Damn. Fine. Pizza. The people here are awesome. The pizza was fabulous -- perfect crust!!! Got the pizza right when it came out of the oven -- heavenly! This establishment was the perfect finish for a perfect evening. I can't say thank you enough to the wonderful staff for their patience and for that taste-tastic pizza goodness! read more

This is my favorite pizzeria in NYC. I always come here for lunch and they have the best service as well as pizza. I wholeheartedly give them 5 stars. read more

Proto's Pizza NYC - Baked ziti pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ignored. I wish I had a chance to review the place based on the food but such was not the case. I walked in and was totally ignored. I tried getting the counter persons attention three times but it is extremely frustrating when your standing in front of the dude trying to order while he carries on a conversation with one of his homies completely ignoring you. . Read my yelps, I'm not a tough customer or a obnoxious yelper, I generally rate business pretty high but this place is ridiculous. The chubby round faced guy acted as if I wasn't even there. I was standing right in front of him, trying to make eye contact, even saying " excuse me I'd like to have.." But alas, to no avail. I really wanted to try their pizza because it looked pretty good but ill hesitate to go back based on this experience. read more

My partner and I always get the margarita slices here. There's not as much mozzarella as on a Prince Street Pizza margarita slice, and the mozzarella doesn't taste quite as fresh, but it's still a great margarita slice, way better than most other pizzas available nearby. It's light and not too cheesy/greasy. Proto's is convenient as they have pretty late hours and they've never had a line when I've been. Prince Street Pizza has a horrible line from 6pm and on, and the quality difference just isn't big enough to be worth it to wait there. Proto's also has tables and chairs so you can eat there without worrying about your pizza getting cold or having to figure out how to dispose of pizza boxes for carryout. read more

It's been a while since I visited New York. I used to live there before moving to Los Angeles. I always tell people how i miss New York Pizza. Recently I went back to visit. After a long day of walking around i needed my PIZZA :) My friend recommended we stop at Proto's. I absolutely loved the food. The owner itself greeted us. What a friendly and awsome staff. Very positive and passionate about their dishes. Proto's is definitely one of my favorite places to visit every time I visit New York. read more

If you like your dough extra thick and your toppings poured onto the slice as if they were going out of style, this is the place for you. And though the dough is thick, it's not heavy or gross--it's actually pretty light and crispy. I wouldn't bring out-of-towners here to show them what NY pizza is all about, it's not that sort of place, but if you're in the neighborhood and want a slice, it's a-ok. Random aside. I sat at a table next to a woman who ordered too much for herself, and told me she had a 6'3" garbage disposal back home -- her son -- that would take care of any leftovers. I hope he said thank you to his lovely mother. read more

Currently having some delicious buffalo chicken pizza! The guys are very welcoming, friendly and great customer service! Definitely will keep coming for more. read more

Great pizza for Manhattan a select few I like and I love pizza only problem Manhattan pizza is a catch 22 this place along with royal pizza on 3rd ave are the only ones I love I will frequent this location again friendly staff small outside place walkup and sitting in or outside read more

Not a bad regular $2.50 slice, but certainly not the best. The personal pan pizzas that dominate the displays look interesting, so perhaps you should opt for that instead. And let me know how it goes! read more

I popped by here when I was in a rush on my way to a bar in the area. It was good for what we needed - a yummy slice of pizza. There was seating and in addition to that they had tvs with the game(s) on so that was nice. All in all this place is A-Ok by me and a nice pizza joint to crash when you're in a hurry Enjoy! read more

Happened in by chance. This was amazing. Definitely recommend the garlic knots and the spaghetti with meatballs. Our slices were fantastic as well. Great food and great staff! read more

Excellent Roman style pizza. Thick dough, fresh toppings--Delicious! Don't expect this to be your normal NY slice; it's not that saucy or cheesy. I totally happened upon this one night on the way to KGB for a reading and though this is slightly more expensive than a regular slice of pizza, it feels more like a true meal. They've got tons of options--try something new and surprise yourself! There's some seating, but not tons. read more

**Great Authentic New York Pizzas ** So many options, ALL Amazing and Delicious. If you LOVE calzone, its well worth the wait 10 min and they will make it fresh just the way you like it; I Guarantee it will be the best you ever had =-) . Also they are **Vegetarian Friendly** . There pizza's are thick, slightly crusted, perfect sauce and cheesy like a pie but not overwhelming, there just right. They have 1 big t.v. inside so you wont miss any sports game while you get your grub on. They are super friendly and Born and Raised New Yorkers running the joint =-). Affordable. Stop by if your in the mood for satisfaction. --enjoii read more

Proto's Pizza NYC - Order here - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This has been our go-to pizza place for a while, but we recently tried their eggplant parm heros and they were so, so good. In the past when we wanted eggplant parm we'd order from Parm, but these are SO much better (and much cheaper). The bread is delicious and there is the perfect amount of everything on the sandwich. Also, the owner is so nice and always gives my dog a treat when we stop by. Would very highly recommend! read more

One of my all time favorite slices of nyc pizza. The people are always nice. I don't think there is a person in the east village that the owner Hal doesn't know by name. The pizza is great. The place is clean and the people are nice. That's pretty much everything I look for in a restaurant. read more

This is a fantastic gem in East Village, been there many times. The pizza is great quality. Yesterday I had the Grandma Slice and the Penne Ala Vodka with grilled chicken , the sauce was delicious. The pizza is thin and crispy and has a great taste. I appreciate the pizza chef Hal and always have great conversations with him. Don't miss it if you are in East Village. read more

Great place. Hal the owner makes everyone feel at home. Try the Penne Vodka or Margarita pizza

I love this place!! Pizza is great and Finally good BUREK!!! It's hard to find a good Burek in NYC! Balkans would understand me! So happy that no need to go to Queens for it anymore. Go and try, you will not regret! read more

Proto's Pizza NYC - Burek with potatoes(krompirusa)! Yummi - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped in for a slice of thin crust with pepperoni yesterday. Pizza was very good, especially the crust. Great flavor, light, and a little bit crisp. Sauce was tasty, right amount of cheese. Service was a little off -- maybe the guy behind the counter was having a bad day. He rolled his eyes when I ordered (because I only got one slice maybe?) and after I paid he kinda threw my change to the other end of the counter when I was standing right in front of him. Anyway, good pizza. Glad to have them in the neighborhood for a go-to slice. Next time I'll be sure to smile real purty when I order. read more

Came here to grab a slice of pizza right before watching a performance of Stomp. We were on the hunt for a slice of NY style pizza and were so happy to stumble across Proto's. The place was small but we (myself and two teenagers) all agreed the pizza was delicious! We just had the cheese and pepperoni slices, but they hit the spot on a cold January afternoon! Wish we could have stayed longer and eaten more slices since everyone in there was really nice and it didn't break the bank! Looking forward to coming back next time we are in town! read more

Proto's Pizza one of the best places when it comes to quality and consistency. Wonderful ambiance, clean and good service. I really like every thing I have ordered there. The servers are extremely helpful and polite. You will not be disappointed with Proto's Pizza. read more

Maybe the best by-slice pizza I've ever had. Good variety of pies, all interesting and delicious. Friendly staff, reasonably priced. Huge slices. read more

My new favorite hole-in-the-wall late-night pizza joint. Went twice in one evening, just so I could try both the Bruschetta slice (tasty, fresh ingredients) and the Philly Cheese slice (complete with melted almost fake cheese on top). Delightful... Their slices are thick and fat, but still very light, almost fluffy. Love the crust, too. Will be back! read more

I often find myself here ordering a quick, late-night Buffalo Chicken pizza after a long day of work. Normally, I would be ashamed of myself for not "mixing things up" a little and ordering, maybe let's say, their Eggplant Parmisiani pizza--but I'm not. If you still haven't realized the undertone that this review assumes so far, I'll say this-- ORDER THE BUFFALO-CHICKEN PIZZA. Also, the guys behind the counter are pretty awesome. "Awesome" constitutes a distinguishable level of "friendliness, courtesy, and acute level of attentiveness to customers." So there you have it. read more

Don't waste your time looking for a tastier pizza in East Village. Great Pizza!!! Friendly Staff !!! Clean Store & Bathrooms !!! read more

I had a chicken parm here with my mealpal app - it was quite delicious. It was a great portion and prepared quickly. Sometimes items like this can be quite bland - but it has a lot of flavour read more

I have never been more thrilled with something in NYC. I have a lot of loyalty to philly but this place tops it all. I was visiting friends and we stopped here and I loved the pizza so much that I memorized the number. Then got wasted. Fast forward to wasted Paige and she doesn't know her own age but she knows the number to Proto's. We order multiple pizzas and never been happier. read more

Best pizza!!!! And genuinely nicest staff ever! Great variety and eat flavor for NYC pizza. Great for any time of the day or late time. Would highly recommend anyone and everyone to go here. You couldn't ask for anything better than this!!!!! read more

Great place to get a slice of pizza! They have some good looking chicken rolls too! Definitely stop by here if you want fresh, thin crusted yummy pizzas! read more

Stoped by while in East Village and loved it. They have a lunch special two slices and a free drink. I ordered grandma slice and pepperoni. I can easily say one of the best pizzas I ever had. If you in the area it is a must. read more

Unfriendly service. I couldn't hear the 2 people behind the counter mumbling at me over the TV that was blaring a Mexican version of Judge Judy. Very poor pizza. This would pass as good pizza in middle America, but when you serve pizza in NYC you need to step up your game. The dough was dry and bland. The slice was served a degree over room temperature. This joint was empty at 8pm. I'm guessing the neighborhood folks wrote this place off a long time ago. 2 stars is generous. read more

I work in the neighborhood and this place is slowly becoming my favorite. We order in a lot and their delivery is really quick. Beside pizza that is probably the best in the east village, pesto ravioli and the meatball parm hero are to die for. Next to try will be their specialty called Burek. Can't wait. read more

I was starving right before a movie screening and decided to wander down the street. I went into Proto's and ordered a slice of pizza (the topping on top look really fresh, mine had tomato on it, can't remember much else). I thought the pizza dough was really fluffy and light. Definitely hit the spot! read more

When I tried to call to order for delivery, recorded message snipped that they did not accept hidden phone numbers. WTH??? I have never had any problem in this respect with any other place, so I won't be patronizing any pretentious slice joint that wants to invade my privacy. I choose not to give out my primary phone number, so I use a secondary ringtone number which I cannot call out from. Because, stalkers and I just don't want my real number out there. I guess I won't be trying Proto's meatball sandwich anytime soon... read more

It's under new ownership apparently & as such this is once again a great neighborhood pizzeria(Enzo's was the best)! Food is awesome, staff is great, so nice & helpful. One star off for cheesy decor but hey, you're not here for the view so no worries! Protos delivers also so keep it in mind for those miserable nights you don't want to go outside and forage for food, Salut Protos! read more

I absolutely LOVE this pizza place. The staff is always super friendly and efficient and the pizza is DELICIOUS. Proto's is my go-to spot! Highly recommended. read more

I had a cheese slice and another Sicilian looking slice. Niether impressed me with their taste and flavor. There are other joints at this price point that taste significantly better. read more

OK so i have to say that even after coming here almost everyday, they don't disappoint. I love how friendly and efficient they are. Will continue to come here read more

Owner is a rude slob and aggressive. First of all he looked intoxicated and proceeded to ignore me while I waited to order. I finally ordered a margarita slice because I was told by the employee that it came fresh out of the oven. The guy warms up an old slice which I didn't notice. When I did I mentioned to him that I wanted a new slice because that was the selling point. The owner then butts in and gives me attitude and says I have to throw this slice out or charge you for two slices. Should have walked out at that point. The guy was a dick and the slice tasted stale and old. Don't try to sell me on a slice being freshly baked when in reality you're trying to sell me an old slice. read more

Pizza had a hair in it and the place was very unsanitary. Bathroom wasn't clean and it smelled bad inside. The guy w tattoo in the front was also a jerk. Gross pizza don't go here. read more