Fantastic pizza place that I went to for years while working in East Harlem. Gonna have to go back there soon.

This is another beautiful gem that our friends introduced us to right next to their home. We ordered out and did it in two large pizzas. One of them was a chicken, cutlet pizza, which I had never experienced before and, and it was really good. The second pizza was my personal favorite pepperoni and mushroom. The cheese was really good. The crust was thin, but the ending was very crunchy. I really love that part. I was really happy that oregano was available to me at the house, but I hope that next time when I go in myself, that they have oregano available for me. The garlic knots in the middle of each pizza was a really nice surprise. We have some similar to them at home, however, they usually come separately. They were really good. So I'm sorry if I ruined the surprise for someone who's never come here before. read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - Chicken Cutlet Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

What happened to this pizzeria? Wow the quality of the pizzas went down, the service and the Saturday afternoon/ early evening atmosphere became ghetto? read more

Love La Nostra. They've been my go to pizzeria for over five years. I look forward to the garlic knot.

Great chicken roll, and even though I ordered less than the minimum, the gentleman still made an exception and delivered to me. Will definitely be ordering again! read more

This is the go to place for my school to order pizza for our students and staff and it never disappoints. The pizza is always fresh, warm and delicious. The size of the pizza is great too and they also have great salad platters as well. Today the principal of my school ordered us lunch and I got the chicken parm here and was it a delight to eat. Easy to eat that I almost finished! Can't wait to have some later. Cannot talk on the actually place but delivery is always efficient and delivery person from their establishment is always nice. Highly recommend! read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - a plate with a sandwich on it - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Found myself in the neighborhood and hungry. This place looked interesting so I stopped in. Pretty good choice. Truth be told, the interior here has seen better days. It's large, but a bit on the dingy side. The floor definitely could use some work. But, I don't go to pizza places for their floor. The pizza was surprisingly good, since this neighborhood isn't exactly known for their Italian cuisine. The slices were large, and moderately thick. I did enjoy the taste. And, at $3 per slice, worth the money spent. I'll be back. read more

Hands down I been eating pizza from this place since I was a kid! Best pizza ever, no competition! Affordable and just mmm mmm! If your in the uptown area stop by this place and grab a slice! read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - Large pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ok, so we stopped here because we needed a bathroom, lol. But we decided, hey, the pizza looks decent and had 7.6 on the one bite app. Yes, we're serious about our pizza. So we tried a cheese and a grandma slice. For an unplanned stop, I am so glad we stopped. This pizza was crisp, thin, and flavorful. The sauce on the grandma slice was zesty. This corner pizza spot gets it right!! read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - two slices of pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Walking into the pizzeria. The staff were very welcoming. They have a variety of pizzas. I got the pepperoni and sausage pizza and it was very delicious. I even had to get seconds. The pizzeria was also kept very clean. When leaving they thanked us for coming and we would definitely come back. read more

still great. this pizza is the quintessential NY slice. $3.25 a slice as of Feb 2024, $1 more extra toppings, and well worth it read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - a slice of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Omg yes!! I love them! They're great when I want pasta and I'm on the east side. The portions are AMAZING! You get a lot of food for the price point. Seriously a lot of food. A plate can be shared and everyone will be full. Or you can take it down yourself. They take cash; they take card, what's not to love. The price is reasonable for the amount of food like I mentioned before. The quality is also good. The noodles are made well, nice bite to the pasta; never mushy or under done l. I recommend the spaghetti if you have to feed two people or just want to be full FULL. (Just as choice of pasta). The chicken parmesan is amazing, so is the tortellini and shrimp alfredo and shrimp parm. Delivery is always great with them and they have nice timing. Ordering over the phone is a lot better for me and I never have a problem. The guys always have a good tone even when its busy. Go give them your money. You wont regret it. P.S. the pasta comes with bread!! Pictures of the menu have been attached. Happy hunting. read more

See all

This place hit the spot last night. After some drinking, my friend and I were in much need of (affordable) sustenance. We both got a slice of the bacon chicken ranch, $4 each. The huge slices were so filling and delicious! This pizzeria is exactly what you need when you just want to grab a slice. Yes, they're not a dollar slice, but you'll be paying for quality! read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - Chicken bacon ranch slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

True 3.5. Listen it's not quality pizza, buts it's good enough pizza. It's the type of pizza one would be happy with if your job or school ordered a bunch of pies for a pizza party. Cheesey enough, cooked well done, crust is solid. Sauce is reasonable. read more

Great pizza!!! Just amazing fantastic! Really patient Um yea.... I love their pizzas read more

Work and live right by here and have been coming for years, a good quick slice. Cheese slice is 2.75 and pep slice was 3.25. Staff always is nice and quick. Classic NY style read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Tasty, fast delivery, great hours. Loved the garlic knot on top to keep from getting crushed.

5 start for the food but the service 1 start, I orden two slice for my baby and me when I have to pay the person who was charge me say the card machine was not work and he told me its a ATM there so I went take out money I pay so i was waiting for my order when I came back I saw the other person has the their order so I asked about mine . i was there waiting the whole time and lied to my face saying they called me but they didn't . he packed my order to go but I never said to go and I told imma stay and eat. As he was taking the food out the pizza was falling all over so I just asked for my money back. read more

Such a great spot to get a gigantic and delicious slice of pizza. I used to live in the building above this pizzeria and I have very fond memories of coming here. So for old time's sake, I dropped in to have a slice the other day. Miss you guys! read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Solid margarita pie for delivery I don't think a slice when you are at the restaurant and a delivery can be compared The pizza was tasty Fresh mozzarella The delicious tomato's had garlic on them The basil was just enough Sauce was good Crust was good Got a side salad with olives, tomatoes, cucumbers and whore onions and great Italian dressing I didn't dine here but the delivery to 96th was great read more

Felt like walking into a pizzeria from a movie scene, has that kinda old school aura to it. my son tried the sausage/onion and buffalo chicken slices. he loved both! Hearty slices, you may have to use knife & fork to start. they're very generous with the toppings. This is our new upper east side pizza stop. read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

There pizza is soooooo gooood! There salads especially the antipasto salad it's fire!!! One of my other favs is the chicken parm hero light on the sauce is authentic!!!! Delicious this place won't dissapoint read more

I jus don't understand how you expect someone to eat something that looks like this ....like never again ....I've had a ranch and bacon pizza before never looked like this smh read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

One of the best Pizzeria's in NYC...Solid slices...amazing taste..truly embodies an NYC Style Pizza Place..

Not sure why this place gets good reviews, or even fantastic reviews if you're using Seamless. Even for a neighborhood slice shop, the quality is substandard. Sure the slices are huge, but they're overly greasy and salty. Desserts appear to be store-bought. And my $27 order had an additional $9 in fees for delivery. read more

The pizza was good, next to a papa John's... Choose this place. There's many menu options however I got the half pepperoni half cheese pizza. It's a typical new york slice, nothing special but better than those random franchises read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - Half cheese half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

My grandfather was an Italian Chef in Coney Island during WW2. I know good pizza. I grew up on amazing Italian food. This is good NYC traditional Pizzeria Pizza. Meatballs are good too. They give you a little garlic knot in the middle of your pie instead of the plastic thing. Environmentally smart and a great little treat! read more

Food taste and the prices are fair. Outside appearance isn't all that great but the food and customer service makes up for it read more

This pizza taste authentic! The sauce taste delicious, the mozzarella is fresh and taste of excellent quality. The pizza crust is perfect. I like my pizza hot. It is usually warm, I ask for it to me extra hot.... the effort is there as they put in oven longer .... still warm..., C'est la vid !! The staff is friendly and attentive. read more

My standard for pizza is pretty high. The pizza wasn't bad just not a go to spot. I do like that they use a garlic knot to prevent the cheese from touching the top of the box. Pizza overall was ok, a little sloppy with the sauce. Tiramisu was pretty good tasted homemade but quite a small slice. read more

Ok i usually get the same thing when i order which is a large pepperoni with extra cheese. I always put in the notes i have a 2 year old and 6 year old, and to bring it upstairs. Well they give me an issue, why is there an issue when you charge a delivery fee plus they still want to be tipped. We have a large police presence as well as large NYPD lights (don't be scared) what took the cake for me is he had a bike lock and no other deliveries so your tip definitely gets adjusted. Overall the pizza is salty and its not the meat the whole pizza is salty which leaves me with a headache. Guess its time to get up and cook. read more

Second time ordering from them. Delicious pizza and speedy delivery. Friendly and professional staff as well. Personally I've never been to the parlor, only have placed orders, but have always been pleased with their service. Our order was a small white pie which is pretty big, enough for a few people and a large cheese pie with half extra cheese. The extra half side had some serious extra cheese added. Not stingy at all. Also the non-burnt crust is a plus. Very good and this will definitely be the go to place for pizza delivery from now on. read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - Large cheese pie with half extra cheese. That's some serious extra cheese. Delicious and satisfying. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The pinnacle of New York style pizza. With this location it is tough to get an authentic Italian slice but HERE is my go to !

The other weekend a bunch of us descended upon The Duck to do some drinking! Of course the urge to feast came upon us after a few rounds of cheap booze. It's always a plus when a dive bar lets you bring in food from outside. This is where La Nostra comes in. As they are literally across the street from them, and the only pizza joint in the area, I ran over to grab a pie. The place is set up as a basic NYC pizza shop, except this one has a kind of gangsta vibe with pictures of famous tv and movie gangsters on the walls. Ordered up a large pie which they made fresh for me. Decent pizza pie here. Heavy on the oil and lots of cheese. I usually like a little more sauce on my pies but this one was ok. Maybe it helped that I had a lot of beer in me. $13 for a large pie, and $2.25 for a regular slice or Sicilian slice. The normal menu of pizza joint items. Not bad at all. What was bad were the bathrooms. They are pretty nasty, and the place itself had no AC on and it was humid as heck outside. It's never a good sign when the bathrooms look like you don't want to touch anything in them. Go for the pizza. Avoid the bathrooms. read more

We needed a quick meal before our flight at LGA and this was EXCELLENT. They have a variety of insanely large pizzas that are on display and ready for your choosing. We decided to get four slices- buffalo chicken, chicken and broccoli, spinach, and ham and pineapple. These slices were so large, each piece was equivalent to about two normal slices of pizza. Everything tasted so fresh and delicious: the perfect crunch with each bite and the toppings were loaded with flavor. There was a good bit of indoor seating and there is a drink cooler as well. The staff was friendly and soo quick. I guess I'm just not used to the hustle and bustle of the city but I did not get a second to think about what I wanted! Dude was asking me my order as soon as I walked in the door lol. Good thing everything we got was good anyways! For 4 slices and a soda, it ran us about $17, which is a pretty good deal considering that we each couldn't finish two slices. They do deliver and it was obviously a neighborhood hot spot. Would definitely return if I was in the area. read more

La Nostra Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

My hubby and I dropped in to La Nostra because I hadn't eaten all day and was starving. I'm not a huge fan of pizza but I decided to try it out for a regular slice. The staff is extremely friendly and patient, considering the fact that I was hemming and hawing as to which kind of slice I wanted. I finally chose a nice Tomato Margherita-type slice which had a nice thin crust and was pretty big. The price was so bad, either. If I'm in the area, I would definitely return. They do a good job with their pizza. read more

I will be fair and truthful in this review. I want to start with the positives. Delivery in fair time. The mini pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms was average +. Thin crust cooked with a perfect doneness on the crust. As for the negatives. Chicken parm hero what a disaster. Was on some fake Italian white bread. Overly sauced and cheesed. So much tasteless mozzarella and under seasoned tomato sauce. When I order a chicken parm I'm Expecting it to be on fresh brick oven baked bread. This chicken was under seasoned and one of the cutlets was a very tough rubbery piece I had no choice to throw in the garbage. Spaghetti with meat sauce was dry spaghetti with barely no sauce at all. It was topped with poorly seasoned ground beef and a load of fake processed mozzarella which basically made it into a pasta Parmesan. Why would you dredge it so much mozzarella? I ordered pasta with meat sauce not a pasta parmigiana. The Stromboli was made with processed American cheese inside. I've never seen a Stromboli with yellow cheese. It was basically a ham and cheese with canned mushrooms peppers and onions. Not even a Complementary marinara on the side. The house salad had a ton of huge thick white onions all over it. If there is going to be onions on a salad please do it with red and had them finally sliced. The white onion smell was so over powering. Maybe walking down the street and you want a quick slice on the run I could recommend. To order anything else besides a SLICE of pizza I would highly recommended to stay away. read more

Great pizza, great pasta, no complaints. As a guy from Queens I know how hard it is to find good pizza in Manhattan. La Nostra is a very good pizza place a with reasonable prices. Their white cheese pizza is actually what it's supposed to be unlike most pizza places that don't know what a white cheese pizza is. Wonderful food, wonderful staff. read more

La Nostra Pizzeria is simply really terrific. Clean, vibe is cool. The menu is really amazing, so many good choices, I had to go with Mini White Pie, and it was incredible. Staff are incredibly pleasant. They're attentive, respectful and always on their game. Glad to see a place like that in this area. read more

During a vacation to NYC, after an exhausting day we decided just to get some takeout. I was in a pizza mood and La Nostra happened to be just a few blocks away. I ordered a stromboli and a piece of stuffed pizza, as well as garlic knots. My wife had gotten some random stuff to eat earlier so it was just for me. What a mistake!! I ordered way too much for one person. The fact it was $13.07 after tax, right in NYC, had me fooled. This was way too much. I ate half the stromboli, half the stuffed pizza, and a single garlic knot and I could barely move afterward. It was all delicious, especially the garlic knots. For the quality, I'd give it four stars. For value, I'd give it eight stars, but since five is the max, it'll have to do. Very prompt service when I picked it up, too! read more