I like their pizza as well as the the large new location on High street. Easy access with lots of parking. They also have a dedicated pickup counter for your call in order. read more

I love the bread sticks!!!!! They were temperature warm, served with a luscious side of ranch. There was a poster when you walk in that said "Auburn As Good As Gold," AND they mean it, y'all! My pizza had pineapple, bacon, and whole milk mozzarella. Heaven, y'all!!!!! I didn't orders a dessert but we did have M&M's. Another review from WWD, food critic(8 year old) read more

See all

TheBEST PIZZA around..been eating there for years..been to location in roseville a few times and just as good

Great new location on High street, and still the best pizza I have eaten. They have a covered roof-top eating area, and a bar on both floors. read more

Went to this restaurant tonight with a large group for pizza and cold beer. After patronizing this business for 35 years we were informed that they donot have domestic beer. The waitress we had informed us that "we like to promote the local brewery 's in the Auburn area. Like we were just going to say ok and drink something we dont like. She kept trying to push free samples on us after many times saying NO! Since the move to a fancier place Reese Browing has gotten a little to BIG for his britches. Reese, people like it the way it was! Thats why after 35 years we were still coming to your restaurant. But guess what??? No more....you LOST a loyal customer and many more after our experience. C.Ford read more

I am an Auburn local and have been a loyal patron of OTP's for a very long time. That loyalty ended on November 8, 2023 when I found a foreign object hidden under the cheese on my pizza for a second time. The first time that this happened to me was shortly after OTP moved to the Salvation Army location where I discovered a decent sized portion of a Hidden Valley Ranch label under the cheese on one of my slices. Thank god the cheese slid off in one piece to reveal it. I'm still perplexed as to how that managed to make it on my pizza unnoticed and then had toppings put on. Absolutely abysmal attention to detail. I don't normally give restaurants a second chance when they mess up my food as bad as they did the first time, but it happened right after they moved to the new location and I could tell they were struggling to acclimate in the new setting so I eventually let it go. This time the foreign object was a long piece of string that I initially thought was just stringy cheese, but to my surprise and disgust was not. I immediately informed the floor manager and inquired as to where the string could have came from. He told me that it was from the brush used to put sauce on my pizza, which he and I both knew was a complete lie, and when I asked to see the brush to verify he refused to accommodate. All I wanted to know was where this string came from for peace of mind, but I wasn't getting anywhere. When I asked to escalate the situation for answers he came back with a card to simply email another manager who was not available. Finally after being adamant about getting to the bottom of the string, the supposed regional manager came out and was equally useless. OTP prefers to cover up for their staff member who lacks ethics and integrity instead of showing any accountability. Absolutely disgusted with the way they handled the situation, and they should be ashamed of themselves. Especially the supposed regional manager. No one should have to question or fear if someone is tampering with their food, and OTP needs to do better about holding people accountable. I hope that OTP takes this seriously and looks into it because they may face litigation if they don't. The pieces of string pictured are pieces of a longer portion. I tore the entire pizza apart with my bare hands to ensure that there wasn't anything else hiding. I'll finish this rant with the classic, I'd give zero stars if I could. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pieces of the long string hidden under my cheese - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

Service was good, place was nice but the food wasn't good! I'd choose a different place for pizzas

I like their new location on 510 High street. We sat upstairs on their balcony. The misters were a nice touch to keeping us cool. Nice variety of beer on tap and the pizzas were delicious. We ordered the gunfighter - pesto and mother lode. Crispy crust and good amount of toppings. Definitely coming back to try their other items. read more

It has good food. The people that work here are nice. I get good service. I love their pizza.

This place is incredible if you love pizza and beer. The dough is light, we love the white sauce build your own with some sausage. I'm a craft beer guy and the list has some of the absolute best and they do flights. 6 stars. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

The best pizza anywhere around. Hand tossed. You know you're eating good good pizza. Artisan tasting pizza. I like the mother loan on cauliflower crust lately. But all crusts are good. The cheesy bread sticks are to die for. read more

Very Less Cheese, toppings and white sauce we paid $100+ for big group. Pizza without Cheese is no pizza. We go to Old Town Pizza in Roseville. Their old Auburn location relocated here so we came today 5/21/2023. We always get the choo choo train (Ros) doc's chicken named different in each location they expanded got Bigger location but quality and quantity of their pizza went down. Their old auburn basement location made better quality pizzas and their Roseville location so we will stick to their roseville location. Today this big location was a big disappointment!!!! read more

The young women servers upstairs were rude, unprofessional, and down tight nasty. Management should be embarrassed they hire such disrespectful employees. Worst experience ever. She made me feel uncomfortable and unwelcome. read more

This is possibly the best pizza I've ever had ,crust was just right ,and service is great

I had a specialty pizza delivered to me at work for lunch today and it was PERFECT! Delivery was early and the guy was nice. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

You cannot get better pizza or better service!! We have been going their for a lot of years!!! Their quality cannot be beat!! They are the best!! read more

The food (Pizza and salad) and service were very good again and we will be back for more!

Good food good vibe pizza was delicious and the beer was epic. My family and I enjoyed the visit

Really good pizza, family friendly, attentive servers! We went there on a hot day and the ac was very nice!

The service is always great . The pizza choices are unique and delicious. Many good beers and wine to choose from in the cozy atmosphere

Decided to stop in Auburn for dinner on our way home from Reno. Saw OTP and good reviews on Yelp so gave it a try. Some of the best pizza in NorCal! Staff was super friendly and went out of their way to provide great service. Crust was crispy and just the right thinness. Not too doughy. Great sauce and plenty of meat and cheese. We shared a medium and had plenty to take home for next days lunch. Highly recommend a visit! read more

Pizza was pretty good, environment is cute but words cannot express the level of disappointment I felt after asking for a side of ranch and getting handed these gross little packets. Homemade restaurant style ranch would up the game and be well worth the up-charge. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

Food and service are excellent! We had the veggie pizza with the white garlic sauce -yummy!!! The crust was perfect and the vegetables were fresh. Shared the caprese salad and even though it's the wrong time of year for fresh tomatoes, it was also very tasty. Jeff, our waiter, was friendly and very responsive to our requests. We have tried all of the pizza places in Auburn and this is definitely our favorite. You will not be disappointed. read more

They have really good pizza. The breadsticks are really good as well. The staff are are really nice. Always have had good time here. Been here a few times with my mom and we always had a good experience when we come here. read more

Very nice good service good fresh food Atmosphere is relaxing. Also the delivery service is great. read more

Had been told the food was amazing and was looking forward to sampling it. we received our drinks placed our order and proceeded to wait ... After an hour we ask if there was a problem and they had never even made our order . Apparently visiting with each other behind the bar took precdeence over our food. They did offer to make it for us and after we said no thank you they wanted to comp our drinks so I give them that . We paid for everything and gave her a tip and left , too bad the service was lacking I was looking forward to tasting their pizza. read more

I absolutely LOVE this OTP location!! The staff is always amazing with awesome service every time! The pizza always comes out hot a delicious!! Their salads!!! THEY ARE COLD, CRISP and FRESH!!! This is my favorite OTP!!! The location is great and the atmosphere is large and open, it can get a little loud but it balances out. read more

Great pizza, super friendly staff. You can't go wrong ordering anything on the menu. If you're gluten intolerant, the califlowet crust is the bomb. read more

Old Town Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Auburn, California

Yesterday was my first time trying this place and let me tell you it did not disappoint. The breadsticks were amazing!!!! The pizza was so good and I will definitely be returning! read more

This place is great. I rarely write reviews. I'm writing this one due to Sergio, our server. He was fantastic. My three year old daughter had a birthday tonight. He made it fun for her by engaging her and the finale was ice cream. Let's face it, the cost of going out has gone up quite a bit. For that reason I feel it has to be worth it. Old town has an amazing beer selection, really nice atmosphere, and staff that makes you feel welcome. I'll be back. Thank again Sergio!!! read more

We have been going to Old Town Pizza for over 10 years, since they were in the old location. We drive an hour and 20 minutes one way because we love the pizza, but today was our last visit. Today is our 39th wedding anniversary and instead of going to a steak house we decided to go get pizza. We got there at 1:15 and there were very few customers but it took over 20 minutes before we saw our server, then it took 30 minutes before they brought our pizza to our table and it was cool so it must have been sitting for a while before they brought it out. We decided to order dessert, my wife ordered the flourless chocolate cake and I ordered the chocolate sundae, it took 25 minutes for my wife to get her cake and over 30 for me to get my sundae? The kid who was bringing out the food was walking around doing anything except bringing pizzas to tables, it was a damn mess! I don't know what is going on there, but these kids need some adult supervision so that they will do their job. I miss the old location, it was small and had good service but now that they have this new nice location, the service sucks, very sad. read more

Yes yes yes . Love the new building , pizza is on point every time . Can't wait to go back for date night . Always have the best Customer service . Order extra and have left overs . read more

Wow. What a gem. Impulse stop on our way to Tahoe. We were hungry, took pizza to go, but it was great. Thick crust was crisp on bottom. Toppings were fresh and flavorful. Can't wait to come back and sample more (as well as a beer -- looked like lots of choices on tap). See u next time read more

Fantastic pizza and atmosphere. Glad they moved to a bigger building with more space for big parties

I'm trying to cut down on carbs so I reluctantly ordered a cauliflower crust pizza. It was SO DELICIOUS!! I was expecting it to be blah but it was completly opposite of that. It was so good that I thought maybe they messed up and gave me the real (bread) pizza crust (they didn't). I highly recommend the cauliflower crust. Don't be scared. LOL!! I'll be ordering it everytime I go there. I forgot our server's name but she was great! read more

This place is so understaffed. Wait times are just ridiculous. This is the second time we have received a "surprise" in our pizza. We will not be going back. read more

Friend showed us this hidden gem! Love the Wings' with BBQ sauce' sitting at the fire pit' very friendly staff!

Their pizza is excellent and their beer selection is insane. They carry beers from Great Notion, Bottle Logic and Russian River. However, they need to figure out something for their parking at their new location. I drove around the building for 20 minutes trying to find a spot to pick up my pizza on a Friday. Never found a spot so we had to illegally park next door. read more

During my recent experience at the new location, my pizza had barely any sauce! It was disappointing since it was lacking in flavor. I also find that my pizza always looks like a grease ball on top. I never use to dab oil off my pizza.... I've looked back at other one star reviews and I find that the owner, Reese, is very rude in his responses to customers. I don't appreciate poor upper management. Disappointing. read more

My husband and I wanted to try this place. We really looking forward to it. We got there we asked to sit upstairs and we asked allow dogs? They said let me ask my manger and double check when she got back she said no. I'm disappointed how they don't allow dogs and how rude they were. If you allow service dogs and you should still allow dogs too. I don't recommend this place and very rude and not good service. I'm very upset and disappointed. WORST service!!!!! read more