I don't know what happened to my original review. It's vanished. We were in the city for a play, and my mother wanted lobster rolls for dinner. Luke's now has GLUTEN-FREE BUNS! I was delighted. It's not really a "roll" without the roll. It's just a salad. They also have crab and shrimp rolls now! I ordered the crab, because I really, really like crab. It was wonderful! Everyone else had lobster, and thoroughly enjoyed it. We also got Cape Cod salt & vinegar chips. Yum. We had the rolls at my mother's apartment, so didn't enjoy the onsite friendly vibe. Each roll was carefully packed in a paper box thingy, which kept them safe. Great compostable packaging! The crab roll was overstuffed (I got the 6 oz) and absolutely delicious. The dressing was light and didn't overpower the crab. read more

See all

I love how everyone in here is always so friendly! The lobster rolls have generous portions and are served with chips, a drink and a delicious pickle! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Super yummy lobster roll. Loaded with lobster and crispy buttered bread. However, price is definitely kind of steep considering the casual atmosphere and you can probably find a better deal elsewhere. But the food is very good. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Had a hankering for a Lobster Roll. Since I was on the Upper East Side, I dropped into Luke's at about 2:30. Ordered a roll, small Lobster Bisque and a Natalie's lemonade to wash it all down. First, ambience, quaint little spot. Gives the feeling your in Portland Maine by the docks where the lobstermen bring in the catch. Service, fast and friendly. Now onto the main event. Soup perfect tons of lobster bits with the creamy soup texture. Onto the lobster roll. Plenty of meat enhanced with just a smattering of melted butter. Yummy! Lastly, Natalie makes great lemonade. Just lemon juice water and pure cane sugar. Excellent. I will go back next time I'm in the mood for a lobster roll. Luke does a great job! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Lunch! - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Got a lobster flight while in NYC and loved it! Chef's kiss! Also, all the employees gave this mom and pop shop a chill feel. I really enjoyed the vibe. S/o to Alifia who took our order. She gave this spot a a real chill local feel. She has CA to visit on her bucket list so feel free to give them to her recs and tell her Nichole from CA sent you:) Also props to Darwin and Gloria for their NY recs and hospitality as well! read more

See all

Luke's Lobster was a great idea over a decade ago--fresh, affordable lobster rolls served in what looked like a shack--but as it spawned a chain of Lukes, the quality started to dip. The last Luke's Lobster storefront I'll ever go to was the one I walked into last night at 242 East 81st Street in Manhattan.The first Luke's Lobster was funky in an almost hippie beachcomber way. This place was just drab. There were three of us, with three different needs: a small, hot lobster roll; a large, cold lobster roll; and an advertised trio of mini shrimp, crab, and lobster rolls. Also a small bowl of lobster bisque and some cole slaw. The woman behind the register was perfectly nice but didn't get it, despite going over the order three times. (This is when anyone unsure should say, "Okay, let me read this back to you.") She disappeared into the interior and came back with two trays. One had a small cold lobster roll and clam chowder. The other had a large roll. The third tray arrived with my trio and the cole slaw. But the real issue was the food. The clam chowder was a flour-thickened mess of potatoes and a distant memory of clams; the bisque that finally arrived was gray and bland. The crab meat in the trio was white shreds that looked and tasted a bit like sauerkraut, and the shrimp in the shrimp roll were small, stone-cold, and watery. Okay, but how was the lobster, the real reason that anyone comes to a place like this? Not fresh, all of us agreed, and that's unforgivable. As humble as it sounds, a lobster roll is a high-ticket item. As we were leaving, the server mentioned that all the dinners came with chips. We grabbed three bags for the road, and I carried them. When I reached for one 10 minutes later, I saw that it had already been opened. ---- One point to note, and I should have mentioned it earlier: The server did bring us a hot lobster roll to replace the old one, no charge, and also didn't take back the clam chowder we didn't ask for. That should count for something, and I'll up the rating by a star. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Crab, lobster, and shrimp mini rolls and something billed as bisque. - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Prompt courteous service fresh lobster claws and rolls were on point. Cute little spot right off a main road would be perfect at City Island with the water effects in the background. The gentleman that took our order was efficient and handle the crowd well after we came in. The clam chowder and lobster bisque was tasty too would definitely return. Wish the other location was still open. read more

Early Saturday dinner at their cozy Upper East Side location. We had lobster rolls, crab rolls and clam chowder. The lobster roll consists of generous size pieces of lobster with just enough mayonnaise to bind the succulent pieces of lobster meat served on a toasted brioche bun. The lobster rolls are really good! Kin was a great host pulling some tables together for our family. read more

See all

So yummy! Warm buttered 6 oz. Lobster roll, no frills and so much better than the mayo versions. It's not cheap but it's very good. I just wish they had French fries instead of potato chips. Happy Yelping! read more

See all

Very clean location (we did arrive as they opened). Lobster rolls were delicious! It would have been nice to have the option to have a warm roll but it was still good. Service was friendly. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Always love a lobster roll - Luke's Lobster always fulfills my craving for it too! My fav is the warm lobster roll and my boyfriend loves the lobster roll flight with the 3 different flavors. Not a cheap meal, but I appreciate the lobster portions in each roll. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Came here for dinner, and I was late, I made it in time before closing quite a walk from 86th St. station. But it's a cute place very cozy. I had the lobster roll flight sampler, which comes with 2 Oz mini samples of: A truffle butter, lemon butter, and spicy honey butter. I must say all three tasted the same. It took about 10 min to prepare, and I couldn't distinctively taste the flavor from either one. I was excited about trying them out and the spicy honey i really wanted to experience, but it was a letdown. Not to say it wasn't good, but it was lacking each flavor. My date had the crab roll, and he liked it. When I first had lukes, it was at the Cipriani food tasting, and the bread had me going because it's soooo good; I'm not really a lobster person, but I'm getting there. The lobster was good as well, so I wanted to try this location. Maybe because it was late and closing time, but nevertheless, it should have been right. I do appreciate the workers for letting my date, and I stay in to eat they were very accommodating and nice. Kudos for that. I will try the closer location on 42nd and give it another try. But if you ever feel like traveling to the UES or are in the area def pay them a visit for a quick read more

See all

We ordered via Uber Eats, so I can't speak to the service or ambiance of this location. We ordered a crab roll and the sampler or rolls (shrimp, crab, and lobster). My friend had the crab roll and said it's his favorite. I had the sampler, and it was great! The shrimp roll was delicious and full of shrimp. The lobster roll was my favorite--a very good amount of lobster for the price! I ate those two immediately, but waited about an hour before eating the crab roll, which is why it may have been my least favorite. Other considerations: the seafood is cold although the bread is warm. There is a gluten free bun option, which my friend says is pretty decent. read more

Very chill location seems like you're not even on the upper east side. High food quality very fresh lobby. The staff is very knowledgeable and approachable. My only thing is that this place closes a little too early in my opinion but hey we all have to go home right? read more

We stopped by for an afternoon snack at this Lobster restaurant located in the Upper East Side of NYC. We each had a 4 oz Lobster Roll $23 at the counter. We waited a few minutes inside until they brought it to our table. It was very tender and delectable. Simply made with lobster, butter, mayonnaise, lemon juice and seasonings on a New England split top bun. read more

See all

Travelling around New York and we really wanted to try something close by. Stumbled upon this place and I'm a huge sucker for lobster rolls... Hands down, one of the best lobster rolls I've ever had !! Worth. Every. Penny! Even the lobster bisque was a nice addition on a cold day. Highly recommend ! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Truffle butter lobster roll. The biggger size - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped by for a quick lunch on a Tuesday. Not busy but there were a few people chillin and eating. Plenty of space inside and outside and pup friendly ! We got two lobster rolls and a sampler. So much meat and the seasoning was just right! Roll was perfect and each bite was perfect. Solid lobster rolls! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Lobster roll ! - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Very tasty but expensive lobster roll. Order was ready for pick up. But the roll was dry needed more mayo

Very disappointed. Have gone to this location for the past 5+ years. Always great. This time the lobster had no flavor. Tasted like it was just thawed. Wont go back. The person in charge was great. He was very upset that we had a bad experience. read more

So what does one day after a wonderful day at The Met? Two words: Lobster Roll. My buddy heard about this place and suggested giving it a try. I hadn't eaten many lobsters rolls in my life, but I figured I'm on vacation. I'm in NYC. And......I was hungry. The roll was sublime. The meat was plumb, tender and sweet with a hint of garlic. The bread was toasty. I ate it like I just came back from Survivor Island--fast, sloppy and without modesty. It was quite shameful as I was sure I was frightening the small children that walked by our outside table. It was a very, very good lobster roll and a Go-To spot whenever I'm on the Upper East Side. What a magical place. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Service and food are great. I am telling you that their lobster rolls are amazing. They don't include celery in sandwich. Great job

Must try: Lobster Roll and Lobster Mac & Cheese! Why: Fresh lobster that is seasoned well on a delicious roll! They fill the roll with large chunks of lobster. I get lunch here probably every other week (via MealPal), although lately it's been weekly because I've been craving seafood! They pair the roll with potato chips and I really like the Salt & Vinegar flavor. I also loved their Lobster Mac & Cheese, Chowder, Crab Roll, and Shrimp Roll. Notes: Yes, seafood is on the pricier end but their Maine Lobster is 100% worth it! This shack is a small and cute location on the UES with indoor and outdoor dining. Clean location with friendly staff too! They also have a Lobster Roll Flight, which I can't wait to try! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

This review is for the MealPal. I got a lobster roll and salt/vinegar chips. What a FANTASTIC deal. The lobster was perfectly cooked and delicious. The bun was well buttered and crispy. This place is efficient in getting the order to you quickly when you arrive for your pickup time. I would definitely order from here again! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Amazing lobster roll and clam chowder! I've frequently walked past this location, and didn't realize we had such a gem on the UES! Quality seafood and friendly service, I definitely recommend going here if you're in the mood for some "Maine quality and style" seafood. Minus one star for the price, as I didn't expect to pay $41. Aside from that, it had just the right amount of sauce on the lobster, and the flavors were light and fresh. The clam chowder had plenty of clam meat inside (which was a pleasant surprise) and had a nice medium consistency. Each roll comes with a bag of chips (not pictured) which is a nice pairing. I would highly recommend visiting here, if you're in the area. I'm looking forward to trying their roll trio and cole slaw on my next visit! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - 6oz lobster roll, clam chowder, and blueberry drink - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

I'm speechless! This place is the most amazing and delicious for lobster roll. #1 Best Lobster Roll in NYC read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - 1/2 Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Delicious. OMG was so happy I stumbled across this place. Had the warm lobster role with butter and it was delightful. The service matched the food being excellent and I really enjoyed the ambiance with the story of the company playing on TV. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Decor - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The lobster roll flight is a great deal! I wish they would throw a lil warm lobster roll in the mix because is there any pairing better than lobster and melted butter? But that's a me problem, not a Luke's problem. The lobster bisque was delicious and while I did not partake in the lobster Mac and cheese because for some reason I don't like lobster Mac in general, it was full of lobster and I'm told it tasted delicious. The prices are high but it's lobster and you can't get even a tiny lobster tail anywhere for less than $30 now. If you're having a craving like we were, go for it! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Luke's will forever remain the best lobster roll in Manhattan for me. And get this -- the least expensive out of all the best spots too! So, how can ya beat that?! Picked up from this location a week or two ago and they had an awesome Covid safe set-up (see photos) which I really appreciate. My favorite things about Luke's are that they NEVER skip on the amount of lobster you get, their secret seasoning sprinkle on top, and the cool soda's and carbonated beverages they offer like Blueberry soda and Ginger soda made from real ginger! Keep it up guys. What an incredible brand read more

See all

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side Heaven! I started to order a plain lobster roll, maybe when I get my check! I usually have the shrimp. The roll is toasted warm and buttered. The bread and seafood are very fresh. So delicious. I never heard of Lobster and Shrimp rolls until I heard about Luke's. Now I wish I could afford this lunch more often. The employees are great at teaching me the drill and the price of everything. They are very patient with me. I've been to the Luke's by Bryant Park. I've also been to a Luke's Elite week event a couple years ago. I have eaten at the Luke's that is at the Plaza Hotel also. I'm definitely a fan. It's nice to have this location near home. This is a great alternative to a hot dog when I'm hanging around my neighborhood! If you like seafood and delicious bread you gotta try Luke's Lobster. Yum! read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - My favorite Shrimp Roll. Posted 10/17/2020 - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The best lobster roll I have had in years including those that I have had in CT and MA. Three cheers to the lovely lady chef in the kitchen (whose name I am so sorry that I forgot). I had the 4oz lobster roll. It was full of delicious perfecly seasoned chunks of lobster. The roll was warm and toasted well. Darwin was running the front of the house with such ease and expertise during a very busy rush-creating a calm environment. Thank you Luke's what a treat, I'll be back very soon!! read more

Was in UES yesterday, our old neighborhood, decided to walk around and ended up having dinner here. First time at a Luke's Lobster so I was trying to not have the highest expectations versus what we've enjoyed in Newport, RI. Turned out to be really good! I ordered the lobster roll with bisque and drink, opted to upgrade to a 6 oz rosé for an additional $8. Hubby had the crab roll + lobster mac & cheese. And yep, strategically always good for sharing everything! Their bisque was deliciously comforting. The lobster mac & cheese was actually surprisingly really good. Hubby enjoyed the crab roll and I also loved the lobster roll. They have a small outdoor dining area outside and on a beautiful not so cold evening, this was absolutely perfect! Staff were also great. Polite, smiling, actually liked taking care of customers type. May actually use that loyalty card as it works for UWS branches too! On our way out, we waved and thanked the team who took care of us, with a quick thumbs up! Thanks guys! This will definitely help satisfy our New England cravings until it's safe to be traveling again! We'll be back! read more

See all

I have ordered from Luke's for years, from other branches. Always good. However, this order, through uber eats was extremely disappointing. Items ordered were not packed for delivery, and charges were also incorrect. With Lobster Rolls you are supposed to get both chips and a pickle. Neither was included. Also, a promotion was going on for a free soup. I was charged for the soup, and the store was not helpful on either issue. read more

This was phenomenal. The chowder, the lobster roll, even the drink. SO. GOOD. This is definitely a must try. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Lobster sandwich - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

First time trying a lobster roll. I wanted to try all 3 different rolls so I ordered the combo. The buttered toast added a solid foundation for the chilled seafood meat. The seafood had a light seasoning to it and it was decent. My favorite would have to be the shrimp roll. I had the lobster bisque as well and it was tasty but it tasted like something you could get from a grocery store. We also tried the blueberry lemonade and it was very tart, not as sweet, but still refreshing. Overall, decent food experience but was a very forgettable one to want to come back. read more

See all

Gimme the LOBSTAH!!! Had my first taste of Luke's Lobster while visiting New York, and I've gotta say that it was pretty impressive. This particular shop is conveniently located right in the heart of the Upper East Side just a few blocks down from Museum Mile. I stopped here to grab some lunch before heading over to the Met Museum. The interior is very cozy but also quite charming. There isn't a ton of seating inside but it's still a comfortable space to enjoy your meal. The gentleman at the counter was very helpful and explained the menu options to me in full detail. After perusing the menu, I finally settled on Luke's Trio which comes with 1/2 crab, 1/2 lobster, and 1/2 shrimp rolls, a side soup, and a drink. For my side soup, I chose their seasonal lobster corn chowder. This entire meal was lip smacking GOOD! The rolls came seasoned and filled with an adequate amount of seafood. All of these rolls were served cold which isn't usually my preferred choice, but they were all pretty tasty. The crab roll was hands down the best of the three! It had a nice buttery flavor and the clumps of fresh crab were just perfect. I also really enjoyed the lobster corn chowder. The chowder was hearty and filled with large chunks of lobster and potatoes that practically melted in my mouth. Yep, that chowdah was very yummy! Although I really enjoyed everything, I felt that the portion sizes were quite small, especially for the half rolls. I know that they're only half rolls, but they seemed like kiddie sized portions. I do, however, feel like the trio meal was a great deal for everything that was included. But if I could change just one thing, it would be to increase the size of their rolls because they're damn good and I want MORE!!! Aside from that, everything else was perf. They recently opened a Luke's Lobster in my hood, but I'm kind of afraid to try it because nothing really compares to the original. Glad that I finally got to get a taste of that good ol' lobstah! read more

See all

I would give this place 3 out of 5. It's pricy and just ok. Not really worth the price. 2 lobster rolls, chips and 2 beers 89.00. The place is cute and it's lobster...but 89.00... read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Lobster roll 4oz. - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

My absolute fav freaking chain restaurant. Holy crap I cannot rave about this place enough. Mr. Luke, wherever you are, God bless you. I love the food here. Some might say I am addicted. I say I have a deep appreciation for delicious and quick seafood. My favorite item has to be the lobster truffle roll. It's just ridiculously good. Mind blowing. My most frequent order is the shrimp roll because 1. It's the second best tasting thing there and 2. I'm broke af and can't afford $20+ lobster rolls all the time lol. I've tried everything at Luke's. All recommended but the winter items just hit different man. Get em while they're still out. Anyway enough of me gushing over this place. The food is amazing, the overall brand is awesome (can't beat sustainability) and Luke's Lobster just makes me all warm and happy. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - White truffle roll and lobster grilled cheese. Winter menu items! - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

After walking in Central Park my family and I decided to eat at Luke's lobster. It was around a 20 minute walk from Central Park to this place. It was nice to stroll through Madison Ave and look at all the shops and homes. The food and service was absolutely amazing. I would 100% come back if I were in New York. I recommend trying the Trio to experience the crab, lobster and shrimp roll. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Luke's Trio, New England Clam Chowder - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

Food was great! Yummy, fresh, and buttery lobster trip. Will say that customer service was less than good. Had to pick up the chips from a black tub separated with card board set on a table in the middle of the dining area (just hand them to the customer or add to the tray?) and the man taking my order kept giving me snippy comments - I said oh! I thought the chips and lobster meant fries ha - and he replied well we aren't in England. Fair enough - But then I watched as he served 2/3 people after me and continued with snippy comments and overall an unwelcoming demeanor. Everyone has bad days I get it, but then coming up to an elderly couple enjoying their food and checking in, and them being obviously annoyed at being bothered to the point where they have to put their hand on their tray and tell him directly they weren't finished eating, and then the second they place their empty bag of chips down the tray is taken from their hand isn't good service - it's rude. People are allowed to converse and eat in the dining area. Same thing for me - the second my chip bag was down the tray was taken from me without asking while there was still lobster on my plate that I paid $40 for. Maybe he just wanted an empty dining hall but overall this person needs to chill. No one is asking for him to do more or be more helpful, just a lot less rude. Food was great but if he was on shift again I would go somewhere else. Not asking for a welcome party but not a fan of being rushed out the door or watched like a trespasser. read more

Been to different Luke's lobster place before, this is the only one makes me upset, food is good as usual but the customer service? Nah, that guy seems like he's having a bad day, no patience whatsoever so ever. Bad enough to make me write a review on the next day. But overall the food is still good. read more

Luke's Lobster Upper East Side - Seafood Near Me - New York, New York

See all