Went to Polly's for lunch today. Tried the Asian chicken salad. It was awful!. Unlike any I've ever had, and I love a good Asian Chicken Salad. This one had horseradish in the dressing! Big thick slices of red onion (not the usual green onions). Had unripe mangoes instead of mandarin oranges. Had thick round slices of carrots instead of julienne slices. Fat cucumber slices and weird chicken ( canned maybe and soaked in the dressing). No Chinese noodles of any kind. Got ranch dressing to put on top after waitress didn't offer to replace it with something else. Also very slow service and had to ask a waiter to find our waitress when she didn't check on us. So disappointed. We used to go to the Polly's on Beach and Roscrans. Sad that it closed. It had good food and good service! read more

This is a cozy and spacious place. We came on a Tuesday morning at around 10 AM and there's just a short wait time. Everything we ordered came in generous portions and tasted really good. The service was just slow and wait time for food seemed long. But it was worth the wait! It just seemed like they needed more staff. read more

See all

If I could leave zero stars, I would. we had a shockingly disappointing time today at Pollys for dinner. We waited about 45 minutes for our food and when it arrived to the table, it was stone cold. When we got there, the restaurant was not busy so we don't understand why it took forever to get our food. The tables were very dirty and no one cleaned them up from the time we got there to the time we left. When the manager(KIM) dropped off our food, I told her the food was cold, and she had a very nonchalant attitude about it. She said the only thing she could do was remake the food and have us wait another 45 minutes for it. I came with my sister-in-law who used to work there and she was very upset of how Pollys has gone downhill. I will definitely not be returning for dinner time at Pollys if this is the state of how the restaurant is. We decided to walk out bc of cold food and nasty manager's attitude, she really didn't care. We decided to go to Dennys instead and have a a wonderful and speedy dinner. read more

all servers are always giving the best service . tonight she was amazing . just had Thanksgiving dinner craving and went with the corn bread very noist and good. glass of tea .So I saved half to go . . then stuck around for slice of pie ! read more

Asked for a cheesecake to take home. Just gave the guy my card not really thinking to ask how much it cost first (my bad). Total was $22 and some change. This was probably the worst cheesecake I have ever had. The taste was ehhh but the texture it was made it gross. Polly's have never let me down before... I guess no cheesecake from Polly's ever again :( read more

Edit: so I returned after being given a gift card as an apology for the below experience. I have changed my rating because it does seem as though I did unfortunately miss out on some great food and some great service as well. Thankfully this time, Elizabeth was not present. I had a chicken fried steak and eggs, with a giant cinnamon roll and everything was fresh, hot, and delicious. I also took home some pie that looked amazing and I am excited to try. Glad I was able to give this place another chance! --------------------------------------------- Well, it would be wonderful to have been able to actually taste the food. Unfortunately the manager Elizabeth drove my party away before we even got our menus. Even though we were asked to be put on a waiting list and complied with the request, by the time we were sat Elizabeth rudely told us that there was a waiting list, and when we told her that we were on the list, she immediately started asking accusatory questions about it to her employees. Tjis horrible treatment caused us to decide it wasn't worth it and we promptly left. If this is who Polly's Pies chooses to run their establishment, I don't imagine I'll be returning in the future. What a shame. read more

Had a lovely breakfast this morning. Food is always good here. Hearty American breakfast staples. What made today special is the service of Giovanna. She was excellent and that's an understatement. Always had what we needed when we needed it. Cheerful. We'll be back soon. read more

I've never eaten inside before so this review is for take out pies only. I've taken out the strawberry pies and the branberry (banana and strawberry) pies. Branberry pies are $15.49 I believe. One time I bought 4 pies. I purchased them, had to use the restroom, and when I came back to pick them up, they were in a huge Polly Pie's tote bag. I was astonished by this kind of gesture. The awesome cashier (I tried to get her name but didn't have a name tag) she even packed napkins and forks. The service here is exceptional. And I love the homey atmosphere inside. This type of service shouldn't go unrecognized and it makes me want to keep coming back. I can't believe summer is already over, so the waiting for strawberry pies begins till next summer! Polly's Pies is my #1 stop for dessert! read more

I've been to other Polly's Pies and I have to say Fullerton does it right. This place can hold lots of people so really not having to wait in long lines to get a table. The inside feels like a farmy feel also with the smell of fresh baked pie the whole time. I love it! I came here on Mothers Day with my parents and we all had a very good time for our breakfast. The line was very short and we got a great booth to sit in. We ordered right away I had a cup of tea while my parents both enjoyed some famous coffee. The cup of tea had a lot of different tea bags that I could choose from. They were green tea, earl grey, chamomile and chai, spicy tea. For breakfast I had California styled egg's Benedict. I like how plain and simple the name is and also what is in it ! Just pretty much a few slices of hearty avocado, turkey and tomato on top of two poached eggs. It was soo delicious. I got my hollandaise sauce on the side. I do this just because sometimes when I go to places the sauce taste really bad so I give it a test run before I put it all on :) But overall I had a really great breakfast and I need to come here more often. For so many reasons such as: 1. You feel full when you leave. 2. The prices are very cheap, even cheaper than Dennys ! 3. I love the pies they have and they taste great. 4. Fast and quick service ! All the things I love about this place makes it well worth the drive to come and eat here! I love it and I hope you do too! ;) read more

See all

I've been coming here since 10 years ago, and they've always been such a good restaurant! Their staff is such a beautiful community! I couldn't ask for a better place to eat great food, and great service. read more

I think this is probably the best comfort food restaurant in this area. The prices are very low. I had the burger, but it was dry and not good, I was a sucker for that meal coupon... My GF had the chicken and dumplings, delicious Bread basket, full of hot tasty treats, cornbread, banana bread, rolls, pumpkin bread/ amazing!! This place is a deal/ get a comfort food item!! read more

Polly's Pies Fullerton. An interesting experience and despite the illustrious location (namely some terrible civil infrastructure) the business itself is a 5-star experience for me. Came here on a Sunday morning for some breakfast. Put my name down with the host and within 2 minutes they had a table for me. Sat down, within 5 minutes had drinks ordered, within 2 minutes had entrees ordered, within 15 minutes had food served. I ordered the cinnamon apple pancakes along with a side of sausage and medium eggs. While the medium eggs turned out to be a little more on the easy side, this is something easy to forgive as the kitchen was running very busy for a full Sunday dining room. Serving sizes are huge here, so it makes sense for the price point that you are paying for. There is WiFi here, but I found my T-Mobile 4G LTE to be faster, which is ironic, but hey, I don't come to Polly's Pies to study. All in all, decent experience. Couple words about the rest of the business: - Restrooms are private use only which is nice if you have paruresis (yes this is actually a thing, google it) - Outside shopping center is under construction as of May 2018 and has been for several months now as far as I know) - Generally roads in Fullerton suck, at least as of 2017 and 2018 as those are the two years I've lived in Fullerton so far. The civil engineering in Fullerton just sucks. - The neighborhood for this Polly's Pies is... Odd. The first Polly's I went to was in Yorba Linda, which is a super nice part of Orange County, so maybe I'm just spoiled here. read more

See all

Fullerton bad service and good seats, the one in Cerritos uncomfortable seats but Awesome service!! The choice is yours....

It was okay food portions definitely got smaller on my end they gave my husband twice the amount of hash browns as I got and I asked for them crispy I didn't know that meant burnt got two meals coffees and our total came out to $50 so that's what I paid cause our lovely waitress ignored us the entire time we had to ask someone else to get refills on coffee for 20 minutes it was 12 pm they weren't busy and had no wait the only time we saw our server was for initial order taking and dropping our food off read more

This Polly Pies is great! The food was amazing. Our server was very kind, patient and attentive. It's quite spacious and has a cute touch to the ambiance. We will most definitely be back! The manager Ethan is doing a fabulous job. read more

During the week they have the best breakfast specials. I always get the early riser. It brings everything and it's such a good price. I can't say anything about the pies. My husband loves them. read more

Service was bad and really slow. French fries are uncooked and not crunchy, really greasy. Not a single crunch was found in any of the fries. Muffin was also a little soggy but fine. Pies smelled fine but i've smelled better. read more

See all

Omg I bought a cheesecake and it's delicious! There peach pie is good but the cheesecake left us speechless. Curbside pickup for pies is a little on the waiting side takes a little too long. read more

Went day after thanksgiving.. they did not have any bread.... No bread, pancakes raw.. eggs bad... so sorry.. not coming back!

This is supposed to feed 4 people. so youre telling me THIS is supposed to feed 4 people? seriously?This whole meal is NOT worth $50! We will NOT back, this is unbelievable. The portion size is rediculous. Save your time & money!! Better off cooking yourself even if you can find this stuff at the market, BUT at this rate i would rather of went to the store instead of ordering this meal. Just look at the turkey, the plate isnt even full!! read more

Polly's Pies - Meal not worth $50 to feed FOUR people - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

Their pancakes omg so good! So fluffy and delicious! Their hash brown and eggs are normal but good! Apple pie was nothing super special but will keep coming back for those pancakes! read more

Horrible service been waiting half an hour for my breakfast and still not here This is the slowest restaurant I've been to Will never be back read more

Delicious pies. The pies are great value and loaded with flavor! We take the frozen pies home when we have guests and cook them. read more

I was very disappointed in how Polly's handled a situation yesterday. We are trying to support our local businesses and so we'd gotten a chocolate cream pie for Easter. We have ordered this pie many times before. When we were ready to serve it on Easter the pie was so runny you couldn't even cut into pieces. This is not how it ever was before. My husband went to return it yesterday because it wasn't edible. The person behind the counter was less than gracious and lacked customer service. Instead of apologizing and quickly offering to replace it. He focused on "if you cut it day later of course it's going to be runny." What planet Polly's does he come from??? I've never had this happen even days later. He was quite defensive and was a bad experience especially because we specifically wanted to support local which includes him and that's how we're treated. He needs customer service training and realize he finally did give us a replacement and he could have avoided all the negative feelings he engendered. Costco is the gold standard for customer service...it is only 1 mile beyond Polly's for us to drive. Why would I not go the extra mile and avoid such a bitter taste in my mouth???? Polly's give me one good reason!!! read more

Ashley was our server she is completely prejudice. Served all the old white people before us. There was my table another table and one other, people of color and Ashley completely ignoring us for 40 minutes! I've seen reviews about this place doing that. You are a waiter (as am I) get your shit together Ashley. You are a server. Do the damn job read more

I would rate this higher if it wasn't for the poor service. I swear to God, the waitresses here disappear for almost 15 minutes before you see them again. The Management really needs to get their sh*t together here. There is a reason why this place is empty at night. Update (12/23/19) - Holy crap this place has the worst service ever. The waitress took our order and I didn't come back to check drinks or anything. read more

Going off of the holiday orders... I have not eaten in the restaurant yet, but if the food and service is as good as I have experienced with Jeff and staff, I am sure that it will be exceptional! read more

Ate here often when I lived nearby and was very disappointed that the quality and service have really deteriorated. We stopped in for breakfast on a Sunday morning recently and waited 20 minutes to be seated. Looked to me like management is running understaffed and compensating for that by making us wait for 20 minutes when there was plenty of seating available. That seemed to hold true with the server, who was slow to get to us. Too many tables for her to keep up with. 1. Ordered over-medium eggs and we were served raw eggs (seriously). Sent back and asked for O/M and then received regular over easy eggs (not over medium). 2. Hash browns were undercooked and soaked in some kind of ghastly rancid grease making the potatoes inedible. 3. Chicken Fried Steak was good and is the only reason this is not a one star review. 4. Polly's bakers apparently baked the bran muffin a month before serving it to me. Awful. 5. Pancakes were raw and gooey inside. These people need lessons from the Polly's in Norco. read more

This is the original Pollys. What can I say? Theee best pumpkin pie ever. Crust is simple and flakey. Filling is solid and baked all the way. No runny pies here. The taste is just enough to keep you coming back for more. Nine if that whipped cream that gets hard after a day. Just add your own and have a great pie break. read more

This is the perfect go-to spot. It's not the fanciest, nor is it specialized. It's just the perfect kind of place when you don't want to cook or you can't decide where to go. Our server, Ashley, was awesome - attentive but not pushy; pleasant to chat with, but not too quiet or too talkative with a cheery disposition. The food is good, inexpensive, and cooked just the way you order it. We love coming here, are extra happy when Ashley is our server, and often bring our out of town friends when they visit. Give it a try and see for yourself! read more

Ordered though grubhub. The cheese burger and fries. It was awful. Tasteless Ordered from them to help there a few blocks aways. Will not order from them again. read more

I'm not even sure how to begin. This place has always been great, the customer service is great, the pies and the food is great today the manager on duty was so nice in helping me out with a pie issue I had. I can't be grateful enough to appreciate him and his service there at Polly's. The staff always friendly and helpful as well. Don't hesitate to come here, you'll love it read more

Polly's Pies - Apple pie and Banana Cream pie - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California

Good food. Great service. The server was training a new person & they were both so nice & pleasant. Customer service goes a long way for me and both of them were just amazing. Even helped me decide on my meal. Thank you so much for hiring kind & caring people read more

Waited too long to be seated. In fact, others were seated before me. Brought coffee without offering creamer, I asked a passing server. That's when I noticed the table was sticky and gritty. I moved to another table. Finally, my server arrived. Edgar was my server. Fabulous! Great service, good food, reasonable price. I probably won't come back because this was my second time here and I recall the first time was very similar experience. read more

Not a place I would recommend but my server was great. Just the management was horrible.

We had the Best server tonight Janett. She was helpful, very quick to bring more coffee, water and lemonade to our table. She has a great smile too. I wish all servers were as great as Janett. Thank you for making our meal so enjoyable! read more

Came and dined in with my niece Food were mediocre. Soup I ordered was butter squash but it was not good at all. I did not find any that was great. Worst was service. Couldn't find server and when I did it was hard to get attention from them. Wasn't even busy tho. Probably won't come back again. read more

The quality of the foods is always five star! I've been coming here for years. However, the service by some of the waiters is extremely poor. Also it appears that management is not staffing appropriately. The bathroom was dirty and there was no toilet paper. It's so sad to see a great local restaurant decline. It really doesn't havee to be like this. It all about attitude. read more

Hubby and I are familiar with Polly's Pies because of work. Which means that we see and hear about food allllll day, everyday, and even during our off-days, because that's our work. Trust me, it's not as awesome as it sounds. :( Anyways, at some point in time, we decided to start ordering stuff from Polly's Pies. Probably because of pies. I've noticed that while on diets, I tend to crave more sweets. Which is horribly stupid because of how many calories desserts have and, yet, it kind of makes sense because my body wants more calories on a diet. Booo.... Anyways, we've eaten here before, and we've done a lot of take out. Based on how the service has been, I'd rather do take out. I know people try and pull race card sometimes, but, man, I have no idea why the servers just ignore us. Is it the table? Is it cause we blend in with the walls? Ehh... so, yea, service hasn't been great when we're eating in. But, while their actual service isn't awesome, the actual servers have always been polite and professional. When we take our orders to go, it has been a bit "ehhhh" as well. Mainly because we still have to wait to pick up our order. Oh, and if you plan to pick up one of those Thanksgiving or Christmas banquet meals, please be aware that the food is cold, and you'll need to heat it up when you get home. In our situation, it wasn't ideal, but we got by. I wish there was some kind of fine print about it :( Food-wise, though, this is where Polly's shines a bit. We've had salads, sandwiches, dinner entrees, drinks, desserts, pastries. All of it has that wholesome feel that makes it very "Polly's". Like, you know it came from Polly's. The strawberry lemonade is a MUST have to get here, especially if you like strawberry lemonade. The salad, sandwiches and entrees are done very well where you feel very satisfied after eating it, and yet you don't feel gross. The desserts, well, their namesake shows their pride in that: pies are pretty good. Hubby really likes the custard and sunnylicious pies, while I tend to venture to anything. They also have this crazy pie shake where they will put an entire pie slice into your shake. Geezus... very tempted to try it, but it'll take up my entire count for a week. :x Haven't had their cinnamon rolls, but their biscuits are very good. Prices are okay. Reasonable, for the most part, based on the food. Based on the wait, meh. Parking is very easy, though the construction along the streets make it a little difficult to come here from the south end. So, overall, will be back, but only for certain things. read more

Just finished our Thanksgiving Dinner only to discover that the $30 special order boysenberry pie was plain apple. What's almost as bad is that the apple pie didn't taste any better then a u-bake one from the local grocery store. Don't waste your time or money. read more

Polly's Pies - My special order boysenberry pie. - Bakeries Near Me - Fullerton, California