Best kind of place. No frills. Good food. Reasonable prices. A large menu hangs on the wall. This place serves more than pizza. There are lots of appetizers, tenders, wings, pizza, family-sized specials and more. We had the lamb gyros--2 for $5. You could choose chicken gyros, too. They were full size and really good. Inside there are a few tables, mostly where people sit and wait for their carry-out orders, and you can eat there. Coolers hold a lot of drinks and cheesecake desserts. Check it out. read more

See all

Service was solid, food very well priced, not the best area but good experience in general. read more

Jerusalem Pizza & Grill - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Best prices! We love the 2 gyro deal. They make it fresh! I call in my order it's always ready in like 10 min. They have options galore if you want pizza or fried fish. I haven't tried that but seems like they sell a lot of it. read more

For the price, honestly can't complain. You call, get food, leave. I know some people want a different environment but there are other restaurants for that. The 2 gyros for $5 is the greatest. I have had gyros of the same quality for far more expensive. Are they the best ones you'll ever have? No, but they will be the best cheap ones youve had. And we need that in the age of even McDonald's getting expensive for what it is read more

We had the best time ever today at jerusalem pizza , we came in the morning and had the best lunch ever its more then perfect we loved it read more

Jerusalem Pizza & Grill - Catfish 2 pc - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

The price, 2 for 5 Gyros, its unbeatable. Not only is it incredibly cheap it tastes fantastic as well.

Finally tried this place after passing by it and seeing ads for the past couple of years. Ordered the chicken tenders with parmesan garlic sauce with a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was what you'd expect. The sauce was good, not sweet or bitter, kind of middle of the road. The stand out was the tenders. Fried to perfection with a sauce that was out of this world. The sauce wasn't salty like most places and had a nice blend of garlic, parmesan, & vinegar. Definitely a must try. The menu also has Mediterranean foods, subs, gyros, fish & chicken dinners, plus a lot more. Prices are great and well worth the amount of food you get. read more

Best 2 Gyro's for $5 That said, not my all time favorite tasting Gyro. Don't get me wrong. I eat plenty of less than stellar things in this country, that lures me in for VALUE. I found these 6" stuffed items to be very large. I added a medium(no small size) french fries, not knowing what portion size I was getting. Anyone who has had this, is reading it as, "I can't believe he ate 2 and a fry". Well I couldn't. There was an active carryout business going on, as well as a young man dining in. Menu's hang like flags over the back counter. Smart, because the owner told me he likes to change up the menu about every 6 months. Take down a flag. Hang a new flag. The menu pics on Yelp are old. Yet they haven't been removed by the business owner, who posted them. I should have taken current pics, but wondered how long they would be accurate. There are also paper menus on the counter. It's a walk up/order kind of place. Have a seat until your order is ready. Lots of combos on the menu. Primarily remembering Fish, Chicken, Pizza, Gyros and sandwiches. I know there was much more, but I do not have that photographic memory. Prices looked very fair. The fries had that red finely ground seasoning that I did not identify. I ordered mine crispy or well done. They were. The produce on the gyros were fresh and crisp. The lamb meat was underwhelming. I would have to say the same for the Tzatziki sauce. That's only because I caught no pop of flavor from it. The meat was a bit dry, as if it were shaved off the spit, and not floating in a broth bath. I honestly do try to resist the fried items. So I should resist working my way around the menu. There are some other thing I can get. We talked about some of the salads. I honestly will be that guy that comes here occasionally for the bargain gyros. There is a large bank of reach in coolers on the right inside. Plenty of drink choices. I also saw an array of pre-cut dessert slices boxed for carryout. Come to think of it, I wonder if they have baklava. Hmmmm I wonder if there was alcohol in that cooler. read more

See all

As you may have seen from their enormous signage out front or the multiple reviews, they have 2 gyros for $5. And when they say $5, that's all in, tax included. This little hole in the wall is legit though. The pita is warmed on a flat top grill and if puffy and soft. The tzatziki is tangy and creamy. The lettuce, tomato, and onion (the classic toppings) are all fresh. But most importantly, the gyro meat. Shaved fresh from the vertical rotisserie, it is well spiced and piping hot. Nothing greasy here. Wrapped in silver foil to go, this was a great quick stop, but I cant recommend the ambiance. read more

I ordered the fried chicken and a cod fish dinner which it came with salad and fries, both of the them were good. The chicken came in whole pieces and not the little wing dings just the way I like it. The fish was good and crispy to perfection, the salad wasn't anything special but since it came with the meal I cant complain. The place is not that big, but they do have a few seats where you can sit down and eat it you like. What I like is that you can call you order in and just pick it up, service is friendly and greeted me when I walked in to pick up my order. This was my first time here and I would have to say I will be coming back for more. read more

See all

I only had a Falafel gyro ($4.50), they didn't even fill the bread but that's ok because I didn't like it, Fries, and Gyro. I took 1 bite of the falafel and didn't finish the rest (such a waste of money), the fries not fresh cut and they poured tons of seasoning salt all over them( tell them no salt if you plan on trying) the gyro was ok. They also put very hot fries in a styrofoam container and we all know styrofoam MELTS! They should put a piece of aluminum foil there so fries don't have melted styrofoam taste, didn't finish fries either. read more

See all

My Mom and I went into the restaurant last night. My mother was trying to make small talk and be kind. The guy the delivers and takes the orders got really rude with her and slammed his hand down infront of her. He then told her to order her food she has 10 minutes. She did and it was awful. My order was good. Now, if you are upset with a customer trying to make conversation don't make their food bad. They up charge for the sauces because of the cost of the containers. The one man needs to get his attitude towards customers corrected. I had noticed that they have lost business. I was thinking it was due Covid now I know it's his attitude. Just fix the food and get it right. read more

Good food reasonable prices. Made fresh as you wait. A good selection of middle eastern or American fare made really well and fresh from the grill. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed. read more

I like hidden gems, and this place fits the bill. I got the falafel, which was just as good as the falafel I had over in Europe a few months ago. will definitely be back for this place soon! read more

Ordered for the first time tonight. Got Chicken Tenders, Large Fries, Carrot Cake and soda. They were out of carrot cake, but called quickly to offer substitutes. I opted to substitute the Oreo Cake which was tasty though quite melted from the heat of the fries and tenders (maybe a separate bag?). Overall, exactly what I wanted; warm, tasty delivery at a great price and of exceptional quality and quantity. I'll order again and recommend. read more

Worst Philly sub ever. they need to clean the grill , the sub taste burnt when you open the sandwich you can see the burnt grease from the grill . I literally could not finish without nearly vomiting. Up side the bread was soft . read more

Jerusalem Pizza & Grill - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Staff does NOT wear their masks. Their food is reasonably priced and very delicious. I'm sad to say that My fiancé and I will no longer be a customer, along with my sister and two nephews, until they wear their masks. The two men in the kitchen were not wearing masks and the front desk guy who touches all the condiments, takes your Payment etc did not have on a mask. I asked him why they did not have on their mask and he said it was too hot in there, especially in the kitchen as he states it was 80 degrees on the thermostat. My gut told me to leave without my food but I wanted to support our local business during these trying times. It's not worth putting my life at risk. read more

Had their lunch special, 2 gyro's for $5. Wasn't much to it but the ingredients (tomato, lettuce, onion, banana pepper) were all fresh and it was a great lunch for the value. Will be returning next time I am in the mood for a gyro, or maybe to try something different. read more

I love their gyro combo meal. There is plenty of food included, and the fries are delicious!

I get the fish special two or three times a month this time to fish taste old and they gave me more fish than they usually do thinking that would make up for the fish not being good I am not impressed this time at all it will be a while before I try it again read more

I am not exactly sure why they decided to name themselves as a pizza place because I have never even considered getting the pizza there. They have a giant sign on their window that shows that you can get 2 gyros for $5. This shows me that they pride themselves on gyros......and they should. I really enjoy their tzatziki on all of their sandwiches but I usually end up with the slightly higher priced chicken schwarma. It comes with fries and a choice of their 30 or so canned drinks. If you are looking for a deal then you can't beat their 2/$5. If you want something that is more of a meal they have a ton of options and the fries are fantastic that come with each one. Something about that spice they use just does it for me. Plenty of things to try so the only thing to do is to just give it a shot. read more

I love there chicken wings plain. I love there fish yummy the salad was ok. The gyro is ok. They give you a good portion for price. The fries were ok. It's a good thing I don't live close because I can't be eating fried food all the time lol. read more

I ordered from this place for the first time and it will be my last time I ordered two pizzas and they charged me for three the guy that answered the phone was super rude I ordered a Philly steak pizza and mushroom , sausage and pepperoni pizza and they charged me for a third pepperoni pizza which I didn't order not to mention the food was salty as hell read more

The pizza was pretty awful. Soft, doughy and under cooked enough that the cheese wasn't fully melted. I would never buy the pizza again. But, the Gyro was pretty good. Tasted fresh and wasn't greasy. The Ttzatziki sauce was really good. The french fries were also Ok. Crisp and still thick. I would try some of the other Middle Eastern stuff there again. read more

Excellent Gyros with banana peppers...You can not beat the 2 Gyros for $5 deal. Best place if you are catering for a lot of people. I visit whenever I am in the area or catering for my lodge. .'. Also, they have subs and pizzas too! read more

Fish seasoned and cooked perfectly. Good price for the portion. Order in advance if you don't want to wait

Delivery is fast and accurate, the food is amazing, and the cost is more than reasonable. The pizza is pretty good too, especially at that price! read more

Good food. Had the falafel and humus. Pita was good. Food was made quickly but the worker who took my order was not friendly and was very short in his speech. Overall good food mediocre service. read more

I will never eat from this place again. We have been ordering from this place for several months.The food is good and well priced.However, they are not able to deliver food. They told us It would be an hour. A hour and 20 minutes later, they said 10 more minutes. 20 minutes Later they said 15 more minutes. We asked if there would be a compensation for how long we had waited.They said no, then CANCELED our order for asking!!!?!!!I have never Been treated so poorly. read more

I heard good things about this place and even saw it listed on a site on Facebook for hidden secrets of Columbus. I ordered the chicken philly and asked for no mushrooms..it was supposed to come with onions, green peppers and banana peppers but they put mushrooms on it per my request not too and only had onions in it. Didnt even put any sauce on it..was pretty disappointed. Also ordered 5 wings with hot sauce on side...wings were good but the sauce was horrible. I ended up using my own hot sauce at home .maybe i tried the wrong things but was super disappointed with the chicken Philly. Bummer! Only giving 2 stars for good customer service. If you are taking to go, check order before you leave! read more

This pizza was quite depressing. I see why they only make one size. We got onion rings, they tasted like generic oven cooked and the mozzarella sticks had unmelted cheese. Those who know me know it takes a lot for me not to eat pizza. This got one slice and thrown out read more

I'm been a customer for years, used to come here with my father all the time. Food's pretty good. I've had close to everything on the menu at least once. The gyro's are nice and you receive a good amount of meat per sandwich. I'm addicted to their fries ! they are amazing, the seasoning they put on them is fantastic. My mother enjoy's their cheese pizza and their Chicken Sub. My personal favorites are their Gyro's,Platter's (Chicken or Gyro meat), their fried Catfish is top notch and previously stated their awesome fries. (Highly recommend the cheese fries). read more

Not the worst gyros I've ever had, but a very good value: 2 gyros, fries, and a can of soda for $7.99. The tzatziki was more like a ranch, the meat was okay, and I really enjoyed the fries. 2 stars on the food with an additional star for value. read more

The gyros are really good at this place i liked the way the chicken is seasoned. I also love their fries. The ingredients that they use seem to be fresh. And their prices are not bad either. I will defenitly go back for sure! read more

So someone left a bunch of their menus in my office, so I decided to give them a try. Got their Jerusalem Pizza, a cheesesteak, and a gyro. Their pizza was lacking. Lacking sauce, lacking flavor, lacking substance. When I got out to the car, I actually lifted the lid to see if the box was empty because it was so light. My brother-in-law seemed to like the cheesesteak. I had a bite of the gyro. It was OK, but they use sour cream instead of tzakziki sauce, so that was disappointing. I don't think they get much business: they didn't ask my name when I came to pick up the food - just handed me what was on the shelf, and there was no other food cooking. read more

Soo yummy . with great people, that treats me well. It's always clean and I feel comfortable in the restaurant.

Gyros was ok, just ok. But the hot wings, boy, those wings were terrible. They were so soggy. It looked like the wings were suppose to be crispy but they were mushy and drenched in oily buffalo sauce. We couldn't even finish them. Total waste of money. We will only be coming for the 2 for 5 gyros. read more

VERY disappointed. Came up from the Southside by bus just to go there. After an hour and a half trip, I wanted to use the restroom and wash my hands. No bathroom. Took a 10 minute trip to and from a gas station nearby. Ordered our food and waited at our table. No trays or plates. We were given our food in a brown paper bag. Asked for ketchup and was told it was in the bag. Glad we didn't need anymore, I would've felt like I was imposing on the taller of the 2 guys that worked at the counter, he had a very dry personality, was more focused on his cell phone than anything else. Noticed his black t-shirt said 'whatever' on it, how appropriate. All in all we spent $17.50. Will not be going back. Food was great, price was great, no restroom, no paper plates or trays for inside dining, ketchup bottles on the tables would have been nice, customer service seemed to be aloof and fairly indifferent. Should be 4 1/2 stars, but only giving them 2. read more

The 2 for $5 gyros are an amazing deal. They are pretty good and I have done just that several times. The fries are alright. The pizza was slightly less then ok. They do offer delivery. And the customer service is great. If it was not for the 2 for $5 I would have not even tried the place. But really it's a great deal and they are fast! read more

I have ordered from here a thousand times, as every time I called I order the same thing. Today was no different, the gyro was so greasy and nasty looking. My fingers were dripping with oil. The we ordered had been micro waved. The plastic container it comes in was burnt at the bottom. I am truly disappoted to say the least. I will never step foot in this establishment ever again. They lost a customer today, because of their selfishness and in a hurry to make a quick buck. read more