Almost like NY pizza if all you want is a good slice and some great lemonade. Wish they made dinners and lunches too ! Vito's also has calzones . Pretty short menu but still on point ! read more

I used to love this pizza and I would recommend it to everybody but, it has change. They did something different and it taste very bland and oily. I wouldn't recommend this place. It's a shame they changed something. I wish they would go back to their old recipe. read more

Sad writing this because this use to be my go to. Ordered one night and took almost two hours to get my delivery. Tried calling after hours numerous times and nobody answered (granted it was past 9) when the pizza finally came it was wrong and looked like the driver had dropped it. No biggie mistakes happen. Next time I called I explained what happend the previous time and the lady got an attitude and said it's impossible that happened because they always answer the phone. I mean she was a total b**** about it. Pizza is good but the customer service is hot dog water. Never give them another dime read more

Yum. Enough said. Never had a bad experience here. Food is always delicious hot and fresh.

Best pizza in town! I will drive the extra 15 minutes from Argyle to eat here..

This is what it's all about, Yeeps. I love Vito's simply because they're Vito's. They don't need 50 different kinds of pizza, pasta and accompaniments to set themselves apart from the rest. They do NY style pizza, and they do it well...so well, in fact, that they've been a fixture in the community for years and years...and this is a tiny, no-frills, family-owned establishment, not a big-name chain. It's located in the Blanding Square Shopping Center (next to McD's), on the corner of Blanding and Jefferson, Orange Park area. Eats: $2.99 for two large one-topping slices and a drink, $3.99 for the three slice special, and a large 1-topping pizza is $7.99 That's some awesome deals, especially if you're rolling on a tight budget. I got my two slices with bacon, and they were LOADED with thick yummy bacon. No, these weren't bits...but good sized real-deal bacon pieces. The sauce was pleasant as well, as it wasn't overpowering, but instead played an equal part to all other components. Being that it's a NY style thin crust, I was a little worried that, at such a good price, taste and/or texture would be compromised. To my relief...nope. The crust served as the perfect vessel, providing just the right amount of crunch to complement the cheesy, bacon-topped goodness. It may not be the best slice I've ever had in my life, but it's definitely a true contender, and the top ranked for value! All-in-all, I'll go out on a limb and vouch for this joint and call it a definite hidden gem. "So why the 5 stars?" you ask? Easy. As I sat eating, I looked around this 7-8 table basically nondescript joint, only to find, upon closer inspection...that their walls are filled with "Thank You" plaques, pictures, and letters. All coming from various local youth sports teams, schools, charities, and organizations that they've contributed to throughout the years. THROUGHOUT. THE. YEARS. They don't pump money into chic decor, instead they let their food speak for itself and give back to their community. This experience alone amplified my profound admiration for the family-run joints out there that struggle day-to-day to make it. From the Lunchbox Deli to the Whiteway Deli...whether by European Street or Maple Street...support your local restaurants and businesses! For great service, food, and value 5 stars and 2 thumbs way up for Vito's! read more

Vitos Pizzeria - 2 slice lunch special with bacon! - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Naomi B, you were spot on. :-) Nothing special or in your face, nothing that would make me run home and tell mama. Just great NY style pizza, with prices I wish all other business would mimick and a warm staff. They obviously love what they do and don't need to throw a parade to do it! The Walls of Appreciation is pretty impressive too...that on top of everything else mentioned is what gets these folks a strong 4 stars from me. I have only been a couple of times so once I get a more thorough experience, my rating will probably be bumped up or down, depending. Simply put, this is a great lil mom 'n' pop pizza joint! read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Wall of appreciation :-) - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

The best pizza place in Florida. I go here every Friday, and I'm always greeted by the workers and owners. They are fast and efficient in producing high quality pizza with the perfect amount of cheese, the best ratio of sauce and the soft crust pulling it all into one. I highly recommend going here with your family and friends and giving this restaurant a try. read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

My husband and I had a craving for pizza. Tired of the same "chain pizza", we searched for something different. We found Vito's and were excited to try it out. We went after 2pm and this place was fairly busy the whole time we were there. It's a fairly small restaurant with only six or seven tables, but don't let the size fool you! The menu is simple, mostly serving pizza, calzones and cannoli. We ordered a large pizza with three toppings: pepperoni, bacon, and onions. They pile the toppings on too! The price was great and most of all the pizza tasted awesome! The crust is a thin New York style with a very nice texture and flavor! The sauce was tasty too! Our children raved about this pizza after they gobbled down the leftovers! The servers were super nice also. The prices are very reasonable. We will definitely eat at Vito's again! read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Pepperoni, bacon & onions - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Our pizzas were delish. We got Supreme and Meat eaters. Cooked to perfection! This is our go to place from now on! No pics this time.

We're originally from NJ so we were on a mission to find good pizza. We tried almost every pizza place in the area and Vito's was the closest thing we could find to a slice of NJ. Now we get pizza from here every other week! read more

This been happening for about two weeks now first time the pizza was very undercooked toppings slid off the pizza my family decided to try again tonight our pizzas where very stale they looked like they where sitting up on that oven for hours not 30 mins the pepperoni with red sauce was cold as well i called to complain but got a busy signal every time the staff need to know how to better handle the large number of crowds they are receiving best in clay county isnt a very true statement unless fixed i will not be back read more

See all

This spot is dirty and disgusting. Nobody wore a mask while preparing the food. Everyone working there was around 18U so obviously they didn't care. Tables were not wiped down, and insects were flying around. If you want to risk getting COVID I'm sure you'll get it here. We also waited over an hour for our pizza and it came out floppy as can be. Had to get it sent back to the kitchen and by that time I lost my appetite. Wouldn't recommend this pizza joint. Pizza wasn't good at all and that's coming from an Italian himself. Try elsewhere. read more

Met the owner "Vito" and he was the one making the pizza himself...which really impressed me since I was able to watch him make the pie. Best Pizza in Orange Park!!! read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Lunch specials are amazing! Fresh hot and ready in minutes. Friendly staff and clean environment. read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Lunch special $3.99 -3 slice deal with drink (paid extra for the deluxe slice BUT WORTH IT!) Fresh Hot and ooooo so yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

The only reason I'm giving this a 2 star rating is because of the receptionist who answered the phone and very pleasantly took my order and also the delivery person who was very nice and earlier than what was expected. This is our 2nd and last time ordering from here. The first time we asked that the pizza to be cooked extra-what we Got was a super crispy burned pizza. This time we didn't ask for the cooking extra On the pizza and calzone, we just let that be. OMG! What was delivered was pizza and calzone soup! UGH!! You couldn't pick up the pizza, everyone of the ingredients just slid right off while the pizza just flopped like a wet rag. The calzone was awful-the bottom was mushy as if it had been sitting in its own sauce for quite a while. I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND this restaurant to anyone, or, eat at You Own Risk. read more

Had a calzone last night! Absolutely delicious! Definitely my go to spot for Pizza and now Calzones too! 2 calzones and 2 drinks were 17 bucks and change!! Can't beat that!! read more

Let me start with the staff. They were very friendly and despite our showing up (without our knowing their hours) about 15 minutes before closing they made us feel welcomed and not rushed. Next for the food. I had the calzone with pepperoni and sausage added and it was more than I could eat. It was extremely good. My family ordered a specialty pizza and also thought it was very good. Last the price. For $23 my family were extremely well fed and we took almost half of the food home for later. read more

Apparently no one in this area knows good pizza, because the pizza at Vitos tastes like school cafeteria pizza. Bland sauce, soggy crust, just yuck. read more

Pizza was delicious, hot, and served with a smile. This business has come a long way and I am so grateful they are around my neighborhood.

Fast service TERRIBLE pizza... crust was extremely thin but wasn't thoroughly cooked (I don't even know how that happens) the cheese fell right off the bread. I don't know what and where they got the mushrooms from but it was GOD AWFUL (they were like pickled mushrooms, is that a thing?). There were hardly any meat, it was just bad. I thought I had terrible pizza before but this tops it. We ordered the DELUXE PIZZA-picture is self explanatory. Don't waste your money here. $16 plus $4 tip. Save your money. read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Theee absolute worst! - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Had an order delivered to my home today by my nephew in N.Y. When the driver came to my door I told them I didnt order a pizza that was because it was a surprise. The driver went to his car to verify the order instead of coming back to my door he left. I found out who was kind to order me pizza and I contacted the pizza place. I called at 6:15 pm and was told by a girl that she was there and understood and would get the pizza re delivered. It is now 7:45 pm and still no pizza. I called back and this time I got a boy on the phone that was very nasty. I was trying to find out where this pizza and desert was and he said lady do you want to order a pizza or not. I said to him I was checking on am order and he said again lady you ordering a pizza or not. I told him the pizza was paid for and I was wondering why the girl at 6:15 pm was delivering it and it was not here. He said to me well we are closing in 15 minutes and your not getting it. I asked for his name he wouldnt provide it nor give me the manager or owners name. This was uncalled for and rude. You would think with Covid-19 and all the liss of revenue these small business had and wanting locals to support small business this is one I will not frequent. How rude of someone to talk to me like he did. Does he know perhaps I have more job no money and someone was feeding my family. Totally disgusting people. I will not use them Inwill jot reccomend them to anyone. Theres plenty of pizza places in Middleburg. read more

Awesome pizza by the slice. Terrific service and very friendly staff. 2 slices and a drink for CHEAP!$. I will definitely make this a weekly lunch stop. read more

Some of the best pizza I have ever eaten. Crust is perfect nice and light not too thick yet holds all the toppings. Crust hand made every day and toppings fresh cut. Had a large with 5 toppings and 2 drinks for less than $20. Family run with friendly staff. This is what I think about when I think of a "pizza joint". They don't try to be anything else and are successful! read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Large with extra cheese, jalapeño, mushrooms, pepperoni, and Italian sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

I'm sure it's great if you're dining in since they do have good pizza. If you're ordering delivery...save yourself the hassle. You'll have to give them all of your info everytime you call and they think Excel is a point of sale system. You'll get pizzas with all of the toppings slopped off to the side and the box dropping with grease. You'll hear repeatedly that its a new driver issue and they'll offer you a new pizza. If you don't mind waiting 2 hours for your replacement pizza then go with Vito's. read more

Vitos Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

What can I say other than great New York style pizza. Prices are incredibly reasonable and the staff is super friendly. If you are in the area you must give this place a try! read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Large cheese pizza-missing two slices because it's just that good! - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

Pizza is still amazing, but after multiple occasions when their credit card machine has been down, it is now up, but with a caveat: $1 surcharge if you use plastic. Taped to the front of the register is an article that makes mention of a court ruling in which small business owners are allowed to use a surcharge for card purchase. I worked for a large bank for many years, and the cost to run one of these machines is like .002 per transaction. But whatever. We all have to make money somehow. Hence the reason for my updated review, with one less star. Sorry guys :-( read more

The best pizza . I even drove from Fleming Island. You can't beat the quality or prices.

Stopped at Vito's pizza after the volleyball game and it was awesome as usual. Always a favorite of ours. This time we had 10 players and 7 adults and we all ate for just over $100. We are talking pizzas, calzones, breadsticks, brownies, drinks... it was wonderful and fast. We'll be back during basketball season!!! Thank You! read more

This is definitely one of my best places to eat pizza. 799 for a pepperoni and cheese. And five dollars for a calzone. Calzones are so big you need to share with someone you love. Great stuff, great place anytime when you're in a hurry or not. Thanks Vito read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Delicious, homemade thin crust pizza. Exactly the way I like it. Greasy? Yeah, but it's pizza. I don't expect any less. This place isn't like the normal take out pizza places with boring crust. I truly appreciate this place & I'll be back. :) read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Menu. Simple. Awesome. - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Poor customer service, food over cooked and the delivery service takes forever. I would not recommend.

We had a voucher from an online deal so we decided to check them out. My husband and I are novice food critics since we eat out often. And pizza is high on our lists. The staff was very courteous and filled our order to perfection. I had the white pizza which had broccoli instead of spinach, a nice twist I might add. My husband had the meat pizza with double anchovies. We both enjoyed the pizzas, they were cooked very well without burning. Its a tiny hole in the wall in a small strip mall But I encourage others to check them out. read more

Love this place, it's become our go-to for pizza. Definitely a reason why they were voted best in the Times Union. I wish they would add lasagna to their menu. I hate that in Orange Park you only can get Italian or Chinese for delivery.. 1980 called. Oh! Awesome cannolis too. read more

Ordered a large Delux to go. This is a mom & pop Ny style pizza, not Chicago. They make their own sauce & crust. It was a very good pizza, with enough, but not too many veggies. Tables are available for eating in, and it was clean. A non franchise mom & pop, with a good product., and limited menu. I'll return. read more

I am new to the orange park area and wanted to try one of the local pizza places. Im glad I tried Vitos. Pizza was cooked to perfection. I ordered 3 types of pizza & one was extra cheese and it was really cheesy. Will be ordering again! read more

Oh GOD! This is the best pizza you can find around! I love this place and the staff is super nice! The prices are just perfect! And when you get extra cheese, you really really get extra cheese! read more

Although this place has minimal resources and very few bells and whistles, the food was great. Everything was authentic and the meats were far from fillers. The crust was probably the best I've ever had. I'm iffy to give it give stars because of the ho-hum kind of new business feeling, but that's why I'm giving it four. read more

Vitos Pizzeria - Front of the delicious pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Located in the Blanding Square Plaza (on the corner of Jefferson Avenue and Blanding Avenue) in Orange Park, Florida, Vitos has been "Voted Best Pizza" by Florida Times Union readers. Don't know what year(s) but maybe the owner, Sandra D., can tell us. You don't come for the ambiance but it is clean and has a warm and friendly personality that comes from the pizza staff. Their menu is small and limited, keeping the focus on pizzas (12" medium and 16" large) with the dough made daily from an old family recipe. I had the Deluxe Pizza made with fresh ingredients (Pepperoni, Onions, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Italian Sausage, Extra Cheese). A family owned business, Vitos offers dine-in, carry out & free delivery (limited area) six days a week (closed Sundays). There's a extra $1 charge for those paying by credit card. read more

See all

This used to be my favorite place to eat, hands down. They made calzone that were to die for, and pizza just like I had when I lived in New York. Lately, however, the quality has gone down. We ordered calzone about a month ago on delivery, and the bottom was burnt, the order wasn't compete, and the marinara was frozen. We called them and they sent another one, but it wasn't great. So, we waited a couple of months and tried again. This time, we just ordered pizza. The crust was super chewy, the pizza had almost no flavor, and the marinara was, once again, frozen. I don't know what's going on over there, but it was definitely disappointing. read more