Cancel

Open app

Search

Mamma Lucia of Olney

2.9 (264 reviews)
ModeratePizza, Italian, Seafood
Closed 11:00 am - 9:00 pm

Mamma Lucia of Olney Reservations

Order Mamma Lucia of Olney Takeout or Delivery

Mamma Lucia of Olney Photos

MAMMA LUCIA OF OLNEY ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Dogs allowed
Good for groups

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Mamma Lucia of Olney

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Gary H.

This location never disappoints us. Long time customer and also a small resteraunt owner myself. I was taught to make Carbanara in the 70's by one of the leading chefs in Virginia and I have had Pasta Carbanara all around this country and world and this is in the top 5. Resteraunt is always clean and service is always top notch. Our server tonight was Kristal and she was superb, very attentive.

Wings
Rumesh V.

I was at the friend's house in Olney. They rave about this pizza often. So I finally decided to join them for dinner. They were about to close so their service was understandably rushed. We didn't have a lot of time to think about the order. We went with the classic - wings and pizza. Wings were pretty good. Pizza was good as well. I wish the pizza base was slightly thinner. Ambiance was good as well. Price is nominal. Lots of parking spots.

Eimy B.

My favorite thing about my experience at Mama Lucia was the bread and oil. Ordered a large pizza, half margarita and half hawaiian. The bread on the pizza was extremely thick, not enjoyable for me. Server was waiting tables at the other end of the restaurant so it was a challenge to get refills or ask for anything. This was not a great experience and food was mediocre. The reataurant was dimly lit, smelled a little funny, didn't look too clean. I don't think I'd give it a second chance.

Ngan D.

Went here for dinner when we checked out the opening of smoothie king nearby. It was a nice day so we decided to sit outside, might not have been a good idea because flies kept going around us lol. Got the spaghetti and meatballs and loved it. Noodles was soft and flavor was just right. Also love the garlic bread that comes with the meal. My husband ordered a seafood pasta dish, he didn't like it as much. He said it needed more flavor. Service was good at the beginning but they probably forgot about us near the end, had to go look for them after waiting for some time.

Chicken Alfredo

This was the first time at this restaurant, and heard good things so gave it a try. The chicken Alfredo pasta sauce was watery and had no flavor. The chicken in the chicken Parmesan was petrified and I couldn't chew it to break it down. Both dishes sent back and we said we didn't want anything else. The server said "I'm so sorry you didn't like our food" as he handed me the bill for $72. At the end he gave a free cannoli, which didn't offset the low quality of food.

Linguine with White Wine Clam Sauce

See all

Photo of Deepak B.
85
154
3

15 years ago

My wife and I loves this place. The bread and salad yummy. The entree is awesome. Don't go there for the decor, but only the food;-)

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Rick S.
7
74
29

15 years ago

The best pizza in Olney. The Tuesday night special is a great deal considering the pizza is a little more pricey but worth it.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

love this place..we get good service everytime and the amount of food you get for the price is wonderful!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of J A.
2
8
7

13 years ago

Service was great and the food was fantastic...... Awesome calamari and lasagna.... Will be my favorite place for Italian,food.....

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Rok L.
0
187
7

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of H. S.
0
115
29

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

The service is never very good, the food takes forever to come out and it never tastes good. Wouldnt go again after the 3 visits I had.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Very mediocre food, and quite expensive for an Italian Restaurant. Suggest you try a different restaurant.

Business owner information

Photo of Mamma L.

Mamma L.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of A C.
0
40
1

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

The food is always good. The service is always excellent. Its one of my and my wifes favorite spots !

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 7 of 7

Ask the Community - Mamma Lucia of Olney

You might also consider

Feasty crab

Feasty crab

3.9
(189 reviews)
5.7 mi

We normally come here for their all you can eat special, but decided to switch things up a bit, on…read morethis visit. It had been a while since we last ordered from the menu. On this visit, we both got selections like what we had around our early times of visiting this spot. I cannot remember what my friend got, but I ordered one of the "Feasty Specials" which had 1/2 Snow Crab Legs and 1/2 Headless Shrimp. It came with sausages (sliced in pieces), 1 Corn (about 1/4 size), 1 Egg, and 2 Potatoes (the skin easily comes off). You get to pick the seasoning and I had Old Bay. What is presented to you is a large clear bag, steamed up and tied, with seasonings and all mixed up. It is served on a metal tray, and they also place an empty bowl on your table for discarding things. Plastic bib was on, bag opened, and I was ready to dig in. The seasoning took me back to my second visit a few years ago. It was when I first tasted their Old Bay mix and became a fan of it. This Feasty Special was just enough and I was glad to switch things up for a change.

Overall, this is an average experience out…read more The good - plenty of options on their all you can eat menu, or at least for us. Overall, the food is good, and, in our opinion, you do get what you pay for. Keep in mind that they DO charge you if you have leftover food on your table when you are done. Be mindful of that and make sure to let them know as you are finishing up, and want more, to scale down your portion size. There is a 90-minute window to eat. The servers don't really go over the menu much, so if it is your first time for all you can eat, make sure to take notice that the crab legs do come with a few different flavor options. The bad - They started a new policy, which I understand, but do not like. If you want all you can eat, everyone who is at the table must all order it as well, or nobody can. I understand they are protecting their profits, but that has taken us away from this place on more than one occasion to eat elsewhere as some wanted it and another family members wanted to order off the main menu. Also, service can be extremely slow, and I am not sure if it is intentional or not, but we have complained more than once and made them extend our time. Last time we went, they set our first order of food down on the table and as we were eating, the waitress walked by no less then 5 times and didn't bother to ask if we wanted anything else. Then, magically, when our food was gone, we could not get anyone to come to the table for 15 minutes. Upon ordering our next round, it took another 20 more minutes for the food to arrive. They are sticklers about the 90-minute time frame, and we explained that twice this has happened and 60 minutes of our 90 minutes was wasted waiting on a server and then the food took forever. They allowed us one more round of food, which we appreciated and thought was fair. We start a stopwatch now and if we feel things are going slow, we address that with the server and sometimes put in a new order when the food is being dropped off. Overall, we are pleased to come here a few times a year. We only get all you can eat and usually are happy when we leave. The food is inconsistent as we do get the lobster tail with all you can eat, and it is usually overcooked and can chew like rubber, but still has good flavor. The crab legs sometimes come out waterlogged with salt, but most times piping hot. This is your typical "average" 3-star restaurant. If you are prepared to spend the money for all you can eat, you will leave satisfied and full, but never will you think "I wish I could come here every week". I have not ordered specific entrees off the regular menu so I cannot speak on portion size or quality of the food by ordering that way. Staff is always pleasant, but you do need to get on them if they are slacking.

Photos
The exit. Cute fish and Feasty Crab merchandise on the wall.
The exit. Cute fish and Feasty Crab merchandise on the wall.
Snow Crab Legs from part of the All You Can Eat Dinner special. March 2025. We got more later.
Snow Crab Legs from part of the All You Can Eat Dinner special. March 2025. We got more later.
I love the shells both hanging and on the shelf.

See all

I love the shells both hanging and on the shelf.
Salt & Vine

Salt & Vine

4.2
(318 reviews)
0.1 mi
$$$

This restaurant is beautiful inside. From the moment you go inside, you feel like you're…read moretransported somewhere else in the world. As for our server, something seemed off. He rushed us to order, made us uncomfortable when we were deciding what to order, and asked us if we wanted the house made bread. I knew the bread was $5 but he made no mention of it. If I was coming to eat there and was asked if I wanted bread and didn't know there was a charge, I would be upset. It was kind of deceiving, and when the bill came out, shoved the handheld device to pay in my face and I couldn't go over the bill. He told me to put my phone here when paying and that was that. The bill was incorrect and I had to get a manager to fix it (the manger was very friendly and took care of everything). I also have an issue when a server asks us how the food is, right when the food gets put down on the table. We hadn't even had a chance to take a bite. Now, why I gave this place a five star. Like I said before, the ambiance was amazing, if we had a different server, I'm sure it would had been great! The food: it' was top notch. Some of the best food in Maryland. I wouldn't had changed anything with the food. Everything was seasoned perfectly, had the right textures, and tasted so good! Would I go back? Absolutely!

chose this restaurant because of its strong ratings and decided to take my husband there for his…read morebirthday. Unfortunately, the experience was underwhelming overall. We started with the Grand Caviar tasting, which was the most expensive caviar option on the menu. For the price, I expected much more. The caviar was extremely salty, to the point where it felt like additional salt had been added on top. The tasting included three varieties of caviar. The caviar they used on one was the exact caviar they used in sushi. Our second appetizer, the tuna dish, was significantly better. While the presentation could have been more refined and visually appealing, the flavor exceeded expectations and was one of the stronger dishes we tried. For my entrée, I ordered the branzino. The fish itself was decent, but def not crispy but it was salty. The sauce was salty and the fish was salty making the entire plate feel like salt layered upon salt. Additionally, the skin was advertised as crispy, but it lacked the crisp texture I was expecting. My husband ordered the rainbow trout stuffed with crab. It was enjoyable and probably the most balanced entrée of the evening, though it wasn't particularly memorable. For sides, I ordered the wild mushrooms, and my husband chose the risotto. The risotto had good flavor but seemed slightly undercooked. The mushroom side was also on the salty side, and despite being described as "wild mushrooms," it consisted primarily of portobello mushroom.

Photos
Entry hall looking nice
Entry hall looking nice
Watermelon Salad -- juicy watermelon with watercress, red onions, pickled Fresno chilis, pistachios, Castelvetrano olives, min...
Watermelon Salad -- juicy watermelon with watercress, red onions, pickled Fresno chilis, pistachios, Castelvetrano olives, min...
Ricotta Siciliana -- creamy whipped ricotta piled with grilled corn, blistered cherry tomatoes, and fresh watercress, finished...

See all

Ricotta Siciliana -- creamy whipped ricotta piled with grilled corn, blistered cherry tomatoes, and fresh watercress, finished...
Cava Mezze - Olney

Cava Mezze - Olney

4.3
(501 reviews)
0.2 mi
$$

7.17.26 It had been…read moreover nine years since my last visit. I came in for an early dinner on a Friday afternoon to catch up with a friend who was a former colleague and is retired. We were hoping to find a quiet table where we could enjoy a long conversation. Unfortunately, we later discovered it didn't matter where we sat because the restaurant was so loud that it was difficult to hear each other. That aside, we thoroughly enjoyed the service provided by the charming and personable Andrew. My friend had several questions and special requests, and he remained professional, patient, and accommodating throughout our visit. Andrew started us off with complimentary pita bread. We initially paired it with the harissa, but found it a bit too spicy for our tastes, so we asked for butter and olive oil instead. We ordered the spanakopita, chicken souvlaki, gyros, and loukoumades for dessert. Of the four dishes, the gyros were our favorite, although everything we tried was delicious. The only disappointment was the spanakopita. At $14, we felt the portion was on the small side for the price. When we arrived, there were only a few other diners, but within an hour the restaurant was packed. We were definitely glad we came early. Overall, we both agreed that the food and service were exceptional. The only drawback was the noise level. We had so much to catch up on, and it would have been a much more enjoyable experience if we hadn't had to compete with the volume of the restaurant just to carry on a conversation.

They have a lunch special between 11am to 2:30pm, from Mondays to Fridays called "Sandwiches &…read moreSalads". If you order a sandwich, you can get both a salad and fries with it. We started off with the salad. It is in a nice sized bowl with greens, cucumber, tomatoes, onions, green peppers and feta cheese, but it is drenched in dressing. I'll have to see if they can make the dressing optional the next time. I ordered the Cava Gyro that also came with fries. Everything was so good as I expected it to be. Perfect temperature too. The other in our party had the same thing and enjoyed their sandwich as well. For dessert I enjoyed their Greek donuts called Loukoumades. In a few pictures online it looks like it is served with the fixings already poured on the donuts - the Nutella and the honey and walnuts, but when I received the dish, each item was separate, so they put you in charge of doing the drizzling of those toppings - I like it. The donuts were round and plump (7 total) with a little sprinkling of sugar and are very airy when you eat each. It has become one of my favorites here. Joey was our server and he provided top notch service. Hope to get him again.

Photos
Cava Mezze - Olney
Gyro Platter with rice 11.30.23
Gyro Platter with rice 11.30.23
Pita (7.17.26)

See all

Pita (7.17.26)
O'Donnell's Market

O'Donnell's Market

4.5
(205 reviews)
8.2 mi
$$

Sat at the bar in back. Soft shell crabs were terrific - went with the fried option rather than…read moresautéed, quality fries and a killer kale and apple salad. My Mom had their green beans as a side and I had a few - they were crispy and very good. Too many places over cook things. Waitress behind the bar was great. Nice 'neighborhoody' casual atmosphere. First time here - will hopefully be back within a few weeks. Five stars, albeit based on one visit Decent beer selection, nothing I hadn't had before. But that's a personal problem, not a restaurant problem. ;-)

Three stars for the nostalgia of rum buns alone. Been meaning to stop by this place for YEARS and…read morefinally made it! Any Marylander of the Boomer and GenX generation knows about O'Donnell's RUM BUNS. I used to come here with family back in its heyday and these were served table side before our meal. How crazy is that, a nice lil somewhat sinful dessert BEFORE some MD crab?! Those were the days! The rum buns are more nostalgia more than anything, I wouldn't say they'll blow your socks off, but hey, nostalgia is nostalgia. Well, I'll need to dine in here for a full and complete verdict, but my quick grab and go visit was a tad chaotic. Service for taking orders could improve - you walk in, there's a seafood counter to your left, bakery counter to your right (both were unmanned when I walked in) and in the middle is a deli section with the cash register where I assume they take orders. We stood there for a few good minutes before getting anyone's attention despite the fact a manager asking staff (not customers) if everyone was being helped. Clearly staff did not know who was waiting to check out, take orders or just waiting for their orders to arrive. So it was just weird. No one greeting you as you walk in either, it just also weird because there's no clear line anywhere you stand. Otherwise, rum buns were as I remembered them. Also picked up crab dip and chicken salad from the grab and go section from the back and they were just ok, not bad, not great. So will come again for a future visit hoping to have a much better meal and experience!

Photos
Items you can purchase
Items you can purchase
Birthday cake cheesecake (March Special)
Birthday cake cheesecake (March Special)
Inside

See all

Inside
GrillMarx Steakhouse & Raw Bar

GrillMarx Steakhouse & Raw Bar

3.6
(640 reviews)
0.2 mi
$$

It was our first time at GrillMarX in Olney, and overall it was a very good experience. The place…read morewas packed when we arrived, and it was pretty noisy inside, so sitting outside turned out to be the right call. The only rough part was the welcome. The hostess seemed to avoid eye contact for about five minutes even though we were standing right in front of her. It felt a little like we had shown up too early for a surprise party that was clearly not for us. Once we were seated, everything improved. Our waitress, Paige, was attentive, thoughtful, and made the experience feel genuinely warm. We started with the mussels, which were exceptional; meaty, creamy, and delicious, with bread good enough to make restraint feel optional. We also had the mini Paloma oyster shooters, which were fun and memorable. I ordered a seasonal cocktail with very little simple syrup, since I usually do not like sweet drinks, and they got it exactly right, which is rarer than it should be. For the main course, we had the seasonal surf and turf special, an 8 oz filet mignon with crab meat over asparagus and succotash. The crust on the steak was excellent, the vegetables were perfectly seasoned, and the filet was cooked exactly as ordered. We finished with their newer take on key lime pie, which was very good and nicely balanced; not too sweet, not too tart. We spent just under $100 per person, so this is not an inexpensive night out. That said, the food quality and service largely justify the price. Overall, aside from the awkward start at the hostess stand, this was an excellent first visit. We spent just under $100 per person, so GrillMarX is not playing in the bargain bin, but the food and service were strong enough that we would absolutely come back

I came here on Sunday evening around 4pm for a catch-up with my best friend and this was the…read moreperfect time to come. We were seated immediately and out food came out super quickly as well. We wanted to spend most of our time talking so we only ordered an appetizer and drink. I got the half rack of ribs and a coke & she got the spinach dip and water. They both came out at the same time and was perfect to eat and chat. The only thing I would comment on is the fact our server kinda seemed like his shift was about to end and wanted us to hurry up and close our tab. The only reason I name it so specifically is because I have felt like this before when I used to work at a restaurant but the difference is that I would give the table their space and allow them to finish organically.

Photos
GrillMarx Steakhouse & Raw Bar
Surf and turf
Surf and turf
Mussels

See all

Mussels

Mamma Lucia of Olney - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...