We arrived at closing time and the staff was still friendly and happy to serve us. The food and drinks were all awesome . We and the kids and the grand kid really enjoyed ourselves. I just wish we had found Castaway Cafe earlier in our stay so we could have checked it out for breakfast and lunch! read more

Amazing food, great location, low key and wonderful. Great find in Maui. Highly recommended!

Hands down the best bang for your buck on this side of the island! Staff is excellent and super friendly! And the best part is the food and the view. read more

This place is tugged away from the main path, but nicely located close to the ocean with quite a few tables outside. I decided to try it for lunch, but won't be back. BLAT sandwich was tasteless and the bread was disgusting. The guacamole looked and tasted like that nasty supermarket stuff that is bright green and has the consistency of mayo (almost) - and it tasted old. The chips were stale, and the pineapple salsa (what attracted me) was served in a tiny cup - very small amount, so quite disappointed overall. read more

I visited Maui for a long weekend from Oahu and my friend always goes there so she had to show me the place. We ended up eating their twice because we wanted reasonably priced food while sitting feet from the shoreline with amazing views. We both ate The Big island Omelet and shared a pineapple boat. The servings were large and the fruit and veggies were all fresh. The servers were fast and friendly. The best part is to be steps from the water and not be over charged for that. But the really best part is that I left my credit card and called them, spoke to the manager, Craig, and he quickly confirmed it was there in their safe. It arrived at my front door step first class the next day! I recommend avoiding the food coma brain farts that happen to me but its very appreciated when you can trust the staff and manager. read more

Delicious food. Great view. During our breakfast here we had the most spectacular view of a rainbow, but I know we're on Maui, so rainbows are not as rare as they are back home. But when your having breakfast and sitting at your table enjoying your loco moco, you look up and there is that beautiful rainbow you think, damn I could really get use to this. read more

Breakfast was fantastic and the view was amazing totally worth every penny and everyone around is very nice!

The new ex. chef is really making sure the food, service and attitude of the staff is super! We had the most amazing Lilikoi Ricotta Lemon pancakes in the morning and in the evening the calamari was incredible. I made a meal of the caesar salad and calamari. The portions are very generous. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming. The service was super as well as the view. You feel like you are in Hawaii in the old days, relaxed atmosphere, beautiful ocean view and the real spirit of Aloha! We have been coming to this restaurant for 40 years and this chef is the best yet. We will definitely be back. read more

We ate here for most of our meals during our visit to Maui, as it is located on the same property we were staying, and loved that we didn't have to venture far. Oh my goodness...the food is so good! Seriously the best pasta dishes we have ever ordered! The carbonara pasta was to die for and mom felt the same way about the shrimp fettuccine she ordered. Wednesday night they have a pasta special, so it is BOGO and sooooo worth it! Do yourself a favor and order their Kalua pork fried rice dish off the "local favorites" section. I still can't decide which dish was my favorite between it or the pasta. I also recommend the Hawaiian fruit bowl with the cinnamon sour cream! Who would've thought cinnamon sour cream was a "thing"? And a very tasty one at that lol. With the exception of the older waitress with the long blonde/white hair/pony tail, the staff was exceptionally friendly. (The pony tail lady needs some practice in this area). I will definitely return to the CC when I visit Maui again. read more

I visited the Castaway Cafe back in 1997 and 98 . . . and it stands out in my memory as one of the places I enjoyed dining the most (along with Roy's and Cheeseburger in Paradise)! To this day, I've never had a breakfast that could compare to the Macadamia Pancakes (with included bananas, pineapple and coconut syrup, if I recall correctly) I ordered on repeated visits. Simply put, it doesn't get better than this! Out of this world! And being the mega hamburger junkie that I am, I can honestly say that their burgers were some of the very best I've ever had. You can't beat the location. Right on the beach . . . perfect for the tropical sunsets and cool ocean breezes. Just right for experiencing the epitome of Hawaiian relaxation. One last (exceptional) note: During those two years of visits, one waitress comes to mind at the Castaway Cafe . . . an angel named Stacey. I have no idea if she's still there, but she was one of the highlights of returning to the islands year after year. Never has a more friendly, caring, outrageously funny person drawn breath on this planet! If and when I ever return to Maui, The Castaway Cafe will be among my very first stops. read more

I have been coming to Castaways for years, mainly because of the wonderful people who work there - all so friendly and welcoming, and the unparalleled ocean view. While it is true that the servers are very casually dressed, their attire is perfectly appropriate for the setting. It is Maui after all. Castaways is not and never will be a fine dining destination. They do some things very well - breakfast, burgers, fried calamari, spinach salad. That said their menu is in serious need of an overhaul. On my recent trip, entrees on offer included bacon wrapped pork chops, braised short ribs and a Gorgonzola New York steak. This is just not the sort of food I want to eat when in Maui. They do offer a number of fish entrees but their fish is clearly not fresh and is usually overcooked. The vegetables that come with the entrees are just sad with no seasoning of any kind. Castaways could be a really wonderful mid-priced dining destination. They just need a new chef. read more

Amazing! We ate here 3 times during our stay at Maui Kaanapali Villas! The service was fantastic! Food was great! Don't miss out! Amazing sunset views! They make sure you are happy! read more

We walked to the Castaway, breakfast was $25 for 2 the view was priceless. The service was decent. If youre close enough to walk then you should go here for breakfast...they also have a bar and a pasta night every week for dinner. read more

A little gem in Maui! Great bartenders! Food is average but the drinks are kapow! I highly recommend the sunset punch. The magic is at the bar. Not worth the time on anything else. The guys are friendly and make the scene worth it. I could see myself settling easily in to the 'Cheers NORM' stool. read more

This place is great. A true feel of Hawaii. Food you can afford. And it's really good

Great food, Great view while eating and great prices! Will definitely be back when were back in hawaii next year!

The Service is excellent. The entire staff is extremely friendly. The lemon-ricotta pancakes are outstanding! I am not a big pancake person, however, these pancakes were exceptional. The Lilikoi sauce and blueberry sauce on the side of the pancakes makes a great combination. I highly recommend it! read more

Breakfast was delicious and the staff very friendly. They are very generous on the plate of bacon. Pricing very reasonable, especially with the hotels around. They need a little more signage from the beach, but that's just because the place is wonderful! read more

My wife and kids really enjoyed the breakfast, large portions, fried rice breakfast and breakfast burrito! Not to mention the guava mimosas! A hidden gem without the hour wait to get in. Located on the water at aston kaanapali village. read more

Went here because it was late and it was within walking distance. Dinner was fine and the staff was friendly. Returned another day for lunch and had the chicken sandwich. It was surprisingly good. I was hesitant to try this place because of the poor reviews but my family and I enjoyed the food and the view!! read more

Soooo... sitting here on the patio for 15 to 20 minutes . Nobody has greeted us .. had to get our own drinks ( coffee and ice tea) drank that and still no one has brought us napkins or ANYTHING... I get that it's laid back. .. so maybe with service like this instead of tables I recommend bringing a hammock ...... still waiting..and there it is ....John Mayer in the background playing STILL WAITING read more

Good food and decent service in a great location right on the beach. Try to get a table outside if you can and you might spot some whales playing in the ocean. I've only been there for brunch but their cocktails look good too! read more

The service staff seemed confused by our presence in their restaurant. Difficult to find as it is located in a condo community, Castaway Cafe was incredibly underwhelming and unwelcoming. read more

There were many empty tables but yet they could not seat us without a wait. They seem disorganized and frazzled. Water had a bug in it the first time and then a dirty cup the second time and the third time they actually didn't even bring us water. The waiter was not friendly did not smile or say much. The ocean view is nice though. read more

Before I travel to eat at a restaurant I like to go online to read the menu and get an idea for what the prices are. THERE ARE NO MENU PRICES ON THEIR WEBSITE! Food was OK. Price is on the high side which I found out after traveling 30 miles. But to not show their prices is ridiculous! read more

Prices are the same as we saw a couple of years ago. Portions seem a little smaller and the service was a little slower. It could be because they are low on waitstaff today but we were served water only once with no refills and it took a little bit of time to get service in the first place. Overall our meal was fine. We all had Denver omelettes and the short stack of paradise pancakes which include macadamia nut topping, diced pineapples, and bananas. If you sit outside you can see the ocean very easily and enjoy the weather. If you have a choice between Gazebos and Castaway Cafe you'll find the food to be close to the same, better prices at Castaway, and faster seating time and service times at Castaway. And if you're in the Kaanapali region you can walk or take the free trolly to Castaway Cafe instead of driving to Gazebo. read more

This was a nice little place for breakfast, we sat outside and enjoyed the view while we ate. Breakfast fare was good, prices were reasonable, service was fine. You can get a parking permit at the nearby hotel, no charge for customers. read more

This restaurant has a great view, but when I called to reserve a spot (i think it was Jason) outdoor, he said there was plenty of seats and refused to take my reservation. As a matter of fact, I called twice. When I came 10 minutes later with my family, it was all booked. To tell you honestly, the experience sucked which made me grumble at my food. read more

Aloha! I can't emphasize how amazing the food and service was at this precious gem of a restaurant! From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and was seated right in front of the beautiful views of the ocean. I have to comment on the amazing "PUPUS." The Edamame hummus was out of this world. Creamy, velvety, rich, and simply the best I've ever tasted even from Israel my homeland. Craig, the General Manger stopped by and his genuine passion of making the guest feel special was extremely imminent. I ordered the Macadamia Nut Crusted Mahi Mahi and the fish was perfectly cooked. Chef Derlin created a masterpiece with his utilization of Yuzu butter that truly complimented the fish! Definitely recommend this fabulous place! It's just too bad there isn't a location in California! Hopefully they will open one specifically in Beverly Hills or Downtown LA, anything near Westwood....Hopefully will be back soon! read more

Loved their breakfast especially the lemon ricotta panacakes! Location: A+ Food: A Service: B Price: pretty affordable in Maui read more

What a disappointing breakfast. We have eaten here before because someone told us it's as good as the Gazebo and no waiting. Last time we eat there it was close but no Gazebo. Now they added a 2% surge for the cooks ( not my fault you don't pay them enough!) order omelet, you get your choice of toast, potato's, fruit. Just one. The omelet was good, but half the size of the Gazebo, with no potato's! We visit here twice a year, Castaway is now on the list of "do not return". I gave it 2 stars for the location. Lots of better places to have breakfast!! read more

Oh my LORD. This place is hilarious!! It was the best places for a bevy on the beach. First Chris was the best and funniest bartender. His Mai Tais are incredible. No. I mean they're the best EVER--F#@ing INCREDIBLE!!! The view is amazing, and the sunset is the best on Maui. Go to castaways and you will love yourself for spending your Maui sunset with Chris!! read more

Best laid back Restaurant/Bar with a staff that has mostly been there for years...that should tell you something! We have been going to the Castaway for years and the staff is always friendly and fun to talk to. They have a great menu, I recommend trying the fish taco's. You can view the ocean from pretty much every seat and after dining the uncrowded beach is only steps away. You won't regret going to Castaway Cafe! Aloha! read more

I had lunch here & this place is located at the Maui Kaanapali Villas. It's tucked away be the beach for a nice view. The food & service was decent, we stayed during the time of the renovation of the pool area, so the jack hammering was quite noisy. They do have a bar which closes at 9:30PM. The atmosphere is very casual & relaxed. read more

My husband and I loved this place for breakfast while staying at Westin Ka'anapali Beach. Their mac nut pancakes are the best - mounded high with crushed macadamia nuts - and their loco moco was great as well. You can't beat their view - the restaurant is right on the water, and the lanai seating provides unobstructed views of the beautiful Pacific and, while we were there in February, lots of whale activity! Their service was prompt, attentive, and friendly. Meals are $7-10 per plate. read more

Located conveniently on the grounds of Aston Ka'anapali villas, I frequented this place the most often during my stay in Maui because a) it was only a 3 min walk from my hotel room and b) it's the least crowded place to dine at with a nice view of the beach. When my bf and I first arrived, we were so exhausted and hungry and so we came here for dinner. I ordered fish and chips which was served with fresh mahi mahi. I actually never tried mahi mahi before but I feel that whenever you fry any type of fish, it just tastes like a flaky tilapia. But either way, you can tell it's fresh and it wasn't something they microwaved from the freezer. We were sitting outside and just in time to see the sunset. It was quite a remarkable and romantic ambiance. If you do not wish to dine in, they have a bar area where you can order quick bites and drinks. We did this during the day and ordered sliders and fried pickles. The sliders were bigger than the ones I normally had. It was almost the size of a regular burger. Like most places in Maui, service is really friendly. read more

Castaway Cafe - deep fried pickles - American Near Me - Lahaina, Hawaii

See all

I didn't really like the food here at all, but I wanted to give Castaway Cafe an extra star for their bartenders. The two gentlemen I've ordered from were friendly, funny, and remembered my name after one visit. Not to mention, they make some mean Mai Tais. read more

We've eaten here several times now and have had pretty good meals. Nice simple fare with great service. Location right off the beach is very nice. read more

Average food but great prices, fantastic service and beautiful views! A great way to start your day.

Wife and I had breakfast here in it's beach house setting. My scrambled eggs were done very well & her French toast was thick and syrup made perfect. We both sampled the coconut syrup and neither of us were fans of that flavor. On the beach, hearing the surf, made for an enjoyable breakfast. Waitress was friendly and prompt. read more