First time visit Friendly greeting Big parking lot Outdoor dining is available Trying Pork Flatiron with a Diet Coke with lemon read more

The Spy - New American Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

From being greeted with a smile, to the Tofu Wings, Beet Salad and Mushroom Toscanini....it was all delicious with excellent service! Sitting on the porch on a lovely spring evening set the stage for a fun nite!!! Next time I'll have to try that Vile Drink I heard about read more

Their burger is a joke. For $18, the price of the (beef) burger I got a plate with all the regular fries, bun, etc. But the burger itself is two small (half) sized beef patties, one on top of another. White Castle size. First of all, why not make ONE regular size burger, and for $18, don't cheap out on the amount of meat. It tasted ok. But not worth the price. Next time I want a burger I'll go to the local diner. read more

Saturday night in the Hudson Valley. The Mrs and I have no reservations and decide to get in the car and go somewhere. Driving up 209 she says what about High Falls? Sure says I and we agree to call "Spy" to see if they can squeeze us in A lovely voice at the restaurant says I have one table and will hold it for you Things only got better The voice belonged to the owner and Bridgett unleashed her husbands super competence over fried long stem artichokes salmon and pastas all of which were delicious If you ever need a warm welcome and super dope food Spy is it! read more

Amazing time spent here. Our server Taylor was so attentive and so sweet. A really relaxing & excellent time. Taylor really added to our experience, would love to come back again! read more

The Spy - New American Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

the food - we had artichoke & eggplant ball appetizers, duck confit and mushroom pasta entrees - was incredible. The service impeccable. We'll be back. read more

Went here and sat at the bar after a long day of climbing. It is a nice atmosphere, the service was wonderful, and the short ribs were some of the best I've ever had. Also they got the potato to short rib ratio right... read more

The Spy - short ribs - New American Near Me - High Falls, New York

Stopped in for dinner Saturday night while spending a weekend in the Hudson Valley. I made a reservation via email a week prior but we changed our seats to the bar when we arrived since there was space and we wanted a more casual vibe. The bartender working Saturday night was very friendly and chatted with us throughout our meal. To start, we shared the burrata special which came with 4 pieces of toasted bread. For our mains, I had the pumpkin ravioli special and my boyfriend tried the meatloaf. Both dishes were generous portions and very good. We finished off the meal with the cheesecake. We also each ordered the mule off the cocktail menu which they made with ginger ale vs. ginger beer which gave it a nice taste. Was a very enjoyable meal and glad we stopped by while visiting the neighborhood read more

See all

We were questioning our choice when we pulled in, however, we trusted the reviews. When you walk in you begin to feel the unique experience that this place holds. Food was outstanding and we had a great time. Staff super friendly and attentive. read more

Made a last minute reservation Thursday for their dinner. It was pouring out there, but they have an screened-in porch area that we can sit. We were there for their duck breast, but they were out; they have a double duck confit for the night in place of the duck breast. So we got the duck confit, strip steak, and braised short rib for the 4 of us. Honestly, their food was mediocre at best; the steak was not seasoned well, the duck confit was a bit too salty, and the braised short ribs were kind of tough. They are missing half of the items in their dessert menu also. So food was worth 3 stars. The extra star is for their accommodation. It was pouring rain outside, rain was splashing in through the screen. The owner / manager lady was really helpful when we expressed our concern. Made multiple suggestions to help, even offering to move us to another section, thankful for that. Their pre-caution with patrons is superb. No guests can come in without masks, and they can only take masks off when seated. Hope we will be back in the area in the fall to try something new in their menu. read more

See all

I was at the Spy last night to meet some friends who were in from out of town. The bartender was super friendly and his service was too notch. He admitted only being a bartender for 4 months but you could not tell. I ordered a Martini a very specific way and he nailed it! My whole experience at the bar was fantastic. Here is where it goes bad ... I went over to a table where my friends were sitting. They invited me to join them and I immediately exchanged pleasantries with the people at the table. In the middle of me complimenting the ladies at the table I was rudely told to be quiet by the waitress so she could get through explaining g the desert menu. When I said excuse me, she again told me to shhh and explained to me that she was very busy. After complaining to the very nice bartender about my terrible experience at the table, he told me the waitress was the owner. I guess my experience at her restaurant wasn't as important as her desert menu. read more

One of the best meals I've had recently. I had the mushroom toscani pasta; tofu "wings" which were crispy & flavorful and the apple crumble. We sat outside in the covered/screened porch which was lovely. Staff was attentive & helpful. Easily 5* read more

We stayed at a local Airbnb and this place was recommended by our host. This is an adorable local spot with outdoor and covered porch seating. We sat on the covered porch, able to enjoy the breeze without any bugs bothering us. We had drinks and appetizers (mussels, beet salad and the fried artichokes). Everything was delicious, the service was great and the decor very warm and welcoming. Definitely recommend this place! (Also plenty of open air in the parking lot to enjoy a fattie before or after your meal!) read more

We had stopped going to this restaurant when it was called THE NORTHERN SPY. The food was fine, but there were tree places to eat in the town. But after they reopened as THE SPY, and with a new menu, I'm happy to say it's now one of my favorite go-to places in High Falls! The service is alway professional. The prices are reasonable. Who could ask for more? read more

Got takeout and was delicious. Super cute ambiance when we picked it up - will definitely return!

One of the best meals my parents and I have had in a long while. I was hesitant based on the stars, but the ingredients in their dishes looked stellar, so we decided to make a reservation. We were so happy with the meal we made reservations for dinner again later this week. We had the bruschetta appetizer, which had hens of the woods, ricotta, andcarmelized onions, and it was superb. My parents had the duck confit and I had the mussels, and both were stellar (I was tempted to ask for a soup spoon, the mussels broth was so good). The staff are so lovely, and I could not recommend this restaurant more. If I ever hear people mention coming to this area, it will be my go-to recommendation! read more

The Spy - Bruschetta special - New American Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

This is by far the greatest restaurant in our area. When ever friends or family come up to visit I make sure we take them to the spy. It feels like a home away from home. The chef and owner duo are a power team of talent and hospitality. I can't rave about this restaurant enough. Each time I go there is a new fresh, seasonal and creative special from ramp ravioli to a meal served with a side of cookies. High falls would not be what it is without them. I actually feel giddy and excited every time I know I am going to get to eat at The Spy Social Eatery. Do yourself a favor and head there as fast as you can, they book up really fast during the warm seasons. read more

I have limited selection of foods here. what I do order is all ways quite good the cauliflower pizza is a tasty delight of creamy mushroom and peas. read more

Delicious fare, friendly service, good wines, lovely atmosphere, a local treasure. I've had the duck more than once, yum yum! And my husband's birthday dessert was recommended-- fresh churned vanilla ice cream, topped with strawberries picked that day, and drizzled with balsamic vinegar. Who knew? So fabulous! Served by singing staff persons too, perfect. read more

Food is very good. The service and ambiance are excellent. Like the calamari appetizer and pork flat iron.

Food was exquisite. Duck confit was perfectly executed and roasted vegetable sides nicely caramelized. Mushroom pasta was savory with lots of mushrooms. Drinks were well executed and the vibe works for a celebration, date night, or just a nice family meal. read more

Everything here is great!!! I highly recommend their short rib dish which is cooked to perfection and soooo tasty! The service is also wonderful, the servers make you feel welcomed and the owner is an absolute sweetheart! The ambiance is also really cute! I have come here a few times with different friends and I must say every time I come here it has been an amazing experience! Love this place! read more

Great food! The owners really care about their community! Try the buffalo tofu wing or the shrimp and mussels linguini. They are my favorites. read more

3.5 stars The service here was a bit slow, the prices are what I'd see in Manhattan, and the food is good. Good for kids as they has a kids menu. My party of 11 arrived for dinner on Saturday night. The lighting was dim and intimate, the menu is a mix of American, Italian, Mexican and Asian which is fun. _ SESAME TOFU WINGS ($10) I recommend this for its uniqueness, FLAVOR, CRUNCH, and portion. _ FRIED CHICKEN ($22) Enjoyed its boneless-ness and thin-ness of cutlet. Good portion of chicken (big enough for 2 people to share) although I'd prefer a higher collard greens to smashed potato ratio. _ SPY BURGER ($14) Pretty good. _ KAHLUA CAPPUCINO ICE CREAM Kahlua syrup was a bit too sweet but the = Coffee ice cream was nice! _ GINGER SPICE BUNDT CAKE w/ORANGE GLAZE ($8) I'd prefer less or no icing. Otherwise it was = tasty Would return, especially for the Tofu Wings. read more

The Spy - Spy menu: Specials - New American Near Me - High Falls, New York

See all

Cozy and welcoming spot with delicious menu options! My husband and I were staying at an Airbnb nearby and visited The Spy twice for dinner. Servers were very friendly and attentive. The decor is very inviting, I would say "cottage chíc." The bread before dinner was warm and fresh and their roasted chicken in particular was incredible!! Sadly we were too full for dessert both nights, but if we are ever back in the area, we'll certainly be back for some!!! read more

The Spy - Roasted chicken with mashed potatoes and green beans - New American Near Me - High Falls, New York

The entire dinner was perfect. Nice waitresses. Comfortable and stylish decor. Food absolutely outstanding. A gem.

Wonderful dining experience! What a great find! Beautiful atmosphere. Looks so unassuming. Inside we found a menu that would hold its own against any you would find at the hottest restaurant in the West Village. Food was delicious. Great drink menu. An accommodating and highly professional staff (in the middle of COVID, no less). Simply put, we loved this place and will definitely be back when future travels bring us this way. A great place to spend a special occasion (as it was one for us). We are picky, and really loved this place (enough to write a Yelp review). read more

I really enjoyed the menu choices and the food was very good. The wait staff was extremely attentive, professional and nice. I would definitely go back especially as it gets warmer and enjoy the outside seating. read more

Super delicious fresh bread, chicken pot pie, and pretzel. Pleasant atmosphere and kind wait staff! Highly recommend.

This is one of my favorite neighborhood spots. It truly is a social eatery! It's been so fun to become a regular and recognize everyone working there. Food is solid. Greatest free range tofu wings around, the flatbread special is always amazing, and you can't go wrong with the pastas! Ambiance is wonderful. It makes for a perfect date spot. Inside is beautiful and the screened porch and outdoor seating are lovely and breezy as well (and feel very Covid safe). Brigitte is so warm and welcoming, and I HIGHLY recommend ordering wine if only so you get to talk to her about all the options! She is both knowledgeable and fun to talk to. Book ahead on weekend nights to guarantee you get a table! read more

We had the best dinner in years here. All 4 of us loved our dishes. The food is Manhattan quality without the hassle and the prices. Can't wait to go back. I don't give out 5 stars lightly. read more

The bar menu has classics as well as some unusual liquor selections. The food and service are excellent. The menu is tightly put together and well-thought out. The restaurant is cozy and has outdoor and screened-in porch dining options. read more

Terrible service. Not child or family friendly. Horrible attitude towards our little girl. Bridget the owner is very rood and nasty, with an obnoxious attitude. We left without even finishing the food. Never again will we visit this trashy establishment. Alex G. read more

My husband and I have been coming to The Spy for many years and we have never been disappointed with our meals or the quality of wines that we chose to go with them. The slow cooked pork roast with a bottle of nice Cote du Rhone is always a delicious choice. We love eating on the porch at The Spy. Feels like home and is very cozy. read more

Romantic setting, great food, impeccable service, really nice family owners. Perfect place for a date night.

What an amazing meal!! Buffalo Tofu appetizer, followed by the Turkey Kale Pink Peppercorn Burger - WOW!!! They have a great screened in outdoor porch as well as tables inside. They work with local farms and the service was fantastic!! Well worth the visit!! We will be back. read more

The Spy - New American Near Me - High Falls, New York

The Spy was fabulous! We called ahead to make sure they were serving outdoors during Covid and we were able to bring our small dog and sit in the garden, with plenty of space. The food was delicious-- all ingredients were very fresh and the specials menu was extensive! Brigitte was incredibly welcoming and warm. read more

If you're in High Falls, don't miss The Spy! The food was incredible from start (hot fresh bread and herb butter) to finish (excellent warm cookies). I had the roast chicken blue plate special, which was perfectly seasoned and incredibly tender. We appreciated the extensive list of wines and ciders. We sat outside on the patio, which was a beautiful space. Service was attentive -- our food came quickly and we always had a full water carafe. The restaurant is simultaneously cozy and elegant, which is embodied in Brigitte: she makes the whole place feel like home! read more

Ok, so here's the thing: my girlfriend and I went to the Catskills thinking we would have a lovely time eating and drinking at fine establishments. We were batting 1.000 until The Spy. First, the tofu wings: the wing sauce was a tepid barbecue, the dipping sauce was some form of sour cream abomination. Neither tasted good. The "asparagus" ravioli of the day: To our knowledge, there was no asparagus anywhere to be found. The raviolis were cooked very well, and that is the most this dish had going for it. Tossed in a "sauce" comprised exclusively of unseasoned canned diced tomatoes, this dish was ironically the most palatable of their offerings. Lastly, the "toasted corn" risotto: If you ever wanted to have an entire can of sweet creamed corn, much like that dispensed by every lunch lady in America, and mixed with a few scoops of arborio, then this is your dish. Except in this case, it cost $23 and could not be finished, due to the cloying sweetness of the omnipresent corn and an overall mush-like quality better reserved for our canine and feline friends. PS, I am nearly positive that the extra parmesan cheese we requested arrived compliments of the green Kraft tube ubiquitous to any Giant Eagle this side of the Mississippi. read more

Such great ambience, food was so delicious, drinks were yum (loved the Northern Spy), and most of all, the staff was so kind, accommodating, and attentive. Had such a wonderful experience here, cannot wait to come back! read more