Pie Dreams makes a mean key lime pie! It's quite tart, which I love, but I can see others turning away from that. The texture was so, so creamy. Their sleeper is the hand pies. I got the blueberry lemon and the flavor combined with the sugary crystal crust made it perfect. On the day we went, the owner's two kids handled our order :) read more

Finally tried for the first time. Had a slice of blackberry custard and banana black sesame. Super tasty, unique, and delicious crust. Need to come back earlier to try more options! read more

So good!! Orange Dreamsicle and Chicken Bacon pie -~ Delish!! Will definitely be coming back here again. read more

Pie Dreams - Orange Dreamsicle and Chicken Bacon Pie. - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

This family owned business is one of our favorites to support in Newark. The family is so nice. & the pies are delicious. My favorites are the matcha and chocolate. I've also been told their lemon chess is perfect. + A special mention for their hand pies, which are great to order if you're feeling savory! I'm always looking forward to seeing what new pie flavors they come up with read more

We have always seen this place and have always wanted to check them out ever since seeing quite a long line during pie day, but we never had the opportunity to until now. My husband and I stopped by here since we had some time before picking up our daughter from her tutoring session. The inside of the establishment is simple yet clean; there is a menu on the wall that shows what is being sold that day, and a display of some food item and drinks for sale. The gentleman who was at the register helped us out, kindly welcoming us, and explaining what the pies that were on sale that day and what ingredients they had in them. Since our daughter had some food allergies, we did ask if there were any tree nuts or peanuts in any of the pies. He truthfully told us that there were not tree nuts or peanuts in any of the pies, however in the past they have sold pies containing walnuts. He also mentioned that the pies contain nutmeg which technically isn't a nut, but he wanted to tell us anyway. We bought a caramel apple pie and a blueberry lemon hand pie during our visit. My husband loved the blueberry lemon hand pie, and everyone in the family loved the caramel apple pie :) Both are really delicious, with not one flavor being overpowering over the other; they both had a perfect balance of flavor. We will be coming back again to try out this location's other pies in the future! read more

See all

The pie fillings are great, love key lime, matcha, and carrot custards, but the bottom crust is too hard. The price is a bit high even though it's a family business and the quality is good. read more

Pie dreams has amazingly delicious pies. Love that the shop is finally open, but it is only on Friday-Sunday from 12pm-5pm. Nice intimate shop and the owners are always super nice and friendly, wife asked for stickers and we were given some. Ordered the chicken bacon and it was so good. Reminds of of chicken pot pie with bacon. Also ordered the French silk pie which is one of my favorites. read more

See all

Service was great. The owner was very apologetic. We came at 1pm and all the whole pies were gone. Please not they on at 12pm on Sundays until 5pm or until sold out. It looks like it will be a sell out early kind of day. We came in and there was one person ahead of us. Lucky goose too the last whole pie so plan ahead. They are only open Friday - Sunday and menu items posted on their insta [pie.dreams] with their rotating menu. They do not update throughout the day about available items tho and no do not have a phone number it seems just an email contact info or dm their insta. Slices range between $7 - $8 and the whole pies I saw were $38 - $42 give them a try if you are in Newark. They took over the spot that formerly was starbread in the large Safeway plaza! read more

Pie Dreams - Carrot pudding pie! - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

See all

My husband picked up a rhubarb and a crumble pie from here for a potluck and we thought they were just okay and a bit on the sweet side. But a few months later, a friend got a matcha custard pie for her birthday and it turns out this is the one to go here for! Loved the flaky butter crust and creamy matcha. I'd go back for this pie ... it seems like they have a rotating menu which can be great for trying new pies but a bummer if one that you end up liking is seasonal. Glad to have to found this local gem! read more

Absolutely the best pies I've ever tasted! The flasky homemade crust and the tasty fillings. It's a little far from me, but the drive and the $7 toll fees are totally worth it! Definitely going back soon! And stocking up on their Dark Cherry Hand Pie read more

Pie Dreams - Orange Dreamsicle Pie. The right tartness and creaminess - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

See all

I ordered an Apple pie and I was not disappointed! The crust was phenomenal. Service was excellent and the location was cozy...overall, a sweet experience! read more

Pie Dreams has finally opened up a store front in Newark, replacing the old Star Bread. I've tried many of their pies and they are all delicious and very tasty! You have to follow them on IG to know what pies they have available, and they only open on the weekends. I've had the following pies: Salted Caramel Apple Hennessy Pecan Pie Strawberry and Mango Pie French Silk Pie All have been hand made to perfection, and my all time favorite is the French Silk Pie. It's so, so delicious! Highly recommend giving Pie Dreams a try if you haven't yet. The service is great, the shop owners kids run the front, while Ricky watches over them. Digital payments only in the shop, no cash is accepted. read more

See all

My first time visiting yesterday after a friend has been raving for months about this place. I got a slice of the Guava Haupia. As a baker and a Hawaiian, I gotta say... I'm impressed! The haupia had the right texture and delicate flavor, the guava was subtle with floral notes to complement the warmth of the coconut fat. The crust is a perfect bake, buttery and flaky (see the photo). Pie Dreams, I wish you success! read more

Pie Dreams - Guava Haupia topped with toasted coconut - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

See all

Amazing tasting pies, but difficult to catch them open and even more difficult to catch the French silk pie. Really delicious pie. It looks like they're open weekends, but even then I've seen a few times where it was unavailable. The pies are good enough though to keep trying. read more

I have been meaning to try pie dreams for the longest time. But it's hard to go since the opening days are just limited in a week and I heard they sell out fast too. I got lucky that there were some left over pies on a Sunday and I got to reserve some pies through dm'ing the shop through there Instagram stories. I tried the key lime, raspberry chocolate and apple pie. All the fillings were so good! My favorite part is the crust, it reminded me of a buttery croissant. Hopefully I can try more of there pies in the future! read more

Pie Dreams - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

See all

My sister brought their strawberry mango pie for my birthday, and it was beyond delicious. The filling was chunky and the whipped cream was heavenly. The wiggly crust was a bit too thick for my taste but our whole family finished the whole thing in one sitting. This place is . read more

Pie Dreams - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

See all

The pies are great they all taste good I have tried the French silk my favorite their lemon key lime is also very good d and blueberry pie .

Great pies, hours are not customer friendly. They also keep changing their menu which I guess is good, yet so disappointing when you like a flavor and have to wait a year to get it again read more

Took a whole Key Lime to a family gathering which was met with high praise for the buttery crust and smooth filling. It was so rich that my aunt said a slice of 1 whipped cream dot width was enough. Plus a shout out to Ricky's 2 daughters for helping out at the shop! Entrepreneurs in the making for the future read more

My Pie Dream experiences are few and far between because it's so hard to get one! The Instagram ordering game is fierce, yo. And for good reason! Every time I have a slice after a long hiatus, I remember why it's SO WORTH the price, the competition on the website, the trip into Newark, etc... Most recently I had the strawberry matcha boba pie, which was so perfectly balanced. Usually for matcha products, it's too bitter, or the other flavors are overwhelming. Another challenge is that the boba can be overcooked and hard. But no honey, no, this boba was still unbelievably chewy, a feat which is beyond me, since even well-established boba spots have their off days. How do you bake a pie with boba whilst keeping its perfectly chewy consistency?! Pie Dreams has surely perfected the art of magic. Today my good friend brought over a savory pie (I think it was the carne asada). The crust was beyond flaky and buttery. And the filling was PACKED with big chunks of meat! No skimping on the meat here; it got girth. We are not at Marie Calendars. Last thing I'll say is that I don't know the owner, but I stalk I mean follow him on IG and he seems super humble, genuine, and hard-working. He will receive blessings tenfold because of the blessings he has bestowed upon us poor Bay Area foodies. Bless you, Mr. Pie Man. I'm super excited for the grand opening of the brick and mortar location! Hopefully these high-demand pies will be easier to get my chunky paws on. Definitely a worthy treat to bring to holiday parties, special events, and just because you want to to treat yoself. read more

After following Pie Dreams on social media for a long time, my husband was finally able to pick up a pie and it will unfortunately be the first and last time I try anything here. We had a whole pie of the blackberry peach which was decent, the filling was fresh and the crust had a good butter flavor. However the top crumble was still a bit gooey and the bottom crust was also a bit under cooked. I had a severe stomach ache after having a slice on two separate days. My husband's stomach was also upset. We may put it in the oven to bake more, but I don't think I'll be risking eating the rest of the pie. read more

I'm not a big pie person, but this guy knows how to make a fantastic pie! The lemon chess, French silk, and cup of cocoa (seasonal) are my favorites. Always greeted with a smile. Local treasure! read more

My fiance and I have bought several pies from Pie Dreams and they never disappoint. The quality is top notch and the flavors are unique and unlike what you can typically find in the Bay Area. Highly recommend coming here for any occasion! read more

This review is based on my first visit to the shop and my two selections. The small, clean shop is in a good location with lots of parking. The two kids (the owner's I presume) taking my order were delightful. An adult came out later (Mom?); she was very nice. The cherry hand pie was awesome - not too sweet, and an amazing crust! The fresh peach pie also was not too sweet. The crust was hard to cut through, but good. It's a little pricey, but I'll return to try other yummy flavors and because I love supporting new, family-run small businesses! read more

Best pies ever! My husband and I have been there a few times already! We had Blueberry Lemon and 3 Berries hand pies, slices of lemon cheese, caramel apple, key lime, all so delicious and not sweet at all! love their pie crust! Definitely filled our dessert cravings. Can't wait to try their french silk pie and other new pies. We had their savory pies as well, all good! Wish they open at 11 am so I can go get me some pies during my lunchbreak! Service is awesome! Definitely going back for more.... read more

Love love Love this place. I live on the peninsula side so I'm lucky I don't live in the east bay Newark side as I would probably be there weekly. As previously mentioned, I didn't like pies...but these pies are soooo good. The crust is unbelievable and the variety of the fillings are yummy. It's a cute store front on Jarvis on weekends only. The owner and his lovely family work the store and are very customer oriented. You do need to read the website to see what is on the menu or make sure they are not closed for an event. I made that mistake once....but as I mentioned, the pies are so yummy. They are accommodating for special orders. I have to watch my waistline so I need avoid showing up weekly...but it's so good. This is mt 3rd review...and they have not disappointed me. Highly recommended! read more

Excellent pies, excellent customer service. Excellent across the board. To all those 1 stars, clearly you don't know what it takes to build a business from the ground up. If you got off your high horse, you might realize that someone had the courage to follow their passion. Something most others DON'T do, probably including yourselves. read more

Loved that we came across this local business. Pies were great. Keep being amazing! Kudos.

It's always a TREAT to get pies here! Whether it be savory or sweet, you cannot go wrong with any one you choose. I think I've tried almost every pie that's offered here and they get better every single time! The service is great and the owner Ricky is such a handsome fellow. His pies excite me. ;) read more

Strawberry, Matcha (read: custard!) + Boba in pie form??? Sign me up or rather, let me make sure I order by that Wednesday at 8pm. I've only recently heard about pie dreams from a coworker and she so kindly let me try the s'mores pie. I love anything s'mores, so that might make me biased but it was tasty! This strawberry matcha pie, though...different level. Firstly, the pie looks cute. Secondly, I love the texture of the matcha custard. Lastly, the boba is soft!! Even after being in the fridge...amazing. I also love that this isn't so sweet. I'm so glad I was able to try this and bonus that he offers two sizes: 10" and 5". I'm so excited he'll be opening a store near my place! read more

Pie Dreams - Strawberry matcha pie! Yum! - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

Ricky and his sweet and savory pies are simply the best! The flavors of the pies, customer service where he remembers your name, just such a great experience! The regulars know to get there early before selections get sold out. Whenever I share these pies with friends and family, they've always been a hit. You can't go wrong with any of the pies, allergens are clearly labeled, and they're so delicious. The all butter crust is amazing and holds up great. Savory pie fillings are stuffed and tastes so good, and sweet pies are not too sweet. No fork needed, just pick them up with your hand and devour it. If I had to choose favorites it'll probably be the salted coffee chess, French silk, key lime, all of the savories, campfire , triple berry, blueberry lemon, American apple, I guess they're all my favorite! read more

See all

I must give credit where it's due. I love pie and I don't mind driving from Santa Clara when the pie is this good. I've been buying pie from Ricky for a long while now. I've had both sweet and savory and have never been disappointed. The 5 inch pies and hand pies are my favorite because it's just my husband and I. I purchase the larger ones when sharing with friends n family. Super flaky, high quality crust and fillings. Ricky is super nice and will answer any questions for you. Enjoy! read more

Pie Dreams - Mixed berry pie - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

Pies are fantastic! Can try a slice, a hand pie or whole to share with friends and family. Favorites are caramel apple, strawberry mango, and the sausage quiche. Support local business! read more

I am soooo excited right now! Hubby just picked up our DIY Apple Pie KIT from Pie Dreams! I cannot wait to make this delicious pie with my kids! The kit comes with all of the ingredients pre-measured not to mention the super cute wrapping! Along with the kit I have been emailed a YouTube video of Ricky teaching us how to make it! What I love most about this kit is that Ricky is not worried about losing business for sharing his secret recipe and instead is genuinely helping pie bring families together. I have ordered from Pie Dreams too many times to count. Tri tip chimichurri, cheeseburger, strawberry mango, pumpkin pie and his apple pie are all absolutely delicious. If I remember correctly, the savory pies come uncooked and packaged where you can freeze it (unless requested to have it baked) and the sweet pies come baked. My favorite thing about the pies are THE FLAKY CRUST and how flavorful they all are! COVID protocols are safe! You text when you arrive and he places it on the table for you if there is nobody else there at the same time. If someone else is there he has you wait in your car until everything is clear! Hand sanitizer is also readily available on the table as well. read more

Pie Dreams - a bowl of apples, lemons, and other ingredients - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

Amazing Pies! If you like pies, go buy a pie from Nation's or some other place. If you love pies, or just want a delicious treat, go to Pie Dreams. read more

I can't get enough of these pies! Tried the summer menu and Strawberry Mango was Delicious! I don't know how Ricky throws down these pies like he does. Well done! I can't wait for breakfast where I'll be eating fruit (pie) read more

See all

I LOVE Pie Dreams! This cute, family-run pie shop is my family's go-to for special event and holiday desserts. And sometimes I come here just to grab a slice. There is a rotating list of offerings, and the piesmith is always coming up with inventive, delicious new pies. I can't recommend this place enough. read more

Pie Dreams - Gorgeous Mother's Day pie. Lemon chess pie, one of my favorites. - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

This place is always so good. We have tried their delicious treats when they are sold at Devout Coffee. There's always a long line for these desserts. How can you resist a yummy sweet with a great cup of coffee? We've had the Pie Scream on Halloween. It was ice scream with some of their delicious pie in a cup. Our cousin picked up some of their mini pies (ube and strawberry matcha boba) at a December pop-up. The strawberry matcha boba was my favorite because it really tasted like a strawberry matcha latte boba drink. Looking forward to tasting more of their other pies. read more

Pie Dreams - Mini pies: ube and strawberry matcha boba - Desserts Near Me - Newark, California

A bit overrated. I had matcha pie and tasted very greasy. The first bite seemed rich but then definitely started to taste oily. Sweetness wise was controlled well, not too sweet. Won't gonna go back for another try. read more

Absolutely amazing!!! We came here unintentionally and it couldn't have been better. The strawberry mango and apricot recommended by the owner and son were amazing. read more