I was so disappointed today. I go here all the time. The pizza I ordered was the works. There was literally 5 meatballs, no vegetables as asked for that. Like 5 pieces of pepperoni . Small tiny pieces of mushroom . Iv had the works many times. There's not even ingredients on the top. And the woman wasnt so friendly either. If look up the works, which Iv ordered several times . There's hardly any ingredients on this iast order. So disappointed read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Hardly looks like the works - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

I went Papa John Lake Mary at 11.00 AM. May 7 2024 Papa John in this location 4300 Lake Mary Blvd, Lake Mary, FL 32746 My Pizza not ready, I am hungry and I am not Racism but The black lady work in the back not make my food. I'm so hungry. She just played music use ipod. Pizza not that long to make it Work use iPod not a good impression Go home better listen your music. No need go work bad behavior. Bad Employees. read more

I placed my order at 12:35 PM I received my food at 1:30 PM cold wings soggy! I am beyond furious and this was the 2nd time. I'm done with this location for good! I order from this location on a regular basis but I see I am not a value customer. NOT HAPPY! read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

See all

Thank you Papa before being there for me during this time. I've had really bad anxiety about going out to pickup food. I decided to to order delivery even though I was nervous about it. I was impressed how Papa John's went above and beyond to make this a peaceful experience. When the pizza man arrive he knocked on the door, stepped far back and left the pizza on top of his bag on the ground. I grabbed the pizza, and he did not take a step forward until I had closed the door. Each pizza box had a special sticker seal. Once I got the pizza inside I dumped it into some clean glass containers, and thew away the boxes. The food tasted fresh and delicious. Thank you Papa for being there for your customers during this time. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

Quality of their toppings are so good I sometimes wonder how they do it. However the portions are small so I guess that is how.

This location is hit or miss. Good service, but the pizza is either really good or "meh." The last time, which was about a week ago, it was just 'meh.' We ordered a large pepperoni and bacon with extra cheese. I only ate one piece and then ate a bowl of cereal. LOL Also, we ordered extra cheese on the pizza and there was most definitely not extra cheese. I'm sure we'll eventually order from here again, but based on just the last experience, I'll go with Pizza Hut next time we are craving pizza. read more

I'm not sure if I should be doing a review as I didn't eat any pizza but my 17 year old daughter loves their pizza. She only eats cheese on it but she said it was very good. I also ordered dry wings with sauce on the side and they were not very good nor was the sauce. Quibble on delivery. I ordered it delivered at around 6:15 and it ended up arriving at 4:30. Not a place I would order from again unless the girl wants pizza. And I'll order at the time we are ready. I'm guessing they are on a par with the other large chains, so if that's what you're looking for then this might be the place, but not for wings. read more

Warren had an amazing demeanor when aiding an upset customer, and showed that even despite it being 12 in the morning, that he treated every customer well and with patience! He then helped me with a smile with my every need, and absolutely made my night! Hands down my best experience at a Papa John's. Good service and nice people go a long way. read more

mid pizza, pizza as soft as my grandpas dysfunctional erectile area. not great way too much sauce and cheese. i don't understand how this pizza is so floppy. y'all no cap it was dominos not papa johns my bad i'm changing my 1 star to 5 cause i've never been to this location in my life. Mod lowkey better tho read more

Papa Johns Pizza - soggy ass pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

See all

Last night we decided it was a perfect pizza delivery night so we ordered some PJ's! Normally, I'm more of a Pizza Hut pan pizza girl but my son requested PJ's. We ordered a large pepperoni pie and a large "The Works" (Pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and black olives). I have to say, both pies tasted nice and fresh and the crust was cooked perfectly. I really haven't had pizza from here in quite awhile and was pleasantly surprised that it tasted delicious and fresh. In the past, my husband was a fan of ordering a pepperoni pizza with fresh tomatoes added at the end. The juiciness of the tomatoes is a really nice combo with the salty pepperoni. The delivery guy forgot to bring our diet soda that we also ordered, so he quickly drove back and picked one up for us. No biggie. read more

I had a situation where I had thought I had messed up the locations and the manager was the most kindest person ever and was so understanding and sweet about it all. I have been going to this papa johns since I was a kid and they have always had the best pizza (honestly even better than any other location even tho it's the same recipe I think it's because it truly made with love) I will forever go to this location as opposed to any other! They are wonderful! Tall manager needs a raise for his genuineness and just overall hardwork and dedication to the papa johns name! read more

Order taker on the phone at the store kept getting my order wrong, so I called back to speak to the manager and she faked a little lie and told him I was rude to her, when it was the other way around. Mgr took her side without ever listening to the Call. I guess in this store the Customer is never right, even when the employee is lying. I guess All those negative reviews are spot on read more

What is this ?! A slice of pizza for ants? :( someone should contact me to deliver some Bigger slices of pizza. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

Tasted like sawdust, not done with little flavor. Worst pizza ever. Hello are you listening Papa. read more

Great service tonight.. for the front cashier young fella.. he handled all my needs professionally food was nice and hot

Online ordering is the way to go since it's quicker and you earn rewards. You can always find a coupon on Retailmenot for 25% to 50% off. This location does a good job. I've never done delivery but always do carry out. Sometimes parking can be a miss. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Mary, Florida

I suggest you check your pizza before you take it (if takeout), or before the delivery person leaves. I think they are leaving the meat off the pizza to save money....given the situation with the epidemic, etc., I ordered from them tonight and there was an incorrect order (no meat at all) even though the only meat I ordered on the pizza was pepperoni. The sticker on the outside of the box said sausage and canadian bacon, which I didn't order AND also were not on the pizza. I have ordered from them many times before we all were advised to stay home due to coronavirus and they never got the order wrong. Interesting. I would recommend just checking before you take the pizza home etc. read more

Poor customer service on the phone! My husband called Papa John's Tonight as he was driving on his way home and asked what their special was. The male employee replied "You can look online if you want to see what type of specials we have" Needless to say, he went somewhere else. read more

Ordered online and it was super easy. I was able to track my pizza online. Service and quality of the pizza were great. Will order from this location again. read more

Been living here in downtown Lake Mary for almost thirty years and I finally decided to try Papa Joe and of all the Pizza I've tried in this bedroom community I gotta tell you is the best in town..very please will difinitly be my new favorite Pizzeria.. read more

Ordered two pizzas they were very good until I found a huge long black hair in it. More like In my mouth . I brushed it off and said to myself hey sometimes it will happen . I then grabbed a new pice from a different pizza and sure enough another long ass black hair ! Wtf so if u get a pizza check for hair !!!!! read more

Better ingredients, better pizza. Taste the difference. Good value for my money. Had 5 STARS until the black hair incident. NO HAIRNETS?? Ewww!!! read more

I ordered one 14" pizza for my dinner last Sunday , they were fast and pizza is well , but I think some mushrooms that on the top that is dark that is mean not fresh. Maybe the temperature is so high in the Orlando, I didn't eat all of them, I will try another day . read more

I ruined dinner and had to order pizza for the family. I was so flustered that I didn't even order the correct toppings! The gentleman on the phone was very courteous and offered to make the correct one for free! Thanks for saving our dinner! Great customer service and the pizza was good too! read more