Although we decided we were going to eat lobster most of the time we were on MDI, Havana was the spot we picked for dinner the first night. The folks running the place were very kind to move our reservation back by a night when we missed our inbound flight due to weather - and thus avoiding having to enforce the missed reservation charge. Even at 9 PM (which is when our updated time was), the restaurant was still quite packed, although it had emptied out a bit by the time we had finished dinner. There are many different areas of the restaurant, as it feels like it has been cobbled together from different structures, and we ended up sitting towards the back in front of the vast wine collection that Havana has. I ended up settling for other drinks, but their pisco sour here is excellent - unlike most, it didn't get very diluted when the ice started melting; and the beer selection is solid enough - I would have liked more local beers, but the Lunch IPA from Maine Brewing was a solid selection as well. Our waiter was quite earnest and made sure everything was brought out with relatively good timing.
To start off, we shared a couple of appetizers - the mixed meat plate and an order of crab cakes. To be honest, the latter had decent flavors, particularly on the lightly fried outside, but it was a bit dry once you got to the center of the cake - without the moisture, the succulence of the crab really isn't there. The meat plate, though, was excellent; I really enjoyed the chorizo on it, and the filet mignon bite was perfectly seared and marinated to perfection. Alongside these was an excellent bread basket; the corn bread was quite natural but also a tad sweeter (which I liked). The sourdough was also fresh, and it worked very well with the assorted spice-infused butter and oil that you could put on the bread. I'm usually not a fan of variants of butter and olive oil, as I sometimes feel messing with a good thing that is simple and straightforward leads restaurants to be a bit too clever. However, the butter was excellent here, and I really liked the slow heat that the chili-infused olive oil had. For our entree, my wife had the famous seafood paella, and the flavors did not disappoint. Although it's not served in the pan itself, they do a very good job of making sure you get the crispy bottom parts of the rice in the paella. Even though the food tasted great, the one notable downside was that there was not a good deal of attention paid to cleaning the shellfish; there were multiple rocks in the paella in the mussels. Although not a huge deal (and perhaps indicative of being a very fresh haul), this seemed careless to say the least. Most restaurants I know of would have discounted or comped some portion of a dish that was served with rocks, but there was no offer made - somewhat disappointing from a hospitality perspective. I had the halibut (which was the fish of the day) - excellent preparation, and it came in a very good sauce as well.
We were too stuffed to go for dessert, but I can see why the First Couple dined here a while back. The food is excellent, and although it is Cuban/Latin-inspired food, it does a great job of adapting everything to the locally available cuisine. I don't give it five stars largely because having rocks in seafood dishes feels a bit amateurish (that has never happened to me anywhere else), and the crab cakes honestly were overpriced for how small they were and how overcooked they ended up being. That said, I would certainly come back, and if you're tired of visiting lobster pounds for every meal, it is a very nice change. read more