We are doing a bike trip and went there last night after we checked into our hotel. Burgers were over cooked. Both of us asked for pepper jack cheese and got cheddar, waiter never came back. Had to ask a different waitress to send him out just so we could get our check. Waitress was being pulled on laps of drunk people and one guy in the bar was talking bout pulling his junk out. Place sucked will not go back. read more

Sally M's right... this is the only bar in Fish Creek, as best I can tell. We headed here mid-camping trip earlier this fall to catch the Packer game. We're devoted like that. Here's a breakdown. (Break it down, now!) -prices reasonable on some items, on others prices seemed a touch high (my guess is that is due to the fact that Door County is a cute/kitschy tourist destination for lots of folks... so they can probably get away with it) ex: some beer seemed reasonably (even cheaply!) priced, whereas some other varities seemed drastically over-priced. I guess I'm not sure about distribution/availability in this part of the state, but still. Noted. -service from the bartender was pretty dang spotty, although the owner/manager dude (from Riverwest!) that we ran into was great and super-nice (big ups to the R-Dubs!) -food was okay, and I wish I could expound, but I can't; it was bar food, nothing too terribly special, but it wasn't markedly bad, either. -this spot was super-busy for the game (perhaps in part to the fact that it seems to be the only bar in Fish Creek?) That said, the crowd thinned out considerably after the game ended. -this spots boasts a town-y vibe in the best way possible A-OK, Bay Side Tavern! Should we find ourselves camping at Peninsula Park in the future (and I can't imagine we wouldn't!) we'd definitely stop here again for a game, a brew, or a bite should an occasion call for it. read more

I'm from the Midwest . Hell, I even served tables at Al Johnson's down the street for two years...I really would've appreciated better service at the bar-perhaps it's a 'single woman at the bar' epidemic that equals bad service. I waited longer for my food because they got the order wrong, I fought to get a glass of Chardonnay as no one acknowledged me. I asked for a glass of water that I never got, and was basically disappointed all around. Learn to give good service to everyone! read more

Seat yourself place. If I didn't have to give a star to write this review, they'd get none. Sat here for close to 20 min while watching 4 servers behind the bar getting menus,etc. Thought they would get to us soon, but ended up greeting a table that came in after us. Sat another 5 min and after seeing 2 tables come in and immediately get served, we walked out.. If the service was this bad, I shudder to think how long it would take to get our food after we ordered. read more

Our favorite spot in Fish Creek. A hidden gem. Excellent staff and food. Exactly what you'd expect from Door County. Love this place!

Recommend to us, bottom line was the service was excellent the food B-. My wife had the club and I had the chili dog and fries. Good dog modest chili so so. Flat screens and video games all over. We each had a drink for $30. Not a bad place but many places to eat here read more

We dined here on a Monday night in March. They have great burger specials on Monday night and the place was slowly filling up while we were there. The bartender was super nice, and he gave us recommendations for places to go when we asked. The food was really good. The hot turkey sandwich (mj) was awesome, as were the pepperjack bites. My husband had the pepperjack Philly sandwich. --- I would definitely come back the next time I'm here. It wad really nice especially because it was one of the few places open during the week. read more

We stopped by on Black Friday looking for lunch. This place felt like home to a lot of people- busy, cozy, and run by women who know what they're doing. The food was great. I would definitely go back. read more

Typical bar food, spotted cow on tap. We came because they have gluten-free options they were out of gluten-free bread. I really wanted to like this place but I probably would not come back. read more

The best bar in Door County. Amazing bartenders, inexpensive beer and a good jukebox. They also have amazing cheese-tastic pizza. read more

Had a wonderful evening at the Bayside. The bartenders, Kathy and Brandon were sensational! Great ambience. A must visit when you come to Door County! read more

One of my favorite spots in the county. My family and I have been summertime locals for years, and regular patrons of Bayside, and will continue to be regular patrons when we're here for the summer, or popping up for a night during the winter. Exceptional, friendly staff who make it a point to get to know you, which really makes it like going to Cheers in a sense. Cannot imagine making anywhere else my regular nightly hangout. Keep up the great work Bayside crew! read more

I can't find a complaint about this place from the time I spent there. The food was good and the service was quick. The atmosphere at Bayside is friendly and every seemed to be having a fun time. A great casual place to grab a beer and a bite to eat. read more

Service was fantastic, food was wonderful! We came here while in vacation in Door County because my Dad grew up down the street from the owners, and we were pleased to find out that it's all still family owned. The Macdonalds are great! Highly recommend the brat burger and the chili (very meaty!), all in all GREAT PLACE! A Door County tradition! read more

Great staff, great food, even if they miss the mark with a sandwich from time to time they pizza and Friday night perch is so good I Dream about it. Just go and don't be a kitty kat read more

My friends and I stopped here for dinner after a very long bike ride around the peninsula. They have plenty of beer on tap. The bartender was happy to let me try a couple before I decided. Their burgers are also yummy and the three of us shared an order of fries. There was a Badger football game on that night too so the place was packed. A great slice of Wisconsin! read more

Nice enough "townie bar" in downtown Fish Creek. Nice 'Up North' atmosphere, but not as divey and 'local' as I might have expected (and hoped). I have to wonder if they bump up the prices in the summer for the Chicago tourists and send them back down over the winter? Prices were in line with what you'd expect in the Chicago burbs on this late June weekend. Didn't try food this time around, but I hear this place is one of the better choices in town. read more

It's pretty much the only late night hang out in Fish Creek. Prices are reasonable. A classic Wisconsin divey-type bar. The staff is friendly. I haven't eaten here yet but heard the food is pretty good. read more

Great atmosphere. The best Alaskan batter dipped pollack in door county and that's saying something.

Ate at Bayside for the last time. Always ridiculously packed, mostly with day drunks. Waitress seems pissed off you're there while she spends 10 minutes making a ridiculous drink table side with coffee and lots of booze and then sets on fire. Prices are obviously for rich Door vacationers. $32 for 2 iced teas (which were never refilled), 1 order of fries, 1 chicken sandwich and the worst turkey club ever served is ludicrous! Shared our table with strangers because there was nowhere for them to sit, talk about awkward! Not worth the time or money! read more

We eat here every year during our annual trip to Fish Creek, sometimes we eat here 2-3 times. Always have their Fish-n-Chips and Cheese Curds, and the pizza is great, too. Our usual spot when there's a rainy day, but sunny days don't keep us away, either. Don't forget to head out back down the alley for some Malibu Moo's to top off your meal. read more

Stopped in for a few beers. Had a beer and bloody mary. Bartender lady was super friendly, inviting and warm. Bloody Mary I didn't find anything special though, thought the mix could have some heat and salt. The season salt on the rim was pretty old I think. Didn't taste very good. Only reason I'm leaving 4 out of 5 is the service, that's what will have me come back. read more

The Bay Side Tavern is place for locals that lets even the tourist in. It is a bar and a fun bar at that. It is one of the best places to be on Halloween weekend. It is just plain fun. Their bar burgers are the best in Door County. The chili if not the best is one of the best in Door County. Have both with fries and you will not be disappointed. read more

A local bar ... plain and simple. I've spent a lot of time in other places like this in Wisconsin. The service is "local" ... not express. The beer is good and reasonably priced. The chili is to die for! True Green Bay chili, the kind you find at Chili Johns or at Real Chili in Milwaukee. If you are a chili fan at all, this is a must. Add onions, but maybe not the cheese. A great stop every time we are in Door County. read more

What can I tell you? Good food, 16 beers on tap, fast service. A great local place for a bite. Prices for the food are a little steep, but what do you expect for Fish Creek? read more

Great spot to grab a beer and something to eat. Can't go wrong with a BLT, Hot MJ (Turkey), huge club, or a grilled cheese with bacon and tomato. read more

Seems to be the only casual bar in Fish Creek? Decent beer selection, friendly staff, good atmosphere, great bar food. Not stunning but more than adequate - the bloody mary is excellent! read more

I have to say that it really pains me to give this classic place that I have been going to since I was 6 years old 3 stars. This place was not being run correctly when we were there this summer and it really showed. When we were able to get a table we sat down and piled all of the old dishes from the last people at the end of the table. After about 5 minutes we went up to the bar and all we asked for was that the table be cleared as we already had drinks and knew what we wanted. They had two bartenders and only one waitress working so our table took about 10 minutes to get cleared and that is about the time we finally got menus and some service. I felt sorry for the waitress until I saw her take a drink order then go make it herself despite the bartenders taking shots for themselves. The waitress had no priorities and it seemed she did not know how to handle multiple tables. Their house beer The Bayside Brew is still one of my favorites and their chili is still the best I can find anywhere. If it were not for my history of loving this place and their awesome food and beer then I would give them less stars. All it would have taken is maybe one more server and this place would have been fantastic but unfortunately we may have caught them on a bad night. read more

We came to Bayside Tavern 2 nights in a row during a recent trip to Door County. It seemed to be the only place in Fish Creek that was open after 10pm so got a little busy then but we tried to come earlier for drinks. Nice ambience and their beer cheese soup was fabulous! read more

Horrible server last time!!!! We got her twice in one weekend! Food is decent enough bar food! We usually stop in for a drink at least once on our annual fall trip. This year we tried watching a football game & eating dinner there. The waitress was awful. It was Saturday of fall Fest (very drunk fun Fest, we thought we were far enough away from it since its up in sister bay) & a group of rowdy college age kids came in & were very drunk & pretty much took over the bar! They pulled tables together & were playing flippy cup & being very obnoxious, normally in a bar that's fine but it was only 8:00 & most ppl there were trying to eat & watch the game. They were finally asked to leave when one of them kept falling over! Good to stop in for a drink or appetizer while shopping, don't recommend for dinner & gets crowded for night drinks! read more

Stopped on a week day afternoon in the off season for lunch, only about 8 people in the place, very different than the weekends in summer. The service was great, friendly conversation with the bartender. I ordered a cheese burger and fries, my wife had the Ruben. The fries were excellent, very crispy, cooked perfectly. My burger was delicious. The Ruben came on rye bread which was cut thick, the meat was a little chewy but tasted great, overall a good sandwich. I stop here whenever I'm in the area and will continue to do so. I have never been disappointed. read more

Absolutely the place to be after doing all the touristy stuff you did all day. I can't really speak for the food as I only had a cup of smilen Mikes chilli (which was pretty good) but wow was it the hot spot. If you're looking for a social gathering of mainly 30 somethings on up, this is it. There were plenty of younger people there too but in general it was a nice mixed crowd. Go there, you won't be bored. read more

Good beer selection. Food was a little pricy but when you get your food you see why. Totally worth it.

Had dinner here tonight as the fish fry was recommended by the front desk at our resort. Kids meal corn dog meal had cold fries, wife's burger was small, my perch fish fry was also cold and was $17. Clam chowder was decent but I wouldn't stop again. Slow service, couldn't get a refill or our check delivered or taken. Ended up walking up to the bar to pay so we could get outta there. read more

Food & hospitality good. Service was terrible. May be due to young server. Would go back but hope they work on speeding up service. Had to find server a few times to order drinks & served ourselves coffee. read more

Cold beer, great service, friendly place get the bayside lager. Great break from shopping or while your wife is shopping.

I ordered a sandwich and it tasted like cardboard. Seriously, reminded me of cafeteria food. I've had frozen dinners I enjoyed more. And it still cost around $15. Come here for the drinks or not at all. Two stars because the music selection was pretty respectable, and atmosphere counts a lot in a bar. read more

Great stop for a beer especially on the off season. Awesome locals. The food smelled amazing.

My wife and I never miss the Friday perch fry when we are in Door County. We've been to a lot of them and Bay Side is the best. The friendly service can get bogged down during a shift change due to demand, but they are always super nice. read more

While visiting friends and taking a tour of the area we stopped into Bay Side Tavern for lunch. It was our first visit and the place did not disappoint. There were a lot of items to look at throughout the bar and there were plenty of tables and bar stools for sitting. The food was also delicious. We had the party platter which had a great variety of pub samplers and their Brat Burger (a hamburger patty on top of a brat patty with cheese) is totally worth it. This place also has RC Cola which I have not had in years. Our waiter did a great job. He was friendly and checked us often. He later told us it was his first day and we think he did a good job! This is a great place to eat if you are stopping in Fish Creek! read more