Ehhh... no one ever says they "Master Pizza"... its just edible, quick & convenient w/ nice employees...

Very surprised at some of these negative reviews. IMO the best pizza in town, and I live here for 30+ years. Consistently delicious pies and extremely well priced. read more

Nope! If the attitude of the workers isn't enough to make you not want to patronize, then the deadly delivery drivers will be. Also, I wonder if the cooks ever taste the food they make? Chicken Wings with Nuclear sauce isn't any more spicy than the milder ones. Be careful if you're driving through Livingston because one of their delivery people might mow you down. Hide your kids, Hide your wives. read more

Really bad, the employees are very rude and the pizza is not on point with other local options. Entrees are way over priced for a local takeout pizza joint, avoid this place. read more

Terrible Service, Forgot to bring my 2 liter soda and then wanted to make me wait another 30 minutes so that the delivery guy can get it while dropping off other deliveries?? Truly terrible service. The food is nothing exciting, Its edible, but that doesn't say much. I tolerated the food because I was hungry. Now I wont recommend anyone to eat here. Save your money order from some other place. read more

A lot of these negative comments I'm reading sound very, very silly. It makes sense that these people are from the area... The food is great and the service is very friendly. Business can get hectic on a night that is very busy. Just because you had a few minor unpleasant experiences, doesn't mean you should tell people not to eat there. read more

Fast and reliable. The food is also very good, the pizza rates only behind Star Tavern that I've had in NJ. The subs and entrees are very good too, it's high quality Italian take out, if your looking for a good meal done fast it's great. The employees know the regulars by name and are very friendly every time I walk in. read more

I loved their salads and their pizza. When we order for delivery they always come in a timely manner and the pizza is always hot. Would definitely recommend! It is little pricey but worth it given the quality! read more

I called them for a delivery and the guy was so rude on the phone, hung up without saying goodbye and I could hear him being annoyed and talking to his co worker. Pizza is average, find somewhere else to go read more

We LOVE Master!! Their delivery service is the fastest in town and we love how they offer personal, medium and large size pies. Their BBQ pizza is a guilty pleasure and every single we have ever ordered is delicious. read more

That was the most flavorless pizza I've ever had. Had two reg slices and had to add every condiment I could find to get the most minor semblance of flavor. If another pizza restaurant open across the street with a better sauce this place would be out of biz immediately read more

called them. the hung up on me. they were very rude. i tried the call the back. but i cant order because it said call failed do not order from here they are the worst pizza ever. i am telling you. this is the worst place. the guy look like he hated his job or what. i would give this zero stars because they are shit. if you see this caller fuck yourself get a life and better job. read more

We ordered pizza and wings. Simple enough. The pizza arrived cold and soggy we had to put it in our toaster oven to finish cooking to make it taste decent. We've ordered a few times and always hit or miss. We were hungry and ordered last night for last minute dinner but it was our last. If you order pizza and you end up having to cook it again after it's delivered, it's time to find a new pizza place. read more

I've been ordering from master pizza for years and I've had some issues in the past with non delivery and late delivery, but the quality was always perfect. The last 6 times I've ordered from them, a variety of items, pasta, pizza, cold sub, hot subs etc have tasted awful. Whether the chicken wasn't fully cooked, or it was overcooked. They'd use different ingredients that either were or weren't selected when ordering online. It seems they don't look in the special instructions box anymore when ordering online. Master pizza used to be my go to place for pizza and subs, but not anymore. I don't think I'll ever order from them again. It's just not worth the risk. read more

I saw a roach under the garlic knots bowl and it just stared at me. Some ppl inside are cool especially the older guy. Food is mediocre, but they have their days. Never wear gloves and have a crude humor. Don't Eat Here. read more

The food is fine, but I'm writing this review in the hopes that they'll catch it and stop putting plastic utensils in our order. We always request no utensils in the notes of our weekly order, but because they always miss it, we've even called a few times to request that they don't put it in. But it always ends up in our order. Last time I called and mentioned this issue, the guy who answered said it's hard to get the team to read the notes. I suggested that it be the default to not include plastic unless requested, and he said then those who want it wouldn't get it because no one would read the note. I think that's bad logic. Either way, you potentially have upset customers (either those that want plastic and don't get it, or those who don't and do get it). And why not go for the solution that helps the environment, saves your business money, and makes some customers happy? I really wish master pizza (and other restaurants) would get on board with a more environmentally-friendly approach. We're in a pandemic, it was a Saturday evening and our address includes an apartment number, so we have silverware in our home. so the default should just be no plastic unless requested (even when the pandemic is over). It's a win-win - they save money for not using plastic utensils and the "zero-use" plastic doesn't go straight to the landfill. I really don't understand why more businesses don't do this and why it's a struggle to get businesses on board. read more

Always great quality food. Quick deliveries. Employees work hard and are very genuine. Great service. Highly recommend!

This is the best pizza and italian food in the area of Livingston, NJ. We stop by every friday to eat a pastrami sandwich and a slice of pizza. The pizza options are great and the taste is stupendous. The pastrami sandwich is amazing, fresh, and delicious. If you are in Livingston, NJ you have to stop by Master Pizza, I guarantee you will come back! Spotless Pools read more

This place deserves zero stars. Food is mediocre. Not terrible but definitely not great. Customer service is atrocious. They got my order completely wrong. It happens but when I asked for a credit to use next time they asked if they could charge me for the item they sent by mistake! Cut up pieces of chicken that I wouldn't pay $2.00 for. Any descent establishment would just take this order as a loss and do what is necessary to make the client happy. These guys want to fight with you and charge you for their mistake? Lost my business for good!! read more

Amazing capellini and meatballs and/or meat sauce. Love that I can customize the salad as part of my large pasta order online. Quick, convenient delivery for $1.25 to St Barnabas. A lifesaver. Always enjoy the food from and my experience/interaction with Master Pizza. read more

First of all let me start off with a warning. Do not eat this pizza!!! It will leave you feeling like vomiting or diarrhea or some combo of the two. It is by far the worst pizza I've ever had and I have had a lot of pizza. If you pick any random pizza place in Jersey it will be better than this place. I cannot understand why this place is still in business. Probably because the people who eat here have never have real pizza. The last time I had pizza from here I tasted 3 types cheese, pepperoni, and some type of potato Bacon thing. The cheese is by far the worst. When you get the pizza it doesn't even look real it looks like those cartoon drawings of a pizza. The cheese on the pizza is what makes the pizza so terrible. It tastes like play dough and overall does not look appetizing. The sauce is the second problem. I know for a fact they opened a jar of your standard pasta sauce already with the ingredients in it. That sauce is crap. They add sugar in it when tomato sauce doesn't need any sweetness. The dough tastes like frozen pizza dough. Now I will compliment one thing. That potato Bacon cheese thing actually has a good taste to it because they don't use the sauce and its a better cheese. Problem is its over priced and will leave you feeling sick afterward if your not used to eating crap food. If you are so desperately seeking a slice of pizza from this place, have a strong stomach and aren't afraid of getting food poisoning then go ahead and have a slice. My biggest problem with this place is that its pizza isn't real pizza. It's far from Italian. Lots of people from Livingston seem to enjoy eating this pizza and its been in business awhile so they must be doing something right. But seriously, go somewhere else. I've heard great things of star tavern and reservoir used to be good awhile ago. And when I said pick any random pizza place and it'll be better than Master Pizza I was serious. Happy eating. read more

We used the 3 medium pies for $19.99 coupon we had gotten in the mail, which got us three plain cheese pies. The crust was thin and soggy and the cheese was heavy and not warm enough or just a type of cheese that didn't melt quite right. We were still hungry after eating these pies, which we forced ourselves to on principle. Found the service to be rude as well when we went to pick up our order. read more

LOVE the margherita pizza! It's not easy finding great pizza outside of NYC - We get pizza from here all the time. Crust is just the right amount of crunchy and delicious. read more

We order dinner from here all the time. Online ordering is really convenient. Love love love the food and the options, like whole wheat wraps or crust, low fat mozzarella, etc. One of the few places I can order from when I'm on a diet. The burgers are amazing... go figure, at a pizza place!! They're huuuuuge and inexpensive. Glad they deliver to us, our orders are always correct and the drivers are very nice. read more

This is your average local pizza place. There isn't a thing special about Master Pizza but there isn't really anything bad either. They have a system that makes ordering a breeze and remember your credit cards so you won't have to give it every time you order. The wings aren't bad but I recommend you either get the sauce on the side or ask for extra. read more

Awesome food. Go for the Chicken Caesar wrap. Never a bad sandwich. Chicken park hero great to. They always welcome you in, treat you right, and go the extra mile. A must for you to try in Livingston. read more

Great pizza - perfect sauce. Chicken parm dinner order makes a meal on Friday night and a sandwich lunch on Saturday. Extensive menu. Quick delivery. Our local favorite. read more

1st time & was disappointed. I ordered a plain slice while waiting for my chicken cutlet hero. Slice was warm but bottom was burnt. Bread for hero was tasteless & chicken cutlet was dry & greasy read more

Haven't tried much of the food here but the pizza is terrible. No consistency and delivery takes forever.

On Friday evening I ordered a large pizza with x-tra sauce and ex-tra cheese, a large tossed salad and a small pasta fagioli. They said delivery would be about an hour and it was. However, when the delivery got to the front desk of the hotel the delivery guys calls me to ask me to meet him in the lobby to get the order. I finally got him to bring the order to the room. He hands me the bag with the salad then open his padded bag for the hot stuff. He pulls out the bag with the soup and half the soup is in the bag the other half still in the container. Hands me the pizza box which I immediately notice is extremely heavy on one side. I open the box and all of the cheese and sauce is on 1/3 of the crust and the rest is in the corners of the box soaking the cardboard to the point of failure. on top of all this, the pizza is luke warm at best. Then he wants to give me options. What an ass. I slam the door on him and tell him to get lost. I now call to speak to the owner/manager, on hold for 8-10 minutes, still no pick up. Needless to say the only edible thing was the salad and that's because it is supposed to be tossed. Do I have to actually say that we will not ever order from here again or was it implied in my review?? read more

It's always amazing! Fantastic pizza, great dinner dishes, and fast delivery. I've ordered from here so many times. It's easy to customize anything. They catered my New Years party last year which was also amazing read more

This place can be hit and miss sometimes the pizza is delicious and sometimes just cold and chewy. I tend to go in for lunch often but regret it later. Every time we have ordered the large pizza, we have never been able to finish it as my kids don't really like it, Whereas from other places it's gone straight away. Service could be improved and staff are not as friendly as could be read more

Great pizza, super friendly staff. I'm there twice a week for lunch. They're vodka sauce pizza is amazing

I work at St Barnabas Medical Center in the ER and I always order Master Pizza for lunch. Always on time, food is always good, no complaints. I will continue to order from there! read more

Great sandwiches!! Good mix of cheese and sauce. Ordered delivery while staying at St Barnabas. Really hit the spot.

I made a large order for a party this weekend, and I was a little nervous because I'd never even had a slice of pizza from this place, but everything was great. It was for a surprise party, and the driver was right on time. All of the food was delicious, I got several different pizzas, salad, rice balls, everyone loved it. I would definitely recommend this place. I got a 2 foot Italian sub that looked like it was closer to 3 and a half feet and probably could have fed everyone I've ever met. read more

The hospital employees live this place! Delicious, hot and tasty! With fast delivery from around the corner. Custom order your pizzas, salads, sandwiches and pasta! Yummo!! read more

I've been ordering pies from here since the mid-90s and in my humble opinion, it's the closest thing you can get around here to NYC style pizza. Thin crusted, greasy, so cheesy it almost falls off, just the way I like it (although I'm sure this isn't for everyone). One of our favorites is the margherita pizza. If you're into gourmet style pizza, this place probably isn't for you, but we love it! read more

Very very disappointing. When ever I was in the West Orange/Livingston area at lunch time I would stop in for delicious margarita pizza. I would grab a couple of slices and be on my way. So enjoyable, fresh mozzarella, plum tomato sauce, fresh basil, maybe some olive oil and THATS IT! Well tonight I ordered a margarita pie that someone else picked up. This was not the pizza I was expecting. This was amateur at best. It had regular mozzarella sliced which looked waxy, plum tomato sauce, some fresh basil, and alot of dried basil, which doesn't even belong on there. When I called to question what I had received, I had to explain to two different people and I guess the second guy was of importance because he got defensive. He insisted it was the same pie, same recipe as always. Half hearted he offered a new pie , but said it would be the same thing. Yeah, that helps! Needless to say I will never go back and not recommend this place to anyone I care about. If you want a very good margarita pizza the way it should be, Shop-Rite in Parsippany is a good choice, believe it or not, and they are friendly! read more

Food has gone down hill. Pizza is still good, however I ordered a Greek salad and they left out the tomatoes. I called about it and the a snot nose person that answered the phone said that I'd have to wait 45 minutes to get me the tomatoes. I wasn't asking him to bring me tomatoes, I was notifying them that the salad was not up to par. Also, the two cannolis I ordered were stale and smelled rancid as if they have been in a cupboard or shelf for a long time. Seriously disappointed. read more