Fast service for slices already there - and they toast them before serving which makes the crust so crispy! Good sauce & topping ratios. $10 for 2 slices & drink - so that is really cheap for a DELICIOUS pizza lunch! It's clean & staff is friendly. read more

The only positive was the $8 for 2 slices and a drink. But the selection to choose from was terrible and looked old. One of my slices was decent and the other was not edible. Tasted like soap or chemicals read more

Paulies Pizza Of Clifton Park is absolutely the best pizza in the area. If you like pizza that's as close to Jersey or the city style as you're gonna get, this is the place. They are consistent. The quality is unbelievable. It is real Pizza. If you call places like Pizza Hut, Domino's or any of the other pizza places in town then you don't know what Pizza is. Then keep eating what you want. If you can't rate this five stars for flavor, consistency, quality...then you don't know really good pizza. I give this my highest recommendation. These are good people who take pride in what they serve and deliver to you. SemperFi read more

Very good. Their Pepperoni Hot Honey Pizza is my favorite comfort food (currently sick and it's the first thing that came to mind). They're not a big fan of DoorDash, which, hey, fair enough. read more

Worst place I've ever been. Saw roaches crawling everywhere, pizza was soggy, tasted spoiled, and the whole place felt filthy. Honestly felt like a health hazard. Never going back. Called my autistic son a retard! read more

Best pizza in Clifton Park. Quality ingredients, even the crust is tasty. I also like supporting hard-working family businesses!

Called back within seconds of a out of stock item. Great customer service. Delivery fast and accurate

Great pizza! Eating pizza in NYC and NJ; Paulie's is right there with the best! Texture and flavor are great! Recommend the chicken parm pizza - AMAZING!! read more

Steak sub overcooked and dog choked on meat. Would not order steak sub next time . I would try something else.two stars

Ordered at the end of the night, and the chicken in the chicken Caesar salad was as fresh as it gets, the dressing was thick and delicious,. On a separate note, I don't like garlic knots but deal through them when my gf typically orders them..... Paulie's Garlic knots however.... I think I ate most of them. We also ordered meatballs last night. And they were exactly what a good meatball should be. They will def be part of our too busy/lazy to cook nights. read more

I grew up in the area and still have family and friends around. In a recent trip home I ordered some food from Paulie's and was very disappointed. The pizza that I got was the worst I have ever had. The crust was hard, the sauce tasted foul and the toppings were raw. Plus the order of garlic knots were rock hard. I have told my family and friends in the area to avoid Paulie's at all cost. read more

Doesn't look like anything from the outside but great pizza. Really good crust! Would definitely go back again.

Order was completed quickly, followed special request, great portion sizes for the price and food was delicious. Could eat a tray of those brownies read more

See all

My first experience with Paulie's was at the Rosa Rd location. It was only by chance that we came upon Paulie's in Clifton Park since alas, this establishment replaced an old fav, Cusato's. Now we may accept Paulie's as our new pizza parlor. The crust is obviously something to return for. Today we tried the a Supreme pizza. Pizzas are abundantly topped with toppings never making you guess what it was you ordered. If they include more diet beverages, maybe we could go up a notch. Your only choice is diet mist and diet pepsi. Previous pizza proprietor included diet teas AND my fav diet orange. sigh. maybe the diet fairy will bless us with more selections in the future. read more

Paulie's Pizza - a car parked in front of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Clifton Park, New York

I am not one to write negative reviews but this entire experience has been appalling. I received an ad in the mail of a very attractive margarita pizza and decided to give it a try. I ordered a large with extra cheese. After taking just short of 2 hours to arrive, the pizza we received was cold and unrecognizable from the ad we received. The picture speaks for itself there. What really rubbed me the wrong way was when we called the establishment to try to reconcile the situation. We were met with a rude and arrogant manager who offered no help and made no effort to improve our situation. Save yourself the trouble and avoid this mess. read more

Paulie's Pizza - What was advertised - Pizza Near Me - Clifton Park, New York

See all

I would rate this place zero stars if I could. First, we were told the pizza would be delivered in about an hour. Two hours later, still no pizza. So we called and checked on the status and they said it was leaving the shop momentarily. When it got here the whole order was cold. And the margarita pizza we ordered because we saw the one advertised looked nothing like what was shown. And to make it worse, we ordered extra cheese! We called to ask for another one to be sent and the manager was arrogant and nasty on the phone. Offering no way to fix the issue and not apologizing for the situation, but instead blamed the fact that there was no cheese on the pizza as them being busy. I would not recommend this place to my worst enemy. read more

Paulie's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Clifton Park, New York

See all

This restaurant does not deserve your business. I recommend you use our other local small businesses that value and treat customers properly. When I picked up a pizza, a man became irritated that I gave him a credit card that he needed to walk back in. He proceeded to mouth off to me in front of my small children that were in the car blaming me for not walking inside to pay despite having a curbside pick up sign on the front door of the restaurant. I called back to speak to a manager, and the same man picked up and told me that I "better get along" since they had more important things to do. I called back again and was told that man was the owner. There is no excuse to treat a customer - or anyone for that matter - with such disrespect. I will never go here again. There are many hard-working small restaurant owners that treat their customers right and are far more worthy of your hard-earned money. read more

I had a coupon for a large sub and side salad for 8.95 so I ordered a meatball sub. It was decent. Not the best one I've had. But it was mediocre. Put it this way, I won't order it again but I'd def try something else. The price was def right for the size of the sandwich. read more

I'm really sorry folks.... I ordered the margarita pizza and I thought I was eating something from the frozen food section of Hannaford's. I received a 6-piece...and gave 5 of them away to the hotel staff. Even THEY agreed it wasn't very good. Again.. I'm sorry. I do not like giving negative reviews, but in this case, it was warranted. Your driver who delivered the pizza, however, was very nice, cordial and respectful. read more

Don't bother going here, when they screw up they will adamantly defend their position even if it means they lost a customer. I used to order here at least 5 to 6 times a month. Cheap asses. read more

Started purchasing food from Pauline's about a year ago. Always good food but the last few times it went down hill. Today I received a bag of greasy onion rings, so greasy the bag ripped and a clump of soggy greasy onion rings fell out. Not worth returning for a refund, but with a pizza place on every corner I won't have an issues finding better read more

We have been getting pizza from Paulie's for a few months. After Ferretti's closed last year we tried several pizza places in the area and have found that Paulie's is now the best, in our opinion. Nice thin crust on the 8-cut and they will make it crispy by request. We always order it with eggplant topping and they don't scrimp. Sauce is very good and just the right amount of cheese. Employees are friendly and they deliver. The store is in a small strip mall right opposite the computer store and has only one driveway entrance so it is easy to miss but worth turning around if you do. read more

Paulie's has become our go to when we order pizza now. The sauce is incredible. The pizza always gets to us hot and no damage. They have the most polite delivery drivers. We never order from anywhere else. Customer service is also really good. We had an issue with ordering through grub hub recently, they delivered our pizza well after they closed anyway after we spoke to them on the phone. Good pizza. Good people. Really recommend. read more

Excellent pizza and wings here. Very friendly staff and reasonably priced. We always order pizza from Paulie's.

I can't rate it any lower then one star? If I could I would. The person who I assume to be the cashier walked away in the middle of me talking to them only to call me a fat fuck and an asshole. Very unprofessional and honestly even the lobby is clean, I can't imagine their kitchen. read more

Made my first visit to Paulie's Puzza based on the positive reviews I read. Very tasty pizza. I would go back for another. I did deduct a star from my rating because they use cornmeal on the bottom of the pie and I personally don't care for that. Otherwise no complaints. Nice thin crust and fresh ingredients. read more

We went to the Clifton Park restaurant and discovered our new 'go-to' Italian restaurant. Great pizza! Dinners are delicious and portions are generous. Antipasto salad was great ... plenty of meats & cheese and topped off with a great house dressing. No hesitation in recommending this restaurant! read more

Long Island quality pizza in upstate New York. They call Sicilian a "12-slice" but despite the name, it's delicious

This is the best pizza by the slice I have had in the area. There dough is the difference maker. Nice flavor and never soft or mushy. Sauce is a bit on the sweet side if you order cheese only but with pepperoni, I think it works good together. Have purchased slices over 6 times and it has been pretty consistent. I didn't like their wings. I would say, if you are like me and have been looking for a go to pizza by the slice place, give this place a try. I haven't ordered anything else other than what I mentioned. read more

Pizza was ready promptly and delicious!!! The gluten free pizza was better than most gluten free pizzas!!

First time trying Paulie's Pizza and it was very good. The woman that took my order was very friendly as well. I eat a lot of pizza and I definitely recommend it. read more

Food was good, no issue. My issue is the fact that I arrived at my pick up time and was told it would be 5-10 more minutes. Fine, no problem. Go out to my car for 10 minutes. Come back in expecting my food and it wasn't even started yet. Waited another 15 minutes for the food, half an hour late. This place might have changed their name but it's still the same crap. Same thing happened when you would order from. Cusatos. Probably won't waste my time, a shame because there was nothing wrong with the food. read more

First time ordering tonight. Ordered online with modifications. Food was fast, fresh and hot when it arrived. Decent pizza (not my favorite sauce) boneless wings were saucy and crispy. Italian mix sub was just how I ordered it and delicious! Prices were reasonable compared to other in the area. Will definitely be ordering again. read more

This is our go to pizza spot in the Clifton Park area. We are a big fan of their cheese pizza and they have really delicious french fries. We order from here once a week and never have an issue with the food or service. read more

I order from here about once a week. Pizza is always great. One of these days I'll try something different but the pizza is so good I'm always happy. read more

it must be ran by children! when ever we order something is forgotten if it's not the soda it's the extra blue cheese they didn't forget to charge you for but didn't put in the bag, wings are always reheated and tough pizza could be good if it wasn't cold by the time it gets to you.... read more

Got 4 cheese pizzas for our team of skaters and hungry parents while at the local ice rink. The slices were a decent size and the pizza was delicious. The crust was one of the better crusts I've had and we eat a lot of pizza! read more

Had an order of the Buffalo Garlic Parm wings-outstanding! Nice and crispy, but not too dry-highly recommend these

Probably the worst customer service I have seen. Very rude and unprofessional. Judging by responses from other negative reviews it really shows how unprofessional they are. Went in with a 50% off coupon from restaurant.com which they apparently don't accept. The lady (manager) told us they stopped accepting them at the end of last year which we went in last year with one as well and was told they didn't accept them at that point either. She said it was a scam and they took their logo but not sure how it's a scam when you were accepting them? Maybe do something to have it removed then!? She said imagine how we feel...there's nothing I can do and was rude. You should be concerned a little more about the customer and customer service. So I turned to my girlfriend and said maybe we should start going elsewhere as we were about to pay for our order. We were then told just leave now and go somewhere else. So as regular customers we left and went to Caputos just down the road where the customer service was absolutely amazing, friendly and the food was great. We will definitely be bringing our business to Caputos from now on. read more

Authentic N.Y. style pizza my ass, this was the worst pizza I've ever had. I had the shits for three days after eating there because of the oil!! read more