I feel bad writing a negative review but I just could not get past the disappointment. This was…read morejust my experience, but the pizza was full of flavor, very tasty but the pizza had extreme flop...I have never had such floppage on this type of pizza before which is supposed to have crisp and we ordered it extra crispy but it was just a floppy mess.

First, the good: 1)…read moreIt's very cool that there's a pizza place literally *inside* the Bandera HEB! You can put an order in and pay at an automated kiosk, then pick it up when ready. (They text you when it's up.) 2) Cost is reasonable, as of July 2022 it was $12 for a 16" specialty pizza like a Meat Lover's or Supreme. 3) Service was fast and reasonably friendly (I did show up at 11am though, with no one else in line, so YMMV.) The not-as-good? Simply put, the pizza is the definition of 'meh'. Instead of sausage, the Supreme includes hamburger crumbles, which are chewy and bland. The other toppings are also pretty mediocre in quality, and we got an over-abundance of black olives. So the predominant taste is one of salt. The crust isn't foldable like a classic NYC style slice, it's droopy and listless. To my amazement, it reminds me of the pizza served to me in my grade-school cafeteria! The member-berries were nice, but not great pizza. Finally, everything here looked clean enough. But it was a little disconcerting to see a container full of chopped red onion sitting on the floor near the trash can. If it's trash, put it in the bin! To sum up, there's truth in the old business saying. "Good, Fast, and Cheap. You only get to pick TWO." This place scores a 2 out of 5 on the 'CTJ Scale', as noted below. 5 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Jesus good. Would be OK passing away after finishing a plate here. 4 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Mary good. Would be OK having a nosh here with Mother Mary. 3 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Joseph good. Would be OK having a beer here with Jesus' Dad. 2 out of 5 stars: Come-to-the-Apostles good. Meh. Wouldn't have my last supper here. 1 out of 5 stars: Come-to-Nobody good. I wouldn't have my penultimate supper here, either.

Eva, Noe, Mas, Mike, Jerome, Rush, and Zander did a great job tonight! Really great pizza!!!read more

Mattenga's name comes from the couples names together that started the company. I was in the…read moremedical area and I was so happy to stop by and get some pizza, it's nice to be in San Antonio to get all the things a big city has. You will love the Supreme Pizza and they have varied many others like Texas Pothole Pizza and Honey Bear Pizza and salads, the website shows so much more of the variety. They have a classic machine that is a dough maker that shurns the dough in house, everything is fresh and so tasty, so far this is my favorite pizza. I am so grateful to a place like San Antonio that truly has everything. Take your friends! Take your Family! Take your Beloved! You will be pleasantly surprised! :) P.S. This business is owned by people who are Christian and love the Lord, there is Bible verses all over. I loved that a lot :) As a Catholic I enjoy seeing faith in businesses.

Awesome pizza service was great workers were so nice and polite will come back soon .read more

This isn't my normal location. I was driving through and was craving there cheese and pepperoni…read morerolls. The cheese was hardly cooked/melted on the inside of the rolls. The dough had way to many air pockets so based off that it wasn't fresh dough. The flavor wasn't anything like the rolls I have had at the Austin, Leander, or Georgetown location. I will not be returning to this location regardless if I am passing by.

BUYER BEWARE!!!!!!! WORST pizza I have ever tried to eat. Cheese was like rubber or bubble gum…read more Crust was raw in center & burnt on edges. I cooked is specifically as directed. AND...."NO REFUND" EVEN if you didn't eat it!!! "Too bad" the manager told me, "WE don't refund" !!! So 30$ in the trash!!! IF I cld give zero....I wld!!!

Went to do my Halloween tradition of getting the pumpkin shaped pizza! Only thing is partner and I…read moreare vegetarian so we can't get the pepperoni version, which has never been a problem before. Employees were oddly rude that we wanted the pizza just without the pepperoni. They claimed it was "premade with pepperoni" which would've been fine if I wasn't watching them make several of the jackolantern pizzas RIGHT next to me as they said that... Really weird. Employees were just over all rude even when we just decided to get a plain pizza anyways. Definitely not coming back any more. Store small and crowded but it is not meant to be an eat in area so that was fine.

Went in for lunch and the pizza was great! Great price and the service was excellent. We will be…read moregoing back in for more!

Sofia's Pizzeria is one of those spots where pizza isn't just pizza--it's a decision…read more The crust? Just the right balance of crispy and soft. The toppings? Generous enough to make you feel like they actually care. And the flavor? Let's just say one slice turns into three real quick. It has that cozy, neighborhood feel where you can bring family, meet friends, or just show up hungry and leave happy. This is not the place for diet plans. This is the place for "I deserve this" energy--and honestly, sometimes that's exactly what you need.

Got two slices of plain Cheese pizza and it was amazing made fresh and hot…read more I don't know what else to say. I was trying to keep the review short and sweet, but Yelp doesn't like that.

I came by this place since is was close due to being super close. Never again. When I walked in it…read morewas super dark, not a single person to be seen at the counter. I honestly thought it was closed at first because almost all the lights were off. Someone finally took my order I was told it'd be 5-10 minutes. It took almost 25 minutes. They were seemingly annoyed I was there. This place feels more like a front than a resturant. The cashier forgot my drink and the girl who gave me my pizza seemed bothered I asked because she had to pause her AirPods to acknowledge me. After giving me my drink I went to get a drink and all the drinks were watered down. The pizza was fresh I'll give them that, but not gourmet at the place claims. You can get better pizza for cheaper prices literally anywhere else. First and last time here.

Absolutely fantastic experience at Chicago Pizza San Antonio! We started with the mozzarella…read moresticks, which were delicious, and then went for the deep dish pizza--and it was absolutely worth the wait! A true deep dish pizza takes time, so expect around 45 minutes or so. Trust me, it is well worth it. Ours came out cooked perfectly, loaded with toppings, and packed with incredible flavor. You can tell they take the time to do it right rather than rush it. The staff was also incredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Great food, great people, and a seriously delicious deep dish pizza. We really appreciated the experience and will definitely be back. Highly recommend!

Awww... this was a bust!…read more I just got back from Chicago and was excited to compare this place's deep-dish pizza to the real thing. Since I'd never been here before, I had high expectations, especially after our server told us it was San Antonio's version of Chicago style pizza and the best in town. I thought, "Yes! I can't wait!" Unfortunately, it was a letdown. The crust didn't taste like fresh bread. It reminded me of Pillsbury dough from a can, and it even had that same yellowish color and flavor. I was also surprised it wasn't baked and served in a traditional deep dish pan. I think this place has potential, but if they focused on making the crust more like actual bread and served it as a true deep dish pizza, it could be a much better representation of San Antonio's take on Chicago-style pizza. AList

Can't believe I did not know about this pizza before. FANTASTIC pizza. Awesome staff. Cut lil…read morerestaurant in castle hills. The taste and quality of their pizza instantly ranked in my top 5. Possibly top 3. It was really good. The pepperoni balls were just ok. To doughy for me but they weren't bad. Definitely go check them out soon.

First time trying this place and we were pleasantly surprised. The place is clean and quiet. A…read morefew tables for a sit down lunch or dinner. Very friendly service and staff. We tried the Pavarotti pizza and it had great taste and a very nice crust. I definitely recommend trying this place and we will definitely be back