! Gordy's has the charbroil open flame grill and you see the flames flare up when they flip the Burgers, this gives them that great flavor and juiciness !!! They serve the Burgers on a Kaiser Roll and have a wide variety of toppings. The Burgers come with shoestring fries, but you can get Sweet Potato fries for a small upcharge. Heidi makes a delicious, light and so creamy cheesecake that you simply must order for dessert !! Great booths that seat 6 and each booth has it's own TV !!!!! Me and my mom always sat in the front booth by the window for lunch. My mom passed unexpectedly on Sept. 17th, so when I go, I still sit in that front booth every single time. Thanks Gordy, Thanks Heidi !! read more

Friendly service and the food was delish! I will definitely be back! Each booth on the restaurant side has a tv with your own remote great place to watch a game and have a beer and delicious burger. :) my daughter got the chicken fingers and loved them ,and she is a chicken tender connoisseur LOL. Glad I found this gem! read more

Got the Philly cheesesteak with fries. Was not impressed with the cheese they used or how it's served on a Keizer roll rather than a wedge. Fries were to die for. I probably wouldn't get the cheese steak again but I definitely would go back because the owner is VERY nice and I want to give their bacon cheeseburger a shot. read more

Good food, nice,friendly service. I like that they have TVs in every booth. Nice homemade desserts! Highly recommend and will return! Nice to have a local place. read more

Gordy's Burger House - Burgers Near Me - Bronxville, New York

See all

Just had lunch at Gordys for my birthday. The steak was medium well and cooked to perfection. Onion rings were out of this world and the French fries were delicious. Couldn't ask for a more perfect birthday meal. Thank you Gordy. read more

Stopped here right off the free way on our way to JFK airport. Excellent food and value. Homemade onion rings are amazing! House bbq sauce for their wings rock! Local's diner with an all New York feel. Service was terrific.! You can stop in eat a great meal and hop back on the freeway within minutes! read more

Gordy's Burger House - Burgers Near Me - Bronxville, New York

I found Gordy's place while taking a stop going to NYC on a rainy day. It was a Sunday morning so decided to eat a burger for brunch. The place looks great from outside having parking spot on the road, clean bathroom and service was exceptional. I ordered bleu cheese burger with everything. The burger was well cooked and the bun was really fresh with crispy French fries. Our server was very helpful and the place was quite. Not suggested for vegetarians. Over all great experience with fantastic food and service. read more

Below average grocery store burgers/shoestring fries with very little flavor. Bacon on burgers was raw. Needs a major remodel and higher quality food ASAP. read more

Food was on point dessert apple pie amazing service so nice my family really enjoyed the food got a new spot for sure

Awful service. Waitress disappeared constantly, wanted two forms of id to serve beers to me and my friend. Claimed broccoli rather than fries was extra when the menu said it wasn't.... Never coming back read more

Was surprised by such mixed reviews and decided to try it out in search for a great burger place. I found it! We ordered three burgers, each with their own directions and toppings and got exactly what we asked for. These burgers were perfectly cooked to a medium, still pink at center, and the flavor was delicious! It's almost an addictive open grill flavor, a little smokey, and served in a soft fresh Kaiser roll that can handle the size of this big burger. Served with shoestring fries and coleslaw, we were quite content! The Buffalo chicken sandwich was oozing with sauce and quite delicious as well. Best of all may have been their French onion soup! Great food across the board worthy of five stars. The missing star is for the looks of this place- not just antiquated, but in dire need of a facelift. I hesitated to even go in and give it a try just based on its dingey exterior. Glad I did, but think I'll keep it as a take out spot because the food is great, but it's not at all appealing to the eye. Please renovate! read more

This is everything you want from a local restaurant. The food is fresh and the staff is very nice. The fish sandwich is delicious and the bar is fully stocked with cold beer and drinks. read more

Went to Gordy's tonight June 17th at 5:30 with a friend. I am 30 and my friend is 26 we were excited to catch up and have a drink with our meal. We both ordered beers and were asked for ID by the waitress.The waitress came back over to our table and asked for a second form of ID. We both gave her credit cards and my friend gave her another picture ID. The waitress returned back to our table to and says she can't serve us because she has a bad feeling. She was the only one working and we couldn't talk to a manager.This was extremely disappointing as we were both looking forward to have a drink with our dinner. We both will never return to Gordy's. read more

If you ever want a beer and you're way over 21, definitely don't come here. ID was asked which was obviously protocol and understandable. Then my friend and I (who is 30 and myself being 26) get asked for more identification. We both provide credit cards and I add my school ID. I asked if their machine for identifying our IDs were broken and she said "no, I'm the one checking them" Our waitress takes this and comes back to say "she cannot serve us because she has this bad feeling?" And that there was also a detective that walked out at the same time. What more could we have provided, we live around the area..so again if you want a beer..bring your passport peoples. This put a huge damper in our meals and time. Super upsetting. read more

This place is highly underrated. Staff are very friendly. I would take our three kids here when they were all in high chairs, and they would always make a mess. Servers are always friendly and never seem surly or frazzled. They have a TV in every booth which is great for the kids. The food is served quickly and the burgers are, in my opinion, even better than Pipers Kilt. They even have all these family discounts and special rates, which the waitresses are always very good about simply applying to the bill. I never even ask, they just let me know. They don't always have lunch or dinner specials, but I have had good luck on the few times I didn't order a burger. Once went there with my uncle and they had a steak special for 10 bucks. I wasnt in the mood for a burger so I tried it. I steadied myself that it couldn't possibly be good. I was wrong. It was great. Another time they had steamers, and they were also fantastic. A lot of people enjoy that you can order a beer or stiff drink even though it is a true family restaurant. Great menu to appease any child, and booze to soothe the most weary adult. It seems like they are very content with their business. They never advertise. The bar closes very early (I presume they don't want the hassles that come with being open late). They don't do delivery and one could even drive by the place and never think twice as it is so non-descript. Only issue is parking stinks, and if you have to cross New Rochelle Road at rush hour with kids, it's not fun. Having said that, I am always surprised this place isn't more packed during the week. read more

Husband and I were in Manhattan for our very first time late last month and returned back to LA early May. Sometime during our trip we rented car and drove to Boston. During our drive we decided to grab some lunch. So we just Yelp'd restaurants close by and just did an eenie meenie minee mo and decided on Gordy's. What a pleasant surprise! My husband chose the Shrimp and I knew I wanted a burger. Wow, was I sooo glad I did. I have had many a burger and this was pretty darn amazing. The meat was really good. I had the burger with bleu cheese, and because the meat was so tasty and the potato bun was perfect it would have been an absolute waste to add any condiments or anything else. I can not say that for any other burger I have ever had. AMAZING BURGER!!!! We plan to return to Manhattan again in the near future and Gordy's burger is definitely on my list of must go back to have that delicious burger. read more

They serve great burgers. TV's in every booth is a MAJOR perk, but only if you don't have small children, then you are stuck watching Nickelodeon... read more

The burgers really did the trick. Great price, good food, each booth had its own tv... Half bar, half restaurant. Kids eat for $3.95, just in case that is what you need. read more