I agree with some reviews where the wait and service can take a while. We've been here twice and the first time we came at an off time and got seated right away because we were told to seat ourselves. The second time, it was Monday when the oysters are $1.25 and we weren't acknowledged, so we decided to seat ourselves at an open table we saw just to be told to wait and that someone would be with us....we stood at the counter waiting for a good 5 minutes and no one came to us so we sat on the bench in the front for what felt like 15-20 minutes. Finally, someone came just as I was getting ready to pick another place for dinner. Based on that wait time to get seated, we were smart enough to put in everything we wanted to order for our meal since we knew it would take a while to get someone's attention again. I like coming to Shuckin' because of that oyster deal and everyone else might have the same idea which is why they were so busy. Minus the wait and mid service, what brings up the rating for me is their food. Everything I've gotten here is pretty good and I haven't gotten anything yet that I didn't like. read more

See all

Stopped in and had the BLT lunch special. It was great, one of the best! Will try other items on next visit

This place was really good. Went there for lunch and a drink and was impressed. Does not look like it is going to be very nice from the outside but the inside was a good vibe and much bigger than it looks. Food and drinks were really good too. Good place for a quick bite or to watch a game. read more

See all

Went for the first time and will definitely be back. Tasty food, friendly service and great vibes. Thanks to the staff for a fun evening.

I was disappointed with our experience. Although we had reservations it took a while before anyone tended to seat us. It took a long time for our food and once we received it, it was cold. The sauce was forgotten for our appetizer and the butter for our Shrimp! The food wasn't bad it just seemed like maybe they were understaffed. Staff were friendly when we could get their attention and the atmosphere was nice and welcoming. We did receive an appetizer gift card for the next visit for the inconvenience. read more

See all

For a much needed girls night out, my bestie and I stopped in at Shuckin' Shack in Naperville and boy were we in for a treat. The restaurant, though a bit small, it was festively decorated with the bar in the center of the space. We went on a Saturday night where they offered live music. Our night started with their $5 margaritas which though sweet, packed a punch..or my alcohol tolerance is extremely low, one or the other. My bestie let our waitress know this was my first experience with oysters. However, my first experience was years ago and it did not go well. This time it was the complete opposite! We started off with both char-grilled jalapeños / cheddar and garlic/parmesan oysters. Yum!!!! Though being very good, they layered the cheese on very thick. I very quickly transitioned to raw oysters and they did NOT disappoint! They write the special "flavors" of oysters on their announcements/daily special wall. My favorites were Sweet Jesus and the Great White....just delicious! We also tried their fried seafood platter which included fried calamari, fried shrimp and their cold crab dip. Absolutely delicious!! The one negative, this platter came out lukewarm to cold. However, we ate, better yet, I ate every bite! The service was top notch! My bestie and I had a wonderful experience and will definitely be back. I'm hoping for a sit right under their retractable windows in warmer weather! read more

See all

I need bar with plenty of televisions and that sells oysters and primarily focuses on that the oysters I had were very good there from Michigan and I could not be more impressed in this place with a better choice and auto alcohol and food items this may be the only Oyster Bar I ever go to and maybe the best in the area overall the service was very good and I was pleased with the items I had ordered this is a is a Hidden Gem in Naperville read more

This is a nice cozy restaurant if you're on the search for an oyster spot in Naperville. Along with oysters, the full menu features classic seafood entrees like shrimp and grits and po-boys as well non-seafood entrees like burgers and chicken tacos. There are also daily drink specials. I ordered the oyster daily special which was from the east coast (I don't remember the exact name) as well as the mahi tacos. The oysters were fresh, but I did wish they were a bit brinier. The mahi in my tacos were cooked well. Service was quick and efficient. I will definitely go back to try more! read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Oysters - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

First time customer. I had never tried Shrimp and Grits. Was very delicious I am looking forward to returning and try more of them menu items! read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Amazing Oysters, so fresh you can taste the brine and salt from the ocean! Bartender was so friendly and attentive I wish I remembered her name. Place makes you want to book a vacation to the ocean!! You feel like you're in a FL bar! Drinks were very delicious as well. I will definitely go back again especially for their happy hour! Check out their website for their happy hour specials you won't be disappointed! read more

If I could leave 10 stars I would. Atmosphere makes me believe I am somewhere other than boring Illinois. The seafood is fresh why we keep coming back! Not just the food....Shari the bartender is wonderful. As a former restaurant owner she would be an instant hire. She remembered our drinks, what we like to order and our names...I met her once. We were impressed! See you soon! read more

Had been looking for a true "Oyster Bar" - one with a variety on offer and no minimum quantities which prevent sampling. They had seven on offer, one sold out. High end was $4.25 each. Low end I think was $2.50. Monday night have $1.50 specials. We were there on a Wednesday which happened to be trivia night. Nice friendly vibe. Tried three oysters, got the fried calamari, the steamed mussels and the crab cake. The batter on the calamari and crab cakes were a little salty for our taste. Mussels were steamed with no sauce. But still good. We'll be back to try more. read more

First of all, if you order shrimp, it's like the baby garbage shrimp you get at the grocery store that's like $1 a bag. I got the fried seafood platter The baby shrimp like I mentioned above and like 6-7 small fried oysters with fries Cost $23!!!! Like the food is not even as good as long John silvers!!! Yeah 100% a no go for me. read more

They need another waitress only one that ran the bar and tables,not that there were a lot of people. To get the food took forever. They move to slow, we had mussels and clams they were good. The waitress was good. read more

The food and service was exceptional! The ambience and as perfect!! The oysters were so good and the shrimp and grits were the best I have ever had! read more

Parking plentiful. Seat yourself upon entry. Pleasant greeters. They explained the menu and the drinks were great. I went for oysters I was expecting charbroiled but I think they were grilled. Overall, pretty decent taste and flavor and very fresh as I went with the house oysters. The melting of cheese made the temperature more luke warm than hot. The clam chowder was okay more potatoes than clams and needed a pinch of salt otherwise good consistency. Scallops were on the bland side but they weren't over cooked which was great in my opinion. The ceviche had more fish than shrimp and could use a pinch of lime but good appetizer. Great bat options and great drinks as mentioned. Great staff. I believe I would go back again one day but I would love charbroiled butter and garlic oyster options. read more

See all

**Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar: A True Pearl of Naperville** Nestled in the heart of **downtown Naperville**, **Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar** is a must-visit for seafood lovers and anyone looking for a laid-back, welcoming atmosphere. With **plenty of free parking** right out front, getting there is a breeze, and from the moment you step inside, you're greeted by a **colorful, vibrant, and friendly space** with a fun nautical theme. The **chalkboard menu** is packed with **daily specials** alongside their **regular printed menu**, offering a great mix of options--from fresh seafood to creative cocktails. Speaking of cocktails, their selection is **fun, colorful, and unique**, perfect for pairing with their **fresh seafood** and **incredible oyster selection**--arguably the best in town. But if seafood isn't your thing, don't worry--they've got **burgers, chicken, and plenty of choices for land lovers** too. I started with **The Grega**, a **deliciously fresh and generous portion of cold lobster** served on a top-sliced roll with **butter and a house sauce** on the side that added just the right kick. It was the kind of sandwich that makes you slow down and savor every bite. On a return visit, I had the **double-decker crab sandwich**, which was just as indulgent as it sounds. Another day, I went for the **shrimp and oyster combo**, and let me tell you--it was **heaven on a plate**. I also tried their **fish and chips**, but instead of traditional fries, I opted for **potatoes and sausage**, and it was a game-changer. My colleague shared a few of their **chicken wings**, and I was blown away by the **crispy, panko-like texture**--absolutely fantastic. Beyond the food, the **island vibe** here makes you feel like you're on vacation. There are **regulars who feel like family**, and the **owner is often present, ensuring perfection in every detail**. The staff? **Friendly, attentive, helpful, and incredibly knowledgeable**--the kind of service that makes a place truly special. One of the best surprises was how much there is to **see and take in** while you're there. The walls are filled with **historical menus from Chicago and beyond**, plus **posters and signs that tell a story**. I spent at least **20 minutes just exploring**. Another fun touch? The **Polaroid wall of oyster lovers**--if you eat enough oysters, they take your picture and add it to the collection. One guest recently **ate over 100 oysters**! Everything I tried at Shuckin' Shack was **nothing short of perfection**--this is the kind of place you visit once and immediately start planning your next trip back. Whether you're a seafood fanatic or just looking for a welcoming spot with fantastic food and drinks, **Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar in Naperville is a must-visit!** read more

See all

I'm a neighborhood resident and have been supporting Shuckin' Shack since it opened. Unfortunately, I'm noticing they are starting to cut corners with their food. The last couple of times I've eaten there the food has come out suspiciously quick. Tonight I ordered a 1/2 pound of boiled shrimp with an order of fries. They were both just lukewarm and the shrimp was overcooked, which is what I've noticed before as if they were both precooked and dumped on my plate when ordered. I want to continue supporting them but it is becoming increasingly difficult to do so. read more

This 'take me away from winter in Illinois' location was recommended by a 'local', and the locals know a great find when they happen upon one! You honestly cannot beat the price of oysters on a half shell for $1.25 with their Monday special. It's not only a great value, it's a high quality product! We order a minimum of two on our bimonthly visits! The location is convenient because it's legit three block walk from downtown Naperville! I also like the location because it's our celebratory spot after an infusion visit! The bartender was also very accommodating with my portable oxygen tank! I top off MY OYSTERS with their 'Nutritious' and Extremely Tasty Bloody Mary and their Delicious, Palatable New England Clam Chowder with a dash of Tabasco! Their grilled chicken sandwich isn't too shabby either! Check it out for an appetizer, lunch, or dinner... Why not all three?!?!? Enjoy! read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

We've been in here twice. Each time the place Is almost empty. Today was early on a Tuesday so maybe it's me, but I hope it's not struggling because it's a great spot. The shrimp & grits were delicious. The hush puppies were maybe a little too crispy. My wife had the taco Tuesday special. ($3 tacos which are usually $15 for 2, and they are big tacos). There are plenty of choices for people who don't eat fish. The decor is eclectic beach and our nostalgia. Cute enough in a hokie way. But the bar looks pretty cool and there are lots of TVs, so probably great to watch a game. Their brunch menu looks good. I want to go back for that on a Saturday or Sunday. read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Shrimp 'n Grits Hushpuppies - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Shuckin' Shack is a solid place located in the Gartner strip mall (worst parking lot!). Drinks are solid with the bar and restaurant area not very large but well laid out. The beer menu is pretty average, and service has always been solid. Some of the better dishes are the Shrimp n' Grits and Louie Salad. A lot of fried options and decent appetizers on the menu. read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Shrimp 'n Grits - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

We ordered just about everything. It was all delicious. The oysters were so yummy and the shrimp and grits were unbelievably good. Such a great experience. The service was on point, informative and had great recommendations. Casual and and fun ambiance. read more

Went on a Saturday afternoon (1/2/26), it was quiet, not too busy, around 2:00pm. The server/bartender was very attentive and polite, explained anything on the menu we had questions about. We tried a few oysters, the crab ball appetizer, fish platter and hush puppies. All food was good quality, portions were a little small, but very good. We will definitely go back and try more of the food options, plus it's hard to find a local oyster place. read more

Nice atmosphere, cozy and a low key dockside vibe going on. We ordered the Saul T Steam pot. The shrimp and corn were really good & cooked perfectly but sad to say the steamed oysters were over cooked & the clams were a little gritty. We got the calamari and it was not really that great. The breading was the problem with these. The lobster roll sandwich was good. The hush puppies could have been cooked longer but the oil they were cooked in could've been changed. The raw oysters were really good and clean. The fried pickle spears were a really good appetizer. Our server Deanna was accommodating. We've had so much better at other places so unfortunately this wasn't worth it as the prices were really expensive for what you got. This was about $200 for 3 people. read more

See all

10/10 food and service. Bar vibes but with great food. Bonus for having books. Keep in mind the seafood plates to not come seasoned in a bag but are still amazing. Season yourself and they give you butter. Also one of the best micheladas I've ever had. They also have a hot sauce bar? Love it. And I'm so sorry to the bartender who kept catching me staring at her. She was just really pretty. read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

We found a great place because I had the taste for clam chowder! The calamari. shrimp and grits, seafood bowl(we did breaded shrimp and fish), and sides of hush puppies(my boyfriend liked them & he doesn't usually like them)& coleslaw were so yummy. They had a good live band. There was also a great Leukemia fundraiser! We donated and got a Hey cancer Shuck off shirt. Our waitress was great. read more

See all

My friends and I have come twice now for their trivia night (Tuesdays at 7&8 pm), which has been a lot of fun! The host is engaging, and if you win you do get gift cards to the restaurant (so you keep coming back!) Part of our trivia group was vegan/vegetarian, which is admittedly difficult at a seafood restaurant, but they did find the black bean burger and salad options on the menu, which were apparently ok. So far on trivia nights I have had the shrimp basket and the crab cake sandwich, both of which were pretty good. One friend really liked the fruit vodka crushes, especially the watermelon one that tasted like a Jolly Rancher. The service we received (different waitresses) on both trivia nights was good: attentive while realizing that we were also preoccupied, haha. Overall, we'll be back, particularly for trivia! read more

See all

We had the clam chowder and it was SO SALTY I could barely eat it. We have eaten there before and it was delicious. Have to find a new place to eat. read more

I thought about going to Ramsay's Kitchen for restaurant week but decided to come here instead. The menu looked great, reviews looked solid on Google and mediocre on Yelp. It's located in a strip mall, so parking was more than sufficient. You can easily find a spot and walk over. The restaurant itself is not small, about average. We got greeted upon walking in and they said we can sit anywhere. Our server was Robyn. It started out good but gets worse. So, it took her a little while to take our orders. It wasn't busy at all so I let that slide. We ordered half a dozen oysters and cold crab dip. Usually, appetizers don't take long to prepare and bring out. They weren't very complicated items yet it felt like an eternity. I'll go through the food ratings later on. We finish but Robyn doesn't take away our dirty plates. She completely forgot what we ordered for our entrees. She wrote everything down in the beginning. We ordered shrimp n' grits, greggah with clam chowder, and shrimp po boy with sausage and potatoes. She brings out shrimp n' grits and low country boil. At this point I was hangry and didn't feel like correcting her. For some reason she gave us one clean plate but didn't take away the previous dirty plates. I had to remind her about my po boy and she forgot about that. Eventually, she brings out the po boy with the sausage and potatoes. She asked if we needed any boxes and I said yes, just one. She doesn't come back. Then, we order the desserts. She asked if we needed any boxes and I said again we needed one. She brought out the boxes at last. It seemed like she forgets very easily except for taking the payment. Definitely one of the worst services I have ever encountered. It seemed like it came straight from an episode of Hell's Kitchen. You're just watching and thinking if people are really this bad in real life. Yes, they are terrible in real life. Overall, I would not recommend this place. You have a waitress that can't perform basic duties like taking away dirty plates, remembering orders on slow nights, and being very inattentive. -half dozen oysters 4 - oysters on the smaller side but juicy. -cold crab dip 3 - it could use more crab meat. It was decent with the roasted garlic bread. Dip was a little on the salty side. -low country boil 5 - shrimp was really fresh and meaty. Sausages and red potatoes were well seasoned. -shrimp n' grits - 3.5/5 - interesting spin on the classic but fried grit cakes were okay. Not memorable. Grilled shrimp was moist and meaty. That smoked sausage gravy was delicious and would pair well with the traditional mushy grits. -shrimp po boy with sausage and potatoes 4.5 - toasted French bread was warm, soft, and flavorful. Shrimp and signature sauce paired well with the bread. It was a very decent po boy. Portions were generous. It hit all of the high notes. -creme brulee cheesecake 5 - not as heavy as the chocolate cake. This one is lighter, moist inside, and more robust in terms of flavor. It's like a symphony of goodness on my tastebuds. -chocolate cake 4 - a bit rich, good use of whip cream and strawberry syrup. read more

See all

I've been here a few times. Shuckin Shack has now become my neighborhood Taco Tuesday place to go. Their tacos are amazing! I get the grilled mahi taco and the grilled tuna taco. They're generous in size and the fish is always fresh. I love the aïoli that they use on their tacos as well. You can order the tacos grilled, blackened or fried, Their hush puppies are good, too. Although the couple of times I've ordered them, they were fried a little too long as they were very dark in color. My husband loves their taco chips and salsa. Their chips are salty and thick, but they could use some more salsa on the plate as the ratio is way off. They give you a very small container of salsa, which is about an 1/8 cup. Get more salsa on that plate with those tasty chips! We come on Tuesdays especially for their nightly specials. Last night my husband and I had two tacos and a margarita each and spent $22. Yup, such a great deal! Tacos are $3 each à la cart and margaritas are $5 on Taco Tuesday. Don't miss that deal! read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Grilled Mahi Taco and Ahi Tuna Taco - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

The food was too salty. They has decent fast service. I don't know why their breading is so salty. I guess so you can buy beer? The breadcrumbs coating the fish n chips tasted like a hush puppy covering. Maybe it's a corn bread flour breading ? I was unimpressed with their food. I won't be going back. read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Po Po' Boy - Oyster - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Create a sauce or marinade. The flavor is not there seafood is dry and boring. Service is slow read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Seafood is very basic and bland. Seasoning is poured right on top. We got both - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

There was only one server working here on a wed evening . There were wine specials $5 per glass!!! oysters are $1,25 each and huge!!

What a gem in a strip mall !! Ok first off Mondays are 1.25 oyster days. So we had to try them. OMG. I live for going down to the gulf for seafood but these were so delicious !! We also had mussels. Also delish and hush puppies for appetizers. Onto the food. Lobster roll, this was all meat on a toasty bun. Nothing more to say other than yum. Two shrimp po' boys. Loved the option of grilled being given. Also exceptional. The staff was great the manager (or owner can't remember) came up to us and asked how we liked everything and told us about their ugly sweater party competition with the other restaurant. We will be attending and eating more delicious food !!! read more

Went back to give this place a second chance. Very glad we did! It was wonderful with great service read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Clam chowder - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

Raw oysters and clam chowder were fantastic. I didn't appreciate them charging me $10 because I used a credit card. Obviously, I subtracted that from the tip. Who carries around $250 in cash? Not me. read more

This place is Absolutely Amazing the waiters were very kind and funny. The food is amazing I had the oysters and some mussels and it was absolutely delicious. The decorations are very nice and cool there are a lot of cool pictures and decor. I would absolutely recommend this place it is a must try will come back read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois

See all

We have been coming here every few months since it opened, and over the last year it has declined so much. No matter whether we go for lunch or dinner on any given day, there seems to be one main server for the entire place. Tonight, there were actually 3 servers I believe, but one never left behind the bar (even though all 3 were making their own tables' drinks), another was waiting a handful of tables but would greet new guests at the door with a 'someone else will help you', and then the server who always seems to be there. They are 'family friendly' but have no high chairs or crayons for the kid menus. The wait between ordering food and receiving it was nearly an hour. Tonight we got a lobster roll (which tasted like dirty dish water), ahi tuna app, a grouper basket, a side salad and an order of wings. None of these should have taken long, but 45min in I asked the server to go ahead and bring out whatever is ready when ready because I have 3 hungry kiddos, and was met with the rudest defensive blaming a table of 8 for holding up the 2 cooks in the kitchen. When I suggested the people who sat at the bar after we had ordered already had and had eaten most of their food, she stormed back to the kitchen and then slammed the food ticket down on our table telling me to look at the time stamp of when it went in as proof. When the food did start coming out, everything but the ahi tuna arrived, that showed up 5min later. The server 'graciously' took that off due to the wait, which also happened to be the cheapest item we ordered past the salad. The over-fried 5 wings that cost $19 were absolutely not worth it. We used to love coming here and would suggest it to anyone that listened, but I think we're done after the experience tonight. read more

Pretty good food. Clean and nice for the price. Shrimp are a little small but there's a lot of them. Service was a touch slow feeling at times but not bad. read more

Decided to try this place with the help of some coupons off Facebook. I didn't even know it existed, but super glad we came! I ordered the Shrimp Po' Boy and had the potatoes and sausage as a side. The sandwich was huge and very tasty. Could've definitely split it, but ended up finishing the sandwich and taking the side as leftovers. My friend had the Hermit sandwich and also really liked it. She also had leftovers. Absolutely recommend this place; it's fun and kind of tucked away, and the dishes had a lot of flavor. It's unusual to find a seafood spot in this area with so many different items on the menu. read more

Shuckin' Shack Oyster Bar - Shrimp Po' Po' Boy with sausage and potato side - Seafood Near Me - Naperville, Illinois