Cute place! We wanted to come in and try a variety of sweets especially the cheesecake! Sadly they were out but staff recommended a few other options for us! The pistachio cannoli was so good! read more

See all

I loved watching the tv show so coming into this bake shop makes me happy. Everything looked good and there were lots of cool swag items for people to buy. I would definitely recommend stopping by and purchasing something delicious. read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Inside - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

Treats weren't very good and service was bad. Everything looked delicious but didn't taste close to how good it looked. read more

Oh yes, yes yes! This is the place to overindulge , save your calories and go here! The pumpkin cheesecake was sublime They literally have everything that you could possibly want from cannolis to cupcakes to cookies to cheesecakes to pastries, coffees, and more Don't deny yourself the pleasure of Carlos's read more

See all

We tried the Dubai pistachio cannoli - and I wasn't impressed. I'd love to give it another chance and try something else, but as of now I didn't enjoy what I had. read more

See all

Disappointing experience unfortunately. I recognized the shop immediately after being a fan of the show for many years and had to stop in. We went in pretty late around 11:30pm but it was still pretty busy inside. My boyfriend and I ordered a cupcake and a donut to try and figured it would be quick so we could be outside at midnight to ring in his birthday. Well, despite it being a simple order and everyone getting their orders around us, our ordered took the longest to prepare. I had to eventually ask the guy if ours would be ready soon since the people around us all had left except us. He went to go check on our order and quickly threw it together. We watched lady give us the last sad looking donut in the glass case that had probably been there all day. We also waited so long we missed celebrating his birthday at midnight outside in times square. I still am a fan of the show and won't let this alter that too much however my experience at this location was kind of disappointing. If the food was spectacular it would've made up for the service but it wasn't anything to write home about. read more

See all

Cute bakery right in the middle of Times Square, I received great service with helping me pick out my pastry and I had my first ever cannoli. Super delicious! Loved the setup and the had lots of items to choose from. Will be back for sure! read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Cannoli - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

Complete tourist trap. My wife watched his show and wanted to get something there. It was overpriced and underwhelming. Both of us walked out with regret. I'd venture elsewhere if you want a sweet treat. read more

I've always wanted to go to Carlo's Bakery. My son is quite the connoisseur of cannolis. I picked up a couple of cannolis for us to try. I ordered an original and a pumpkin. The original was good 8 out of 10 and the pumpkin was just ok. It didn't have any pumpkin flavor to it so I gave it a 5 out of town. The staff however were a 10 out of 10!! They offered a bunch of other baked goods as well that I'm sure were a 10 out of 10. Sometimes it's just about the experience. read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - The pumpkin cannoli - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

Not worth the hype. Pastries were very expensive. Got 2 mini cheesecakes, dubai danish and it was over $30 Strawberry cheesecake: 4/5 fresh, very sweet, thick. Duabi cheesecake: 2/5 the top chocolate layer is thick and you can't crack it through with a plastic fork. Had to take it off to eat the cheesecake under. The filling is not a cheesecake consistency. It's more of a thick pudding. Duabai danish: 4.5/5 wish there was a little more filling/phylo shreds on the top but flavor was good. Not too sweet. read more

I saw Carlos' show "Cake Boss" and wanted to try it one day. The location by Penn Station didn't look as nice as this location. This one is clean and bright. It's making a statement: I'm here, come in. This is the day I'm trying it. It happened to be a rainy day so there was only 1 other customer paying for order. While I was exploring, I saw cannolis. Yes, he is known for cakes though I was haven't had a good cannoli in ages. The employees were friendly. After asking which one was better chocolate or peanut butter, I ordered a traditional and chocolate dipped cannoli. Went to the cashier. It cost $14+ then the goods were delivered to me. Yes, I had sticker shock though I am treating myself today. It was delicious. I do have to try his cakes one day. read more

See all

The baked goods are all solid and fresh. However, the prices are quite high, making this establishment give off the vibe of a bit of a tourist attraction. read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Cannoli - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

Just left the shop an hour ago. staff was nice, that's by the two stars. I ordered a dozen chocolate covered strawberries, three cookies and two cupcakes. when we arrived back to the hotel and opened the packages, the strawberries smelled rotten and were mushy on the inside. The cookies were rock hard and the cupcakes were never placed in the box. I called the store and expressed my concerns. the guy who answered replied with "well I don't know what to do about that." I told him I would be in for the missing cupcakes and I wanted a refund on the strawberries. I will bring them in, they are still in the box. he replied with "yeah I don't know if I can do that." I asked for a manager but he said they don't have one. read more

We had a cinnamon twist donut and it was so fluffy and delicious. Also ordered a toasted coconut latte (got me through the toughest mornings). Cashier also had a great attitude (which I love to see in NY ). read more

While visiting Times Square we spotted Carlo's Bake Shop. My family and I used to always watch his show back in the days and his cakes always looked so delicious. I've seen his cake vending machines in Las Vegas, but never purchased one. I had to try one of their cakes since I was there and I knew the cakes had to be fresher than getting them out of a vending machine. Inside it was full of people ordering from the people behind the counter. Once I made it to the case with all of the dessert I had to have a slice of the red velvet. Inside the case they showed whole cakes and big cake slices, so after I was rung up and out the door, it's only then that I noticed that my slice did not come out of the case where they displayed the cakes because it was in a pre packaged container, just like I've seen in the vending machines. The taste of the cake was moist, but the frosting on it was minimal and the cake had a really artificial taste and was a little on the salty side. Not what I would have expected, especially since it was so expensive. I also bought my husband a chocolate cannoli which he said was good. Over all I'm glad I had a chance to try one of his cakes. This place is definitely a tourist attraction because of his tv show. I'm sure you might find something tasty here, but just don't expect to be overwhelmed. read more

See all

Tight space, no dine in table, only takeout. Staffs messes up order, they need a better system rather than manually taking order by paper and coordination with the cashier. Double check what you get with your receipt since they charge you wrongly. See images for reference. read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Inside - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

Pastry's so good. Not a wide selection. Pastry pizza. Service is quick and easy line goes fast. very cute shop. Not much seating space read more

I had such an awesome experience visiting Carlos bake shop. I surprised my brother and he literally ran inside. We haven't been back to this place let alone tried their cakes since we were kids. I definitely felt the nostalgia . My brother ordered the chocolate mouse mini cake and it was really good. The shop has assorted pastries and cake . I remember watching buddy on tv when I was a kid and watching him make cakes. The service was decent . read more

See all

Unsurprising, but this is an overpriced, gimmicky, Times Square attraction. Luckily, we made it in on a freezing night when Times Square, and this place, was empty so I didn't have to wait for a gross desert. The brownie was so dry and unflavorful. The cupcake was overly sweet with nothing special. Both pieces were stale. I'd pass on this spot. read more

See all

Great location right in Times Square. A must stop if you are a fan of Buddy and the show Cake Boss. I am not but decided to stop by since it looked inviting. Lot of different goodies on display including pizza. I got the Cannoli and Dark Chocolate mousse and both were mid, hence the 3 stars. read more

See all

I'd already eaten a fairly magnificent black and white cookie, but I couldn't resist popping into Carlo's Bake Shop while in Times Square. And while I was tempted by some of the other baked goods on offer, I felt like I just had to get the Black & White Cookie ("Soft, cake-like cookie covered half and half with vanilla and chocolate icing"). It's perhaps not quite as good as the version at Empire Cakes, but it's pretty darn tasty. The two types of frosting are sweet but not too sweet, and they taste great together. The soft cake-like cookie is the perfect vehicle, as it's ultimately more reminiscent of a cake than a cookie. They've got an efficient operation in there, too. The place was busy but I got my food within minutes of ordering it. read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Black & White Cookie. - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

I ordered strawberry cheese was great. The atmosphere was beautiful and smell delicious Customer service on point. read more

Carlo's did not disappoint. As we were walking up we saw the line was out the door, that's always a good sign. They move swiftly so we did not stand in line long at all. I ordered a yellow cupcake with buttercream icing. The cake was fresh and the icing was just right. It was a very good cupcake. If you get the chance I would recommend stopping by for a treat. read more

See all

We loved the original Cake Boss TV show so we had to stop in when we recognized the logo walking by. My wife and I shared a classic Cannoli, which had a plain shell and filling with chocolate chips mixed into it. Honestly one of the best cannolis we have had, but at almost $7 after tax, it's quite steep for one to share. We stood and ate at one of the bar counters facing the outside of the shop. You wait in line to place your order, give your name, and then proceed to the register where you say your name again and they lookup your order so you can pay. Worth it to say we tried Carlo's! Update: We went back for a second time to get another Canoli before leaving NYC. read more

See all

I love this famous bakery in New York City. I went straight for the slice of rainbow cake as soon as I saw this beauty. Not only were the colours visually enticing but the layers were perfectly made as though a machine made it instead of a person. The cake was fluffy and the filling was sweet and creamy. It really tasted just as good as it looks. Make sure you brace yourself for the busy-ness of the place but it wouldn't be New York without the hustle and bustle. read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

This store is busy... they have a lot of customers. Their products are well displayed and appetizingly presented. I ordered coffee eclair while my company ordered the classic canoli and chocolate ecclair. The coffee cream in my eclair is not too sweet... just enough for me. But it has an icing on top that is very sweet to my liking so I took it out. The eclair size is also good for sharing. read more

See all

Delicious, definitely worth the hype, I want to try everything within my flavor profile and my allergies will allow read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Classic Birthday Cake Cannoli Pecan toffee blonde - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

See all

After a great dinner, we wanted something sweet to end our evening. Carlo's bake shop was right across the street, so we strolled over and stood in line. The display had so many baked goods to choose from that it's overwhelming! Everything looked so good and tempting! They had cakes, cheesecake, cookies, pastries, danishes, cupcakes, pastry pockets, brownies, eclairs, tarts, savory breakfast sandwiches, and pizza. The line moved quickly, so we had to make up our minds. We ordered a slice of carrot cake, original & chocolate dipped cannoli, tiramisu and a lobster tail! They boxed it up and we decided to dig into it right outside. Too bad they don't have a place to sit to eat your treats! Here's what we thought of what we ordered: CANNOLIS ~ The cannolis were fresh and still crispy with a lightly sweetened filling! 5/5 TIRAMISU ~ It was perfectly rich and creamy! 5/5 CARROT CAKE ~ pretty sweet and the cake was a bit dry. I think it could be more moist. 3.5/5 LOBSTER TAIL ~ The crispy pastry was like a hard lobster shell! I've never had a lobster tail pastry! And it was filled with lightly sweetened vanilla custard. I really enjoyed it! 5/5 read more

See all

Wow this place is fun and energetic! So many baked goods to choose from! Staff was friendly. Definitely a bucket list spot if you love food network read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Strawberry cheesecake - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

The strawberry shortcake was delicious. I liked the cannoli but the strawberry shortcake was the best tasting. The service was quick and the staff was friendly. read more

My husband & I couldn't wait to try Carlo's Bake Shop goodies. We loved Cake Boss & until today had only found their cakes in a Vegas vending machine (no thank you) Upon walking in everything looked delicious so we ordered 2 slices ( Carrot & Red Velvet). We were extremely disappointed after paying to receive 2 pre packaged slices of cake We were expecting fresh cake like the ones in the display cases. This is very misleading & unacceptable. At least post a sign or let customers know when ordering. No one wants prepackaged cake from a bakery! Especially not from one as popular as Carlo's. The cakes had no flavor btw Total waste of money. What you see isn't what you get! read more

See all

I loved all of the options. The service was fast. I bought the mixed berry tart and cheese cake pastry! There wasn't anywhere to sit. Everything was so colorful and neat inside of this location. The staff members were very nice And prompt. read more

See all

I did not know they sell Pizza! Being from Chicago I was not expecting this to be great. I Loved it! They have three options: Buffalo, Margarita and Pepperoni. I went with the pepperoni and let me tell you it was worth it the small wait. So airy and fluffy - different- not greasy at all. Love how they pack it. Definitely a must try. I went because it was Carlo's Bakery, you shouldn't knock a place because it's commercial. I kinda like that I could , if I wanted to, pick up a souvenir. Today I was just in and out of NY but a little girl purchased one, ripped it open and put it on! She loved it! Staff was so patient and very polite. There is so much dessert variety. Cookies, cupcakes , cake , slices of cake and cheesecake. I couldn't make up my mind, like many customers Lol. Than I looked over and seen this cute display so I said Pizza please Definitely go and enjoy the experience and pizza! Ps there are places to sit all around the square! read more

See all

Had to experience the bake shop while here in New York. Cute little shop. Definitely a tourist trap. The service was great. The cream puff cake was good. There was a large variety of desserts to choose from. This was not bad at all just very commercial. read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Cream puff cake - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

Just went in at 10:55pm to get a pastry, go to sit and eat it and they tell me they're closing the dining area. Really? That's not something you think you should tell people before they purchase? You close in one hour and are not allowing people to sit and eat a pastry for an entire hour? I debated returning my purchase right there. Train your staff to communicate these things before taking people's money. read more

Oh WOW!! Had two amazing treats from here...unfortunately only took a pic of one. First had the Lobster Claw which is an amazing pastry dough filled with sensational custard. Original is so good but they also have one with chocolate drizzle or something like that...probably even better. I noticed the strawberry shortcake slices during my original purchase then came back a couple nights later and it DID NOT DISAPPOINT! A nice size portion with a mountain of additional cream besides what is already between the slices of cake. The strawberries were juicy and delicious. The folks I came into contact with on both visits were very nice. Carlo's needs to come to Jensen Beach Florida read more

Carlo's Bake Shop - Couldn't wait to take my first bite- strawberry shortcake YUM! - Patisserie/Cake Shop Near Me - New York, New York

Pésimo servicio . Pedí dos cafés y fue muy desagradable el chico que atendió . Le sentó mal que no dejara propina supongo

0/10 do not recommend. Employees are unruly. Cocoa powder and syrup bottles getting tossed around. The unruly employees got Cocoa powder and syrup on costumers sweater. Dangerous atmosphere. read more

The Cake Boss has open a new Bake shop in Times Square, not to be confused with the other Carlo's Bakery at 42st and 8th Ave. Delicious beautiful presentation of cakes, pastries, everything is on display in a more artistic and better looking new shop with giant cookies on the ceiling. Their have been a few new other cake shops opening in the area but they have little chance competing with the cake boss. Carlo's is definitely for just tourist with tourist prices, and You will find good but not exceptional cakes cookies and other dessert's here read more

See all

New location! Pretty on the inside, you can either order by yourself from the screens or be helped from an assistant. I got some heart shaped cookies and chocolate covered strawberries for Valentine's Day. I liked the strawberries but they did put them in a big box although they were just 6, ruining the presentation (but they tasted very good). The cookies were a 3/5. I went to get a birthday cake just ten days later. I chose a chocolate cake and it's very good! Right amount of moisture and it's still perfect even after more than 24hrs. I haven't tried pastries yet but I definitely will. Relatively fast service. read more