Ambiance (3/5): A lovely space but tight table setting (so tight that the back of my seat was against someone else's, in order to get out, I had to have my seated companion leave their seat to leave mine...). Seating available at the bar as well. A cockroach was spotted outside the bathroom area!! Service (3/5): The owner was very friendly but not helpful when asked what the different red wines were and instead insisted on the most expensive one. I would suggest other patrons do a little research beforehand if you are unfamiliar with Italian wines. Wait staff did not speak English so we had to wait for the owner to get off his phone call, as he was the only one getting orders and closing bills. Expect the experience to take at least an hour 30 min if you are going before the show. Food (2/5): We came out with an expensive bill (1 $17 bottle of wine, 2 apps, 3 entrees for 4 pp @ $270) for the portion and taste. Warm table bread with olive oil - this was great Caesar Salad (5/5): The salad was fresh and tasted great. It was large enough to share with 4 of us. Special menu - Octopus (3/5) $27ish: One singular tiny octopus leg for almost $30. Parts of the octopus was overcooked, but it did have a lovely taste to it. Served with a butter knife which made it difficult to cut. Special menu - 47oz Steak (2/5) $45ish: Well seasoned. The meat was incredibly tough. Surprised to see how small the dish turned out to be. It was nice that it came pre-sliced. Branzino (3/5) $44: A lackluster filet fish with little flavor on an even smaller portioned dish. This was the biggest disappoint of the entrees Stracotto alla Toscana (5/5) ($45): This was by far the best dish of the night. The beef was super tender and had sizable portion and stewed in a sauce that soaked up all the flavor. The menu mentioned carrots and none were included... read more

See all

Really odd (infuriating, excruciatingly slow. Agreeable but just won't do anything as requested) service. Delicious fresh pizza. read more

Via Toscana - Tapas Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

10000/10 experience!! It is very authentic and it was such an amazing experience! All the staff was so amazing and made our experience exceptional!! The drinks, alcoholic and non alcoholic Shirley temple had these fun lights in them! The starters were all fantastic! The calamari was so thinly battered it had such a great flavor and wasn't all breading like some calamari's. The tuna tartar was so fresh I could not believe i got such fresh tuna in New York! The vodka pasta was incredible. We added some Parmesan cheese to it and it was so delicious! The tirimisu was amazing!!! All the prices were so reasonable and we will for sure be back thanks to the incredible food and the outstanding service- we really did feel like family!! read more

See all

service was great food was just okay, the starter bread was good and the moscato. we got the rice balls as an appetizer but they were overcooked (waiter took it off the bill without us asking! so that was great) - The ravioli was really good but i wish it came with more than 2 for the price. the rigatoni with meat sauce was good but bland, not too many complaints. read more

See all

Definitely a fine "grab dinner before a show" type place, but not somewhere I'd frequent - especially for Italian (pasta, pizza, etc). The pizza was ok but definitely expensive for what it was. It gave vibes that it was cooked in like a toaster oven. The pasta was ok, but said it came with "baby shrimp" and then had three medium to large size shrimp on it? The martinis also weren't great. The inside does have a really cool vibe though. Service was also fine - we went early so it wasn't busy. read more

See all

Brand new happy hour menu and arancini wow. This is a must wow and their seevice and staff amazing. read more

Via Toscana - Tapas Bars Near Me - New York, New York

The food was delicious here and the owner was our server and was very fun. I got the mushroom Tartuffe and my husband got the lasagna and both were amazing. The decor was clean and the only thing I'll say is I wish it the decor inside was more vibrant to reflect how fun the owner was and how flavorful the food was! We would definitely go back! read more

Their dishes consistently meet high standards. Staff members make you feel welcome. This place has earned my regular business. Their menu shows culinary creativity while delivering standout taste experiences. This spot creates complete pleasure. read more

We wanted to choose a restaurant on the same street where we were attending a show. I read the Yelp reviews prior to booking this restaurant. We were greeted, seated, and served by the chef owner. He was delightful and entertaining. We first ordered drinks and enjoyed our conversation with the owner. The restaurant is long and narrow, with patio dining weather permitting. The ambiance was warm and comfortable. We relied on the owner choices on appetizers and entrees. Before any food came, we already downed our second drinks. I love to provide a review of our menu choices, but I have little memory of how good they were. I ordered the bronzino, and I believe it was delicious. We were spending most of our dining experience hanging out with the chef owner, which was actually informative and fun. . read more

The plates are not even the right size for a kid. Also, I got something called "stuffed artichoke" and it was literally just three leaves with some sauce on top. I understand what a gourmet restaurant is, but this was a joke. read more

Came during happy hour on a Tuesday. The choice of wine for happy hour was honestly the best I've ever seen... and $8-$10 per glass. We also had some happy hour appetizer's that were great (meatballs and bruschetta) read more

There are so many words that might capture the essence but all I can say is it is in the secret sauces! No matter where I go in the world, it's only old school New York Italian that's pounded out to the thinnest most delicious and lovely dish. Don't miss this small intimate traditional place - you might even hear chef's soprano if you're lucky read more

See all

My friend and I came here for dinner last night. We arrived for an early dinner and we were seated right away. The interior is quite dark, but had decent lighting. The service was good and attentive during our meal. We each ordered the fiore blanco which was pretty good, but they had these odd lights at the bottom of the drinks and we weren't quite sure of the purpose or if it was just for presentation. For food, we ordered the watermelon salad to share and then I got the fettuccine Alfredo and my friend ordered the hanger steak. We also ordered the chocolate mousse to share, which was probably my favorite dish of the night. The salad and entrees were perfectly fine, but nothing to write home about. I don't think I'd come here again, unfortunately. read more

Via Toscana - Interior - Tapas Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My group and I went here in Nov 2023 and looked forward to coming again. The food was divine and the service was great. This time around, not so much. To begin with, compared to the last time we were here, the place was dead. We all wondered what we were missing. After the food came we knew why it was dead on a Saturday at 6pm. The portions shrunk by half but the prices stayed the same! We were all in shock when we got our food. The portion was borderline ridiculous for a dinner portion and price. The service was half as good. The waitress simply didn't take half of the drink orders and we kept having to call her back over for everyone to order their cocktails. The drinks were fine. I'm so upset, as this was our groups favorite restaurant. Pictures show a comparison of the Nov 2023 portion to the Now. I understand inflation, but I would almost prefer paying more and the portions staying the same. Not shrinking! Overall, the food is great but the disappointment in difference of price and service is too much to ignore. read more

See all

Food was perfect. Excellent atmosphere. Service was excellent as well. Definitely would recommend.

Food, service, and ambiance at 10pm on a Sunday was unquestionably the best experience ever. Our waiter was on it! He was very attentive, had great mannerism, and provided us great service. The food in itself was the most authentic and fresh Italian food I have ever had. The calamari was fresh, light, and the sauce was powerful and delicious. The bread served had a perfect light and airy crunch that was to die for! My pasta... SPEECHLESS! read more

Via Toscana - Tapas Bars Near Me - New York, New York

I don't usually book reservations at places with only a handful reviews, and as of the day of our reservation, Via Toscana had 12 reviews. We loved the menu and decided to check it out for ourselves. Plainly put -- Via Toscana was a delight from start to finish. The service was impeccable, and the chef owner greeted us, sat us, and took our orders. The drinks were delicious, and the meals were *chefs kiss* Get more patrons in this place! It was fantastic! read more

Went to Via Toscana, the place was very nice. The music was not loud so one can talk. Had their octopus which was super tender and yummy. A great local wine . Excellent mains, I had the short rib. The dessert almond cake was yummy. The owner was super nice and definitely worth going there for some Italian fare. Give it a try. read more

The ambience, food quality and presentation, wine choices, and attentive staff were exceptional! We were not rushed and thoroughly enjoyed our visit! read more

Via Toscana - Radicchio salad with goat cheese, and cranberries - Tapas Bars Near Me - New York, New York

I just moved to 52nd and this is going to be my new local Italian place! The decor is interesting, but the food here is truly authentic. It's the best I've had in the city since spending a month in Italy. Try their amatriciana with homemade pasta, great happy hour specials, and fire cheese plates. Will be back! read more

Via Toscana - Happy hour wine - Tapas Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Great authentic food. Fast service, owner was warm, cordial attentive. Small & intimate atmosphere. A fine nyc gem. read more

See all

I had a fried chicken dish that was dry and bland. My wife's pasta simplici's tomato sauce was also Bland, with a strong unseasoned tomato flavor. The meatballs were tasty, however as was the caprese. read more

Excellent service! Remarkable atmosphere. Great menu. Every dish offered to our party of 6 was a showstopper. Do not miss this hidden gem! read more

food was very poor. seafood was not fresh, the osso bucco was horrid, it and rest of main courses were sent back. at least the restaurant did not charge us. the restaurant was 90% empty, bad sign because other restaurants within a block were packed full. read more

What a lucky find. A great place for pre or post theater. Or dinner. Or late night cocktails. Perfectly situated close to the theater district but on fifty second street so it's not overrun and you kind of have to know it's there. A gorgeous restaurant/ wine bar owned by the most lovely gentleman from Italy who oversees the delicious menu and beautiful and inventive bar. So many interesting wines and liquers. Everything we had, from drinks to dinner to dessert, was excellent. It's such a great place to hang out. If you are out with a bunch of friends I can't imagine a more friendly, welcoming and comfortable place than here. Drinks, tapas, pizza, dinner or snacks. I hope everyone discovers it because I want it so succeed so I can keep going back. read more

See all

Great authentic Italian food, great happy hour also. Also a good selection of Italian wines, will be back

Andreas was an amazing host. The food was amazing. Authentic Italian food with amazing ambiance.

Exceptional service and great Italian food. The staff were warm and welcoming. They made our evening one to remember- Thank you. I will be back! read more

The place smells bad. We are unsure what caused the odor but we sat down and looked at each other and walked out. The first time I have ever done this. Not sure how they are getting such good reviews. Read the one star reviews. They all talk of the smell. I think they must ask friends and family to post reviews read more

I discovered this place with of my Italian friends from Massa Carrara. I love the authenticity of the Italian taste of chef Alessandro dishes e manager Andrea's welcoming demeanor. I go to Tuscany every and I miss the taste of Italy when I return but Via Toscana takes magically takes me there with every bite. read more

See all

Great neighborhood Italian restaurant!! Homey ambiance with amazing food. Everything we ordered was a hit - we got the octopus appetizer, meatballs (yum), branzino, and homemade spaghetti. We'll definitely be back for more! read more

Via Toscana - Spaghetti Al Pomodoro Fresco Meatball - Tapas Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Fantastic food, great service, terrific chef. Nice atmosphere. I live in NYC and love Italian food. I'm so excited that I found this place which I'll be going back to again and again. My friends and I had the Ceaser's Salad, fried calamari -- both terrific appetizers. For entrees we had pasta bolognese, pasta with mushroom truffle and hanger steak with truffle sauce. Every single dish was outstanding. Cocktails were good too. Did not have time for dessert. Do not hesitate. it's delicious. read more

Fabulous experience! The food is divine, fresh and authentic , while the service is impeccable! The owner, Andrea , is the most inviting and friendly person. He was such a delight to talk to. This place needs to be around for a long time!! read more

Service was excellent. Food was fresh and authentic, but serving size was small. The restaurant was clean but a bit too dark. Bring your phone for a flashlight! read more

On Saturday February 18th, my husband and I had the pleasure of having dinner at Via Toscana. A new amazing restaurant. We were greeted by the owner and Chef Andrea. Their were so many delicious choices and we could not decide on what to eat. Chef Andrea took the liberty of preparing us so many dishes. They were all absolutely delicious. The ambiance is elegant and the staff was so gracious. Via Toscana is a new gem to the neighborhood and a must try. We have found our new favorite restaurant. read more

We've been in the city for almost 7 years and this place opens up and blows everything out of proportion. Small family owned and original NY experience and quality. A secret spot for now. read more

Two blocks from the Gershwin Theatre...pretty place, nice atmosphere, great attentive service, and absolutely FANTASTICO food! I was extremely comfortable from the moment we arrived. The owner is friendly, and his staff, other than not really understanding English, which did not impact the service AT ALL, were on the ball. I cannot wait to go back here! Talk about a hidden gem...and I'm Siciliano/Italiano!! read more

Great new restaurant! The owner was very friendly and makes for a wonderful experience. Food is delicious! Definitely recommend read more

See all

Amazing food! Great ambiance. Fabulous service. Came for a girls night before a show and was above and beyond! Thank you!

Love this place! The service and Isaiah the bartender and the owner Andrea are amazing. The food is unbeatable. You will not be disappointed!! Way better than many spots I've been to in the city read more