After taking the elevator up to the restaurant, you can tell that it is a very beautiful and swanky restaurant. The decor is really top notch. We were greeted politely and warmly at the front desk and were asked to wait a few moments before being brought over to our private room, as we had a decent sized party that evening. I was pretty excited as I have heard nothing but great things over the years. Walking in, the aroma of food from other tables smelled great! I had high expectations for Reserve Cut and was anticipating a good meal. However, once we got down to ordering, I quickly realized that my expectations for the night would not be met. We tried to order multiple times from our waiter and he was always busy and popping in and out. Fine, but on top of our meal, we had to pay a special additional fee for the private room. I feel that if I have to pay an additional, quite high fee and also meet a minimum ordering fee, my server should only be serving my room/party. He also should be knowledgeable about all the items on the menu. Also, one of the women in our party is allergic to gluten- not in the oh, I'm doing "low carb" or "paleo" kind of "allergic to gluten" but would actually get sick from it for days. Every item on the menu we had to ask him at least three times if it had gluten or not- all of them he didn't know. He'd say he'd check and come back but wouldn't come back and just placed the order instead. I'm not sure if this was him being clueless, or not giving a damn. To me, that is just a very dangerous thing to do, to not really check or adhere to someone's allergies listed. Gluten allergies are quite common, so I'm surprised he didn't know at all. The waygu beef was kind of bland and didn't feel up to other places I've had waygu beef. For the prices and the hype, I just honestly expected better food and service. The ambiance here is beautiful, but unfortunately is not enough to make up for the other things I didn't like about this establishment. read more

Came here in April for a team dinner. We had a private room and the ambience was great! U would miss it because it's on 2nd floor and I was surprised that there were actually a lot of ppl when we were there on a weekday. The waiter helped us pick several appetizers. Sushi platters were good! I had a Sea bass which was soft and melting. Ppl on my team, most of them had steak and I think they really enjoyed their food. Overall it was a good experience. Typical pricey steakhouse with standard service. Would recommend if you are looking for a kosher steakhouse. read more

Reserve Cut certainly made the cut as one of NY's finest steakhouses. The joint was popping at the bar and in the elegant dining. The service was top grade and the staff under the direction of the incomparable Ghandi was on their game. Starting off with a glorious selection of sushi followed by delectable chateau b'ent and succulent double cut lamb chops was only bested by the company of the son of dearly departed friend and community leader who is a natural leader himself. Needless to say desert was decadent and over the top. I'm a big Prime Grill fan but Reserve Cut is now in my power rotation when in Gotham City. read more

My second time here. The ambiance is one of the finest in kosher dining. However, the dining experience was lackluster. The corn chowder with lamb was basically a ground lamb stew with some corn kernels in it. Not the sweet summery taste one should expect. The ribeye was very small for the price and extremely fibrous. It was very small and thin to begin with an on top of that half was inedible due to all the fibers. Literally threw it out. Spinach side dish was tasteless. Raspberry creme brûlée was pretty good. Service was very good and the waiter was attentive. I think I'm going to cut reserve cut from my regular dining. Definitely can do better in the city for the prices charged. read more

Came here last week with my husband to celebrate my birthday. I have to admit this place is really beautiful and the drinks are great. The food is good as well, however, very pricey. My husband and i spent 400 dollars with the tip in total. Him and i were very shocked. Some guy wrote that they included a 20 percent service charge but that didn't happen to us (thank God!). Great service good food but 4 starts because the prices are out of this world. read more

Came here for restaurant week lunch. I ordered salad, filet mignon, sorbet. All very good. Love the steak. My friend's soup and cadence chocolate are good too.I would recommend it. read more

See all

Reserved cut is one of the best steakhouse I've been to , customer service is quick and spontaneous to helping us order. The appetizers and the main courses was So good I can't even describe with a great selection of wine, this place is awesome but a little Expensive but you expect it because it's on Wall Street I would highly recommend!! read more

Reserve Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Best food I've had, and being this pricey I must say it's the only time I could say it was well worth is. The service as well was unbelievable. Did not order desert, but when we left the hostess had packed us free deserts on our way out. If youre in the city and craving a kosher steak, THIS is the place. read more

Huge well decorated Restatant. The ambiance is on point. Taco, short rib, lamb slider, appetizers are delicious. The deserts I tasted were great apple pie, snickers. Anyway I was there a bit earlier then the rest of the party, but I couldn't sit at the bar since it was closed for a private party. The men's washroom should be refreshed more often towards the end of the night 8:00. The service was pretty good. They were eager to please the guests. Waiters actually told me I over tipped and refunded me part of the tip. About $190 p/p all in. read more

10/10 for food, ambiance, and service! We have been here about 4 times and have never been disappointed. The food is very well done and the attention to detail in food, presentation, and in the restaurant overall are supreme. Yes, its expensive but we go here for special occasions and I always have felt like I got what I paid for, which is not always the case at other places. Oh + its kosher! read more

Went in on a double date for Valentine's Day. As soon as we walked in the mood was off. Our server seemed so forced and was like a robot. Caesar salad was like actual iceberg lettuce and was not appetizing, steak was good but again not the best in the city. Food overall was good but not GREAT so I really don't think I would ever be back. read more

Reserve Cut - Tuna appetizer - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Was there Sunday evening for dinner. One of us Ordered the Filet Minon and asked it to med rare, also ordered the bone on rib steak and the Branzino fish. French fries and Short rib tacos. Where do i begin. The 1st filet came very overdone. the rib steak was burnt. The waiter agreed on the steaks being over done and quickly replaced them. The Filet came over done again and was watching my guest trying to cut it with great difficulties. Waiter again observed and immediately took it off the check and returned it. The Rib steak came and was not burnt but also not great. the fries were over done as well. The fish was hospital food bland to put it simply. So as for the very high price of a meal and not good food i recommend avoiding this place. They were very nice as to not charge us for the filet and gave us 2 deserts on the house. But still would never return. Sorry ! read more

Went for dinner with my friend and had a great experience!! The food was amazing, we shared some sushi, my favorite the Yellowstone for sure, and the Short Rib Tacos, very good and very different version of tacos. We also had the Apple Tart for dessert, which was great even though I'm not a fan of apple desserts, and of course the Chocolate Tasting, which as a chocolate lover have to say it's one of the best chocolate desserts I ever had. Very good and attentive service as well. Coming back for some pastry for sure!! read more

This is by far the best restaurant I have ever been to in my entire life. Me and my family went to dinner over the holidays. The sushi was incredible. I mean really really incredible. Rivaling Katsuya or any other trendy very fancy sushi restaurant. Soup of the day it was delicious. All of their sides are so good. I highly recommend the brussels sprouts. This is all so, like, the only kosher restaurant to even serve brussels sprouts. Highly recommend. read more

Didn't eat here...but their customer service is over the top!!! We stopped in to grab some drinks, but they were CLOSED until 5pm. Ughhhhhhhhhh. But guess what? For these out of towners, the manager opened the bar early. SCORE. Amazing drinks, amazing service. Go here. read more

My husband and I came for his birthday and when I say that every single item came out wrong/bad, I mean every single item. We ordered the Cote de boeuf and they gave us the special which was a chateaubriand. Unfortunately we didn't realize until after so they couldn't swap it out but still charged us for the special. Then I preordered the soufflé so that we wouldn't have to wait too long and when dessert came out, they brought out the s'mores bar. When I asked for our dessert their response was that we gave us the s'mores bar on the house for the mixup with the steak and said if I wanted the soufflé it would be another 15 minutes. The cauliflower side was so bland we didn't eat it. The tacos were way too sweet and had so much juice it made the taco shell soft. Overall horrible experience. read more

We organized an event here and had very poor experience with the service the events team and everything that followed up. The food was ok but I will not recommend this place for a company or private events. They do not respect any signed agreements and refuse to acknowledge client concerns. Now reading through the reviews, I see that other people had a very similar experience. I will never bring any clients to this restaurant again. read more

I don't usually write reviews but i must give credit where credit is due. I have been to this restaurant 3 times now and every time has been amazing! The restaurant is beautiful, spacious and clean. The food (the most important part:)) is very delicious, you cant go wrong from the waygu steak (which is to die for) to the short rib tacos to the sushi, all of our food was delicious, cooked to perfection and beautifully presented. The service is very good too. The manager his name is Ridvan is attentive, helpful and professional, he helped us pair our food with the right wine. He and his team always make sure we have good time. This place is a GEM and its turning to be my favorite spot! read more

This place is definitely pricy but you get very nice ambiance and the lovely staff complementary. The space is large but a little hard to find on the second floor. Although it says steak house they have an extensive sushi menu and it's white good! Definitely check this place out if you are need Wall Street. read more

Zef the man took care of me and my buddy all he recommended was delicious and service by him was amazing thank you ..dinner was fantastic!!

I had the 22 oz. Wagyu steak. Excellent and very tender as the reviews state. The give you just the right amount and it is complimented well with the pear and marrow. I will come again one day to enjoy. read more

Reserve Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Great experience, decor is very nice. I went there for the first time with colleagues, the dishes we ordered were perfect. Great wine selection and the staff is very accommodating. read more

Reserve Cut - Fabulous Almond Cake - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Wow. Incredible food only matched by their incredibly friendly and courteous staff. Highly recommend the Delmonico steak if you can go on Thursday. Brought the family with three little kids and everyone had a great time and the whole experience was amazing! read more

Amazing food and amazing service, great selection of different foods and a chefs that serves a good meal. read more

Reserve Cut - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Get the reserve cut!!! Amazing!!! And the sushi! we had great experiences with private parties...

This is BY FAR my favorite place. Best Kosher steak house in NY and maybe in the world!!! First, SERVICE. from the hostess to the Manager, the stuff at Reserve Cut are highly attentive and so kind!!! To me, that's the main reason to come over and over again. (it's been already 4 years, every week... Never gets boring!) Now, obviously the Steak is the main reason go to RC, but don't skip on their appetizers and Sushi menu- every special roll there is incredible. Specially the Chilean sea bass roll and The Seared Hamachi. Food is incredibly great!!! Biggest selection of Kosher wines (you would notice right when you get there) And always creative with new cocktails! What else? Place is just beautiful. Ambiance is classy and Romantic! Great place for business meetings, romantic dinner or for any special occasion. LOVE IT!!!!! read more

Was there with my kids. The waiter are sales people recommending to highest ticket on the menue. Food was ok but way over priced Price doesn't justify the food quality. read more

Reserve Cut is an excellent steakhouse with a unique identity and atmosphere, the GM Alessandro and the Owner Albert are fantastic hosts and it truly feels like home. The ambience is extremely elegant and the service is five stars .... the bar/lounge is great for cocktails and bites .... love it read more

The food at this restaurant is far below the standards for non-kosher restaurants. In addition, the wait staff were horrible, as if it was everyone's first day as a waiter. read more

Good place with great service. I got my birthday dinner there. Nice location , staff was very friendly and our waitress was trying to do everything we wanted. Nice and calm atmosphere. Food was pretty good also. It's a high class of glatt kosher restaurants so be ready to pay extra for that, but if it's not a problem you have to visit that place for a nice dinner! read more

I have to admit, I was quite skeptical about having a "great" steak in a kosher restaurant. Yes, I have had good but never great. Well, last night I had one of the best bone in Rib Eyes I have ever had, ANYWHERE. KOSHER OR NON KOSHER! A 20 oz steak, requested and served Pittsburg Medium. The sides were perfectly cooked as were the cocktails. WARNING - if you are looking for a bargain, do not enter! If you are looking for quality and willing to pay for it, you will be happy you found this gem! read more

Very disappointed with management. I was visiting NYC, went there with my nephew Sunday night before 2019 New Years. Ordered some food and coke. Food was okay, nothing extraordinary. Then comes the bill and I see a $25 charge for coke!!!! I thought to myself, it's probably a mistake. When I brought it to the waiter, I was told NYC does not have refills on coke!!!!! I am not from NY, so how could I knew when nobody told me. I was thirsty and kept asking for refills. At the end, instead of taking the charges off my bill, I was given another glass of coke. At this point was already done with my meal and was not thirsty at all. SUCH A DISAPPOINTMENT!!!!!! read more

All the great things a steakhouse should be (perfectly cooked rare steak with good service). And on top of it, it's kosher! Make sure you reserve in advance. read more

Had dinner last night. Was just okay. 2 filets that were just very dry - not over cooked, just dry and tasteless. Third guest had sea bass and said it was pretty good. My side of bernaise was thin and lacked any consistency. For sides the Brussels were ok but could not compare to so many creative and tasty ways that Brussel sprouts are being served elsewhere. Spicy green beans a little better. Kobe carpaccio was lacking for nearly $40..... I was very disappointed with the depth on the wine list. My $125 bottle was again okay. But not great. I "settled" on a bottle for $125. That should not be in a steak house.... $600 for dinner for 3 is not uncommon, but all 3 guests left disappointed. I won't be back. A positive was the attentive servers. I did not need to ask for anything. My experience was very different than what I read from others. read more

I wish I could give them zero stars. Crappy steak and even crappier service. The management (and even the front of house people pre-COVID) need to learn how to talk to customers in a polite and respectful way. read more

We had a very bad experienc. The food was not edible with a very unprofessional new waiter. We went home hungry and paid a fat bill.

Best steak ever. Great service. Great portions. Very happy with this place ! Next time I'm in NYC I definitely be back!

Beautiful ambiance, very knowledgeable & attentive staff. I ordered the tacos & ribs as an appetizer, both were tasty, especially the ribs. Ordered a ($209!) 28oz Wagyu steak with mashed potatoes & string beans for my main dish, plus the chocolate lava-type cake for dessert... all of it was delicious!! One minus - the prices were extremely high. Otherwise, a great night out! read more

As a vegetarian, a steakhouse is not exactly the first place I'd choose for a meal, however, Reserve Cut has much more to offer on its menu. I have tried the Pre-fixe menu, which is decent, but I opted to order directly off the menu the second time, which was a better decision. I was pleasantly surprised with the signature RC salad, it was fresh and creative. The molten lava cake was also exceptional. Staff is extremely attentive and the atmosphere is perfect for a business lunch. read more

I'd never heard of Reserve Cut before eating there, but after stepping into what looks like a generic office building in FiDi and going upstairs, you find yourself in what is a deceptively large restaurant with low lighting and a really cozy feel and ambiance out by the bar. While there's a little bit of seating out front, we (along with most other diners, it seemed) ended up in the back in a similarly low-lit dining room that is past a couple of minimalist fountains and the wine racks. Even when it fills up, it was still easy to chat with folks around the table, and the servers were great at getting stuff to us quick and making sure no one was without a beverage. One thing to note is that the prices are on the higher side here for everything, and it was a little bit of sticker shock when I first took a look. That said, it is worth it - the food here is extremely good, with nothing really striking an off-note. We shared a bunch of sushi for the table, and while I wouldn't say that you should cancel your reservation at a high-end sushi counter to eat here, it was above what I had expected - the fish was fresher than I would have thought, and the rolls were quite decent too...they weren't overpacked with rice as they can be at times. I remember less about the rest of the appetizers, although the sashimi tacos stuck out as being delicious. The steak, though, is absolutely phenomenal...I went with the Prime Reserve Cut, and what a treat that was. The cut of the steak was superb - the texture reminded me a bit of flank steak, but it ate like the prime rib - and cooked medium with a little bit of garlic, it had so much flavor without needing to be dressed up. On its own, the steak was arguably one of the best I have eaten anywhere, even if the price is steeper than some other places. All of the sides The pricing is definitely on the higher side, but it is arguably worth the extra amount in some (if not all) cases. It's worth a visit to try the steak, although you may come out feeling disappointed when other meats don't quite measure up...that is how I have felt at some meals since I have been here! read more