I've come back a couple times (one time someone had to drag me) trying to figure out the 4-star rating and honestly, I'm not sure what I need to try that will wow me.
The first time here, I had a terrible, TERRIBLE experience and vowed never to come back but begrudgingly gave them a second chance because of my very close mainland friends insisted that they must try it. The second time was better and after one more go with a different group of people, I can say with confidence that Noodle Talk is just a 3. They do give you free peanuts and kimchi at your table.
So, I was originally super excited because I love round noodles in my noodle soups and really wanted to try this place! My experience though was horrible. Along with ordering an A1 (beef stew noodle soup), I had ordered green onion pancakes. So let me tell you, I LOVE green onion pancakes, like crave and love them along with most things that are fried. But when this came out, it was cold. It was cut into fourths and after taking one bite, I spit it back out. It tasted like dough that had been soaked in warm oil that was then left to solidify and cool at room temperature, then repeated but at lower and lower temperatures. I flagged someone down to tell them it was cold and the waiter touched it with his thumb, apologized and said they would heat it up. They did so by microwaving it and bringing it back to the table, still partially eaten. Okay, cool, he had brought back food that he had physically put his hand on (super unsanitary) BUT worse, it was still soggy and barely warm and I mean BARELY warm like the plate it was on was warmer. So at least I know they didn't re-dip my chewed off piece into the group frier or anything and probably just microwaved it for 8 seconds like you do with Krispy Kreme donuts. But I flagged them back down because this still wasn't fresh or even hot and just tasted like soggy oil. The waiter came back, touched it again, seemed mildly surprised it was still not hot and when he pulled away his now greasy finger, said they would make a brand new one. They quickly brought out a new plate for us. But this new green onion pancake although warm and almost hot, was not crispy and one of the pieces was discolored so I'm 99% sure they gave me back the other 3 oil-sogged pieces and just cut another quarter to stack on top and serve. I'm also pretty sure none of the pieces fit together so meh. But the pancake still tasted like old oily soaked dough except now it was hot oily soaked dough. It went completely uneaten as I was past complaining a fourth time and also because I was secretly worried that the waiter was mad at us and would spit in our food or something. I was also beyond trying to enjoy the noodle soup so I left there not only angry but totally dissatisfied.
I'm probably not going back unless I'm really craving round noodles and don't want Bun Bo Hue. I'm a noodle soup addict and I can really have noodle soup for every meal of everyday, but their noodle soup is pretty average. The A1 Beef Stew Noodle Soup is actually not that spicy, pretty mild and while the noodles and the broth are fine, the beef is pretty tough and chewy. The A2 isn't much better. I was really hoping Beef Stew would mean softer beef but every time it's chewy so I just eat the noodles. I do have to say though that the broth tastes pretty good to me. Not too strong or rich, more of a subtle, mild flavor that you would expect from just broth. The noodles are good although sometimes bordering on too soft (but that's just because I have a personal preference for thick/chewy noodles)! Maybe because I tend to not like the beef and don't finish it but one bowl doesn't leave me full. If they could make the beef tender and always cook the noodles right, I think I could really like it though! :) read more