Gluten free pizza is awesome. My girlfriend has a gluten allergy and we were in the area and stumbled upon probably the best gluten free crust we've ever had. We ordered a gluten free margarita and a gluten free veggie pizza with mushrooms, broccoli and spinach. Not only that was the food great, but Casper was so accommodating. To work with a soy allergy he minced his own garlic and sauted the vegetables in olive oil. He and his staff also cleaned a brand new surface for the GF crust. We'll try to make the trip to Brooklyn from Manhattan again since the food was super good and was just an all around great experience. Thank you again! read more

I'm just trying to figure out how I've lived in bay ridge my entire life and yesterday was the first time I tried them. Amazing slice.

The gf pizza I've been looking for (Bklyn -of course). Had an excellent Hawaiian pie & penne vodka with shrimp. Red bridge available. Bklyn pizzeria atmosphere, Italian food, and, I left with money in my pocket. Andate, mangiate, Buon appetito ! read more

Bay Ridge Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Would give 5 star bc I luv their food but when you eat in they have the news blasting. Every time I am there with my little one, they are covering a murder/sexual assault, etc. Please consider having something tamer on or have no volume. Thanks. read more

Burnt pizza and delivery was wrong. Plenty of other pizza places to choose from in Bay Ridge.

Some of the employees aren't nice. A lot of yelling going on there between employees.

Used to be my family's go to pizza spot when I lived in Bay Ridge, and now that I visit every 2 weeks or so, I return for lunch. All remains as it was. Fantastic sicillian pizza, most highly recommended. The Grandma and Margarita pizza very good, just a shade beneath the square (IMO, your results may vary). Stop in for a sqaure, a slice, or anything on the menu. Great place! read more

If average had a child with a middle aged-Italian restaurant and said child was a cheese pizza, that was what went into my body. Does it technically fill the void of cheap pizza? Yes. Is it something I will go out of my way to try, no. I will say it was pretty cheap and the other foods looked okay, but what put me over the edge was that I saw one of the cooks taking hot dogs and putting them into the crusts of other pizzas that were being made. I am not sure if I gained more respect for the restaurant or lost all of it, leaning to the later. read more

I ordered a personal pizza couple nights ago. Came on time, but the delivery guy basically assaulted me. He rang my door so I went and was buzzing him in but he wasn't coming up, so I ran and got my coat and ran downstairs to get the pizza at the apartment door. As soon as I open the door the first thing he says to me is "are you on fucking drugs?" Uh what? I'm a clean well dressed guy I like to think, I was even still in my suit from work. He continued to stand there with his hand over the pizza box flap, and wouldn't give me my pizza. He just stood there refusing to give me my pizza while arguing with me about not letting him in. He was waiting for me for all of 2 minutes. Finally he releases his hostage; my pizza, and walks to his car while still yelling and arguing with me before he eventually left. Absolutely hands down, the worst experience I have ever had with a delivery place. I was ordering from here sometimes up to 2 times a week, but I won't be giving them my business again. I recommend you do the same unless you like having a delivery guy assault you and hold your food hostage. read more

Gasper made my experience there great, pizza pie half pepperoni was extremely delicious thank you

The Best Pizzeria in Bay Ridge Brooklyn. The F'in best. Just the F'in best you can get. If you order from anywhere else you have no clue. This Pizza place always makes your food, whether, pizza, lasagna or, lentil soup it's fresh, and awesome. read more

They wanted me to meet them at the front gate (I live on a military base) because finding my house would be a "hassle" (it really isn't)... Not exactly a great excuse. I was willing to let that slide if the food was good. My eggplant parm sandwich (as well as the bread that came with my husband's pasta dish) tasted like how dirty, musty towels smell. Absolutely disgusting. I've never had food so bad I couldn't finish it before. I don't know if they used a dirty towel to wipe off the counter and that stink transferred to my bread or what, or perhaps a dirty towel was draped over the bread, but ew. I don't usually write bad reviews about food, but this was so gross I figured people should be warned. read more

Absolutely love this place!! I've been coming here for over 20yrs and Casper never dissapoints!!!

I hear a lot of people say that this is the "best pizza in Brooklyn." I don't know, it's impossible to judge that, given the different types of pizza that we can enjoy these days (wood oven, gourmet, etc.). I'd say that Bay Ridge Pizzeria is solid "Brooklyn" pizza: thin, easy to fold and nearly flavorless. It's easy to eat large quantities of it quickly. Bay Ridge Pizzeria is our go-to in a pinch or for a party. If only the staff didn't make me feel like they'd prefer that I just leave. read more

Best gluten free pizza hands down. Closest you will get to an authentic slice. Great sauce. Great service. read more

Bay Ridge Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It with said pleasure to say for this crisis in society were everybody knew are names is not open.. It sad when a dear friend who has big heart has say good bye... Hoping the heart of Bay Ridge will open again so we all can get a a slice of pizza. My husband and I stop there on 4/11 and no one was home. Lights were out. You had see my husband face.. He childhood was gone and no where to go... Please open again.. we sure miss your faces.. read more

Whoa, last week they made me a Grandma pie with a gluten-free crust! What an awesome combination of old school Brooklyn style with fussy Park Slopeian food neurosis! Yum! read more

Order was completed totally wrong- My wife got extremely ill because order of chicken wrap has dressing on it even though we told them three times we did not want dressing- read more

Very best gluten free pizza I've had from Brooklyn. Went through soooooo much awful pizza to find them. Everyone's so kind in this place too. There was a point in time when I was on a pizza kick and going there a lot. During this time I requested extra sauce just one time and the next time I went there i was in a rush and forgot to request it. Went home and it was already on my pizza without asking for it. Great spot, highly recommend read more

Listen guys and gals in Bayridge, if you want late night pizza in the area call these guys ! They are great . Here is a few of the menu highlights: Chicken roll Vodka slice Vodka ravioli slice Grandma slice Regular slice Etc etc etc Plus delivery is fast and , this might sound dumb , but I always ask the to call , not to ring my bell ......... never had a problem ! Give them an order you will not regret ! read more

I used to order vodka pies from here all the time. Recently though, they've been arriving with most of the cheese off the pie and on the box. The delivery man blamed my husband for not holding the pie correctly when in fact the pie arrived like that. Because of the nasty delivery man, we've taken our business to ninos and will not be ordering from bay ridge pizza ever again. read more

Bay Ridge Pizza - My most recent pizza... This is not the first time - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I really like this pizza restaurant; however the grandpa pie we purchased this Saturday was undercooked. Upon further inspection, I removed some sauce, and noticed the dough was gummy. If I ordered this again, I would request the pie be well done. read more

Purchase pizza and drinks for family. My kid does not feel well after eating. After checking, we realize the restaurant is giving expired drinks. It's almost 2022, and the restaurant is still serving drinks from 2018. Terrible restaurant!!! read more

These guys are always kind, always smiling amidst a sea of orders. They have hardly ever messed mine up and the one time they did they were swift and sweet about fixing it! The food is awesome and their attitude makes it even better! They make it feel like family there! read more

I came here with the bf since it's right around the corner from him. We ordered a white slice for the each of us and shared some calamari. We were starved so we ate while we ordered some other food for dinner. The white slice was pretty good, crisped from the oven but I added some garlic powder since it was lacking flavor. The calamari was okay; heavy and greasy. We order a bunch of pastas to go. The folks were really nice and accommodated us. The chicken Marsala was my favorite. The other choices had lots of cheese on it. I wasn't complaining but that's all I remember of the dishes. read more

I used Bay Ridge Pizzeria to cater an event. I ordered calamari, chicken parm, sausage and peppers, penne a la vodka, and something else but I forgot. The food was delicious!! The calamari was really big so a few people almost choked on them but they survived. The order came with a handful of Italian bread which was sooooo good. The ordering process was easy and pleasant. They delivered the food on time and it was nice and hot. Plus the food was afforable. I would recommend without a doubt. read more

Every time I'm in Brooklyn (once a year) I can't wait to have Bay Ridge pizza. The Evangelical Free Church of America has a youth event every year in Brooklyn, and we make sure to order about 50 pizzas. They go fast. The locals tell me that It's the best pizza in Brooklyn. I'm inclined to believe them. This is classic NY style pizza, and it comes in huge slices just as it should. The flavor can't be described here; you just have to taste it. I can't comment on their facility since we order out, but with pizza like this they could sell it out of a subway public bathroom and I'd probably eat it... yeah, I would. When in NY make sure you go to Bay Ridge Pizzeria read more

BRP gets a very high recommendation from me,. I like that they are consistent; stable; they never drop the ball. They're actually is my #2 go-to pizza place in Bay Ridge--which is saying a lot. It means that I sample their wares almost as much as my #1 (I like to alternate). Actually I don't even have a #3. The only other pizza joint I frequent (Rocco's) provides me pasta and specialty rolls. So, let me re-state: only this place and Pizza Wagon (to me) are acceptable regular pizza places to order from ...in all of Bay Ridge. True statement. And I've tried them all. It really is one of the very few local parlors 'in the Ridge' which have unique-tasting pizza. They do a great job: large, floppy, 'New York slice' style slices. The epitome of that format. Huge amounts of cheese. Its just a little on the doughy side, if you can handle that then you will choose this place regularly for take-out. The place is clean (though filled with that old-school formica booth you see all over Brooklyn) and the guys behind the counter are cheerful and dedicated. Look: when you want an enormous and thick stomach-bulging pie delivered to your door...BRP must be in your top 5 options. Its as simple as that. read more

Oh god no. The mozz sticks were the worst thing I've ever tasted out of a fryer and I fried some weird stuff in college. I don't think the oil in the fryer has been changed this year. Tasted like room temp string cheese was rolled around in burnt oil and bread crumbs. The chicken parm was solid. I won't be returning here ever again but if you are forced here know that the chicken parm is okay and won't leave you in a bad mood. I'm deeply saddened by my mozz stick experience. When I make the choice to eat "unhealthy," as some overachievers call it, I expect great flavor and joy to come with my "poor" decision. read more

I go here often enough that it is about time that I say that it is my favorite pizza in Bay Ridge. That said, please note that I have only been to 5 or 6 other places so better pizza possibly exists in Bay Ridge, but I have my doubts. (I have been very unimpressed with the other places I have visited). I always order a large pie with extra cheese. It is always cheesy and delicious. The crust is chewy, and the tomato sauce has a good tomato presence, sweet with a slight saltiness to it (though that might be all the cheese. They are not skimpy with their cheese on the extra cheese pizza). I would give it 5 stars, but I have tried nothing else on the menu. I want to, but I can't break away from the pizza. So the failing is more on me than on them. Bay Ridge Pizza might be worth 5 stars. I want to add that they have many gluten free options. Many. I have not tried them because I have no problem with gluten, but my mother does, and I know where I am taking her if she ever visits. I am impressed with the number of their gluten-free offerings. read more

It's actually crazy that the neighboring pizzerias are still in business... the quality of the slice is some seriously authentic NY goodness. Pair that with the service and feel of a 40 year run family business, fantastic! read more

For my money, best pizza in bay ridge and the extras are pretty darn good too. Would recommend to anyone in bay ridge.

BEST rice ball parm EVERRRRRRRRRRRR!!! It's HUUUUUGE!!! My son and I shared one the first time we had it. When the waitress placed mine in front of me, I asked her for a second plate for my son's.....as she turned to get his. OMG sooooooo good!!!! AND...freaking delicious Sicilian pizza! we hit them for take-out for our schlep back to MA. So bummed they won't deliver here :( NICE people, too! read more

A bay ridge classic. Great pies. I've never had anything bad from here and everything always arrives correct and on time. Their pizzas also last A long time in the fridge - not the type of pizza that goes stale the next day read more

So we rolled the dice and wanted to try a new pizzeria. Delivery came an hour after ordering, which is somewhat about average. The food appeared good, but when it came to eatting it, not quiet as expected. Not to beat around the bush but ill be honest, the stuffed mushrooms tasted like pure garlic, the spinach roll was doughy, could of been cooked longer, wings we OK, and the chicken marsala was also ok... don't think will be ordering from here again. read more

See all

I live in Seattle and decided to have a card party with some friends. I decided to have some authentic NY pizza delivered to my home for the party. My sister-in-law lives in Brooklyn so I asked her for a recommendation and she put it out on Facebook. Many votes for Bay Ridge Pizza, so I went with them. When I called I spoke with Gasper who was totally awesome. He said they could ship, and even helped me pick out the best pies for delivery. Then he checked in with me when they were shipped, and again today when they arrived to make sure everything was good. The pizzas arrived pre-sliced with each piece individually wrapped in pizza foil. I had to try just one piece so I heated up a slice in the oven (no microwave warned Gasper! ) and it was delicioso! Great job Bay Ridge Pizza and Gasper for my delicious NY pizzas!! read more

This place makes the very best chicken parmigiana hero I've ever tasted. Juicy and oozing with mozzarella cheese. I've yet to find a place that makes a comparable chicken parmigiana hero. read more

I've only ever had their Grandma pizza but it's the best Grandma slice I've ever had and ultimately, one of my all time favorite slices of pizza, anywhere. It's the sort of slice you wake up craving. It will haunt your dreams. I need some now. read more

This place is more than just a pizzeria. They have a menu as good as any Italian restaurant. Their portions, variety and prices are fantastic. Gaspar and the rest of the staff always make sure you are well taken care of. You feel like family no matter how busy it gets. Whether you grab a quick slice or stay for a full dinner; You won't be disappointed. read more

What a great place to order heros from on Saturday afternoons; they also make a great pizza pie, aye. They have a square hot wings pizza, pepperoni pizza. How about a taco pizza You will enjoy this place. read more