Great pizza. I've been going to Lenny's for a couple of years now and I have no complaints. I go when I'm craving a plain slice or when I'm hungry. My go-to slices are plain, Hawaiian and pepperoni. You can order at the register or order at a touch screen next to the refrigerators. There are plenty of tables and seats--you can sit and eat or you can take your food home with you. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Hawaiian and Plain Slices - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

See all

My friend and I popped into Lenny's because our normal pizza place was a bit farther away. It was busy enough on a Friday evening and I must say, the facilities are nice. There's a decent amount of sitting space and a nice open concept with an outdoor viewing space. I ordered a buffalo ranch slice ($4.50), which, despite being a decent size, was pretty underwhelming. I have a lot of respect for neighborhood businesses like this, but I've had much a better slice in Sunnyside, in my opinion. Additionally, they only take cash at the register, which is fine because they have a touch screen kiosk which takes cards. The whole process was a bit annoying. The employees were still polite, but it likely won't be our go to place. read more

See all

The best pastas in the city, super recommended especially the lasagna it's fire , if tried that you gonna love this place. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

Lenny's is always a go-to. Amazing pizza time after time. Their chicken Franchese pizza is unique and to die for. Stop by and try a slice. All their cooked food is done righteous. And they make thier own chocolate mousse cake...to die for. ***** read more

Great midweek deals! The owner is super sweet and always coming up with great conversation. Love the energy and the pizza here! Pizza is made fresh to go, and they have great choices of pizzas. There is ample seating and the pizzeria isn't cramped. read more

Although I had a great experience but I was sad to lean the owner takes the employees tips. I tired to tip in cash but the person who helped me order said he can't take the tip because the boss takes it. Beware DO NOT TIP! The owner takes their tip. read more

The pizza here was straight up bad? Idk maybe don't get the Sicilian. It's hard to find bad pizza in nyc but I did People seemed nice tho read more

I grew up on the block same as Mr. Burrito's, and I always went here if iq as hungry and wanted food and dinner for my family and parents when I was a kid. i moved to Omaha, and when I come back here, and get a slice here, I shed a tear. this is the BEST pizza place in the area, and o love it with all my heart more than I would a wife. read more

Ordered 2 chicken rolls for delivery last week. Which I have done a few time but this last time I received 2 nasty pieces of garbage that apparently had be sitting in in the display case all day. They were dried out and over cooked totally inedible the chicken was like dried out cardboard. I tried to call to complain but they didn't answer the phone. I would not recommend ordering anything from this establishment read more

This is my nephew's favorite pizzeria so I decided to give it a shot. i love their Wednesday special of $10 for a plain pie. The pizza is pretty good and I really enjoyed their sauce. The crust is not my favorite in the neighborhood but overall a good slice of pizza. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

They follow some covid safety protocols where all staff wears masks and have sanitizers in place for customers to use. They don't have temperature checks in place or space out ppl that are waiting on the line. Anyways, I only get the plain pizza pies here during their Wacky Wednesdays due to their deal which is $10 for a large pie. I found out that they have a deal on Tuesdays too which are wraps. I havent tried that yet. Their pizza pies are good. I will keep ordering their Wednesday pies as it is affordable and a great deal. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

See all

my husband and I eat from here frequently. Their pasta dishes and soups are amazing. I also enjoy the rice balls and heroes. Their pizza is also great! The owner and his staff are so friendly! Best place in Sunnyside!!!! read more

Although I use to recommend this Place to everyone and anyone I noticed their change in staff and honoring coupons. I called to order three pires 24 wings and (2) 2 liter sodas and they would not honor any coupon that I had from them. I asked to speak to a manager to see what offers they had and the girl preferred to say it was old offers and she would rather cancel my order if I didn't want it. So I did. Rather order from another place who will honor at least one coupon and not Lose the whole order to be right. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

See all

I sometimes go here because it's across the street but I really wish they had more variety in their pizzas. Sometimes is a hit and miss , the counter service is good though read more

What a great pizzeria! Was passing by & decided to stop in for a slice. So good! Also noticed they had a Tuesday special on wraps and fries for $5.50. Tried the California Chicken Wrap & Caprese Wrap with my Fiancé and we loved them!! So fresh & delicious, makes for a great lunch, especially for the value. This will be our new go to pizzeria for all they have to offer seems great. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Caprese Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

See all

I got a medium vodka pie and it was ok. It did the job but I've had better. Would probably try some other local spots before deciding which one is my favorite. read more

Delicious food. I have been looking for a good pizza place and Lenny's fits the bill. I'm a huge salad fan and finding anyone who makes salad using arugula is like trying to find a unicorn (lol) well Lenny's make a great salad and uses my favorite lettuce. Chicken wings are fantastic, crunchy and tasty. Love the tiramisu read more

Good pizza, TERRIBLE service. The girls who take orders frequently forget/don't hear/don't care, causing me to wait far longer than one should for pizza. Last time I was there, I ordered 2 plain slices, a beef patty, and a dessert and waited for 20 minutes as other customers cycled in and out - this is because the girl who took my order forgot to go downstairs and get my dessert while I was sitting there waiting, as my food got cold - when she did realize that she completely goofed, she sent someone else downstairs, didn't apologize and instead had an attitude. It's a shame because the pizza is decent/affordable, but I'll likely stay away going forward unless I need a pizza fix badly. read more

We ordered from Lenny's before but this day we wanted to have lunch at Lenny's. So ok, we had calamari, baked clams, lobster bisque and small spaghetti with anchovies. That sounds like a lot of food but of course we had some left over. Of all the dishes, we liked spaghetti with anchovies the best. They made this quite good. I'd like to try and make something like this at home. The calamari was not bad but baked clams we could do without, too much breadcrumbs in baked clams, I couldn't enjoy it. For the simple place like this, I was a bit surprised they serve quite good dishes. The service was good. Maybe I'll try something else from here next time. read more

See all

Pizza is amazing and the pasta is out of this world. Still have things to order but so far no disappointment.

First time ordering and the gyro was good. The chocolate mousse was even better. Saved half the garlic knots for my coffee in the morning :-) read more

After a relatively shakey start, Lenny's has blossomed into one of the more stellar pizza joints in Sunnyside. With plenty of pizza competition throughout Greenpoint Ave, Lenny's has managed to stand out by offering some of the hood's heartiest slices / pies while remaining reasonably priced and tasty. When I first had their regular pie, the cheese was practically falling off the slices. The crust was burnt but the sauce was solid. A first glimpse of the now defunct Taco pizza (thank goodness), was a disaster. The pie was not only heavy and messy, but it the beef was completely unseasoned and the fixins were so bland that my group of pizza lovers and I actually didn't bother with more than half the pizza left. On top of that, the delivery was ridiculously slow and the website was hideous. Now more than a year into their existence and they've come full circle. The website is much better, delivery is fairly quick, and they've managed to turn their place into a regular haunt for many Greenpoint goers. Their slices when fresh out of the oven are decent and they've done away with the odd specialty pizzas and stuck to the simple stuff. Unlike most of the takeout pizza joints in the area, Lenny's offers quite a few tables for in-dining and has taken some consideration into their presentation with pasta dishes and pies. Not sure where to start? I recommend the vegan nightmares pie (i.e. meat lovers), a hearty pie that has no skimpage of meats featuring army of pepperoni, bacon, and sausage bits. Another popular one is their buffalo pizza, which is decorated with ample chunks of chicken and a nice drizzle of blue cheese around the pie. Kind of crazy in theory, but delicious in reality. I am hope they continue to do well. There is some service snafus from time to time, but I know the staff usually means well. I hope they don't succumb to the rising price tags happening all over the pizza joints but for now they get a 4 from yours truly. read more

I must have walked by this place a thousand of times if not more. Today I decided to try the place. They did have a decent after school crowd and I did have to wait a bit to get my order. The staff was very nice and friendly. When I first walked in there were a variety of prepared pizzas, fresh Sicilian pizza, buffalo pizza plus more behind a glass case.. I personally opted for a plain cheese slice of pizza for $2.25. I know that is boring but that is what I normally order. How can you get that wrong? It really looked good and it was nice and hot but after my first bite I found that this slice was nothing special at all. The crust was thin, crunchy but very bland. The sauce.... well there was no sauce on the pizza that I could taste, plus a thin layer of cheese. Normally cheese makes everything taste better but not in this case. I felt that the ratio of sauce and cheese on their pizza was really off. I felt as though I was eating a crunchy cracker with melted cheese. I ended up just ripping the crust off my slice and scraping the cheese down to the to the tip of the pizza and just eating that part of it (hate to waste melted cheese). I unfortunately threw the rest out. Don't get me wrong this pizza itself was just not for me. They do have an extensive and interesting menu that offers a variety of specialty pastas, salads, sandwiches, plus more. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Where's the sauce :-( - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

This place is a hit or miss , the pastas aren't bad for the price. My only issue is the consistency. sometimes the food taste fresh and sometimes it tastes old. Especially the salads and cheeses. I've ordered salads that have had slimy cucumbers and old tomatoes. Now i usually just stick to the pizza and pasta . They also need to change their prices online because it doesn't reflect the prices they have now . read more

Traveling 2 hours to get the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza !! Worthhhhh it The pizza tasted fresh and the so did the garlic knots. I wish I could give an extra star for the super friendly staff who helped me with other food items to try such as chicken roll. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

See all

A completely unmemorable slice. About the only thing going for it is that a regular slice is 3 bucks but it's worth it to spend more to get better quality elsewhere. read more

The Lenny's staff is very efficient and always so nice when I stop in for takeout. I love their Wacky Wednesday plain pie special and their pepperoni rolls are delicious! I've tried other spots in the neighborhood but this is my go-to for a weekday dinner after a busy work day. read more

Excellent keep up the hard work guys great food and service always order from here food arrives quickly and that is the reason why it is always hot love it read more

Pizza has become bland in recent years. Space is not very clean (and tables stay dirty for a while). I think they gave up their liquor license.. no more beer here. Disappointing... Sunnyside needs a good slice place. read more

I always passed by uninterested because I've established that Joe's pizza in the city is the one for me, but I finally tried it and it's a great solid joint right in Sunnyside! They have a $10 whole pie Wednesday, which is what drew me in, and I would highly recommend their arugula walnut chicken salad, a great compliment to your pizza. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

Excellent food! We order from them mostly when we host group meetings for our company. Their food is always well prepared, arrives in time and I like that they label everything with a marker so there is no confusion who gets what. Today we ordered again, and everyone was satisfied. I got their "Our Special Insalata Siciliana" with grilled chicken. I must say, the salad is fabulous! Really fresh and has lots of goodies in it, like carrots, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and artichokes. Unlike most of other restaurants, Lenny's gives a lot of chicken!! :) I think I got a whole breast. My coworker said he loved his shrimp parmigiana, he gets it every time we order from them. :) I really recommend this gem place. Thank you!! read more

Lenny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

They misplaced our delivery and kept telling us the driver was on his way. I hate that, so I cancelled the order. Ten minutes later the owner showed up, apologized profusely and gave us the pizza for free. They made a mistake, but they fixed it wonderfully. The pizza is really good. I'd order from them again. read more

Why did this pizza despising lactose intolerant Yelp reviewer step inside a Pizza shop? For pasta. Lenny's Pizza is the first pasta shop to show up on the radar located in the awkward 6 way cross street of Greenpoint and 44th. By far the best pasta I have discovered in Queens. As soon as I entered, the cashier warmly greeted me and directed me to the menus against the wall. The menu is quite extensive with variety of pizza's, pastas, and Italian food, quite overwhelming at first glace. I ordered a small (large available) linguine with clams in white sauce, my favorite of pastas. The cashier asked me to sit anywhere I'd like and after 5 minutes, delivered the food directly to me. This place is not fast food nor a restaurant, but provides fantastic service! The linguine with clams was elegantly presented with fine linguine in the center sprinkled with sliced clam bites and six little neck clams surrounding the perimeter of the dish all emerged in white clam sauce blended in olive oil. Also served was two pieces of freshly baked garlic bread and one soft bun. Slurping on the noodles and dipping the bread in the white clam sauce rendered total satisfaction. The finest of pasta was devoured here for the fraction of the price for this dish at another restaurant. Lenny's Pizza is truly an undiscovered hidden gem in the heart of Sunnyside and I will be returning! read more

Lenny's Pizza - Linguine with clams in white sauce - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

This is my usual go to pizza spot, however tonight I ordered a beef patty and got It with basically no meat. Called in and asked for another to be sent and this time It looked as if It was old. The guy on the phone had an attitude and so did the delivery guy when he came back. Will not be ordering from here anymore. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Beef Patty - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

See all

I ordered a meatball pie, a salad and some garlic knots and literally the only nice thing about what happened to me here was how quickly the food arrived. The pizza is absolutely perfect if you think that pizza sauce and Heinz ketchup are exactly the same thing. The crust could not have been more flavorless it was like a person soaked some flour in water and put it in the microwave and then put some shredded mozzarella cheese fresh from the underbelly of Jersey City. The garlic knots arrived and I could not eat more than a single bite they were so dry and tough and impossible to understand I thought I was watching Christopher Nolan's 'Memento' with my mouth. The salad by itself would've been okay maybe but they forgot to include the dressing so even that tiny portion of the meal that could've been salvaged was decimated by negligence. I can very confidently say this pizza restaurant is a blemish to the entire city's reputation and if you are in the mode for some undeniably poor pizza because you're a glutton for self destruction but you could save some money if you grab a slice of wonder bread, squeeze some ketchup on it and put a kraft single on top and call it a day. read more

Terrible!!! Experience & Taste. It took 45 minutes longer than told to me. I called 20 minutes after it was supposed to arrive & I was told it would arrive in 2 minutes. 25 minutes later it still had not arrived. It finally arrived, but the pizza was junk. I normally love pizza, but this place is garbage. It's open late & delivers, but save ur money & go to sleep hungry. I will never eat here again. If I could give negative stars, this place would get a negative two. I would rather be kicked in the genitalia by a bull than ever do business with Lenny's Pizza again. read more

It's one of the few places with a REAL fresh crust that doesn't taste like cardboard. This place does a great thin and CRISPY style crust. Its really good. The Buffalo chicken pizza is decent. The thicker specialty Sicilian style slices are great too but not a big fan of the dough. It's very crispy almost like a giant cracker. I'd avoid those and stick to the regular thin crust. The REAL gem here is the Classic Margherita pizza. One of the best pizza's ive ever tasted. They use a fantastic sweeter sauce. Definitely worth trying. $7 for 12" pie $13.75 for 18" cheese pie, $2 per topping read more

Really good pizza,the mushroom my favorite. Friendly staff also. And has plenty of seating. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

I actually haven't tried the pizza here yet, because I'm usually ordering on Seamless for just myself.. God knows if I ordered a whole large pie, I would eat the whole large pie in one sitting! I am freaking addicted to their Alfredo sauce!! I find most alfredo sauces to be disappointing, and just tasting life cream without flavor. Theirs is DELICIOUS!!!!!!! Made with herbs and parmesean. So flavorful and rich but not too thick. I always add some black pepper and chili peppers and its PERFECT. Their pasta options are pretty standard, but dang that sauce is soo good! I'm also a HUGE fan of their garlic bread, especially the one with fresh mozzarella melted on. OMG. Get this please. I have yet to try the garlic knots because I keep ordering this, but based on reviews they sound good and I'll be trying them soon! Can't wait to try more on the menu! read more

Lenny's Pizza - Gnocchi with Alfredo. Pasta is store quality but the Alfredo is homemade deliciousness! - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York

The largest pizza place I have found in Sunnyside so far. Their pizza seems to be more Chicago Style Pizza than New York Style Pizza: the crust is thicker and the toppings are deeper. I am a huge fan of the Cheese Steak Pizza. My eyes say pizza but my mouth says Philly Cheese Steak. read more

Lenny's Pizza - Cheesesteak Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sunnyside, New York