Awesome! So happy Magoo's Pizza is BACK. The combo pizza was just as good as I remembered it to be. The chicken wings were delicious too - nice crunchy batter and tasty seasoning. Can't wait to have this again. read more

Original Magoo's Pizza - Chicken wings, sauce on the side - Pizza Near Me - Honolulu, Hawaii

See all

Thumbs down...4/9/22 your Yelp page say you open at 11AM. But you Facebook page you open at 4...WTF is going on? Get it together. I have to put a star to post my disappointment. You guys get zero stars read more

Easy night in at the hotel. Pizza and wings deal was affordable and good food. Service was good and they waited for us at closing to pick up our pizza. I also like the cheese blend. read more

Ah nostalgia. Tastes just like I remember as a Kid. I don't know if new folks will like it, but for those of us that grew up with it. I loved it! read more

This place pizza is YUMMY!! It's hard to find good taste pizza in here but Magoo's pizza is best!

This pizza is the best period. The flaky crust is just like grandma's homemade pies with a mild spicy tomato sauce that is just right. I like'a da da sauce and you will too. Does not matter what pizza you pick because it's all in the dough. Cheers people. read more

Really disappointed in the food here. normally wouldn't write a review but felt it was a waste of $60. we got pizza and a Caesar salad. The salad came with what tasted like grocery store ranch dressing very thick and jellowy so we just ate plain lettuce. The pizza crust was ok but it tasted like a lunchable for kids, we got the one with roasted garlic and most cloves seemed to be rotten and bruised in the Center. The staff was very friendly so it's unfortunate that the food was so mediocre read more

Took a trip down memory lane and ordered magoos, if you used to have tall pitchers at the university location with 100 of your closest friends, this will bring back memories. Grab some light beers and have a pizza and cheese fries, it's just like you remembered! read more

Original Magoo's Pizza - Crinkle Fries - Pizza Near Me - Honolulu, Hawaii

See all

Got pizza here for the first time after reading some reviews and it was so flavorful. I got the potpourri pizza and every slice was delicious, will definitely be back for more read more

The hot ham and mushroom is so good. We didn't care for the fries, that's why I took away a star, sorry but limp fries aren't really my thing. We'll total come back for the subs though!! read more

I was not disappointed when I picked up my order of 2 giant combos which were huge and filled the entire box and not the 16" round pizza I was expecting since I also ordered 1 giant pepperoni and 1 large Hawaiian and also 24 pieces of seasoned chicken to feed only 11 of us. Pizza's and chicken were great and will return read more

Original Magoo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Honolulu, Hawaii

Magoo's pizza is THE best tasting pizza you will find anywhere on Oahu. The sauce is a little tangy with great flavor. The cheese is gooey and compliments the sauce wonderfully. The toppings are the icing to this pizza cake. Price is comparable to the other pizza places. read more

While the food is great I truly recommend you come for the experience Parker is truly an amazing individual and will have you wanting to come back just to hang with him great pizza better sandwiches and the best service on the island. read more

Best pizza on the east side for sure! Love the hot ham and cheese sub too! Great customer service.

Came back here last week after some time away, definitely a bummer, but will not be returning here any time soon. Loved the food here, some damn fine chicken wings and sandwiches, but the store is definitely not what it once was. Can't sit at the bar without having to swat gnats away from your face constantly. Asked the server(I think he said his name was Ben, very hard to understand) and he just shrugged and said that's normal. I guess that's on par here considering the place looked like it hadn't been swept since the night before, literally had to wipe our seats off before we sat down or we'd be sitting in the previous guests crumbs. I assume it's also normal to not offer ice in our drinks either, had to tell him we didn't want warm soda and would like something COOL as it's 80+ outside. This used to be a weekly spot for me as it's location was super convenient with my commute w/ work, and liked their happy hour offerings. Gonna have to hold off on that for a bit, takeout only if at all. read more

Parker is awesome, friendly, knowledgeable he didn't mind answering a hundred questions. Food great and ambiance is great with a variety of 80's and 90's music. read more

I miss this place!! So glad theres still one left I can get my No huhu on! Same ono ono pizza I've loved for sooo many years!

Pizza was delicious. They do not skimp on the toppings, fully loaded. Large beer pitchers for $20. Free video games. Nice bathrooms. Free parking. read more

Tasty pizza with great variety of choices! This place brings back memories and the taste is consistent from what we remember. The owner is so friendly and was talking story with my mom, whom he remembers from high school. The portions are huge! read more

Still THE BEST pizza on the island. And they have a sweet lil place in Kaimuki Town now with football and cocktails! No hu hu!

We had the famous Magoos combo with sausage peppers onions pepperoni. It's just as delicious as the Magoos in my youth! I grew up on Magoos and it's exactly as I remember it! read more

Best vegan pizza on the island with tons of toppings. I got the large combo vegan pizza and it was soo much better than Pieology.

I've tried to get a seat in the restaurant only to be told that I would have to wait an hour to be served. On another occasion, I tried to phone in a take out order and there was no answer. I tried to call again on another day, and I was told that they had a huge order phoned in before me and I may have to wait for 2 hours for A pizza. I gave up and now the Waialae restaurant has closed, I'm not surprised. read more

If I could have put zero stars, I would. I was so excited to try this place, my gf had told me not to bother because the things she's heard from others as well as knowing the owners. I ordered the "giant" Barbecue chicken pizza which was about the size of a medium dominos pizza maybe a tiny bit bigger. It costed $31.36 which what was not a big deal, obviously I was willing to pay for it. The part that was annoying was that they charged me twice for it. I proceeded to tell the cashier, he said he didn't. I showed him, he said it didn't work the first time he rang it in and he had to try it again. It definitely worked the first time because as you can see I paid twice. My bank account can tell you. I only got one pizza When I first arrived the employees were all gathered around my pizza looking at it, they had put mushrooms on it when I had specifically asked for none. My gf doesn't like them, which is an honest mistake, but they should have called me to inform me because as soon as I got there they said that they were making me another one. They said that they just put another one in without the mushrooms, which was nice that they were willing to fix it, but I didn't have time to wait another 25 minutes. To make things easier I just took the pizza with the mushrooms, she could just pick them off. After-all, the pizza was all around awful, there was chicken skin on it or fat, I'm not sure what it was. I picked it off and threw that away a lot of the chicken was pink and not fully cooked. It was loaded with mushrooms which I can't complain about that part too much because I had said it's fine when they said they would make another one. I just wasn't trying to wait around for another 25 mins. I'm not one to write these kind of reviews, but I'm honestly very annoyed that I was charged twice. The cashier said if you were charged twice keep the receipt and bring it back and maybe we can work something out. I had stuff I needed to do today it's Christmas and I don't have a lot of money in my account because of presents. I paid 62.72 for a tiny salmonella pizza that wasn't even cooked completely they are closed so I have to wait to figure this all out but should have been fixed on the spot when I had asked. like I said I don't write these ever but to much happened one thing I can say they weren't rude they were very polite but polite doesn't cook food right or charge me twice customer service was good other than that the cashier was bad because my money was taken twice when I had shown him my online statement he didn't believe it I definitely would not go back and would not recommend this place and will listen to my girl friend lol I will type another if I don't get my money back so if you don't see another then they solved it ----- update I got the second charge back but it took them 2 weeks still thankful to have it back tho read more

See all

If you appreciate thin crust, just go...... If you appreciate a sandwich where the bread is the HERO, just go... If your impatient and cant wait around for a freshly made, original sauce pizza that may take longer than 15 minutes then please don't go. Magoo's pizza is prideful and unique to Hawaii. You can go to any other pizza conglomerate for that other stuff. Magoo's Hawaii's the only real deal pizza joint that you can absolutely say "made in Hawaii". read more

I ordered my food and waited over an hour. When I checked on my order it still was not made yet. This poor service. If you are unable to to accommodate everyone's order then you should stop taking orders. We ended up going to Papa John's instead and our food was ready within 15 minutes. read more

I ordered online. Was promised to be ready for pickup my 6:40pm. It wasn't ready until 7:15. The garlic chicken pizza wasn't the same as the original. It used to be Alfredo type sauce but they used marinara and didn't taste as good as I remember when I used to buy from their truck on King's. Unfortunately, and I hate to say this, Pizza Hut's similar pizza tastes better. On the flip side, the lady working there was very nice and apologetic about the delay. read more

This is a four star review of their wings. They are awesome. You can have them tossed in buffalo sauce and blue cheese. Delish. The pizza is just okay - to be honest, I'm a fan of thinner crust pizza (JJ Dolans, NY Style, St. Louis Style), so this pizza just didn't do it for me. But the wings are awesome. And the staff is super friendly!! read more

Good pizza ruined with bad customer service. You order on their site they say to call to find out when it will be ready but their phone doesn't ring. It goes to a voicemail. I came AN HOUR after ordering and there were people who had ordered at 3 pm and were still waiting at nearly 7 pm for pizza. Sorry, the pizza is good but not 4 hour wait good. I'm still sitting waiting for my pizza no idea IF or WHEN it will be ready. This is not worth the exorbitant price. Nostalgia is great and from what I remember of this place as a kid, the pizza was great but no restaurant is worth a four or more hour wait. They need to either hire more people or implement software on their ordering website to book pizza orders like a doctors office would book appointments. That would prevent people waiting hours, give customers an adequate time window to know when their order would be ready, and help the employees of this establishment not be as frazzled as they look right now while I stand here watching them tell someone who ordered two hours ago that their pizza won't be ready until 8 pm. Shame. I had high hopes when I saw this place was opening again. Three or more hours for a pizza with no online update as to when it will be ready? No phone number answering by the staff. They just told me 9 pm my pizza would be ready. I ordered at 5. Never again read more

Too bad this Yelp doesn't pull up this place when searching for pizza. I found it on Instagram by luck after craving this style pizza for years. Boy did it exceed my expectations! Worth every cent & drop of saliva at the sight of it read more

Ham and mushroom sandwich is bomb but the chicken wing.... TNT dynammmiitteee!!! Awesome service. Paid for my food , sat in the car and they brought it out to me and triple checked my order and made sure everything was there. What more can you ask for!?! Guarantee going back next time I'm in town. read more

I've always loved Magoo's from back when they were located in Waikiki over 20+ yrs ago. Since then the Hot Ham, Cheese and Mushroom is what keeps me coming back. However lately their fries have been a hit or miss. They changed it from crinkle to potato cut (I think that's what it's called) and the other day when I ordered and asked for it to be crispy it was just a bag of oil. With a dirty oil taste. They looked bad and taste bad. Will that mean I'll never go back, absolutely not. But will I order fries again....HELL NO!! read more

So happy Magoo's Pizza is in business again! Pizza tastes like the original, especially the crust and sauce! We had a combo small size with anchovies and pepperoni giant size. Both very delicious! Downside- parking is very limited so might want to get dropped off. read more

Original Magoo's Pizza - Small combo with anchovies - Pizza Near Me - Honolulu, Hawaii

See all

Would have liked to be reviewing the pizza, but unfortunately didn't even get a chance to eat it today. Placed an order online for a large combo, hot ham and cheese sandwich, and fries for just over $50 at noon today. Only after ordering will you get a confirmation and timeframe when the order would be ready. Our email said 2:30-3:00. Ok, we had to wait a while for lunch, but we figured worth the wait. Keep in mind there isn't any further confirmation about your order, and calling Magoos to check up on your order only gets you a recording. On the way from Kāne'ohe to Magoos at around 2:15, we get a call from them, who said our order will now be ready at 3:30! Not wanting to wait another hour and some change for lunch, we asked for a refund, who the worker said would be reflected in our cc statement in 5 days! The worker apologized, and said it's only their 2nd week of opening. But still, Magoos really needs to figure out how to take orders--just read the other reviews. Ordering your food before they even open doesn't make sense, or them not being able to give you a reasonable time frame that your food would be ready is crazy. Since we were already on the road, and town side of the Pali, we called J Dolan's who had our pizza, fries, and onion rings who gave us a time of 20 minutes, and it was ready in that time! Magoos: We really missed your pizza and grub, ever since Puck's Alley and the yellow truck in the gas station across McCully Bike days; and I even remember the 9th Ave location b/c I lived in the Jade circle building across the street, but you really need to figure out a system to get food ready within a reasonable time--3-4 hour wait, is crazy! read more

So tonight I decided to try a new place besides pizza hut The wait time was about an hour which is kind of normal on a Friday or Saturday night they told me around 830 or when the pizza gets done they will call me no I've eaten a lot of places and I am also a chef so I know how it feels when you're about to close sometimes the quality is just not there when I reply to these kind of messages I do that so the company can make adjustments to better themselves for other customers you cannot always blame the company sometimes it's just an employee or shit happens in the kitchen so I ordered a large pizza it was so bad I only ate one slice the chicken after the skin there's no taste the coleslaw was soaked in mayonnaise the salad is a normal salad once once again sometimes shit happens in the kitchen I look forward to trying this place again hopefully the quality will get better because I spent almost $90 on my meal tonight. read more

See all

Tried calling in the order no one answers and refers you to online ordering. Online ordering seems a little "sketchy" and says you will get a call from the restaurant when your order is ready and doesn't give you an estimated time. Almost 3 hour wait for a large pizza?!!! Come on man... You want to be a success but is seems you didn't plan for success. Last nite was a #FAIL Original Magoo's. Seems like Rookies are running the show there. They got the recipes but not the business plan. They want to be successful but didn't plan for success. #AllHuHuWithOriginalMagoos When I got there you guys were refunding people's money left and right because of wait times that were way too long that you never let anyone know about. read more

Let me start by saying this food review is slanted. I've been eating here for more than 25 years. I absolutely love their hot ham and cheese sandwich it's everything you want. Savory, salty, cheesy, very comforting. Tonight I ordered the combo pizza which was smothered in pepperoni, cheese, red peppers, bell peppers, black olives and sweet Italian sausage- just plain old made with lovepizza. The crust was thin crunchy, crispy and perfectly baked to perfection. Think 6 AM in Paris when the baguette is coming out of the oven, it was that good. Now how do you F all that up- have it delivered to you by Grubb Hub. O MY GOD - What a catastrophic fail. The driver was lost, he wanted me to come down 2 flight to get my pizza, he was rude and indignant, and literally tossed the pizza at Kewit he a "have a goo night", poor English, and scurried away like a troll in the night. Discussed. Head my advice- go get it. read more

We loved the chicken wings! Pizza is okay, I've never been a fan of cheddar cheese on pizza.

Hmm. I'm having mixed feelings about this... Maybe, today wasn't a good day for Magoos. The pizza was not what I expected, I'm not saying it was bad but it wasn't good either. The crust tasted kind of like cardboard and a little rubbery? Or maybe they didn't add enough sauce? Idk Something was off.. The Caesar salad wasn't the greatest either, I would skip on that next time. The upside of this pizza journey was that the pizza was big and they did not skimp out on the toppings. I will try the smaller pizzas next time and see how that turns out. read more

Original Magoo's Pizza - Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Honolulu, Hawaii

See all

Pizza taste different from the original Magoo's combo pizza. Crust they make now is much thicker than the old original pizza. Seasoned fried chicken was pretty good. I would highly recommend to others the seasoned fried chicken. Would like to try the blue cheese chicken on my next trip. Service was friendly and phone order was ready as promised in 20 mins. Was happy to these guys back in business but I really miss the old original Magoo's combo pizza. Thank you for bringing back old memories. read more