No matter what you do when visiting NY or if you're a resident and yet to try, you must get a cheesecake from Eileen's. Prepare to take out or they have standing areas if you choose to stay in but not a lot of room in the space. Various flavors to choose from! We tried the Red Velvet and the Strawberry. It was so beyond , so rich! They get people in and out, our attendant use to live in Maryland. I trusted him when he co-signed with my husband on the red velvet, so so good! read more

See all

I visited this place a while ago but still dream about how delicious their mini cheesecakes are. Located in SoHo, this place offers fresh and airy options to choose from in terms of their sweet treats. For flavors, I got a variety of them including Oreo, Crème Brûlée and 2 others. My favorite was the Crème Brûlée. Even though I got the mini cheesecakes, they do offer bigger portions if you prefer! The space inside is really cozy, the workers are genuinely so nice and there's a cute spot in front of the place to sit and enjoy your little treats which was honestly the best part :)!!! read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Mini Cheesecakes - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I visited 30 minutes before they closed and I received great customer service. It was my first time here so the man at the cashier was very kind and helpful. Cheesecakes are small but filling! Not overly sweet and very fluffy. My favorite was the Oreo cheesecake since it was classic but with that Oreo crunch. They were a bit pricey, sitting at $5-7 per cake. There are no tables here and only have limited bar stools available. I went at a perfect time and was able to sit at the window with no issues. Definitely recommend!! read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Oreo, original, and chocolate cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

This is one of the best NY cheesecakes I've ever had! Definitely top 2. There's quite a selection of small individual cheesecakes, and there are also larger cakes/slices available. For me, it's impossible to beat the classic one. You order at the counter and you can get it to eat there at a small corner standing counter if you like. Very casual with a steady stream of customers. Service is fast! $6.50 for one individual plain cheesecake, worth every penny. I don't live in NY, but I came here for the first time almost 10 years ago. I think of it often and I come back whenever I can! read more

Stopped by Eileen's Special Cheesecake after seeing a lot of good reviews, and it definitely lived up to it. I'm not usually a big cheesecake person, but this was really good. We tried the marble, strawberry, and cookies & cream--honestly all solid, but the strawberry was my favorite. Portion size is on the smaller side (about the size of an egg tart), but that's pretty standard for Manhattan. Works out well anyway since you can try a few different flavors without feeling too heavy. Nice spot if you want something sweet without overdoing it. read more

See all

It's hype. Not taste. At least not anymore. I looked at the cute pictures. Even my pictures I took, the cheesecake looks so scrumptious. I looked at all the articles framed on the wall. Maybe it USED TO be God's gift to man. I got suckered. The mini cheesecakes were flavorless. Shocking, even across the multiple flavors we tried. My kids didn't like these! That's how not good. Nothing to write home about. Kinda on par with grocery store cheesecake... read more

See all

Super friendly guy at the counter, je was very engaging with the customers and helpful in explaining/suggesting flavors. They have a good variety of flavors to choose from. I like that cheesecake are round individual pieces as opposed to slices - they travel better . I had the Salted Caramel (popular) and the coconut. Both really good , the Salted Caramel was definitely my favorite. Texture, creamy and rich but not overly dense , sweetness level is perfect for my taste. I think they are the perfect size to satisfy a craving but not leave you feeling stuffed or uncomfortable. There is a counter if you'd like to stand and nosh or a bench outside. No bathroom. Variety of drinks available read more

See all

My husband and I found this tiny dessert shop while walking around the Little Italy/Nolita area. We ordered a few small cheesecakes to go and take back to our hotel room to enjoy. They are definitely special and great-tasting. I wasn't huge on the pineapple flavor, but that is my own cheesecake preference and nothing against the cake itself. The staff was friendly and didn't rush us. No room to really eat inside except for a small stand up counter. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Inside - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I came here on a little food crawl with a friend and gosh I wish I would have come here first!! I was nearly stuffed by the time I got here but the salted caramel and regular strawberry cheesecake mini bites were so good! The cannoli was so so delicious!! There's a reason there's a line out the door read more

WOW. What an amazing cheesecake! It's light, not too heavy/decadent, and the perfect amount of sweetness. I love that they sell little bites like this for those that don't want to over-indulge. They also sell whole cheesecakes and bigger slices. The store is super home-y and has limited tables inside to enjoy your cheesecake. I'll definitely be back the next time I'm in NYC! read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

What an absolute gem to stumble upon in the lower east side wow. My friends and I were craving desserts after eating dinner in Chinatown. We found this place on Yelp and arrived here Saturday at 5pm during peak tourist season. The line was out the door, and it was packed here despite the cold rather outside. There are so many mini cheesecakes to pick from each of which is around 6-7 dollars for a small tart cheese cake about 1-2 inches in diameter. There are so many options to pick from it was so hard to decide which cheesecake I wanted to try. There is no seating inside, it's quite a small indoors and can get a bit cramped in the crowd. As we walked up to the counter there were 2 people taking orders and seeing all the cheesecake tarts in person made it even harder to decide. I ordered the creme brule cheesecake and seeing them put the topping on top made it even more enticing. My friends ordered the banana mini cheesecake and the original, and all three were great options. While there are so many options my opinion is that each is fantastic and I can't wait to come back and try more. I think I did make the right decision with the creme brûlée cheesecake which I devoured in like 3 bites. So glad to have stumbled upon this place and excited to try more. read more

See all

Soo light and delicious! Eileen's does it right without using thickeners or emulsifiers to make their famous cheesecakes and tarts. The shop is still run by Eileen's daughters and it remains a family owned business service is quick and friendly and they have a variety of cheesecakes to choose from. Definitely worth going out of your way to stop by for a treat at Eileen's. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Strawberry Cheesecake Tart - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Eileen's Special Cheesecake 17 Cleveland Pl. New York, NY 10012 Strawberry Classic Plain Cookies N Cream Salted Caramel Located at the four corner intersection in SoHo is a locally owned specialty cheesecake shop that has been in business for over 50 years. All cheesecakes are handmade daily with no fillers or preservatives. Manager Amanda introduced me to four of the most popular cheesecakes on the menu. As I opened the box, my appetite was filled with joy as I knew I was going to be in for a treat. Strawberry: This pie is topped with a giant strawberry and smothered in strawberry sauce. It was unbelievably fruity and tangy. Classic Plain: This original New York cheesecake was smooth and creamy. If you want to go plain Jane, this pie has your name! Cookies N Cream: This tart was beautifully handcrafted; the mini Oreo cookie added a nice decorative touch. The chocolate graham cracker crust blended well with the cheesecake. Salted Caramel: What makes this pie unique to the others is the hardened creme brulee at the top, giving it a crunchy texture. The dining area is standing room only, but there are plenty of outdoor benches across the street at Lt. Petrosino Square. Be prepared to wait in line, but it moves pretty quickly! Overall, these cheesecakes were phenomenal and I see why this dessert shop has been around for a long time! #cheesecakelovers #eileensspecialcheesecake #eileenscheesecake #cheesecakechallenge #CookiesNCreamCheesecake #classicplaincheesecake #strawberrycheesecake #saltedcaramelcheesecake #CremeBruleeCheesecake #sohonyc read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - 4 Specialty Cheesecakes - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've a huge fan of cheesecake and heard amazing things about Eileen's so I knew I had to give it a try during my New York trip. They offer a wide variety of different flavored cheesecakes but they're mini sized so it's easier to try different flavors. They have a pretty large variety of flavors so there would be something for everybody. I ordered the cookies and cream, chocolate cappuccino, salted caramel, and lemon. I was honestly impressed with all of them but my favorite had to be the salted caramel, which I'd say is a must try. The store itself is on the smaller end and is more of a to go spot, but there is a standing table if you want to enjoy your sweet treat there. Service was also friendly! Overall, I enjoyed Eileen's and would recommend it. read more

See all

This is a premier cheesecake spot! Juniors who? I've heard lots of good things about this place. That people come far and wide and that they sell out quickly. Wide range of flavors as well Despite the wait (long lines at times), very helpful service It's also a small hole in the wall type of spot. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

After a quick lunch at Eataly in Soho, Eileen's Cheesecake Shoppe across the triangle park on Cleveland Place beckoned me. I must have walked past it over a dozen times, but just decided I would drop in. Tiny is the word, even for Manhattan. I like that they also cater to those looking for a small portion. That is what I got. A small cheesecake, plain. Just right for me as an individual serving in the afternoon. The manager was very accomodating. There is a small area where you can eat in. I was very happy, since I was visiting in February with day old snow on the ground outside. Compared to a popular Brooklyn cream cheese based cake, this is a much lighter cake in physical weight and texture, dare I say, airy? Much more to my liking. Not quite the same as an Italian Cheesecake. This one, I thought, was creamier in texture, if slightly sweeter. I feel everyone should experience it, so you can make up your own mind. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Small cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The cheesecake at Eileen's is, without a doubt, the best cheesecake in New York City, in my humble opinion. Unlike the heavy, overly dense cakes you find elsewhere, Eileen's has a remarkably light, fluffy, and creamy texture that melts in your mouth. It's incredibly flavorful, and has a lite taste. Love that you can truly appreciate the quality of the ingredients. The individual-sized cheesecakes are perfect. I ordered strawberry, and salted caramel each individual cost $6.50 each. Customers can purchase bigger size cheesecakes, and Eileen's ship nationwide. The smaller individual cheesecakes options allow you to try multiple delicious flavors in one visit. From the classic plain, rich salted caramel, fruity strawberry, cherry, and blueberry. The shop on Cleveland Place has a cozy, old-school charm that adds to the experience, and while the space is small, if there is a line, just know, the line moves quickly thanks to the friendly and efficient staff. A visit to Eileen's is a must-do for any cheesecake lover in the city. Eileen's is a Soho must visit! read more

See all

Cheesecake is delicious and beautifully presented. Despite the increasing prices over the years, I still think it's worth coming. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - menu - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My nutritionist thinks I'm obese but I'm really not a sweets guy. This cheesecake was fantastic though. Tried the strawberry and cherry, 10 for the strawberry, 8 for the cherry. The lightest cheesecake I've had, juniors is good, this place is amazing. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Eileen's Special Cheesecake is another one of the many places that has been on my list to visit in NYC. I first heard about them in Food & Wine as having one of the best cheesecakes in the United States, and while I could have ordered one online, I wanted to try it at the source in Manhattan to see for myself and get the quintessential experience. The bake shop is small and very charming, truly maintaining that traditional mom-and-pop vibe as a local business with its white and blue interior, artistic chalkboards, and neighborhood memorabilia. The number of flavors to choose from was astonishing, and the service went above and beyond what I expected. The representative behind the counter not only knew each of the cheesecakes and their flavor profiles in depth--it was almost as if I were talking to an experienced bartender. I asked him what his favorite cheesecake was, and he told me the blueberry flavor was his favorite. He explained that since blueberries grow natively in New York, the fruit would be of higher quality compared to most of the other fruit cheesecake options. So I opted for a mini version of the blueberry cheesecake since I only wanted a sample. Unlike many cheesecakes I've had in the past, this one had a light, tangy flavor, and the texture reminded me of a thick mousse. The graham cracker crust wasn't firm but rather crumbly, providing a nice caramel-like flavor that balanced out the richness of the cheese custard. The blueberry compote was very fresh as well, and I could tell the berries were at their peak ripeness since they were naturally sweet. Overall, this was a great place to check out. While I personally prefer a thicker crust, I definitely understand why this place is so popular. With the cheesecake being light and not too heavy, you probably won't order just one--you might get a couple. It's what I'd call the "potato chip" of cheesecakes! read more

See all

Ever since traveling to the city, I've been trying to find the best cheesecake via Yelp! I stumbled across this place with lots of reviews so I had to make a pitstop here. The interior was very cute. Think of like a donut store where you can pick all the cheesecakes you want. The employees were extremely helpful! They gave me recommendations of their personal favorites and seasonal. We ended up getting two smaller cheesecakes for about 13$. We got the strawberry cheesecake and pumpkin cheesecake. Pumpkin Cheesecake - My favorite out of the two. I felt like the flavor profiles worked very well. It wasn't overly pumpkin flavor, but still maintain the cheesecake flavor. I would get this again! It is only seasonal. Strawberry cheesecake - A classic. Nothing wrong with this one but nothing stood out a it's just a classic cheesecake! read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - 6" Pumpkin Cheesecake and 6" Strawberry Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

We had to stop by Eileen's Special Cheesecake, especially since it's one of the most highly rated cheesecake spots in New York! We tried the fall seasonal Pumpkin Cheesecake along with the classic Strawberry Cheesecake. The texture was much lighter and fluffier than I expected, almost mousse-like, and the flavor was subtly sweet without being overly tart. The pumpkin had a light amount of spice for fall, while the strawberry gave that fresh, classic finish you'd hope for. I also appreciated how the cheesecakes came in smaller, personal sizes, it made it super easy (and tempting!) to sample multiple flavors within one visit. On top of that, the shop itself has such a warm, cozy, old-school charm. Seating is a bit limited, but I feel like the space at the barstools continuously open up, so it wasn't an issue for us. Overall, a cute homey bakery with adorable and decadent cheesecakes. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Interior - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Delicious cheesecake! We stopped in on a Tuesday afternoon around 4. It was decently busy. The inside is small with a little bit of counter space to eat at. The girl working was super helpful and friendly. It was super overwhelming to pick just a few to try! She gave a lot of good recommendations, which were much appreciated. In the end, we picked the salted caramel, the birthday cake, and the traditional strawberry. They were all super delicious. Super light. Not too sweet and could easily be shared. I though the salted caramel tasted like crème brûlée, which was really good. The strawberry was a little hard to eat with the entire strawberry on it. You definitely needed a knife for that one. The birthday cake was really good too. Come here. You won't regret it. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Strawberry, salted caramel and birthday cake cheesecakes. - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Eileen's Special Cheesecake (New York, NY)... We went to Eileen's Special Cheesecake because of its famous history and the hype -- and while the name is iconic, the actual experience felt far more like a regular street-side pastry shop than the classic institution we expected. * Atmosphere & space The shop is very small and feels cramped. If you're expecting a comfortable sit-down experience, don't -- seating is minimal and the space is neither cozy nor particularly welcoming. It's the kind of spot built for quick pick-ups and tourist photos, not lingering over a dessert. * Service This was the low point for us. The staff came across as curt and unfriendly; service felt rushed and, at times, a bit brusque. We didn't feel welcomed or helped -- more like an inconvenience. For a place with such a longstanding reputation, better customer care would go a long way. * The cheesecake The cheesecakes look the part -- not the classic New York-style slices but little round cakes. However, the quality didn't blow us away given the price point. Portions and presentation are very street-pastry-shop standard: fine for a quick treat, but not exceptional. Considering the cost, we left feeling a little underwhelmed. * Value Products felt expensive for what you get. If you're paying a premium mainly for the brand or the "famous" factor, be aware that the product and setting reflect a neighborhood pastry counter rather than a luxury dessert experience. * Who should go? If you're a tourist who wants to tick the classic New York cheesecake box and grab a photo, one visit makes sense. If you're looking for a comfortable place to enjoy an outstanding slice with warm service, there are better options in the city. * Suggestions for Eileen.... A friendlier, more engaged front-of-house and a small improvement in seating/cleanliness would dramatically improve the overall experience. Either adjust the prices to match the casual format or raise the experience to match the premium pricing. Bottom line: iconic name, ordinary reality. Worth a one-time visit for the history and the photo if the employees allow you to. The cashier actually told me not to take pictures. -- anyways, don't expect a memorable dining or service experience. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Employees at work - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Called in to order the 10in strawberry cheesecake for a birthday party. Staff were kind and helpful. Overall the cheesecake was delicious. Great texture - creamy and decadent. Took off one star because there was a subtle almost artificial taste to the strawberries/ sauce but other than that - no notes. Would definitely order again. read more

A beloved cheesecake spot in SOHO that's been around for years! They offer several flavors of cheesecake, all in petite portions, so you can easily try more than one even if you're solo. There's a small counter for dine-in, and when I visited, there was even a group tour stopping by -- clearly, word has gotten out. I went for the Original and the Caramel, and both had that perfect touch of saltiness that made the flavors pop. Coffee is also available to pair with your cake. If you're in SOHO, this makes the perfect sweet stop in between shopping sprees! read more

See all

Finally got a 2nd chance at Eileen and made sure each person got their own, to not have to share! Amazing cheesecake as before, definitely one of the best for me. But maybe the inflation is reducing confidence, as the price to get 3 for a simple snack per person started to feel a bit much. For more regular enjoyment on a budget, I've found Costco back at home has almost as good a cheesecake surprisingly. But don't miss the best in Eileenm if visiting NY as a tourist like me. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

So so good!!! These cheesecakes were so light and fluffy and the crust was absolute perfection! Service was excellent and the prices are fair. Highly recommend Eileen's read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Entrance - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My partner loves cheesecake and this place did not disappoint at all. We got classic, strawberry, dulce de leche, salted caramel, raspberry, and coconut. My dad's favorite was the coconut, my mom's the raspberry, and my partner loved everything. The line was out the door when we got there on a Saturday around 2, but it moved super fast! This place is super tiny, definitely not a place to sit down. Strictly pickup. The person behind the counter was helpful and super nice when we kept adding flavors. We thought we were gonna get four but ended up walking out with 8. I'd definitely come back! read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Menu - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great cheesecake option in NYC. They offer different varieties of cheesecakes. They're soft and light for dessert. My kid loved the chocolate chip cookies! The lady behind the counter was so nice and helpful. I will most definitely be back for more. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Cheesecake varieties - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

So yum!!! The cakes were all so delectable but the salted caramel might have been my fave. The chocolate covered strawberry also.... Mmmmmmmmmmm read more

I recommend. A great stop for dessert in NYC, especially if you love variety. The cupcake-sized cheesecakes are perfectly portioned, rich without being too heavy, and made with quality ingredients you can really taste. There are tons of flavors to choose from, so it's easy to want more than one. Service is fast and efficient, making it easy to pop in even when there's a line. While it can get busy, everything moves quickly and the quality stays consistent. A delicious treat that easily earns four stars. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Sprinkles Cheesecake Tart, Plain Cheesecake Tart, Chocolate Cheesecake Tart. - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

An absolute delight to have! The plain cannot be beat, simple and yet so so delicious. Small little place so seating is tough read more

My girlfriend and I were in the city for a weekend and of course that means a food tour was required!!! While we were not planning to try Eileen's, we were in the neighborhood shopping and saw on our Apple Maps. In Discussing it at a local thrift store. The owner mentioned to us that it was a great place and that we absolutely had to go! I have been to NYC a few times and I'm now kicking myself at the fact that I have never heard of Eileen before. Upon walking in you see a refrigerated display of delicious cheesecake tarts, from classic to more indulgent like red velvet!! I also noticed they had full-size cheesecakes. I opted for a simple cheesecake Tart with strawberry on top and my friend opted for the red velvet tart. Eating an individual tart is not difficult whatsoever, in fact, I could have easily had another but I didn't want to spoil our dinner!!! The cheesecake was light and fluffy and not too cheesy. The crust portion and topping ratio were all absolutely perfectly executed. I am so happy to have Eileen and the next time I'm in the city, I will make sure to make this one of my first stops.!! read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

For an afternoon snack after morning tourist excursions, my wife sent me on a 0.7 mile trek to Eileen's Special Cheesecake. She had a list that others put together of must see places....We have been walking, and I have been running all over NYC this past week. It took about 15 minutes to get there. It's a tiny. cozy place right on the street corner. But there was a line...I looked at the framed articles, and watched a TV clip proclaiming the specialness of Eileen's...I ordered two tarts, a salted caramel, and a strawberry. It was packed in a mini rectangular box...they were about $6 each. I brought them back to the hotel. The cheesecake tarts were pretty, the salted caramel was delicious and the strawberry - my favorite type of cheesecake was very delicious, it was the right amount for an afternoon snack with coffee...didn't want to ruin our appetite for our last NYC dinner with my son. read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Excellent place a little small hard to stand in line then get numbed around cause people are trying to come in and leave all in the same time haha Great cheesecake tbh it's so so good for my taste buds. Perfect not too sweet and great texture. Would definitely one back to this establishment. read more

Can't go wrong with cheesecake from Eileen's! Their cheesecake strikes a great balance, rich without being too heavy, and full of flavor without tasting too sweet. Definitely not a dense, sugary dessert like you might find coming out of a dessert chain. They have lots of flavors to try, but you can't go wrong with a classic cheesecake, either whole or in an individual size. Definitely worth checking out! read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing mini cheesecakes - full of flavour despite the mini size! I decided to visit here during my short visit to NYC since it appeared to be a popular spot. Strawberry cheesecake: I decided to get the strawberry since this appeared to be the most fresh and popular choice. There is some casual seating but it's mostly a takeout place. I would totally recommend this dessert spot. read more

See all

I think the cheesecake here is very rich and flavorful without being too much. My ranking of the flavors I've tried are: Lemon raspberry, salted caramel, strawberry, Oreo, tofu based (oddly good), gluten free (I wouldn't eat this one again) read more

Eileen's Special Cheesecake - Strawberry Cheesecake Tart - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Must try! Cheesecake here are lighter than the others but does not skimp on the flavors! Service was exceptional & there was a bit of counter space to eat your Cheesecake. We both could have had a 6" Cheesecake if we were to truly indulge! Our picks this visit were the Strawberry Cheesecake & the Salted Caramel. read more

See all